Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get 18m old DC second hand toys for Christmas?

85 replies

NC4THISS · 28/11/2021 07:39

For the price of one new item, we can totally overhaul the play area with many many new things that are in great condition, already put together and have a lesser impact on the environment.

DH seems to think it’s a bit off since we could afford to get all these items new, but I don’t think spending hundreds on a bloody toddler is a great idea when things can be found for a fraction of the price. My thoughts are they’ll never know it’s second hand, just play with it and then I’ll sell it on/give it away in the future.

For context I also buy myself second hand things if they’re in great condition too, shoes/bags/clothes/phone/car.

OP posts:
venusmay · 28/11/2021 08:13

Yes do it. I've spent a lit of money on dcs gifts brand new but I will also be buying some charity shop toys because I think uts economical and secondhand is perfectly fine.

toolazytothinkofausername · 28/11/2021 08:13

Plastic and wooden toys: second hand is fine.

Soft toys: new is better.

Camomila · 28/11/2021 08:12

DS2 (22m) biggest Christmas present is 2nd hand this year - a happy land train set and extra people. I could afford a new one but I feel guilty buying big plastic things new.

I would make the most of as it's harder buying stuff second hand when they are older - DS1 (5) wouldn't mind about the "newness" aspect but I'm a bit wary of getting big lego etc. second hand in case a tiny bit is missing/it doesn't work properly.

endingintiers · 28/11/2021 08:10

As they get older they tend to ask for specific things for Christmas which are harder to find second hand. I still buy them 2nd hand toys, books and clothes throughout the year but Xmas and birthdays I buy new now. Make the most of being able to reduce costs and reduce environmental footprint!

rumblypumbly · 28/11/2021 08:08

We've gone down the second hand route this year. It started when someone was giving away a huge toy bundle on facebook for free - that basically sorted dd who is only going to be 7m at Christmas. There was a few things suitable for ds who is 4 too. I cleaned it all up and its good as new.
That started me thinking we dont need to buy new, especially when money is tight this year being on mat leave. I also got ds4 main present on FB 2nd hand for £30 instead of £65.

Dont get me wrong we have bought some stuff new but only with vouchers/on sale. But mostly Fb, scouring charity shops and our local 2nd hand toy store which we discovered recently. My older ds who is 8 is harder to buy second hand for as he wants specific hot wheels sets but we got a set in b&m 2 for £20 sale and then another big one in tesco toy sale £17.50 from £30. Hes also asked for Pokemon stuff and again ive found a few second hand bits but had to buy some new.

Ebay is fab as well. I got my neice a limited edition care bear cheap off of there.

Second hand is great, better for the environment too. My kids know some of our stuff is pre loved and dont care. Infact ds8 is all for it as they have been learning about climate change/environment at school. Your lo will love whatever you do OP.

Rosebud100 · 28/11/2021 08:06

I buy second hand toys and clothes for my 1 and 3 year old and some of their Xmas presents are second hand. There are some great bargains, so many toys are as good as new and much better for the environment too.

Caspianberg · 28/11/2021 08:05

Of course. Mil just sent Ds a pile of English books over. All charity shop. There’s about 40 of them and she said all 10p-50p from charity shop. She’s been picking them up all year. They are paperback so he’s a bit young yet, but perfect for next year. Would have cost hundreds new.
We we keep, read and few years, then pass on to someone else

Belledan1 · 28/11/2021 08:04

I did with my dc at that age. A friend who had an older child was selling lots of stuff and let me have it dirt cheap.

saveourtrees · 28/11/2021 08:02

We just finished Christmas shopping. Entirely second hand for our children. New clothes, a new dolls house, a new doll, new books, stocking fillers. Almost everything was second hand except couple of things my DH picked up. We are even going to make cookies instead of buying tubs of sweets.
I even pushed the boat out and got my siblings some second hand branded clothes. I could afford 2 nice expensive shirts, brand spanking new for 6 pounds each. I would usually be spending 20 on one thing for them but only spent 12 and they get double. It makes sense and that means I can afford to buy my parents something nicer. Maybe something for the garden.

fabulous01 · 28/11/2021 08:01

Absolutely.

Save the money for things that will be needed in the future

SalmonEile · 28/11/2021 08:00

I would,
I understand where your DH might be coming from though so perhaps you guys could pop some of the money you would’ve spent on new into a savings account for DC?
It’ll come in handy when they’re older and want a bike or something.
Or use it for days out and such?

vdbfamily · 28/11/2021 08:00

no downside to this at all. We still do this with teenagers and phones/ bicycles/ gym equipment etc. It is better for the planet and better for your wallet and makes absolutely no difference to your child.

Starplek · 28/11/2021 07:59

Ds had loads of second hand toys, most of them were in good enough condition to donate after too. Much better for the environment as well as being better financially.

SW1amp · 28/11/2021 07:58

Completely agree with you.
Good condition second hand makes so much more sense, especially when they are at the age that they don’t know it’s second hand

ThirdElephant · 28/11/2021 07:57

Better for you financially, better for the environment, no difference whatsoever to your kid.

I fail to see a downside.

Dogdogdogdoneit · 28/11/2021 07:57

Go for it

More fool people who buy everything new

Naughtynovembertree · 28/11/2021 07:56

Do it!! Why is it off! As long as they are all clean!
I did this when dc were little out of neccesity, from charity shops, feexyle etc.
It meant once we were fine with them they could be passed back into the system!
Put the money you save into a junior isa for him or a sipp even!!

Holly60 · 28/11/2021 07:53

So much better for the environment too.

lochmaree · 28/11/2021 07:53

we get our toddler almost everything 2nd hand. only things we don't (other than car seats and mattresses) are things that we can't find 2nd hand or can't find in decent quality 2nd hand. for Christmas we will get him a few 2nd hand things spread over a few weeks up to Christmas and he will open family stuff on Christmas day which will be mostly new.

newmumwithquestions · 28/11/2021 07:52

Do it. The mounds of toys they acquire and amount of plastic is horrifying. We need to reuse where we can - there is absolutely no need to buy new, financially or environmentally. I’ve just been perusing eBay for equivalents to the thing my DD has asked for for her birthday to avoid buying mounds of new plastic (it’s going to work out being more plastic, because I can get more toys for the same money, so she is happy and although it’s more plastic I’m happy that it’s reused!)

BeenHereForAges · 28/11/2021 07:52

I loved doing this when mine were little. It also worked great as didnt have to spend an hour or so wrestling packaging and putting stuff together on Christmas day, the elves had already done it! Great idea, go for it and enjoy the bargains.

PrancerandDancer · 28/11/2021 07:49

Nope, I got my DD a second hand play kitchen 2 years ago for Christmas and it's still one of her favourite toys.

This is the first year I haven't bought second hand for her, mainly because the stuff she wanted was more expensive on the selling pages and we got a few good deals.

Seems silly to waste money on new when you don't need to

colourfulpuddles · 28/11/2021 07:49

I would never buy my child secondhand. You don’t know whose had it, where it’s been, how it was looked after.

I understand people buying secondhand if they can’t afford new, but if you have the money I think you should buy new. Not least because it leaves these secondhand items available for poorer families.

Cuppaand2biscuits · 28/11/2021 07:47

Not at all. Better all round, cost, environment, helps out whoever is selling second hand toys.

Ohwhatfunwehad · 28/11/2021 07:47

Yanbu.
Although we tell our children that things are second hand now they are old enough to understand - they still don't care