Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to get 18m old DC second hand toys for Christmas?

85 replies

NC4THISS · 28/11/2021 07:39

For the price of one new item, we can totally overhaul the play area with many many new things that are in great condition, already put together and have a lesser impact on the environment.

DH seems to think it’s a bit off since we could afford to get all these items new, but I don’t think spending hundreds on a bloody toddler is a great idea when things can be found for a fraction of the price. My thoughts are they’ll never know it’s second hand, just play with it and then I’ll sell it on/give it away in the future.

For context I also buy myself second hand things if they’re in great condition too, shoes/bags/clothes/phone/car.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Newmumatlast · 30/11/2021 16:36

@DoucheCanoe

Mine are 15 and 9 and are both happy to buy/receive second hand stuff - we generally have a mix of new and used depending on availability whether that's for gifting or generally.

9yo is currently lounging around in a "new" mermaid tail blanket that she bought with her own money from eBay - £25 to buy new and cost her £8 Inc postage!

We live within our means on a relatively low budget so second hand makes sense financially and environmentally. It needs to be normalised so that we can produce less new stuff.

I can't recall the poster but they said that wouldn't buy second hand for their kids because you don't know where it's been and that it would be talking away from the poor families... So essentially give the cast offs to the poor because beggars can't be choosers? It hasn't occurred to me that this type of rotten attitude was still around Angry

Funnily enough this year I've donated a bunch of toys to a local charity collecting for those who cannot afford it, all brand new, and my child has a bunch of second hand stuff mixed with some cheap bargains new. She is privileged. She doesn't need a bunch of new things. I prefer to use money saved to spread the wealth.
freshcarnation · 28/11/2021 14:17

Fantastic idea. I have ebay watches for things like 'Fisher Price bundle'. I've got some wonderful stuff

Offmyfence · 28/11/2021 13:29

YANBU

EnidFrighten · 28/11/2021 13:12

@BatshitBanshee

I wouldn't if I could afford new, just because I don't want to take away the opportunity from parents who actually need to buy secondhand from their DC.

I also don't understand why your DC is a "bloody toddler". Toddler would have sufficed.

It's not really that cut and dry, the same parents buying second hand might also be donating to clear stuff out. It's a secondhand marketplace where things are bought, sold and donated - not like a good bank with a finite amount of stuff.
EnidFrighten · 28/11/2021 13:09

At least 80% of my kids' stuff is secondhand. The rest was mostly bought for us as presents.

I hate the feeling of paying over the odds for something they might not play with.

It usually goes back to the charity shop when we're done with it too.

As for not knowing where something has been, tbh it's the same with new stuff to some extent - unless you're going to watch it being made in a Chinese factory and transported across god knows where, stored in another five places, kept in a shop or warehouse etc - nothing is sterile!

ChuckMater · 28/11/2021 13:00

Absolutely go second hand 😊 weve got a baby and a 3yo and actually managed such a cheap Christmas thanks to charity shops and freebies!

MagicBlueberry · 28/11/2021 12:56

It's a great idea!
I used to be one of those people who turned their nose up at second hand, refused to go to Carboot sales or look in charity shop because I didn't know where stuff had been ConfusedHmm
I've been making a massive effort to be more environmentally friendly and I've had to get over my bonkers fear of second hand. DDs main present is from ebay, I've saved over 50% off retail price and there are other additional bits there aswell. Means I can buy DD other bits she will like and she gets to have things I couldn't other wise afford, less stuff going to landfill and no need for more plastic tat to be produced so it really is a no brainer buying second hand.

DoucheCanoe · 28/11/2021 12:55

Mine are 15 and 9 and are both happy to buy/receive second hand stuff - we generally have a mix of new and used depending on availability whether that's for gifting or generally.

9yo is currently lounging around in a "new" mermaid tail blanket that she bought with her own money from eBay - £25 to buy new and cost her £8 Inc postage!

We live within our means on a relatively low budget so second hand makes sense financially and environmentally. It needs to be normalised so that we can produce less new stuff.

I can't recall the poster but they said that wouldn't buy second hand for their kids because you don't know where it's been and that it would be talking away from the poor families... So essentially give the cast offs to the poor because beggars can't be choosers? It hasn't occurred to me that this type of rotten attitude was still around Angry

shenanigans5 · 28/11/2021 12:33

Nearly all DS (age 2) Christmas stocking presents are charity shop. He loves a large volume of plastic crap as he enjoys sorting toys and lining them up so to save £££ and the environment it makes much more sense. For £20 I’ve got about 15 things he’ll play with for a year and then they’ll go back to the charity shop.

Newmumatlast · 28/11/2021 12:29

@NC4THISS

For the price of one new item, we can totally overhaul the play area with many many new things that are in great condition, already put together and have a lesser impact on the environment.

DH seems to think it’s a bit off since we could afford to get all these items new, but I don’t think spending hundreds on a bloody toddler is a great idea when things can be found for a fraction of the price. My thoughts are they’ll never know it’s second hand, just play with it and then I’ll sell it on/give it away in the future.

For context I also buy myself second hand things if they’re in great condition too, shoes/bags/clothes/phone/car.

I'm doing this for my 2 year old. Have bought her mostly secondhand for a while now. Buy new if cannot get a toy I am after or similar either at all or cheap enough
Becles · 28/11/2021 11:43

We do this all the time. I very roughly split the savings like this: 50% into the emergency childcare pot, 25% into their stakeholder pensions (trying to get as much into it before they're 18!) and the other 25% goes into our holiday or household contingency fund (depends on which looks lower).

I've become less likely to buy just because I've panicked they don't have enough the more I'm conscious about what I'm spending. Don't get me wrong, I'm a fan of a bargain and haunt the Christmas threads, but I'm not ashamed anymore.

Trinacham · 28/11/2021 11:25

I think it's OK. At that age it does seem a waste to buy lots of new things.

TheLette · 28/11/2021 11:21

Also I always tell my daughter (4) when I've got her some clothes or toys secondhand. I tell her another little boy or girl also loved the toy but is now too big and wants someone else to play with the toy. She loves hearing that. For her it is normal and when I buy things she often asks "did another little child love this before me?"

Florawest · 28/11/2021 10:13

Definitely buy second hand and consider splitting your savings from not buying new between your child's savings account and children's charities.

NC4THISS · 28/11/2021 10:07

tbf the more money people have the less they like to spend

Isn’t it more the case that I’ve always opted for second hand as a first choice, and therefore saved a serious about of money long term? Rather than just being awfully MC and thinking about the environment.

OP posts:
Frazzled2207 · 28/11/2021 10:05

Yanbu at all!

Family always buy new so the kids always have some new stuff but we try (or rather Santa tries) to get pre-loved

Kids are 6 and 8 now and understand and are fine with it

Sciurus83 · 28/11/2021 10:03

Of course you should. The argument that if you can afford it you should buy new sonpoorer families can afford it is one of the dumbest things I've ever heard. There is far far more second hand and things already made in circulation than there are people buying them, there is no shortage and the level of ignorance to actually think and say that out loud would be funny if it wasn't so utterly stupid.

Username7521 · 28/11/2021 10:02

My daughter has mostly had second hand everything from birth! We also use whirli which is really wonderful. I have a code if anyone wants it to get more money off.

Onlinedilema · 28/11/2021 09:59

Great idea.
I've given away many excellent toys to charity shops.

m4rdybum · 28/11/2021 09:59

Our main presents for our LG this Christmas are second hand. A bike we were given for free (we've bought her a brand new helmet) and then a wooden kitchen with all the accessories (which I got off Facebook for £30 when bramd new it would have cost me about £150).

yikesanotherbooboo · 28/11/2021 09:56

The children either won't know or won't mind and for the environment and your purse it is a no brainer.

TheLette · 28/11/2021 09:48

Secondhand for sure! I disagree with people objecting to secondhand generally - do their kids not go to nursery or playgroups, the toys there aren't brought out new each day. Much better for the environment and your pocket. I wouldn't use the savings to buy more stuff, kids get overwhelmed if they have too many presents. Get a few quality things and put any saving in their ISAs. We are trying to do the "something to wear, something to read, something they want and something they need" thing - gives a bit of structure to our buying decisions. We count little stocking gifts outside of this which helps!

MegaClutterSlut · 28/11/2021 09:48

Yanbu, I used to buy most of my dcs presents 2nd hand when they were younger from bootsales. Still get a few bits now they're 15 and 19. Managed to get ds for christmas a BNWT dressing gown for a £1 and its currently online for £20. Nothing wrong with 2nd hand imo

Thomasina79 · 28/11/2021 09:41

I’ve bought my nearly two year old grandchild a (new) pull along trolley for Christmas which I intend to fill with books from charity shops. Good quality second hand toys are a great idea. Go for it.

gingerbiscuits · 28/11/2021 09:31

Go for it! Our toddler son was obsessed with Thomas trains etc & we had several Christmases & birthdays where some of his presents were good quality, clean, 2nd hand stuff.

By the time he outgrew it all, I'd say more than half his stash wasn't bought new by us. It was perfect, though - he was none the wiser, wouldn't have cared anyway, no packaging, better for the environment & some of the stuff was no longer available to buy new so he had some unique sets which he adored.

I cleaned it all, packed it all up & sold it on via ebay & Facebook marketplace. In fact, we've done this many times over the years with all sorts of toys.

I can also remember that one Christmas, our then 2.5yr old son was so overwhelmed with all the presents; he was thrilled with a few particular 'main' gifts & once he'd set them up, they were all he wanted to play with. He wasn't particularly interested in opening his remaining gifts so we put them aside for a few days & when it was obvious he hadn't noticed or cared, we stashed them again, re-wrapped them & gave them back to him a few months later for his birthday!! Again, he was perfectly happy & it didn't feel like we were being mean at all.