Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To deduct this off my rent without landlords consent?

135 replies

Userxxx · 27/11/2021 15:52

We have been renting our home for 8 years. In that time the landlord has fixed stuff that needed fixing (electrics burnt out. leaking toilet, new oven hob, front door locking mechanism) but has done no maintenance at all. We have painted through and changed a bedroom carpet to laminate as it was old and coming up.

Our stairs and landing carpet is the original carpet in the property so over 30 years old and literally threadbare on the landing, and coming off the stairs so is a hazard.

I requested it to be changed over 2 years ago through the letting agent who responded that the landlord had given permission and their maintenance people would do it. It never happened and I stopped chasing it when Covid started.

I requested it to be done again this September. Again told LL agreed to getting quotes done and they’d send their guys out. Again they didn’t come so I emailed them in October and said I’d get it done myself if they didn’t send someone out within 14 days and take it off the rent. No response.

I got quotes a few weeks ago, went for the cheapest, paid for it and it’s being fitted next week. I also decided to change the carpet in the main bedroom as again it’s very old and has holes in it. I decided I’d pay half as we hadn’t agreed to it but the landlord will benefit as the carpet is disgusting and when we leave next year, landlord won’t have to do it.

Lo and behold. letting agent called me yesterday saying they were sending their guys out to do a quote for the Landlord. I told them I’d already sorted it and the bedroom carpet too and was told as I’d done it without permission and their guys might be cheaper, I can’t take it off the rent!

WIBU to just deduct it from next months rent and tell them to piss off? If they try to serve notice, would I have grounds to say they are serving it maliciously? It is £650!

OP posts:
PinkWaferBiscuit · 27/11/2021 19:59

@Marynotsocontrary

Don't really know why you bothered posting OP Hmm Let's hope the house purchase isn't delayed or doesn't fall through, you're putting yourself in a very dicey position.
Agreed. It's an incredibly risky idea for a single professional who could sofa surf but you have children, why would you put them through the very real potential of being evicted for none payment of rent.
saleorbouy · 27/11/2021 19:56

i.Pay your rent otherwise you are in breach of contract and will have no recourse.
ii. Take pictures of the state of the carpet before work is carried out.
iii. Make sure you have records of all correspondence with the letting agent.
Send a letter notifying them of the carpet renewal and the reasons for changing with pictures added. Note the history of when you first asked and the lack of response.
vi.Request the refund for the carpet renewal stating that it was a safety / hygiene issue.

If you do not get a refund just notify them that them when you give notice to leave that you will not be paying the last month's rent in lieu of costs.

Marynotsocontrary · 27/11/2021 19:53

Don't really know why you bothered posting OP Hmm
Let's hope the house purchase isn't delayed or doesn't fall through, you're putting yourself in a very dicey position.

Userxxx · 27/11/2021 19:49

We have stayed despite the house needing lot of work in general as DC school is a 5 min walk away, there are very few rentals in the area and the LL is a professional LL who we knew wouldn’t want to sell every 6 months like the 2 previous LLs we had. Kitchen is falling apart, I have to constantly bleach the shower due to mould, bathroom floor is coming up, laminate through the downstairs has massive gaps and chips, patio doors can’t be opened and make the downstairs freezing.

I will suggest the agency gets a quote done with their people so we can compare. That was good advice, thank you. I can practically guarantee they won’t send anyone out though.

I have decided to deduct it off January’s rent as that gives them a reasonable time to do so and if I haven’t heard from them I’ll deduct it all.

We are planning to buy a house in another area at the end of next year so I’m not bothered about a reference and if LL decides to be a dick and serve notice (we’re month to month), it’ll take him that long to evict probably! Might even not pay rent from when he starts action so that will help with moving costs Wink.

OP posts:
rossclare · 27/11/2021 19:40

As a LL and a letting agent, I would advise you ask fir the LL details (the agent have to supply them) and write to them explaining the situation.

Gottahavehighhopes · 27/11/2021 19:36

@Userxxx

Did you do the whole legal thing of 3 quotes then giving them to your landlord?

icedcoffees · 27/11/2021 19:33

@Userxxx

Are people missing that the carpet is loose as it’s so old, is coming off the stairs and we have been sliding on itHmm.

I didn’t just decide I didn’t like the carpet so wanted a new one! It’s the standard one that is put in new builds, not a quality one and is now 40 years old.

Why should I have to replace it out of my own pocket to prevent us falling down the stairs when I’m already paying £1300 a month to a landlord who owns 29 other properties?

How is it not a repair?

But none of that means you can withhold the rent - it puts you in a very precarious position legally.

Yes, the landlord should pay for new carpet but that doesn't mean you don't pay him your full rent. You need to supply him with the receipts so he can reimburse you.

Marynotsocontrary · 27/11/2021 19:30

OP, go back to letting agents with receipts etc. Ask them to contact landlord re coming to some satisfactory arrangement.

If they play tough, then you do to, quoting Shelter, safety issues etc. Hopefully it won't come to that though.

I'd do all that first before considering withholding rent. You'll have to leave then. You'll be given notice if you withhold rent without prior agreement.

IncessantNameChanger · 27/11/2021 19:25

I dont think you can self deduct tbh. We bought a brand new oven and our tennants said it was broken so replaced it within six months. We had a warranty on it for two years but they part ex'd it without permission. That was 12 years ago and the iven became their problem at that point.

You could have replaced it with a carpet that might only last a few years. So on that grounds I think your in the wrong.

But also as a landlord, your landlord is being tight and a arse. Sometimes the agents dont talk to the landlords. So that's another possibility.

Where we rent our carpet is over 20 years old and apart from the boiler, nothing gets touched. Our house will gutting when we move out including the joists I think as the shower has been leaking for over ten years. If it has dry rot i wouldnt be shocked. I really dont care. It's not my capital.

Morvensea · 27/11/2021 19:24

Why on earth should someone have to leave their home, with all the resulting expense, inconvenience and instability, because someone couldn’t be arsed to fit a carpet?

A580Hojas · 27/11/2021 19:22

@DeepaBeesKit

The problem is that in reality the way you could have protested at years of no maintenance is to simply leave. Why didn't you?
Because, fairly obviously I would have thought, why should op have to move for the sake of a very cheap and easily fixable job?

Uprooting her whole family, their schools, everything else that moving entails because LL is too mean to pay for a small amount of new carpet?

Marynotsocontrary · 27/11/2021 19:22

Agree the landlord was tardy here. But withholding rent is not the solution, talking is.

A580Hojas · 27/11/2021 19:19

If the landlord had responded to op's reasonable request for new carpet in a timely manner, then this wouldn't be an issue. It's not on for LL's to expect very long term tenants (8 years remember) to live in shoddy conditions because they can't be arsed to pay for reasonable maintenance. Or should tenants just suck it up no matter what's going on?

DeepaBeesKit · 27/11/2021 19:15

The problem is that in reality the way you could have protested at years of no maintenance is to simply leave. Why didn't you?

Marynotsocontrary · 27/11/2021 19:14

You will need your receipts btw OP. The landlord will need to know that the carpet was supplied and fitted by a reputable company.

colourfulpuddles · 27/11/2021 19:11

[quote Stellaris22]@colourfulpuddles well, yes, I do. Paying rent, not damaging the property or being a nuisance. Having a right to a home and this attitude is exactly why places like Shelter exist.

But thank you for proving my point about tenants having no rights![/quote]
Oh honey, that’s not how it works, nor should it. You didn’t buy the house, it’s not yours.

Of course you have rights, but you don’t have the right to live in somebody else’s property for as long as you want.

The landlord is letting you live there. If there weren’t landlords, you wouldn’t have anywhere to live at all.

Marynotsocontrary · 27/11/2021 19:07

The issue isn't that you shouldn't get your money reimbursed OP. I think you should, at least with regards to the stairs carpet. But withholding your rent - unless by agreement- just isn't the way to go about it.

Thefuturestory · 27/11/2021 19:04

Ask the carpet company if a refund is possible. Or ask agency to agree for the work at landlords cost.

EightWheelGirl · 27/11/2021 18:58

Looks like you wasted £650! The timing is most unfortunate tbh.

Userxxx · 27/11/2021 18:23

*30 years old not 40.

OP posts:
Userxxx · 27/11/2021 18:20

Are people missing that the carpet is loose as it’s so old, is coming off the stairs and we have been sliding on itHmm.

I didn’t just decide I didn’t like the carpet so wanted a new one! It’s the standard one that is put in new builds, not a quality one and is now 40 years old.

Why should I have to replace it out of my own pocket to prevent us falling down the stairs when I’m already paying £1300 a month to a landlord who owns 29 other properties?

How is it not a repair?

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock · 27/11/2021 18:13

Don't do this, it will sour relations and let's face it the LL will win plus they'll keep your carpet.

lonelyapple · 27/11/2021 18:12

Speak to Shelter. They will have better advice than the boomer landlords on Mumsnet!

ChateauMargaux · 27/11/2021 18:10

Maybe allow them to come and get a quote, if its lower than what you paid, accept that lower amount as a deduction.

Quote the Shelter advice to them.

Offer a reasonable solution.

Put all of the communication, photos of the old carpet and dates and times of accidents on the stairs in writing.

Viviennemary · 27/11/2021 18:09

No you can't do this AFAIK.