Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that that this will not end well

63 replies

subtlesue · 28/11/2021 14:54

A is a 60 year old widow with 2 adult children. She owns approx £300 equity in her house. All children moved out, all renting and struggling for deposits. She works part time at minimum wage. If relevant, £150k of that equity came from life insurance pay out when her late husband (father of the children) died 15 years ago.

B is a 60 year old divorced man with 4 adult children all moved out and renting. He has about £200 equity in his house and earns about £50-60k/year.

A and B have been dating for 10 years and now all the children have moved out they want to move in together, no intention to marry. All children support the relationship and are happy for them that they can now live together properly.

Here is where it gets a bit complex.

A and B are planning to put equity together and buy for approx £400k keeping some as savings in the bank.

A and B both, in the event of their untimely death, want the equity that they have put into the house to be available to their children relatively quickly, and not for them to have to wait for their 'step parent' to die which could be another 20 years.

Is there any way legally that this can be done, or must we rely on the good will of the living partner that they would organise for the release of equity (most likely downsize I suppose)?

No one is suggesting that a bereaved partner should be evicted suddenly. Honestly- no one in the two families is horrible. But surely something formal
needs deciding and something 'put in place' in advance so that everything is clear and all are prepared should something happen to one of the partners. It seems immoral to me that if A were to die, then B could be living in a house with £150k worth of A's children's fathers life insurance money. But also seems immoral that he would be expected to move out of his home to release the equity when he's just lost his partner. And there would be other difficult situations if B were to die and A to live.

So, to my AIBU- A and B keep saying they will 'make sure' that things are set up so that their equity would be released, AIBU to say that this won't be possible and there would be an awful complex situation?

OP posts:
JustLyra · 28/11/2021 18:51

@MsAgnesDiPesto

How about renting out both family homes, and renting a place together using the proceeds? Then the ownership stays within each ‘family’ and each house could be sold independently as the owner dies, to benefit their own children.

This seems a very simple solution, so I wonder if there is something I’m not seeing about it!

That seems like a good option. I guess the big worries would be - the cost of being a Landlord (in monetary and stress terms as they age), both properties would be subject to Capital Gains Tax when sold, the families would have to deal with tenants at the difficult time of the death of their parent, and they'd have to rent somewhere they could individually afford as once the first partner dies the other wouldn't be able to kick out their tenants quickly to move back into their mortgage free house.
EdgeOfTheSky · 28/11/2021 18:44

New house owned jointly rather than as tenants in common. The percentage owned by each to reflect the capital contribution

It is Tenants In Common that ensures that each can own a specific portion of the property and Will it to who they wish.

So: a careful discussion with a solicitor when they buy, and a detailed discussion with a lawyer to make a will.

If they buy as Joint Tenants the property reverts to the surviving partner in the death of the first.

StillWeRise · 28/11/2021 18:42

DP is the stepchild in this situation. His DM sold her property and kept the cash (well invested I suppose) when she died her entire estate bar a cash sum went to her new husband (DP's DF died many years ago) On new husbands death his estate to be split between his 2 children and DP. None of this was discussed in advance just 'you'll be alright'- the cash sum probably seemed very generous when the will was written but did not rise with inflation. So now DP's inheritance from both of his parents depends on it not being spent on care home etc, or the step father not writing a new will.
Which all sounds very grabby, but we faced a lot of issues from his DM when he inherited from her brother (unfairly she felt0
so my advice is be very open and upfront about it.

MsAgnesDiPesto · 28/11/2021 18:38

How about renting out both family homes, and renting a place together using the proceeds? Then the ownership stays within each ‘family’ and each house could be sold independently as the owner dies, to benefit their own children.

This seems a very simple solution, so I wonder if there is something I’m not seeing about it!

Wilma55 · 28/11/2021 18:37

If either let their house and move in with partner won't capital gains tax apply?

slothbyday · 28/11/2021 18:33

what will happen if they need to sell the property to pay for care as they get older? That could potentially swallow up deceased fathers inheritance for step dads care if they are not careful with how the ownership is legally worded.

I would vote for rent one property out and live in the other

JustLyra · 28/11/2021 18:32

@Merryoldgoat

Are they both mortgage-free? If so live in one, rent out the other. It’s surely a no-brainer?
They'd need to take proper advice on that as well.

The house that was rented out would be subject to Capital Gains Tax if sold without becoming a home again.

Plus being a Landlord is a big responsibility and can be expensive - especially at the moment when evicting a non-paying tenant can take many, many months because of the court backlog.

Merryoldgoat · 28/11/2021 18:27

Are they both mortgage-free? If so live in one, rent out the other. It’s surely a no-brainer?

gwenneh · 28/11/2021 18:27

This happened in my family.

A & B were dating and lived separately for years. A owned 100% of a house, B owned 100% of a flat, no mortgages. When A & B moved in together, B sold their flat and purchased 45% of the equity in A's house. A wanted to retain majority equity and kept 55%. They elected to be tenants in common, and had the solicitors draw that up with the sale documents and their wills.

A died a few years later. A's will specified that their 55% of equity went to A's children alone, and that they were to offer B first refusal if selling. A's children offered to allow B to buy their share of equity at the appraised market value, and B did so, which released the money immediately. The total time from A's passing to a bank deposit was around 8 weeks, made possible by the easy wills in place and the cooperation between A's survivors and B.

If B had opted not to purchase the remaining equity A's heirs had a few choices:

  • retain the equity until B opted to sell on B's terms
  • apply to the court for an order for sale and force the sale on A's heirs' terms (yes, you can force someone to sell as tenants in common)
  • buy B out of the property

Your A & B need to discuss their options with a solicitor because it IS possible to do what they're trying to do and protect their heirs, but it takes understanding of the options, along with proper wills and tenants in common.

JustLyra · 28/11/2021 18:27

There's something in particularly bad taste about the 'struggling for deposits', the minimum wage job reference and then highlighting the insurance payment for being widowed young.

Buying in a way that keeps individual ownership and not marrying is protecting the inheritance for the children. They'll likely just have to wait until they get it. Be that right after their parent's death or after the death of their parent's partner.

Arren12 · 28/11/2021 18:17

No advice but this is so glum. I get its wise to think about the future but this just seems so grabby of the dc. I have firmly told my parent to spend my inherentence they have planned on themselves, enjoying their remaining years. Blow it on cake gor all I care its their hard earned money. I'm just glad I get to enjoy time with them now.
In my opinion a and b should move in together enjoy the love and life they have and stuff the dc. They obviously care about each other after 10 years so they should look after each other the dc can sort themselves out.

Hertsgirl10 · 28/11/2021 18:13

What I see here is 2 people that have worked hard their whole lives and moving in together, and all their children/grandchildren shitting themselves that they won’t get their cut of what they think they’re owed, this is awful I can’t believe so many people think they’re entitled to their parents money. What if the couple decided to both sell up, rent and spend all their money on expensive cruises and enjoy the rest of their lives living off all they’ve earned their lives? Would you all kick off and tell them how out of order they are 😂

Earn your own money and if you’re lucky enough to be left money then good for you but bloody hell they are 60 years old and doing what’s good for them, no one else’s business.

girlmom21 · 28/11/2021 17:59

Is the £300 equity a typo?

How much are both houses worth?

JustLyra · 28/11/2021 17:56

They can't both have the surviving partner living in the house long term and release the money quickly. Not without some sort of equity release and that will be costly for the surviving partner as they're generally a bit a rip off.

They also need to take proper legal advice about care fees. Councils are getting much harder on chasing fees so it'll be massively expensive not to take proper advice and make sure the ownership is set up very properly.

Ultimately though there's nothing anyone else can do - A & B will set it up how they like and others will just have to deal with it. Even if it is done in a way they think is immoral.

It is a minefield.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 28/11/2021 17:51

FWIW another possibility is for let’s say A to keep her house and rent it whilst she lives in B house.
If A dies, inheritance goes to her dcs.
If B dies, A can move back into her own home and inheritance goes to B’s dcs….

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 28/11/2021 17:50

Both A and B need legal advice. But the idea that the money will be easily available if everything is tidy up in the house doesn’t sound logical.

The reality is that it will either be waiting for the other partner to die/move to a smaller (?) property. Or expecting the grieving partner to move out to the marital home.
But most importantly they both need wills. Extremely clear wills where they will be able to leave their share to their own dcs.
Because my experience of inheritance is that they will all want different things. The children from the grieving parent will want them to stay in the house whilst the ones receiving the inheritance will be in a hurry to get said inheritance. So setting everything up is essential, whatever they decide to do.

Albanian · 28/11/2021 17:49

What would happen if the remaining partner needed care that had to be financed? They then would not be allowed to pass on the equity from the property but instead be used for the care home fees (and it is remarkable how quickly any capital can be gone through). And if the equity from the property had already been given to the children, and the remaining partner THEN needed care, there could be difficult legal problems to overcome.

Frazzled50yrold · 28/11/2021 17:34

They're relatively young and could live for decades.It may be sensible to make inheritance plans but perhaps wishing them well and worrying less about their estate would be more positive.

alwayswrighty · 28/11/2021 17:29

They can do whole of life insurance in trust so that the survivor can buy the children out as well. Given their age it may be costly though.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 28/11/2021 17:27

Presumably if one of them ends up in a care home that equity would also be needed to pay for their care, so the children wouldn't get it anyway? Has that been considered?

Abigail12345654321 · 28/11/2021 17:25

Not clear why it would be ‘unfair’ for children to wait for the step parent to die even if it is 20 years.

More normal surely that’s they leave their assets to their children legally, but give their partner the right to live there for life. After all, this is the person each of them loves. They may not be marrying and sharing their worldly goods forever, but not unreasonable to share them for both their lifetimes.

The stepchildren involved sound entitled and grabby. They should perhaps suggest this solution to their parents and stop being so selfish. The parents are not marrying, probably to protect their children’s inheritance and perhaps the children should be as generous in return. Both would most likely hate to see the other forced to move after they die and neither should have to live in a lower value properly for their time together just to convenience their children later!

Bluntness100 · 28/11/2021 17:13

@madroid

You can release the equity on a house without moving out. It's very common.

It's like a mortgage but with interest added to the end value which is paid back when the second partner moves out of the house.

Don’t do this it’s an absolute rip off.
AcrossthePond55 · 28/11/2021 16:55

I'm in the US, so take it for what it's worth. Not sure if UK does home titles the same as we do. But a friend dealt with this years ago. They ended up as 'tenants in common' because her husband wanted to guarantee that his share of their house went to his children.

If one owns a house as 'joint tenants' then in the event of death, the survivor becomes 'sole owner' and can dispose of the house how they wish. This means that they could sell the house and NOT share the profits with the deceased person's heirs. Or they could will the house to whomever they choose.

If one owns a house as 'tenants in common' each share of the house is owned as separate property and the owner can dispose of their share as they wish. In the event of their death their share goes to the person(s) they have designated (ie their children/siblings/cat's home).
However, it would take a court order to force the surviving 'occupier' to sell the house so the deceased's heirs can get their share.

Personally, as a financially secure senior with grown children, if I were to become single I would never jointly purchase a home with a partner. I would NEVER sell my home as part of moving in with someone. I would never co-mingle finances in any way. Actually, I'd never cohabit. I like my space and not having to 'consult' with anyone on my decisions.

When my auntie remarried she and her new hubby got a legally drawn up 'right and tight' ironclad pre-nup (enforceable here) leaving each one's property and assets to their own children. They kept both houses and just moved back and forth as the whim took them.

Bottom line is this couple needs to consult separate solicitors as to what is best for them as individuals. Then go from there to see if there is a workable agreement.

madroid · 28/11/2021 16:54

You can release the equity on a house without moving out. It's very common.

It's like a mortgage but with interest added to the end value which is paid back when the second partner moves out of the house.

elliejjtiny · 28/11/2021 16:50

Something similar happened in my family. My relative died first and then my step relative died 25 years later. Money was shared equally between all the dc when my step relative died.