Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To deduct this off my rent without landlords consent?

135 replies

Userxxx · 27/11/2021 15:52

We have been renting our home for 8 years. In that time the landlord has fixed stuff that needed fixing (electrics burnt out. leaking toilet, new oven hob, front door locking mechanism) but has done no maintenance at all. We have painted through and changed a bedroom carpet to laminate as it was old and coming up.

Our stairs and landing carpet is the original carpet in the property so over 30 years old and literally threadbare on the landing, and coming off the stairs so is a hazard.

I requested it to be changed over 2 years ago through the letting agent who responded that the landlord had given permission and their maintenance people would do it. It never happened and I stopped chasing it when Covid started.

I requested it to be done again this September. Again told LL agreed to getting quotes done and they’d send their guys out. Again they didn’t come so I emailed them in October and said I’d get it done myself if they didn’t send someone out within 14 days and take it off the rent. No response.

I got quotes a few weeks ago, went for the cheapest, paid for it and it’s being fitted next week. I also decided to change the carpet in the main bedroom as again it’s very old and has holes in it. I decided I’d pay half as we hadn’t agreed to it but the landlord will benefit as the carpet is disgusting and when we leave next year, landlord won’t have to do it.

Lo and behold. letting agent called me yesterday saying they were sending their guys out to do a quote for the Landlord. I told them I’d already sorted it and the bedroom carpet too and was told as I’d done it without permission and their guys might be cheaper, I can’t take it off the rent!

WIBU to just deduct it from next months rent and tell them to piss off? If they try to serve notice, would I have grounds to say they are serving it maliciously? It is £650!

OP posts:
ChristmasScrooge · 28/11/2021 08:19

Yes you have to pay out of your own pocket. Withholding the rent for a carpet, won't look good in court for you. It should say in your tenancy agreement what they are responsible for and trust me it won't say carpet or decoration.
It will go against you, no landlord is likely to touch you if you withhold the rent and you won't get a mortgage if you withhold the rent either. Why would you risk that for a bit of carpet seriously? HmmConfused

malmi · 28/11/2021 08:04

Sorry, to be clear, they can start the eviction process by serving a section 8 notice. They don't need to chase for the rent first. They can't just turn up and evict you of course.

malmi · 28/11/2021 08:01

Why risk the roof over your children's heads for a bit of carpet?

If the carpet was seriously unsafe then you would have been justified in taking a Stanley knife to it and removing it from the stairs altogether. After notifying the landlord you were going to do this.

Withholding rent means the landlord can start the eviction process with no further notification. It puts you in a very weak position. They may say nothing, letting you assume they are accepting the deduction, and then hit you with an eviction when they feel like it.

Elbie79 · 28/11/2021 04:00

@Userxxx

According to Shelter, tenants can deduct from rent for repairs which are not carried as long as they give reasonable time to do them (over 2 years in my case) and inform them that they intend to deduct it from the rent giving them time again to remedy it (another 2 months).

Even the woman from the letting agency said it needed to be done when she came to look at it over 2 years ago!

This is your answer OP. I'd listen to Shelter over PP!

Also it sounds like the LL not at fault as s/he gave permission for the quote, but rather the agency who delayed. So I'd push back with them, it's a situation of their making, their failure, they need to square it with the LL.

Sounds like you've been a good tenant for a long time, I'd stick to your guns.

colourfulpuddles · 28/11/2021 03:47

He obviously doesn’t give a shit about whether the stairs are safe for his tenants so why should I give a shit about his contract?

Because you want to get a mortgage.

If he wants to play funny buggers and evict a long standing tenant, who’s always paid on time and taken very good care of the property (repainting throughout several times, massively enhancing the garden, reflooring one of the bedrooms to a high standard, replacing skirting boards),

If you did any of this without permission you are not a good tenant.

Whether you are happy to pay or not is irrelevant, you don’t get to make a choice on more permanent features like flooring and painting because it isn’t your property.

colourfulpuddles · 28/11/2021 03:44

@MeanderingGently

In all the places I have rented, I have redecorated, changed carpets etc., but never expected the landlord to pay. In my most recent flat I re-carpeted the hallway (huge, it runs the length of the flat) to the tune of £750 but it was my choice and my decision and not claimable....even though the carpet was crap. If the heating doesn't work, they send someone out but all internal decoration is my responsibility. And no, don't withhold rent, you will be in the wrong here and it will cause you all sorts of trouble.
Did you get permission?

Because it doesn’t matter if you’re willing to pay for it, it’s not your property, so if you want to redecorate or change a permanent feature like the carpets then you need the landlords permission. It is not your choice or decision to make; it’s theirs.

MeanderingGently · 28/11/2021 02:20

In all the places I have rented, I have redecorated, changed carpets etc., but never expected the landlord to pay. In my most recent flat I re-carpeted the hallway (huge, it runs the length of the flat) to the tune of £750 but it was my choice and my decision and not claimable....even though the carpet was crap.
If the heating doesn't work, they send someone out but all internal decoration is my responsibility.
And no, don't withhold rent, you will be in the wrong here and it will cause you all sorts of trouble.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 28/11/2021 02:14

**However if your

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 28/11/2021 02:04

AAAccording to Shelter, tenants can deduct from rent for repairs which are not carried as long as they give reasonable time to do them (over 2 years in my case) and inform them that they intend to deduct it from the rent giving them time again to remedy it (another 2 months).

a carpet isn’t a repair, it’s decoration!

You don’t even qualify for a disrepair claim, frankly you went ahead without permission at your own risk, however your LL was decent then he should refund however he has no legal responsibility to do so.

Marynotsocontrary · 28/11/2021 01:49

are you and other posters saying that I should replace the carpet in a rented property out of my own pocket then?
@Userxxx
Well what I, at least, have said very clearly several times now is that the way to recoup your money is NOT by stopping paying rent, but by talking to your LL. Stopping paying your rent is not the way to address this problem.

If you are as good a tenant as you claim to be I'm sure eviction is the very last thing on the LL's mind, but you are forcing his/her hand by not paying your rent. It's just looking for trouble.

On the issue of then staying in the house for months free of charge while you wait for those eviction proceedings to take place...those laws were put in place to protect tenants in genuine cases of hardship and mistreatment...not for someone who is playing games like you are. The idea of costing your LL thousands just so you can save on moving costs is morally reprehensible imo.

Augustmummy · 28/11/2021 01:36

I did this once with a plumbing issue. The landlord put our rent up substantially. They’ll make you pay one way or another. I really wouldnt take it out of rent unless you enjoy conflict, high rent or homelessness.

Fefifobum · 28/11/2021 01:30

You’ve asked on AIBU if you are being unreasonable over your predicament only to be told by most posters that you are but no here you are protesting that your not so why bloody post if your happy with your predicament?!
You really should have waited on the landlord getting back to you...

worriedatthemoment · 28/11/2021 00:56

Legally no you can't

Userxxx · 28/11/2021 00:53

@AdobeWanKenobi are you and other posters saying that I should replace the carpet in a rented property out of my own pocket then? I’ve already clearly stated that it is hazardous as coming off the stairs, letting agent agreed, and the LL has had since Sept 2019 to replace it.

He obviously doesn’t give a shit about whether the stairs are safe for his tenants so why should I give a shit about his contract? I had no doubt this would drag on for months if I hadn’t got it done myself.

I have to chase for the gas safety certificate to be done every year too, this year 3 months late.

If he wants to play funny buggers and evict a long standing tenant, who’s always paid on time and taken very good care of the property (repainting throughout several times, massively enhancing the garden, reflooring one of the bedrooms to a high standard, replacing skirting boards), over putting in a much needed new carpet which he’d already agreed to replace and will greatly improve the property for future tenants then I’ll play them too by making the eviction process as long and difficult as possible and making sure he’s more out of pocket than me.

OP posts:
AdobeWanKenobi · 27/11/2021 23:28

@Marynotsocontrary

Don't really know why you bothered posting OP Hmm Let's hope the house purchase isn't delayed or doesn't fall through, you're putting yourself in a very dicey position.
Agreed. You'd have been better in the property forum as you certainly won't entertain the idea you're being unreasonable, despite the vast majority of posters thinking you are.
Nanny0gg · 27/11/2021 22:34

@DeepaBeesKit

The problem is that in reality the way you could have protested at years of no maintenance is to simply leave. Why didn't you?
Because they're aren't many rental properties available? Because of the location? Because of the rent? Because it costs a shedload of money to move? Because it's her home?
colourfulpuddles · 27/11/2021 21:14

You’ll have trouble buying a house if you haven’t properly paid your rent and are evicted.

So yeah, you can stamp your feet, break contract and alter someone else’s property without their permission if you want, as long as you’re aware it’s highly likely you’ll be turned down for a mortgage Smile

Sweetchocolatecandy · 27/11/2021 21:04

@MattHancocksSexTape

What happens if the landlord evicts and gets a CCJ against you? Or if the mortgage broker asks why their is no longer rent showing on your financial statements? How will you purchase then?
Exactly. Your refusal to pay rent could impact your ability to get a mortgage and you could also end up paying your landlords court fees.

It baffles me when some tenants like the OP think they have the upper hand- the system has always been designed to favour the LL so please stop trying to kid yourself that you have all of the power here- especially with current housing crisis and massive shortage of rental properties landlords can pretty much do what they want, as believe me when you’re out there will be a queue of tenants desperate to move in.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 27/11/2021 20:51

OP I get it, I was renting a one bed flat for £1400, it was full of black mould, I couldn't afford to move, the landlord wouldn't do anything, I developed health issues that I'll now have for the rest of my life and cost me a fortune in prescriptions but you honestly can't just stop paying rent because it makes it worse on you.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 27/11/2021 20:40

@MattHancocksSexTape

What happens if the landlord evicts and gets a CCJ against you? Or if the mortgage broker asks why their is no longer rent showing on your financial statements? How will you purchase then?
That would be interesting.
BillDates · 27/11/2021 20:32

@Userxxx

We have stayed despite the house needing lot of work in general as DC school is a 5 min walk away, there are very few rentals in the area and the LL is a professional LL who we knew wouldn’t want to sell every 6 months like the 2 previous LLs we had. Kitchen is falling apart, I have to constantly bleach the shower due to mould, bathroom floor is coming up, laminate through the downstairs has massive gaps and chips, patio doors can’t be opened and make the downstairs freezing.

I will suggest the agency gets a quote done with their people so we can compare. That was good advice, thank you. I can practically guarantee they won’t send anyone out though.

I have decided to deduct it off January’s rent as that gives them a reasonable time to do so and if I haven’t heard from them I’ll deduct it all.

We are planning to buy a house in another area at the end of next year so I’m not bothered about a reference and if LL decides to be a dick and serve notice (we’re month to month), it’ll take him that long to evict probably! Might even not pay rent from when he starts action so that will help with moving costs Wink.

Would choosing to to that put your credit rating at risk? Mortgage companies will credit check you and if you end up with anything on your file from rent arrears it could bite you on your arse.
Marynotsocontrary · 27/11/2021 20:32

@WhenISnappedAndFarted

So you're saying you would make the landlord evict you and go through the courts, which is expensive and could take months and months and might not even pay?
Yes, I think that's what she's saying boasting about.

Enough said.

MattHancocksSexTape · 27/11/2021 20:20

What happens if the landlord evicts and gets a CCJ against you? Or if the mortgage broker asks why their is no longer rent showing on your financial statements? How will you purchase then?

Dibbydoos · 27/11/2021 20:12

Let landlords people in to quote, see which is cheaper. Ask the LL to cover costs for cheapest then you might not be out of pocket, but it's piss poor all that time waiting with dangerous carpet. Postpone your carpet fitting of you can otherwise you'll be fully our of pocket...

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 27/11/2021 20:07

So you're saying you would make the landlord evict you and go through the courts, which is expensive and could take months and months and might not even pay?