Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get 18m old DC second hand toys for Christmas?

85 replies

NC4THISS · 28/11/2021 07:39

For the price of one new item, we can totally overhaul the play area with many many new things that are in great condition, already put together and have a lesser impact on the environment.

DH seems to think it’s a bit off since we could afford to get all these items new, but I don’t think spending hundreds on a bloody toddler is a great idea when things can be found for a fraction of the price. My thoughts are they’ll never know it’s second hand, just play with it and then I’ll sell it on/give it away in the future.

For context I also buy myself second hand things if they’re in great condition too, shoes/bags/clothes/phone/car.

OP posts:
RavenclawsRoar · 28/11/2021 09:17

Yanbu! My 2yo is getting a couple of new things and the rest is second hand - a lot has actually been free as friends with similar aged dc have done toy swaps with me. I think it's a great idea.

ThirdElephant · 28/11/2021 09:15

@BatshitBanshee

I wouldn't if I could afford new, just because I don't want to take away the opportunity from parents who actually need to buy secondhand from their DC.

I also don't understand why your DC is a "bloody toddler". Toddler would have sufficed.

More people buy new than second hand, even now. Realistically, second hand needs to become the norm for everyone- go back a hundred years and it was the norm, even for those that could afford new. Just because you can buy it new, doesn't mean you should. For environmental reasons, I've made a rule that plastic comes second hand or from a toy library we subscribe to (I recommend Whirli), wooden I can buy new.
InconvenientPeg · 28/11/2021 09:15

I used to wrap things that hadn't been played with (slightly too old or not the current favourite). Hide for 6 months and regift to the same child 🤷‍♀️

The kids never noticed and I think only one adult ever realised. There's so much stuff that half of it isn't even 'visible'. Then also when I'd bought second hand things, I didn't get pressured into keeping it in the same way. So I was able to pass it on, or give it to the charity shop with much less guilt!

NC4THISS · 28/11/2021 08:50

By ‘bloody toddler’ I’m emphasising the age and therefore the lack of understanding on new/used concepts.. not the toddler themselves.

Great, excellent points I will use to bolster my response as I buy more second hand beauties.

We are staggering over mid December- Christmas then what will be the favourite two we are putting in on Christmas Eve when they’re asleep 🎉.

OP posts:
BatshitBanshee · 28/11/2021 08:47

@BatshitBanshee

I wouldn't if I could afford new, just because I don't want to take away the opportunity from parents who actually need to buy secondhand from their DC.

I also don't understand why your DC is a "bloody toddler". Toddler would have sufficed.

**for their DC.
BatshitBanshee · 28/11/2021 08:46

I wouldn't if I could afford new, just because I don't want to take away the opportunity from parents who actually need to buy secondhand from their DC.

I also don't understand why your DC is a "bloody toddler". Toddler would have sufficed.

Gertie75 · 28/11/2021 08:45

I still buy a lot of second hand for mine and they're 6 and 8, this year the youngest wants Our Generation stuff which is a fortune new, it's a total waste of money essentially paying for the original box which will go in the bin.

She wants the classroom and a couple of dolls which would be over £300 new, I've picked them up for £45 and steamed it all so it's perfectly clean.

I'm surprised by the poster who would rather spend hundreds of pounds extra because she doesn't know who has touched the second hand stuff, even new things have been handled by strangers during production, transport, being put on shelves and then other shoppers picking things up to look and putting them back.

elbea · 28/11/2021 08:44

I went to a ‘toy exchange’ yesterday and swapped some old toys for a box of duplo and a John Deere tractor for my eighteen month old daughter to go with her Christmas presents (toy kitchen and books). She’ll absolutely love them and have no idea they aren’t brand new.

RedRobin100 · 28/11/2021 08:39

Pretty much all the toys I buy for my 18m are secondhand. Including Christmas. Cheaper and much less wasteful / better for environment

EmeraldShamrock · 28/11/2021 08:37

Make the most of being able to reduce costs and reduce environmental footprint!
Which is completely understandable but it knocks a lot of struggling parents out of the 2nd hand market now it is about the environment for the MC.
It is nice to pass on the good bargain karma by donating said toy afterwards or a few tins of beans.
Tbf the more money people have the less they like to spend, I loved charity shops now they're marketed at environmentalism they're too expensive for the people who previously benefited from them.

Morvensea · 28/11/2021 08:34

Fine.

Why ‘a bloody toddler’ though?

Fizbosshoes · 28/11/2021 08:34

I've bought lots of stuff for my DC second hand, even when they are tween/teen.
When they were younger I got hotwheels and sylvanian stuff second hand.
DDs first laptop was £60 from Facebook- it lasted her 3 or 4 years and i wouldn't have afforded her brand new at that stage in our lives. DS first xbox, and 3 of their last 4 phones were all second hand. DD (15) is a big fan of charity shops, boot fairs and the depop website. DH is far less likely to buy second hand stuff but I think that's because it sometimes requires more effort to find

OCM19 · 28/11/2021 08:32

Totally agree with you OP, we’ve bought all of our DC’s presents second hand (apart from his main present as it was in the Black Friday sale and we waited for it). Things like books, toys, puzzles etc. Why would you buy new when you can save and re-home! Great idea. X

EmeraldShamrock · 28/11/2021 08:29

It is a good idea, DD toys were in excellent condition at that age.
If you want to balance out any concerns DH has, donate treats to the food hampers for people less fortunate at the inner city or local food bank, it is a win win.

Blurp · 28/11/2021 08:29

Do it. It's so much cheaper, and better for the environment. Maybe put the money you save into your child's bank account for the future - once DH sees it build up, he might change his tune about secondhand.

Also, if you start young, they get used to the idea - they don't expect toys to come in boxes and they don't question a few scuff marks ("Santa must have had trouble getting it down the chimney!"). We still get secondhand stuff for DS, who's 7.

Moonlaserbearwolf · 28/11/2021 08:29

Agree with you!
My children have had all sorts of second hand toys and clothes over the years. It's saved me a fortune and I pass them on to others afterwards. I like the environmental impact too. On occasion it's also meant my children got a bigger toy that they would have done - I remember one year finding a hideous (!) plastic Disney castle on eBay for a few pounds - it was £150 in the shops and I would never have paid that for it.

softblueface · 28/11/2021 08:27

*all that plastic going into landfill

softblueface · 28/11/2021 08:27

I have seen some brilliant things on fb and gumtree but whenever I message someone has always got there before me Angry
We always sell or give away toys on there though so I feel like we are doing our bit. We have a friend who whenever her kids are done with something they just chuck it! I said please just give it to me and I’ll clean it up and donate it, the thought of all that plastic (as well as it being decent stuff) made me feel sick.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/11/2021 08:25

Not unreasonable at all. Bought second hand for ours and our grandchild is playing with some of it now.

Mol1628 · 28/11/2021 08:24

Absolutely second hand is brilliant.

For our youngest first Christmas he was 10 months old we wrapped his brothers old toys up for him! His brother didn’t remember his baby toys and the baby didn’t care he just enjoyed ripping the paper off stuff.

It is harder now they’re older but as long as things are clean in good condition I really don’t see the problem.

rumblypumbly · 28/11/2021 08:23

I just wanted to add that we sell our stuff on too or give to charity shops and when we buy something second hand or sell/donate something we just say to the kids - someone else has loved this toy/book/jumper before you. Or someone else can love it/use it now. Its the best way ive found to get them used to the idea that things are still good even if they aren't brand new.

PumpkinPie2016 · 28/11/2021 08:22

Not unreasonable at all Smile when my son was about 3, he was obsessed with Thomas the Tank and had been bought one of those little die cast trains by my parents. They were between £7-£12 each Shock

He wanted more trains/track for Christmas but buying new would have cost a bomb.

I bought a big box full if 2nd hand trains/track/Tidmouth sheds/iron works for £40 from a lady on ebay whose child had finished with it. It was in perfect condition and my son was delighted with it.

He has had hours of play out of it and even now, at just turned 8, he still plays with it.

I will definitely be passing it on to someone when he is finished with it.

DanceToTheMusicInMyHead · 28/11/2021 08:19

I've done this loads, especially when younger. I have also wrapped up stuff that the eldest has grown out of as presents for the youngest (though haven't got away with that for a while as they both remember the toys). My mum is always horrified Grin

AuntieMarys · 28/11/2021 08:17

Dh has got his granddaughter a fantastic second hand wooden dolls house with all wooden furniture/ dolls for £20.
Yes he could afford to buy new...but why would you?

BergamotMouse · 28/11/2021 08:16

Absolutely. That's my plan for my 5 and 3 year old. They don't know the difference. I've been selling stuff on vinted and then use my balance to buy toys and clothes. Planning a mostly free Xmas for the kids (it helps that they don't ask for anything specific yet)