Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To deduct this off my rent without landlords consent?

135 replies

Userxxx · 27/11/2021 15:52

We have been renting our home for 8 years. In that time the landlord has fixed stuff that needed fixing (electrics burnt out. leaking toilet, new oven hob, front door locking mechanism) but has done no maintenance at all. We have painted through and changed a bedroom carpet to laminate as it was old and coming up.

Our stairs and landing carpet is the original carpet in the property so over 30 years old and literally threadbare on the landing, and coming off the stairs so is a hazard.

I requested it to be changed over 2 years ago through the letting agent who responded that the landlord had given permission and their maintenance people would do it. It never happened and I stopped chasing it when Covid started.

I requested it to be done again this September. Again told LL agreed to getting quotes done and they’d send their guys out. Again they didn’t come so I emailed them in October and said I’d get it done myself if they didn’t send someone out within 14 days and take it off the rent. No response.

I got quotes a few weeks ago, went for the cheapest, paid for it and it’s being fitted next week. I also decided to change the carpet in the main bedroom as again it’s very old and has holes in it. I decided I’d pay half as we hadn’t agreed to it but the landlord will benefit as the carpet is disgusting and when we leave next year, landlord won’t have to do it.

Lo and behold. letting agent called me yesterday saying they were sending their guys out to do a quote for the Landlord. I told them I’d already sorted it and the bedroom carpet too and was told as I’d done it without permission and their guys might be cheaper, I can’t take it off the rent!

WIBU to just deduct it from next months rent and tell them to piss off? If they try to serve notice, would I have grounds to say they are serving it maliciously? It is £650!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WindyWindsor · 02/12/2021 01:15

*you're typically not allowed to redecorate or change fixtures and fittings though without landlords permission though. Sounds like they agreed to change it at some point though? Was that in writing?

DifferentHair · 02/12/2021 01:14

This landlord should be grateful to you for saving him a job!

It is a hassle chasing tradespeople and getting quotes and scheduling repairs. I would be thrilled if you were my tenant.

But every aspect of the tenant/landlord relationship is covered by law. You can't just make up your own rules unfortunately.

I hope your landlord reimburses you for the work you had done .

WindyWindsor · 02/12/2021 01:08

OP I'm not sure why you're replying with Hmm posts.

Changing a carpet and deducting it from rent is not allowed and a dangerous game to play. It's as simple as that. If you want to invoice the landlord while paying your full rent, that's fine and good luck. Deducting it off the rent, not fine. That's the law.

I'm not saying it is fair, but that's how renting works in this country.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 01/12/2021 19:43

Fair enough if that’s what you were told but personally I wouldn’t argue with information on the official government website, citizens advice, shelter and money saving expert. It’s like saying go out and rob a bank, you might get away with it.

Let’s stick to the legal guidance instead of “my interpretation of the law”

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/debt-and-money/rent-arrears/you-are-taken-to-court-for-rent-arrears/#h-about-being-taken-to-court-for-rent-arrears

www.gov.uk/private-renting/rent-arrears

www.moneysavingexpert.com/news/2012/03/rent-payments-to-go-on-your-credit-file/

www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/does-breaking-a-lease-affect-your-credit/

Pre covid, most LL didn’t used to “bother” with a few missed payments of rent however since the government decided that no one could be evicted during initial covid lockdowns, LL started reporting non payments to the credit bureau which may/could impacts on future rental/mortgage applications.

My company reports after two non payments, vast majority now report after one non payment.

Twillow · 01/12/2021 19:22

You need to try and negotiate with them. Ask that they honour the deduction of their own quote. Be civil about it, show yourself as a good tenant. You may ned up paying a little yourself, but it's better than being evicted.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 01/12/2021 19:11

LittleGwyneth

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend
You're not very bright are you OP?

You want to withhold rent however want a mortgage... then state you will withhold rent for the duration of your tenancy.... which will undoubtly leave your credit file in shatters, give you court costs and put you at serious risk of eviction hmm all because you went ahead and laid carpets without permission

This is a) very rude and b) not true. I got a great mortgage from a major bank without any issue at all, despite having missed a rental payment previously. If you get a CCJ then of course that's a problem, but late or missed rent doesn't have any impact on your credit file.

Nothing of what I’ve said is untrue, missing one or 2 payments puts your credit file in a negative, missing multiple payments puts your credit file in shatters!

I work in this field, I’m acutely aware of the impacts of non payment and court action due to non payment of rent etc...

It’s not rude to advise that someone’s not bright because they choose to put their family at risk of homelessness due to their own impatience actions!.

As I’ve previously said, any decent landlord will refund the cost, however they have no legal obligation to do so.

safariboot · 30/11/2021 16:16

Don't withhold rent, unless you have received expert legal advice to do so. Seek an agreement with your landlord regarding costs.

Regarding the safety issue, you'd need evidence of that. In any case it could have been corrected by removing and not replacing the carpets.

The only situations I would withhold rent are if the property is completely uninhabitable and I have moved out, or if I have reason to think my "landlord" is actually a fraudster and not the owner or mesne tenant.

Sweetchocolatecandy · 30/11/2021 14:50

[quote LittleGwyneth]@sweetchocolatecandy I was told by my IFA that the Experian & Clear Score reports are pretty redundant and not representative of the checks that an actual bank does.[/quote]
Fair enough if that’s what you were told but personally I wouldn’t argue with information on the official government website, citizens advice, shelter and money saving expert. It’s like saying go out and rob a bank, you might get away with it.

LittleGwyneth · 30/11/2021 14:12

@sweetchocolatecandy I was told by my IFA that the Experian & Clear Score reports are pretty redundant and not representative of the checks that an actual bank does.

Sweetchocolatecandy · 30/11/2021 13:56

@LittleGwyneth late and missed rental payments can have a massive impact on your credit score. You are very lucky it didn’t affect you and that you didn’t incur any late fees but the OP and others could if they don’t pay.

www.moneysavingexpert.com/news/2012/03/rent-payments-to-go-on-your-credit-file/

LittleGwyneth · 30/11/2021 13:44

@HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend

You're not very bright are you OP?

You want to withhold rent however want a mortgage... then state you will withhold rent for the duration of your tenancy.... which will undoubtly leave your credit file in shatters, give you court costs and put you at serious risk of eviction Hmm all because you went ahead and laid carpets without permission

This is a) very rude and b) not true. I got a great mortgage from a major bank without any issue at all, despite having missed a rental payment previously. If you get a CCJ then of course that's a problem, but late or missed rent doesn't have any impact on your credit file.
LittleGwyneth · 30/11/2021 13:43

You absolutely should be able to do this, but unfortunately you can't. It would be best to tell them that you're going to find somewhere else to live if they don't sort this out. If you've lived there for eight years and you've always paid your rent they'd be bonkers to lose that over the price of a new carpet (which absolutely you should be entitled to).

Marynotsocontrary · 30/11/2021 13:40

A Section 8 can only be issued if you are 8 weeks behind in rent. We won’t even be two weeks behind so that’s not going to happen.

It's the Section 21 notice I'd be worried about. I'd strongly advise you to talk to your landlord OP.

Userxxx · 30/11/2021 13:28

So I should have taken it up leaving the gripper spikes so we cut our feet on it as we walked down the stairs? Hmm

This is not a council property. If I was only paying a third of what we pay in rent and could live in it for life I wouldn’t mind replacing the carpet!

How much longer should I have waited for the LL to be ‘available’ to replace it exactly?

A Section 8 can only be issued if you are 8 weeks behind in rent. We won’t even be two weeks behind so that’s not going to happen.

Enhancing the garden was filling in all the deep holes in the lawns and replanting the grass, building borders along the fences which were just stones, mud and weeds and re-staining the decking. Together with building raised planters. Hardly making it harder to maintainHmm.

Anyway carpets going down tomorrow so we shall see! We’ve just taken the old ones up and the underlay has turned to dust!

OP posts:
Skyechasemarshalontheway · 28/11/2021 19:39

If the carpet was a trip hazard you could have took it off and left it. Many councils give houses to tenants with no carpets so the carpet being up for a while until the ll was available to put a new one down wouldn't have been an issue.

You can't withhold your rent but can you find away to speak to the landlord directly they might come to an agreement with you over price.

2021namechanger · 28/11/2021 11:26

Might even not pay rent from when he starts action so that will help with moving costs

And that CCJ you may accrue might stop you from getting any property.

Read what people are actually saying to you. Also stop making “upgrades”without consent (I’m jot talking about the carpet, but the garden and flooring). When it comes to moving out - this will be noted on the checkout and you could be liable for replacing.

SilverDragonfly1 · 28/11/2021 11:15

If you had multiple accidents because of the carpet, why didn't you take it up? I know it wouldn't look nice but it would be safe.

Genuine question, not attempt to pile on!

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 28/11/2021 11:12

[quote Userxxx]**@AdobeWanKenobi are you and other posters saying that I should replace the carpet in a rented property out of my own pocket then? I’ve already clearly stated that it is hazardous as coming off the stairs, letting agent agreed, and the LL has had since Sept 2019 to replace it.

He obviously doesn’t give a shit about whether the stairs are safe for his tenants so why should I give a shit about his contract? I had no doubt this would drag on for months if I hadn’t got it done myself.

I have to chase for the gas safety certificate to be done every year too, this year 3 months late.

If he wants to play funny buggers and evict a long standing tenant, who’s always paid on time and taken very good care of the property (repainting throughout several times, massively enhancing the garden, reflooring one of the bedrooms to a high standard, replacing skirting boards), over putting in a much needed new carpet which he’d already agreed to replace and will greatly improve the property for future tenants then I’ll play them too by making the eviction process as long and difficult as possible and making sure he’s more out of pocket than me.[/quote]
Enhancing the garden in some peoples eyes is replacing grass and putting down something different, which the landlord may not want. You replaced carpet with laminate in a bedroom, that's not something I would want. Just because it's enhancing in your eyes is not in others, which is why you need permission to do things like that.

You're quite right to be frustrated about the carpet but every agency I have had to go to has been useless and in some cases I've found out from the landlord that they were never contacted by the agency and stuff has been dealt with when I've got in contact with the LL not the agency.

Trying to make someone more out of pocket than you is spiteful and it may well backfire.

AdobeWanKenobi · 28/11/2021 10:24

are you and other posters saying that I should replace the carpet in a rented property out of my own pocket then?

No. As explained by others above we are suing there are better ways to deal with it than not paying your rent.

massively enhancing the garden

Again, this isn’t an enhancement without permission. DD rents. Her neighbours stained the fences over summer and it leaked through. She asked permission to paint her side the same colour and was refused. The landlord argued that it would then need doing every few years and may become his responsibility if She were to move.
Similarly, the next tenant may not have the time or inclination to take on your garden enhancements.

blusteredbirds · 28/11/2021 10:16

Your letting agency are shit OP.

I wish we had a proper professional private rental market in this country.

MargotMoon · 28/11/2021 10:06

I agree with @Elbie79 - the vast majority of the replies on here are based on opinion, not facts. One even said that tenants have no rights, which is simply bollocks! Just because they think you shouldn't have done it doesn't mean they are right.

If the carpet was a hazard it could potentially be classed as a repair. Did you take pictures and keep a record of all of your requests?

Follow the advice on Shelter and phone them as well - don't ask for advice on here! Good luck, hope you can negotiate before it escalates

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 28/11/2021 09:46

You're not very bright are you OP?

You want to withhold rent however want a mortgage... then state you will withhold rent for the duration of your tenancy.... which will undoubtly leave your credit file in shatters, give you court costs and put you at serious risk of eviction Hmm all because you went ahead and laid carpets without permission

2021namechanger · 28/11/2021 09:24

If you deduct from the rent - they can (rightly) serve a section 8 notice on you for non payment. This will affect your ability get secure another tenancy.

It’s not that you shouldn’t be entitled to get the cost covered it’s the way you’re going about it.

Xfox · 28/11/2021 09:17

Presuming they have a deposit from you, they will just deduct the rent arrears from that anyway. If the rent arrears are more than the deposit because you decide to play silly beggars and stop paging rent altogether they will almost certainly take you to court, and if you need a mortgage to buy that will make getting one very difficult and expensive

Swipe left for the next trending thread