Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be worried about this trend? - Tesco check-out free store.

117 replies

mustlovegin · 28/11/2021 18:04

It was first started by Amazon Fresh I believe.

Now Tesco are trying to do the same with their first check-out free store.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58951984

Basically you cannot physically get into the store unless you have the Tesco App. You also cannot pay by means of cash or a credit/debit card - you are made to pay for your purchases through the App.

Isn't this potentially discriminatory plus it forces customers to fit into their ecosystem and comply with their restrictions?

This particular store is in an area with many council flats nearby. Elderly and disabled people used to shop there and will now need to walk at least 15 minutes to do their shopping.

Where are we heading with all of this? Shouldn't we have more options and freedom not less?

OP posts:
DeepaBeesKit · 29/11/2021 08:56

It's a private sector business, not a charity. They are not required to operate stores in particular ways to serve older customers.

Presumably they think there's a demand for this at that store, they aren't going to do something that loses them custom/money. If there really are a lot of older customers close by whom this will affect and they quickly lose business you will find they rapidly change it.

mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 08:53

Sainsbury's ran a trial store like this a few years ago in the same area

The Sainsbury's one was cashless (which is bad enough) but they didn't force you to use the app

OP posts:
Ifailed · 29/11/2021 08:50

It's willy waving by Tesco. As PP have stated, Sainsbury's ran a trial store like this a few years ago in the same area, because that's where Sainsbury's head office is.
There are some local residents nearby, but the vast majority of the customers will be office workers from the legal businesses etc. nearby, including Amazon's London offices.

mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 08:48

I think Parliament should in the near future seriously consider laws that businesses have to accept certain payment methods, in order to protect the ability of all people to access products and services

I agree.

And I also think they will need to legislate against monopolistic technology platforms. In order to protect customers and also smaller organisations and traders who are often caught up in this mess.

Once Uber have disrupted destroyed the minicab sector, for instance, and drivers who are desperate to make a living are left with no option but to use the platform, what's stopping Uber from making it a condition for usage to provide a DNA sample ? Or surrender something else? Or donate a kidney?

It may all sound a bit extreme, but something similar is being introduced in other countries with more lax data and consumer protection legislation. Small businesses who are desperate for custom hand over whatever is required in order to be able to be allowed to continue to operate (and they are still abused in other ways - upping commission percentages for instance). It's sinister.

OP posts:
EwwSprouts · 29/11/2021 08:38

Similarly, I parked in a city centre multi storey last week expecting to pay with a card. Came back and none of the machines were working. The only way to pay was via QR code. I did it but it triggered multiple fraud alerts from my bank. My parents would not have known how to do that, been frustrated and worried and ended up with the parking fine.

FrogsOnALog · 29/11/2021 08:30

I've recently got myself a very basic phone to try and combat my screen addiction. So I wouldn't be able to use that store.
I find it quite concerning how reliant on technology I am. I'm currently posting on my tablet which I'm planning to give myself rules about using once I've adjusted to a basic phone. Which is ridiculous, obviously.
I find it quite concerning that they'll discriminate against you for not having a device that runs apps. Or what if you've run out of data? Or lost / broken their phone?

Mouseonmychair · 29/11/2021 08:28

Its evolution people need to evolve to their new environment otherwise they get left behind. Checkout assistants need to look at retaining customers need to learn new technologies. It's the way of the world.

icedcoffees · 29/11/2021 08:27

But you're not being forced to do anything.

This is one shop out of hundreds in central London - just buy your bread somewhere else Confused

mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 08:24

It won’t be long before your face is recognised and that is how you pay

So presumably you are ok with banks (which could be Natwest or something more loosely operated like Monzo) or Google accessing and storing your biometric data then? No risk there whatsoever Confused

OP posts:
Silverswirl · 29/11/2021 07:59

This is the way everything is going. Things change and we are entering further and further into the digital age.
It won’t be long before your face is recognised and that is how you pay. No cashiers needed at all or tills. Pick up your shopping and walk out.

mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 07:43

I worry about the spread of covid and the health of my old dog. I may like or not like how a shop decides to operaste it but why would i` worry about it?

I agree, there other more pressing issues to worry about.

But a lot of these changes that have the potential to be very detrimental if adopted by enough companies have been introduced by stealth in the last couple of years when most of us have been understandably preoccupied with something else.

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 29/11/2021 07:39

Thanks for the article Empressaurus

Even if all of those glitches are ironed out further down the line, you can realise how much power organisations can wield with set ups like these

OP posts:
Row1n · 29/11/2021 04:18

Dh and I watched a programme about Sainsburys recently and they had a shop like this on that programme, so if its only newly open then it isnt the first supermarket to do it.
Interestingly they had one hidden till for if the app went down and once customers noticed it a lot of them queued up to use that instead

CheeseMmmm · 29/11/2021 03:13

It says they are trialling it at one store to see what customers think. Not that it's coming generally.

I also can't imagine they are getting rid of self scan option.

They know they would lose loads of customers. The wording says customers can not customers have to.

No way will they want to lose the people who pop in for a couple of things, the people who don't want to use it or can't.

Self checkout of course is still a challenge for plenty of people.

And big stores weekly shops self scan just not going to work. And of course weekly shop many don't do list. So would send them elsewhere as extra work.

So assume checkouts stay as well.

It's as well not instead.

No way will they change meaning lots loss of customers.

Queenoftheashes · 29/11/2021 03:09

I’ve been deliberately avoiding this shop. I use the M&S across the road instead. Probably because I hate Tesco but having read that times article I’m also vindicated in my initial thought that it won’t be worth the effort of the endless downloading etc before you go in.

DaisyNGO · 29/11/2021 03:01

@Megan2018

I think it’s great, it’ll be an age before it gets to me in the rural wilds of the East Mids sadly but I do everything I can on apps. I can start and defrost and charge my car from an app, I do all my banking on apps. I can’t remember the last time I used cash for anything in a shop, must be 3+ years. I think paying for a loaf of bread with £1 coin is odd these days. I don’t know anyone that does that, not even my parents and they are early 70’s, even they have applepay! I love technology, I’m all for innovation and not living in the past.
Is it related to how posh the areais, maybe. In a not good part of london and most people don't use this. Definitely lots of us still using cash. I'd hate to rely on my phone for all this. And download yet more apps, no way.

Agree, the shop location is bang in the middle of many other food stores, I worked there for years...no reason anyone has to walk an extra 15 mins to a food shop.

There is a campaign about access to cash for those who are keen to keep it

www.onepostoffice.co.uk/secure/latest-news/our-business/post-office-launches-campaign-to-save-our-cash/

EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 29/11/2021 02:56

There was a review in the Times last month showing what it’s like if you go unprepared. Sharetoken link: www.thetimes.co.uk/article/c0798c4e-30f4-11ec-820f-e2be9b2cb5fd?shareToken=4cbc38840391d10876061baf44702579

HardbackWriter · 29/11/2021 02:45

This particular store is in an area with many council flats nearby. Elderly and disabled people used to shop there and will now need to walk at least 15 minutes to do their shopping.

I was pretty surprised when I opened the article and saw which shop it actually is! This description of High Holborn as a location is a bit baffling...

Megan2018 · 29/11/2021 02:36

I think it’s great, it’ll be an age before it gets to me in the rural wilds of the East Mids sadly but I do everything I can on apps. I can start and defrost and charge my car from an app, I do all my banking on apps. I can’t remember the last time I used cash for anything in a shop, must be 3+ years. I think paying for a loaf of bread with £1 coin is odd these days. I don’t know anyone that does that, not even my parents and they are early 70’s, even they have applepay!
I love technology, I’m all for innovation and not living in the past.

Ellmau · 29/11/2021 02:25

@BungleandGeorge

Is it to reduce shop lifting? I would do my shopping elsewhere. If you’re in central London you’ve got more choice than the majority of the country who manage to do their shopping
I thought that about the shoplifting.
Smorgasborb · 29/11/2021 02:12

@AtLeastPretendToCare

Oh come on. This is by Chancery Lane tube, the vast majority of people who shop there are from nearby workplaces or are visiting such. It is hardly full of the elderly using rolators. And that is exactly why they start trialling with such stores - such customers are more likely to be tech savvy and willingness to use new innovations.

Now that doesn’t mean literally nobody will be inconvenienced sure but this is hardly the same as dropping it in the centre of a residential area.

Ha haha exactly this! There are no less than 4 Sainburys, an M&S food and a Little Waitrose literally within 5 minutes walk or a single bus stop. There's a sainsbury opposite it! There's another Tesco the other side of Chancery Lane

As it's Chancery Lane it will be 99% office workers through the week.

That's why they've chosen it as a trial location. Plenty of other options close by. Time poor, tech savvy people as their main customers.

There was only the big Sainsburys on the Holborn tube corner but 10 years ago when I was at law school there. Somehow the 'many council tenants and elderly' made do with that

ThinWomansBrain · 29/11/2021 01:37

A bigger concern is the trend of city centre express-type branches of large stores that were pivoted from being a small store with a decent range of basics, to glorified sandwich shops, with the majority of shelf spaces given over to lunch based stuff and very little else. (Shelf of tea, coffee and biscuits also for local office population).
Local residents do not need/want to buy endless sandwiches/salads and microwave meals.

The plus side of covid lockdown and fewer office workers is that the ginormous sushi counters have quietly closed and we have a fresh fish counter again. Grin

DaisyNGO · 29/11/2021 00:58

@Magicpaintbrush

Hell would freeze over before I'd use a store like this. I'm sick of technology, sick of living our lives through screens, can't be arsed to set an app up with payment on my phone just so I can buy a fecking bag of apples. What is so much easier about this than the traditional way of buying stuff?? Select bag of apples, swipe barcode, tap contactless card on machine, leave. It's just smart-arsedness for the sake of it because they can, not because the majority of people want it. I'm tired of life being over complicated by irritating changes I neither need nor want. And phones aren't impervious to buffering (blue circle of doom), shit signal, glitching - gaah! Changes go away!!! I don't ever ever want to shop through an app in store, it can piss right off.
With you

OP I think there's some hope

The smart motorways, driverless cars and drone deliveries are way behind what the plan was for 2020.

safariboot · 29/11/2021 00:37

I agree with your concerns.

Low-end smartphones aren't exceptionally expensive but they still cost as much as one person's food for a week. For someone living truly hand-to-mouth, immediately replacing a broken smartphone is either impossible or pushes them into debt. Smartphones also do require learning to use and therefore a certain level of mental ability.

For that matter a system that makes it almost impossible to know how much you'll be charged before you are charged it will also be very damaging to those on a low income. I'm sure we've all seen, and perhaps been, someone asking the checkout worker to put an item back because the shop costs more than the customer can afford. Or pointing out that a reduction or offer hadn't rung up as expected. All impossible with this kind of checkout-free system.

By contrast using cash or debit card costs the customer nothing and the mental skill required is lower.

One test store probably seems like no big deal. But if this is extended across a whole chain, and chances are they're the cheapest, it becomes yet another way that being poor or disabled is expensive. If it becomes common for all supermarkets it's a serious issue.

I think Parliament should in the near future seriously consider laws that businesses have to accept certain payment methods, in order to protect the ability of all people to access products and services.

I'll close by saying that of course Tesco will get "loads of positive responses from customers" - because the people who can't or won't use a checkout-free store won't be customers responding!

Magicpaintbrush · 29/11/2021 00:10

Hell would freeze over before I'd use a store like this. I'm sick of technology, sick of living our lives through screens, can't be arsed to set an app up with payment on my phone just so I can buy a fecking bag of apples. What is so much easier about this than the traditional way of buying stuff?? Select bag of apples, swipe barcode, tap contactless card on machine, leave. It's just smart-arsedness for the sake of it because they can, not because the majority of people want it. I'm tired of life being over complicated by irritating changes I neither need nor want. And phones aren't impervious to buffering (blue circle of doom), shit signal, glitching - gaah! Changes go away!!! I don't ever ever want to shop through an app in store, it can piss right off.