Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that that this will not end well

63 replies

subtlesue · 28/11/2021 14:54

A is a 60 year old widow with 2 adult children. She owns approx £300 equity in her house. All children moved out, all renting and struggling for deposits. She works part time at minimum wage. If relevant, £150k of that equity came from life insurance pay out when her late husband (father of the children) died 15 years ago.

B is a 60 year old divorced man with 4 adult children all moved out and renting. He has about £200 equity in his house and earns about £50-60k/year.

A and B have been dating for 10 years and now all the children have moved out they want to move in together, no intention to marry. All children support the relationship and are happy for them that they can now live together properly.

Here is where it gets a bit complex.

A and B are planning to put equity together and buy for approx £400k keeping some as savings in the bank.

A and B both, in the event of their untimely death, want the equity that they have put into the house to be available to their children relatively quickly, and not for them to have to wait for their 'step parent' to die which could be another 20 years.

Is there any way legally that this can be done, or must we rely on the good will of the living partner that they would organise for the release of equity (most likely downsize I suppose)?

No one is suggesting that a bereaved partner should be evicted suddenly. Honestly- no one in the two families is horrible. But surely something formal
needs deciding and something 'put in place' in advance so that everything is clear and all are prepared should something happen to one of the partners. It seems immoral to me that if A were to die, then B could be living in a house with £150k worth of A's children's fathers life insurance money. But also seems immoral that he would be expected to move out of his home to release the equity when he's just lost his partner. And there would be other difficult situations if B were to die and A to live.

So, to my AIBU- A and B keep saying they will 'make sure' that things are set up so that their equity would be released, AIBU to say that this won't be possible and there would be an awful complex situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Abigail12345654321 · 30/11/2021 23:41

Also am not suggesting the partner inherit - the children will inherit but would simply leave the assets tied up in the house where they are until the death of the surviving partner. Legally the children would own a share in the house.

Abigail12345654321 · 30/11/2021 23:39

@subtlesue

Think I've got a friend for life in *@Abigail12345654321* Grin

This is what they want to happen with their money if they die. It's not something I've orchestrated.

I think in 30 years time if I were in the same situation I would want the same- for my children to get the money rather than my partner who already has over £200k of his own.

But you carry on!

I will!

@girlmom21 How on earth has £500k equity turned into £1.5m? They plan to buy a house worth £400k and keep £100k as a cash asset. Chucking the cash asset at the kids to shut them up (not that they have given you reason to think they need shutting up!) would be rather daft.

Op, it’s possibly they haven’t considered the mental and physical upheaval the surviving party will suffer if forced to move. Perhaps you could suggest you wouldn’t dream of uprooting the surviving partner if your parent died, just so you can realise your inheritance at that point? Sounds like the kids in this situation need to step up and behave honourably.

rose69 · 30/11/2021 08:01

Moving in older age is horrendous. Expecting a grieving partner to do so seems harsh. Savings may have been used for care etc.

Hertsgirl10 · 30/11/2021 07:49

The fact that the title says this won’t end well, shows exactly what you’re worried about. This whole thing is about money, imagine the other parent passes away and your parent has to move asap to free up the others money, I would be livid, in old age moving can be a huge trigger for dementia getting worse, if someone has already has it in early stages.
You have not even considered if either needs caring for.
And the fact that they are only 60 and you’re worried about inheritance and saying now that this is how they want it is shocking, they want to sell their homes and live together, so what?

Also it’s not your dad’s insurance money it s hers, imagine if they decided to get married would you stand up in the wedding and say no what about our inheritance money.

CapBarnacles · 30/11/2021 07:48

My parent and their partner have this set up and it was decided that the remaining one has two years before they have to move out and sell. I had nothing to do with the arrangement BTW, no involvement in discussion, they came to this agreement themselves.

AndMatt · 30/11/2021 07:43

I just don't think anyone's thought about the reality, they're all (including parents) too busy thinking about the money.

AndMatt · 30/11/2021 07:40

[quote subtlesue]@AndMatt who said within weeks? That wasn't me. The only timeframe I said was in reference to not waiting 2 years. Big difference.
And whilst they might be elderly, it could also happen in 2 years time when they are very much not elderly. [/quote]
OK. Is that what you want for your parent, who's just as likely to be the evicted one?

My DH died early this year. I'm young and fit and capable. I haven't begun to go through his stuff yet. The idea that I'd have to force myself to clear out his stuff and leave the house on someone else's timescale would break me. (More than I am already).

subtlesue · 30/11/2021 07:36

*not waiting 20 years

OP posts:
subtlesue · 30/11/2021 07:36

@AndMatt who said within weeks? That wasn't me. The only timeframe I said was in reference to not waiting 2 years. Big difference.
And whilst they might be elderly, it could also happen in 2 years time when they are very much not elderly.

OP posts:
AndMatt · 30/11/2021 07:20

@subtlesue

Think I've got a friend for life in *@Abigail12345654321* Grin

This is what they want to happen with their money if they die. It's not something I've orchestrated.

I think in 30 years time if I were in the same situation I would want the same- for my children to get the money rather than my partner who already has over £200k of his own.

But you carry on!

They each want their spouse (and themselves) to have to leave their home within weeks of their partner's death? The reality is that the children will be effectively evicting a very elderly recently bereaved person. Even if the will/arrangements allow it, would you actually do it?
subtlesue · 30/11/2021 07:11

Think I've got a friend for life in @Abigail12345654321 Grin

This is what they want to happen with their money if they die. It's not something I've orchestrated.

I think in 30 years time if I were in the same situation I would want the same- for my children to get the money rather than my partner who already has over £200k of his own.

But you carry on!

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 30/11/2021 06:55

@Abigail12345654321 if they've got nearly £1.5m worth of houses they could very easily downsize, give everyone a nominal amount and have plenty to live off.

The kids are clearly only interested in their inheritances so fobbing them off with £50k each would take the pressure off the parents.

everyonebutme · 30/11/2021 06:54

Similar situation for me. We have a deed of trust drawn up as one of us has more equity in the house and a will which says the other can live continue to live in the house for five years, subject to maintaining it, etc after the death of the other. I think this is a reasonable amount of time given the fact that the other will be grief stricken and have a lot to deal with for a while. It makes me sad to know that if my partner dies first I will have to sell my home and move but it's the sad fact of life. We are also not married and it makes me sad that this is not advised as well.

Abigail12345654321 · 30/11/2021 06:27

@AndMatt

It's not the father's life insurance money. It's the mother's money. Presumably it paid of the mortgage to allow her (and the children?) to stay in the house. She could just have easily have spent paying the mortgage or on other living costs or a world cruise.

Both parties should see a solicitor, but if they've been together for 10 years and are married for a further x years, I'd think the spouse should inherit at least the right to live in the house.

Hear hear! Well said……
Abigail12345654321 · 30/11/2021 06:26

@girlmom21

Why don't they sell both houses, downsize and give everyone a chunk of 'inheritance' now?
Because they are not a charitable institution and still need to fund the rest of their own lives?

This thread astonishes me.

Abigail12345654321 · 30/11/2021 06:24

@MsAgnesDiPesto

How about renting out both family homes, and renting a place together using the proceeds? Then the ownership stays within each ‘family’ and each house could be sold independently as the owner dies, to benefit their own children.

This seems a very simple solution, so I wonder if there is something I’m not seeing about it!

Well if the couple are setting up home together they might prefer to own it so they can decorate it how they please, renovate it, put up pictures and not worry if they spill a bit of paint on a carpet. Oh and not worry the landlord will decide they want the property back in six months forcing them to move. What an attractive idea - just to convenience their horrid children.
Abigail12345654321 · 30/11/2021 06:19

@PerfectlyUnsuitable

FWIW another possibility is for let’s say A to keep her house and rent it whilst she lives in B house. If A dies, inheritance goes to her dcs. If B dies, A can move back into her own home and inheritance goes to B’s dcs….
So a couple who could live in a lovely big property or in a nicer area together should sacrifice that for the convenience of their grabby entitled children? Why?
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/11/2021 20:39

But there are some very good imaginative solutions here!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 28/11/2021 20:38

I thought that was just called being tenants in common? So your half remains your own and you can leave it to whoever you want.

Joint tenants is where you own the whole thing together, and whoever survives keeps the whole

AndMatt · 28/11/2021 19:40

It's not the father's life insurance money. It's the mother's money. Presumably it paid of the mortgage to allow her (and the children?) to stay in the house. She could just have easily have spent paying the mortgage or on other living costs or a world cruise.

Both parties should see a solicitor, but if they've been together for 10 years and are married for a further x years, I'd think the spouse should inherit at least the right to live in the house.

girlmom21 · 28/11/2021 19:12

Why don't they sell both houses, downsize and give everyone a chunk of 'inheritance' now?

subtlesue · 28/11/2021 19:03

I don't think they will be keen to become landlords, nor would they want to rent together. (Fair enough). But thank you for all helpful suggestions, definitely give us ideas to think on.

Re £300 equity, I missed off the 'k', it's £300,000

OP posts:
pianolessons1 · 28/11/2021 19:02

Easy stuff for a solicitor to draft, would suggest the bereaved partner is given a year to move out.

subtlesue · 28/11/2021 19:01

Thanks for comments, I will reply to several at once as tagging is not straight forward on a phone Smile

Both A&B have explicitly said that in the event of their death they want their children to get the inheritance relatively quickly when they die. This is their preference. So whilst as a beneficiary of this I am pro this plan, it is not something I am pushing or have instigated. I've started this thread to understand if there are options and pitfalls so that I can support them in any way I can to coming to a decision that they are happy with.

My personal view is that I'd rather come across as a bit distasteful but everyone be in an informed and planned position than be found in the difficult situations examples by many PP below.

Being prepared for the worst is pretty normal in life, I'm not wishing them dead by discussing potential outcomes- is that what you would say to those who take out life insurance?

OP posts:
harriethoyle · 28/11/2021 19:00

@PerfectlyUnsuitable this is EXACTLY what I was going to suggest. Much more certainty all round.