Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Incompetent family members

116 replies

Notsomerryandbright · 28/11/2021 11:44

How do you broach family members who can't deal with everyday things in life?

I mean things like family members who can drive, have a car but won't go beyond their immediate vicinity so ask for lifts/ collections but are very picky about when etc.

Storm damage yesterday but they won't call a handyman or tradespeople so ask us so we had to go round in the afternoon.

Have debit cards but refuse to use them online because it's not safe so ask us to order and then get given cash.

They aren't even old which is the most frustrating thing, late 20s, so it's just incompetence. They don't have a partner and lives alone with his cats.

I'm not begrudging helping people we love but it just feels like these are things that adults should be able to do independently!

OP posts:
ufucoffee · 28/11/2021 16:20

People like him really annoy me. He has choices in life. He is capable of making choices. People doing things for him are enabling him. So what if the things that need doing don't get done because you don't go round. His choice. Won't drive out of immediate vicinity? Then things he wants don't get picked up, that's his fault. He sounds like a child and your kindness is keeping him a child.

lanthanum · 28/11/2021 16:11

I agree with Muchmorethan - wean him off the help by giving him the first step - the phone number of a suitable tradesperson, a link to advice on how to use online payments safely, etc.

Driving - broach with him what the issue is. If he is lacking in confidence, then perhaps you can suggest he gives you a lift somewhere, so that he can have some practice with someone beside him (I know I appreciated that when I was a new driver). Or would a couple of lessons with a local driving instructor be useful, as a refresher?

Muchmorethan · 28/11/2021 15:50

I think a gentle retreat is needed.

So instead of sorting out the storm damage, give him the number of who you use..... he then knows they are "safe" .. and leave him to contact them.

Grey rock approach if he asks you to sort it out. i.e "can't you phone them?" "No you have the number" "but why" " because you have the number too" "I'll wait till you can do it" " l won't as you have the number" etc

SpaceshiptoMars · 28/11/2021 15:41

Is your brother Sheldon Cooper? (BBT)

Cameleongirl · 28/11/2021 15:23

Certain things like driving outside familiar areas and ordering online can be learned with a bit of help - could his brother say that he's willing to accompany him on some longer drives to practice and perhaps suggest that he gets a credit card for online orders as they offer better protection from fraud.

Re. Home repairs. He'll need to start hiring people if he can't learn how to do it himself. I'm not very handy, but there are lots of great videos on Youtube demonstrating how to do DIY, even I've managed to do some things using them. If I really can't figure it out, I hire someone.

Daleksatemyshed · 28/11/2021 15:10

Since they have no SN then you need to be less available Op. Lots of people saying you need to walk them through things but if they are University educated they must know what needs doing, just much easier to let you do it for them. Stop now or you'll be at their beck and call forever.

itsallgoingpearshaped · 28/11/2021 15:01

Just say no. tough love

Thadhiya · 28/11/2021 14:41

I wouldn't even entertain them. I'd just laugh and say no. I have a helpless relative like this, but everyone just says to get off her lazy arse and no one does the things they ask. If someone wants a servant they can go and hire one. You all need to learn to say 'no' more often.

TiddlesTheTiger · 28/11/2021 14:38

they won't ... so we had to go round in the afternoon.

You didn't have to - you chose to.

Tell him to get a credit card and use it only online.
If he thinks it's risky to buy online, why would he ask you to do it?
He can buy stuff in shops, if he doesn't like online.

People are giving you lots of good advice but you don't sound as if you want to take it - just like your family member.

julieca · 28/11/2021 14:31

I think you need to help them resolve this. Because IME although people are more understanding of young people failing to cope, they are not with older people. They simply wont get the help when older.

RampantIvy · 28/11/2021 14:31

@HarveyandGarvey

Buy them a gps for Christmas? Smile
SIL got one as a birthday present one year and has never used it. She just won't drive anywhere unfamiliar.
Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 28/11/2021 14:30

If this is someone close to you then I’d spend a bit more time walking it through with them e.g helping them register their card for Amazon and Tesco, talking through with them the fraud policies of their bank, helping them access pass plus so they have more confidence with driving etc.
Sounds like they could have an undiagnosed condition either anxiety or anxiety as a symptom of another condition. I’d be compassionate, patient with baby steps, proactively helpful etc but I wouldn’t just proper up the status quo with no change whatsoever.

HarveyandGarvey · 28/11/2021 14:22

Buy them a gps for Christmas? Smile

TheCovidScoorge · 28/11/2021 14:21

Also the car thing.

Show them routes they can take on the bus/train/tram to the places they want to go too. Make yourself unavailable to take them, and hopefully he gets the courage to use the routes you've shown.

HarveyandGarvey · 28/11/2021 14:20

The obvious question is, have you addressed it with him, not in a confrontational way, but in a gentle probing way?

What does he say if so?

Some people - especially well-educated people with good jobs - are very very embarrassed and reluctant to admit to suffering from anxiety. It is a question of pride (wierdly when they are not too proud to ask for help).

Or were they always indulged as a child and he is still playing out that role perhaps? Some people as adults can "revert" to the role they played as a child in the family hierarchy.

Surely if you question "why" he won't use on-line banking or suggest he gets some support with driving lessons outside of his local area (driving schools offer lessons to returnee drivers with licenses) then he will get the hint that you are not that keen on doing things for him that he can do for himself?

TheCovidScoorge · 28/11/2021 14:19

He sounds a bit like me!

I have a car, I can drive but I won't drive further than a few miles because of crippling aniexty.

I would be patient and explain they can use their debit card online without problems and maybe ask them to make a purchase and see for themselves. Once the initial worry is proven wrong, they should feel better.

Have they been tested for autism? Because that alone I can see traits.

ESGdance · 28/11/2021 14:12

@Notsomerryandbright

No there's no SEN. He has a degree, is highly educated and has always had a decent job. No autism or social difficulties, he has a good social life with lots of friends, just very restricted in other ways.

They had the same upbringing as my dh and he is fully functional. I know it sounds judgemental but I'm really not and do try to help, I do care and love him very much. I dont even think it's anxiety related, he does do things. He will go on holiday with friends but would pay over the odds for a package holiday instead of booking flight and hotel because its better.

I don't know how to help him. We could be less available but then from past experience whatever they need/want would just wait until we had time. I don't know how to say I think you need to start being more independent without offending or having him laugh it off.

I think it's going to hold him back massively though because I don't think many prospective partners would find it appealing having to baby someone his age through certain things

“I don't know how to say I think you need to start being more independent without offending or having him laugh it off.”

Is it you scared of asserting yourself, responding with very normal boundaries or have you seen this difficult humiliating or defensive / dysfunctional emotional response from him before?

Are you all tip-toeing around him?

Or are you tip-toeing around your DH?

Have you had the conversation with your DH?

None of this needs to be confrontational - just calm, repeated No and/or sign post how to do something once - if you know it’s for his own benefit to learn new stuff then you will feel better about standing your ground if that’s a problem for you - or if you know he is volatile / sulky / manipulative / controlling / exploitative - then you need the same approach to protect yourself …..

daisypond · 28/11/2021 14:09

He will go on holiday with friends but would pay over the odds for a package holiday instead of booking flight and hotel because its better.

That’s normal, though. Lots of people pay extra for package holidays - there’s lots of advantages to them. The other things could be executive function disorder. Not saying that they are, but they could be. I find a lot of everyday living extremely difficult, and I have several degrees and hold down a job.

NowEvenBetter · 28/11/2021 13:54

If he’d laugh off you saying no, laugh off his demands. Ridiculous that you’ve allowed this situation. Say nah. Don’t provide any lists or arse wiping or excuses. Ffs.

WhenSepEnds · 28/11/2021 13:49

@Notsomerryandbright

How do you broach family members who can't deal with everyday things in life?

I mean things like family members who can drive, have a car but won't go beyond their immediate vicinity so ask for lifts/ collections but are very picky about when etc.

Storm damage yesterday but they won't call a handyman or tradespeople so ask us so we had to go round in the afternoon.

Have debit cards but refuse to use them online because it's not safe so ask us to order and then get given cash.

They aren't even old which is the most frustrating thing, late 20s, so it's just incompetence. They don't have a partner and lives alone with his cats.

I'm not begrudging helping people we love but it just feels like these are things that adults should be able to do independently!

I would tell them how to do something if they didn't know and if they were still asking you to do it for them, I would say 'well now you know as much as I do .....'
tulips27 · 28/11/2021 13:45

I had a friend who "didn't know how" to use her cards online, despite me offering lots of solutions such as using a credit card with online shopping protection or having a separate account with a small amount to limit any loss etc.

A few weeks into the pandemic and faced with no other choice (she's CEV) and suddenly she worked it out somehow. Hmm

Concestor · 28/11/2021 13:42

@Notsomerryandbright

No there's no SEN. He has a degree, is highly educated and has always had a decent job. No autism or social difficulties, he has a good social life with lots of friends, just very restricted in other ways.

They had the same upbringing as my dh and he is fully functional. I know it sounds judgemental but I'm really not and do try to help, I do care and love him very much. I dont even think it's anxiety related, he does do things. He will go on holiday with friends but would pay over the odds for a package holiday instead of booking flight and hotel because its better.

I don't know how to help him. We could be less available but then from past experience whatever they need/want would just wait until we had time. I don't know how to say I think you need to start being more independent without offending or having him laugh it off.

I think it's going to hold him back massively though because I don't think many prospective partners would find it appealing having to baby someone his age through certain things

None of those things mean there's no SEN. I'm educated, have had decent jobs, have friends and a social life. I was diagnosed autistic last year.

He definitely has autistic traits, I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss it.

However, you also don't have to do things for him if you don't want to, but I would be very concerned about him and his ability to cope with life, personally, and would be urging him to look into what might lie behind it.

SEN or not, he needs coping mechanisms to help him navigate life.

AnneLovesGilbert · 28/11/2021 13:42

Are his parents still around? Why has this fallen to you? It’s your DP’s family so his problem, don’t get involved.

Masugamanuts · 28/11/2021 13:42

@StopGo

Stop enabling them, have better boundaries.
This.
WaitingForSunshineAndDaisies · 28/11/2021 13:38

By the way, lots of people with ASD have a degree, job and social life - it doesn't stop those things if they're high functioning (as someone who's about to pack her ASD son to Uni).