Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think smoking in the workplace and during working hours should be banned?

118 replies

Floogal · 27/11/2021 21:41

Am I alone in thinking that smoking in the workplace and during work time should be outlawed totally in the UK?

  1. The health aspect. People may be smoking outside but it still seeps in and we're still inhaling it.
  2. The fact smokers get extra breaks. (Beautifully illustrated by that episode of Family Guy).
  3. The social and professional cliques that smokers seem to form. Worse when managers or supervisors smoke (beautifully illustrated by that episode of Friends)
  4. Doesn't look good on the company if employees are smoking outside. Looks very bad on NHS or council etc when their staff are doing it
OP posts:
Iamkmackered1979 · 28/11/2021 12:25

On my ward of 50 nursing staff 2 smoke however they don’t change uniform and mints and perfume just make it worse tbh. I don’t like the smell but it’s not my job to police their habits, they don’t tell me to stop eating so why should I ask them to not smoke.
There is no smoking in nhs grounds but I think they go to their car or off grounds and only during break times. It’s up to management to deal with it if they feel it’s an issue imo.
My mum smokes, so when we visit we come away everything stinks I put up with it because she’s my mum though.

HW1989 · 28/11/2021 12:16

Definitely not fair for smokers to get extra breaks. But I think during their actual breaks they can do as they wish but attempt to avoid bringing the smell back in with them.

EmeraldShamrock · 28/11/2021 11:38

I'm in the NHS, a non smoker, but a lot of doctors, nurses and HCAs smoke. Especially on high stress days or when they’re exhausted and looking for something to wake them up enough to carry on.
Yep but mn won't believe you.
I worked in patient accounts I couldn't believe Doctor's and nurse's smoking.
Paramedics too, DD attends therapy in the off the Paramedics centre, they're always in the smoking area.
As for young people many vape now.
It is popular for tictoc blowing out shapes from vaping.

SickAndTiredAgain · 28/11/2021 11:35

*not just find a new job

SickAndTiredAgain · 28/11/2021 11:35

What about people who’ve smoked for years and would rather change their job than be forced to quit?

I don’t support OP’s idea, but if it happened, then the smokers wouldn’t be able to change jobs because it would be the case everywhere. So it would be a choice between cutting down on smoking during the day, or being unemployed, or just finding a new job.

OberthursGrizzledSkipper · 28/11/2021 11:29

I cannot bear the smell of cigarette smoke and it makes me feel physically sick, but I couldn't care less what other people are doing as long as it doesn't affect me. Can't say I've ever noticed how many times smokers go off for a break. I've always felt it's the start of a slippery slope if you start banning or restricting cigarette breaks. What's next, restricting the number of times you go to the loo or get a drink?

The only thing I find really annoying is that at our office smokers have to use designated shelters but it isn't enforced. The rules say it's a disciplinary offence to smoke outside of the shelters, yet every single day people are out there smoking around the shelter and not in it. Then the smoke comes into our building because someone always has to open the window level with the shelter.

From next week our whole site is going tobacco-free (vaping still allowed) and I'm waiting to see how that is going to be enforced. Quite sure it won't be, so I can't see the point of a ban.

mogsrus · 28/11/2021 11:23

I used to stand sometimes with others in the smoke area until they noticed that I didn't smoke,asking why I was joining them I reminded them that they like me,was paid hourly not paid for an hour and take 10 mins or whatever off,for doing absolutely nothing so thought that I would do the same,,the management agreed after a while & stopped it all, got vilified for a while but it soon passed

FateHasRedesignedMost · 28/11/2021 10:50

What about people who’ve smoked for years and would rather change their job than be forced to quit?

I’m in the NHS, a non smoker, but a lot of doctors, nurses and HCAs smoke. Especially on high stress days or when they’re exhausted and looking for something to wake them up enough to carry on. They go and smoke in the woods though, so not on NHS property.

They don’t get ‘extra breaks’. They use their coffee break to go and stand in the cold. Sometimes I go with them for a bit of fresh air, there’s no rule that you must be a smoker to join them.

Strip people of too many freedoms and you get more leaving the workforce.

TheSunIsStillShining · 28/11/2021 10:48

pls. also ban onions and garlic in work meals. And bad body odour. And coming in without brushing one's teeth. and loud phone conversations.
oh and black roots on blondes. it repulses me. So it should be banned. and reflects bad on a company as well if their employees are unkempt.
and lets not forgot peppermint chewing gum, I hate the smell of that.

IncompleteSenten · 28/11/2021 10:44

Extra fag breaks shouldn't be allowed imo. Smoking on your actual break, outside, fair enough imo but nipping off every hour or whatever is not ok.

RampantIvy · 28/11/2021 10:42

@Rosehip10

Yes, businesses/organisations with staff lounging around outside puffing are not promoting a good image. Looks really common.
The company I work for provides a smoking area well away from the reception because, yes it does look bad having smokers just outside the reception area. It makes them look good that they provide somewhere specific to smoke though.
Rosebel · 28/11/2021 10:40

I've never worked anywhere where smokers get extra breaks and most people who smoke where I work change or cover their tops and usually go off site too.
People generally aren't paid for breaks so nothing to do with the company.

trappedsincesundaymorn · 28/11/2021 10:37

OP you do realise that Family Guy and Friends are not documentaries. To base 2 of your points on fictional characters in an American "sit-com" and a cartoon is a bit dim.

LakieLady · 28/11/2021 10:31

The organisation I work for doesn't permit smoking breaks and staff are only allowed to smoke in their lunch breaks.

However, a lot of staff work in the community. The office-based smokers wanted the community-based staff to be banned from smoking in their cars between visits, to make it "fair".

Management (understandably) declined, on the grounds that it would be unenforceable.

Roominmyhouse · 28/11/2021 10:28

I see where you are coming from OP. I don’t think anyone in my team smokes anymore but when they did people who smoked definitely had more breaks than the rest of us. We raised it as if non smokers took as many breaks we’d have been moaned at. Nothing changed though. But over time less people smoked so it became less of an issue.

My real bug bear is people smoking at the entrances to places. The smell of smoke really clings to my hair, and DH has a sensitivity to nicotine and if he’s around too much smoke he struggles to sleep.

You can’t stop people smoking on their breaks but it should only be allowed on official breaks and in a place that no one else has to walk though.

I haven’t smoked for about 15 years now and I’m definitely the ex-smoker who would happily see it banned in all public places now. Sorry!

CounsellorTroi · 28/11/2021 10:18

I worked with a senior colleague who would switch on some kind of air freshener in their office to disguise the smell of smoke when they came back from a fag break which smelt even worse than the smoke. My desk was right by their office. No escape.

FireworkParrot · 28/11/2021 10:14

I do smoke but I'd agree it's not nice for others to have to smell. If I have a cigarette at work I use the designated smoking area which is at the back of the building and then spray perfume and have a mint before I come in. I think that's just common courtesy to be honest.

I actually agree that smoking right outside doorways or where customers can see you or have to walk past doesn't give a great impression. Same if people are constantly taking smoking breaks but I do think it's for companies to restrict this through their policies.... having a designated smoking area or making smoking break time come off lunch breaks for example.

Completely banning it is a tricky one in my opinion. We once worked with a member of staff that had absolutely awful BO, the cleaning staff complained how filthy his desk and office chair was. That is just as anti social and unpleasant for co workers as smoking if not more so.

Rosehip10 · 28/11/2021 10:13

Yes, businesses/organisations with staff lounging around outside puffing are not promoting a good image. Looks really common.

GlamorousHeifer · 28/11/2021 09:56

Personally I don't care if the company I work for looks bad because of something I do. I go there to earn money to live, why would I care if they 'look bad'? I think you will find most employees are there for the same reason (perhaps the very top tiers will feel differently) so that's not exactly a good reason to ban smoking.
The smell is unpleasant I agree, the smell of Bob who hasn't bothered to shower for three days is also unpleasant, also Barbara's Slimming World curry stinks the staff kitchen out every lunchtime so I'm assuming they would be banned to?
I have never worked anywhere where smokers have extra breaks, they usually have a shorter lunch break than non smokers so again doesn't affect anyone.
Sounds like OP has a bee in her bonnet about it for some reason however the arguments she has given are pretty shoddy.

girlmom21 · 28/11/2021 09:47

Are you an ex smoker or an old fart whose completely against smoking and smokers?

Well that was completely unnecessary, offensive ageism wasn't it?

You actually find younger people are much less tolerant of smokers, anyway.

ShabsLovesTiff · 28/11/2021 09:43

This is hilarious. Are you an ex smoker or an old fart whose completely against smoking and smokers?

Break times where I work we get a 15 minute break per shift if we work 5 or 6 hours and a 20 minute break for a 7 hour shift and half an hours break for 8 hours or more. We don’t get smoke breaks but working in Argos Sainsburys climbing ladders lifting large appliances and objects on our feet all day getting abuse from some customers we need smoke breaks and the 20 minute break I get I have to walk to back of building where no customers can see us in a designated area by the time I get there have a very quick cigarette and walk back that’s my break over no time for a drink or toilet break but that’s a smokers choice. I always spray myself down and hand sanitize my hands so they don’t smell and chew some gum or suck a mint to take smell away.

Obviously it’s down to the employers what breaks and times they allow and I’m sure even being a non smoker if you wanted to go outside for some fresh air or make a cup of coffee or drink of pop then im sure if they’re letting smokers have smoke breaks you can have a tea break? Well within reason for each employee no taking the pee and taking a half hour smoke or coffee break lol. For other places where no designated smoke break and not somewhere in healthcare setting or restaurant and in non uniform let them have a smoke outside of work if your a customer you just chose yourself whether your going to go somewhere that may smell a little bit of cigarette smoke and as for inhaling other peoples nicotine if you were out shopping if you do your own shopping or get the bus and are at the bus stop do we just ban smoking full stop for smokers no smoking outside at all oh and in our own homes incase people who are working from home are smoking in work hours? Okay then but if we’re taking away smokers privliges then why not ban alcohol and stuff with sugar in or high fat foods too and put and ban on earning more than 20k a year and finding new jobs and incomes for all the companies and staff who will be out of a job by the end of all this?

Seems silly really if your not happy find another job or speak to HR or your boss for the unfair behaviour lol

TarasCrazyTiara · 28/11/2021 09:42

Smokers shouldn’t get extra breaks. Aside from that if they’re not in the workplace it’s their choice.

rainbowmash · 28/11/2021 09:32

Yes, but only if visibly eating unhealthy food, eating outside of designated mealtimes, and being visibly obese is made a sackable offense for the sake of the company's dignity and the purity of our society.

See how silly this sounds?

EmeraldShamrock · 28/11/2021 09:29

I've never noticed excessive breaks, in every job there was 4 breaks throughout the day, 2 x 10 minutes and half hour lunch.

You want to outlaw something because it makes a company look bad?

Once you discriminate against one group where would it stop? After the smoker was banned they'd start on staff suffering obesity, next age and good looks.

They should completely ban smoking if necessary force people into withdrawal, not treat them like a leaper while creaming in the tax.
Smoking is a serious addiction.

Newpuppymummy · 28/11/2021 09:23

I work in social care and have to visit the base every few weeks. I swear the same few staff are always out their smoking when I get there and when I leave. Every single time!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread