Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think where is the empathy?

35 replies

eggandchips33 · 27/11/2021 18:32

This week alone I have seen:

Horrible, horrible comments about the people who drowned in the English Channel this week. Not just political stuff but people actually laughing and joking about it.

A story in a local paper about a woman who sadly died from covid. People instantly in the comments talking about how it's scaremongering and propaganda. As if the family need to see that on a story about their loved one.

Endless threads on here where people are just sticking the boot in and insulting others when they are down. Nothing remotely helpful or constructive about their comments, just sheer nastiness. That's nothing new though.

I feel really depressed with the lack of empathy and in most cases, utter maliciousness of some people. Yes I probably need to step away from social media but is this really the world I am raising my kids in? When did people become so cold? How are we supposed to ignore it? I've given up trying to challenge it as people are so pigheaded it's pointless.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EmeraldShamrock · 29/11/2021 13:57

@TractorAndHeadphones I agree.
I'm not going to get into her views online though she agrees with Katie Hopkins and Donald Trump a lot. Grin

Iggly · 29/11/2021 13:01

@Lavenderosemary

I was a big social media user until recently. I realised that I was spending my whole time feeling anxious or irritated about what I'd seen online or the comments or whatever issues were being raised or getting into unpleasant debates defending against unkind people. I stopped using social media totally about a month ago. After a few slightly itchy days of detox I've been more relaxed than I have in years. The original idea of social media is wonderful, but it's grown into a whole different beast now.
This is a good idea.

I’m ok as long as I stay off Facebook nut job groups and just stick to things I need to know. Twitter is similar - it’s too easy to end up in a scrolling spiral of anger.

Lavenderosemary · 29/11/2021 10:15

I was a big social media user until recently. I realised that I was spending my whole time feeling anxious or irritated about what I'd seen online or the comments or whatever issues were being raised or getting into unpleasant debates defending against unkind people. I stopped using social media totally about a month ago. After a few slightly itchy days of detox I've been more relaxed than I have in years. The original idea of social media is wonderful, but it's grown into a whole different beast now.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 28/11/2021 22:56

Try reading the Brexit or anti Tory threads.

TractorAndHeadphones · 28/11/2021 21:54

@Antsgomarching

But yeah people are sometimes assholes. I used to be a lot more positive that people were generally good but not so much anymore. You can believe people shouldn’t be trying to cross the chanel from a safe country whilst also feeling horrified by the loss of life and the brutality of their deaths. If you are mocking it then you are absolutely heartless.
Exactly! I also don't think they should cross however was saddened at the news. i saw people say 'karma' which is disgusting
TractorAndHeadphones · 28/11/2021 21:53

[quote EmeraldShamrock]@TractorAndHeadphones not at all, I love my Dsis but she is a very cold person who lacks empathy it causes her unhappiness, she sees negativity in everything.
My other siblings call her the ice queen, we love her but she is a ruthless character.[/quote]
You know your sister better, but what you've written in itself doesn't make her a cold person.
Homelessness : there's a well known programme about it
metro.co.uk/2019/03/21/fake-rough-sleeper-who-earns-up-to-600-a-day-says-begging-brings-in-more-than-working-8975704/
Foreign aid : Why is not wanting to donate to a specific cause which pays staff high salaries bad? She can spend her money how she chooses. By this logic doesn't matter if she donated a million pounds to UK children not wanting to give foreign aid is cold.

If she said homeless people are lazy and it's their fault, or foreigners don't deserve aid over 'our people' fair enough but all the things you mention aren't cruel or merciless. Unlike people mocking the drowned.

in RL I don't see a lack of empathy like what the OP mentioned I see the opposite ; people getting angry at their causes not being supported.

Antsgomarching · 28/11/2021 19:58

But yeah people are sometimes assholes. I used to be a lot more positive that people were generally good but not so much anymore. You can believe people shouldn’t be trying to cross the chanel from a safe country whilst also feeling horrified by the loss of life and the brutality of their deaths. If you are mocking it then you are absolutely heartless.

Antsgomarching · 28/11/2021 19:56

There was a guy in our town who used to beg by the railway station - turns out he drove a BMW and lived in a nice flat - lived next door to my sister. He was pretty convincing- never know, your sister might be right.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/11/2021 19:50

Most people are decent. They probably do t spend much time here Grin

tallduckandhandsome · 28/11/2021 19:48

You sound jealous of your sister wowb

No, she doesn’t Confused

EmeraldShamrock · 28/11/2021 19:42

@TractorAndHeadphones not at all, I love my Dsis but she is a very cold person who lacks empathy it causes her unhappiness, she sees negativity in everything.
My other siblings call her the ice queen, we love her but she is a ruthless character.

TractorAndHeadphones · 28/11/2021 19:33

@EmeraldShamrock

It isn't only keyboard warriors. I have heard some horrible harsh statements from certain people whose generally judgemental about people and their circumstances in RL.

My niece's BF has been called the N word and told "go back to Africa on more than a few occasions".

There is a huge lack of empathy in society, Dsis try to tell me the local homeless guy has a warm house, he doesn't he street sleeps, I've seen him sleeping in doorways she is a very critical person who believes everyone makes their choices in life, she married a rich men who paid for her education and property investments she forgets where she is from, she won't give foreign aid because the CEO earns thousands. Confused

You sound jealous of your sister wowb
MushMonster · 28/11/2021 08:10

I was told about the reality of himan kind a good while ago.
There was a war scare in my country, and some people wanted it to happen! They came out of the woodworks. People that you would think were normal caring and loving citizens, but no, no empathy, horrible and scary in the inside. My grandma told me about it when I was a child, I never forgot it, and I have seen it myself in recent years, with all this political chaos around us. Yes, most people are what you see, but a proportion of us are not. It is very scary and sad. I better know though, who this horrible people are!

EmeraldShamrock · 28/11/2021 08:04

The particular rag newspaper commentary section is disgusting. DM.

EmeraldShamrock · 28/11/2021 08:02

It isn't only keyboard warriors.
I have heard some horrible harsh statements from certain people whose generally judgemental about people and their circumstances in RL.

My niece's BF has been called the N word and told "go back to Africa on more than a few occasions".

There is a huge lack of empathy in society, Dsis try to tell me the local homeless guy has a warm house, he doesn't he street sleeps, I've seen him sleeping in doorways she is a very critical person who believes everyone makes their choices in life, she married a rich men who paid for her education and property investments she forgets where she is from, she won't give foreign aid because the CEO earns thousands. Confused

ElectraBlue · 28/11/2021 07:40

Indeed. I checked the Daily Hate comments section under the story of those poor. desperate people drowning and I was ashamed of being British by the end of it.

People were literally rejoicing. I think the right wing media and government have a lot to answer for. It is one thing to disagree with immigration, it is another entirely to be gleeful about someone dying. Pure evil.

tallduckandhandsome · 28/11/2021 06:27

@EmmetEmma

I think sometimes people assume this coldness when they are trying to distance themselves from it, as a coping mechanism for all the utter sadness there is sometimes, it’s not ok - but I think it can be a coping mechanism

Oh please 🙄 Laughing about refugees/migrants drowning is not a coping mechanism, it’s racist and evil.

Stop excusing racists.

ThisOldSaddo · 27/11/2021 21:08

I'm saddened by the threads on here that are started by a woman clearly in need, but posted see one thing in her OP and pick up on that over and over again to bash her with.

I remember years ago (I've been on MN since handbag.com went commercial 😂) I was lamenting how grown men and women at a bus stop watched a young primary school aged child get roasted by a man (not his dad) on the walk to school outside my house. I ran from a bedroom in my house to tell him to leave him alone. He had him lifted by the lapels screaming in his face - when recounting the scene I said "he had a very thick Scottish accent" and mentioned it only because I was telling the story and that the boy had a very West Country accent (I could hear him pleading with the man) so making the point it wasn't his daddy.

I was raked over the coals again and again and again for mentioning his accent - nothing said about the child and his household or what I could possibly do to help etc. Just trying to find some xenophobic point in what o was saying.

The funny thing was I could point out exactly where this man was from in Scotland, exactly where he was from by his dialect - because I am from the same place and speak exactly like him.

Whaddyagonnado? 🤷‍♀️

chocolatesweets · 27/11/2021 20:54

When you point a finger remember 3 point back at you. Maybe they don't have the kindness you have in your heart or they had bad childhoods? The way to fight is with love not fire. I know what you mean though, it's difficult. If you can't handle it, best thing to do is to step away.

Luredbyapomegranate · 27/11/2021 20:30

If you are feeling like this step away from SM for a bit. All this does happen but it’s not a balanced picture overall - there is plenty of empathy about.

It’s not normal to think people drowning is funny and most people do not. Most people don’t think COVID isn’t real. Most people on mumsnet are not aggressive to people who are vulnerable, not to say there aren’t spats, but there is lots of support and good advice, and a lot of the bluntness is kindness.

TractorAndHeadphones · 27/11/2021 20:18

@KikoLemons

Agree that a keyboard is a factor. There is certainly more empathy in real life. And a lot of support for people. But empathy like everything is selective. Some people are just supposed to "suck it up" if their situations or very real complaints don't fit with the popular group think.

Empathy is about understanding - not just supporting a cause.

The OP is about people doing nasty things. Such as laughing at drowned people and being rude. This is distasteful. Whether empathy is ‘supporting a cause’ is another matter entirely. Any discussion on immigration policy for example is immediately shut down by a) People being racist b) People saying we’re all part of the human race It’s possible to acknowledge that while we are lucky in being born into the conditions we were - we also cannot solve all the world’s problems and there are several factors to consider. But nope people just want to be emotional on the internet
Clumsyvolcano · 27/11/2021 20:18

Opinions* not options!

Clumsyvolcano · 27/11/2021 20:04

The thing is, people keep saying it’s because they’re anonymous online and not like that in real life. That may be so, but really it doesn’t mean that they don’t have those opinions in RL and aren’t just hiding them so they can be seen as better than they really are.

Keyboard or not, it’s still a person with abhorrent options.

I totally agree OP. Over the last 10 years or so I’ve noticed it’s got worse. A lot more people are awfully intolerant, selfish and idiotic.

KikoLemons · 27/11/2021 19:49

Agree that a keyboard is a factor. There is certainly more empathy in real life. And a lot of support for people. But empathy like everything is selective. Some people are just supposed to "suck it up" if their situations or very real complaints don't fit with the popular group think.

Empathy is about understanding - not just supporting a cause.

EmeraldShamrock · 27/11/2021 19:34

Yes, the complete opposite of kindness especially from behind a screen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread