Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do I NEED to teach to self soothe?

41 replies

happyboobs · 27/11/2021 10:08

Am I being unreasonable by not teaching my DD to self soothe?

Breastfed baby who is eating solids (not loads mind) at 11mo.
Wakes two hourly still through out the night for quick boob and back to sleep.
DH can settle a couple of times in the evening but generally she's screaming for me by 11pm and wants a good feed so this does limit me meaning I can't really go out anywhere very far or for very long.

I'm not back at work any time soon.

Goes to bed in her own room then we generally bedshare once I go to bed.

Am I doing my baby a disservice by not teaching her to self soothe? I've been made to feel that way by a couple of other mums. They basically said it's cruel and I'm depriving her of a nights sleep and the ability to get herself back to sleep! I'm quite happy with our situation but feeling so much pressure to leave her to cry/withhold the boob which is her only comfort (no dummies or bottles she's never been interested).

I'm generally a confident person but starting to doubt myself and wonder if I am being cruel by not sleep training my baby 😭

I really hate feeling so judged and like I am doing something wrong.

Any advice welcome.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EnidFrighten · 27/11/2021 14:03

They're commenting because whether you sleep train or not, you have skin in the game and want to justify your own approach.

Co sleeping is fine if everyone's happy. I have known people martyr themselves through horrible exhaustion though, or feeling split off from their partner sleeping elsewhere. It can also cause problems when a new baby comes along.

Sleep training is also fine. People who haven't done it overstate the unpleasantness, 'leaving your baby to cry' whereas often it's sitting by them or coming in and out to soothe so they know you're there, they're just not sleeping in your arms.

Bonnealle · 27/11/2021 13:53

Oh wow, that must have been really tough! I can’t imagine that level of sleep deprivation for so long. I thought I was going crazy and that was only for two months! I’ve always wanted a big family, but do have a fear subsequent children won’t be as good sleepers - I realise I’ve been spoilt!

Merryoldgoat · 27/11/2021 13:47

That’s the point though - some just will sleep. It’s not about weight or age or any other stuff those experts say with such conviction.

My boy was 5kg at birth. Basically fed 2-3 hourly for 2 months and didn’t sleep through until over 3 and definitely needed overnight feeds until well past 1.

Thehop · 27/11/2021 13:47

YANBU at all. Do what feels right for you.

Bonnealle · 27/11/2021 13:41

Oh I didn’t realise! It worked for me, although we didn’t do it on purpose, they just slept through so didn’t want to wake them. I don’t think they would had advised that with a newborn even if over 5kg. By the time mine hit that weight it was around two months and the friend’s daughter was six months. I guess it’s different depending on the baby. Mine slept solidly through the night early on (which I appreciate is fortunate!), but another friend still has night wakes at just over a year.

Merryoldgoat · 27/11/2021 13:34

It’s such dangerous advice.

Bonnealle · 27/11/2021 13:19

No, this was very recently! Both by a midwife and a friend who had employed a sleep coach (not sure if the correct term!). She had loads of trouble with her 6 month old and sleep and the coach said to drop the night feed. This worked and her baby sleeps through now. I’m obviously no expert, just repeating advice I was given. I guess it depends on the baby, I didn’t need to night feed mine after 8wks as they slept through - big baby though!!

DontWantTheRivalry · 27/11/2021 12:52

I was told that once they get over 5kg, there is no need to night feed as they should be able sleep through.

Jesus - please tell me this was at least 20 years ago Shock

Merryoldgoat · 27/11/2021 12:36

@Bonnealle

What happens if your baby is 5kg at birth?

Merryoldgoat · 27/11/2021 12:35

I also think people forget or ignore what a joy it is to have a warm snuggled baby on you.

My 3yo (who sleeps very well) still loves a lay-on and it’s gorgeous

Bonnealle · 27/11/2021 12:10

I was told that once they get over 5kg, there is no need to night feed as they should be able sleep through. I certainly noticed a difference when mine hit 5kg, they were able to sleep 10hrs undisturbed. I didn’t cosleep but did share a room. They did snuffle and chat through the night, but didn’t cry and would soon go back to sleep. Does your child cry or is it just general noise as if you leave them they might settle themselves?

MatildaTheCat · 27/11/2021 11:50

You really don’t need to share what happens in your own bedroom at night. Just smile vaguely and say it’s going really well if anyone asks.

I suspect most people resort to sleep training if they have a baby who doesn’t settle as easily as yours and is breaking them, is returning to work or is pregnant again.

Crack on and enjoy.

LeftTheWashingOut · 27/11/2021 11:44

It is works for you and you're happy then ignore your friends- they are probably just trying to justify their own choices by criticizing yours. My child is now 20 months and still wakes regularly - gets fed to sleep at 7, wakes around 11 when he comes into bed with us and on/off feeds when he wakes in the night. It's the best way for us all to get the most sleep. I went back to work at 11 months and by 15 months brought him in our bed as I was getting to resettling him in his cot.

In the past few months I've had to start to travel overnight with work a few times and worried as when I'm home he only settles for me, not dad. But the nights I'm away they do absolutely fine- Mum isn't available so he's perfectly happy to fall asleep with his dad. One thing I do wish is that I'd realized a bit earlier and gone out a bit more!

BurbageBrook · 27/11/2021 11:28

YANBU and they are being dicks to even comment. Your style is more baby led and they’re just trying to justify their sleep training.

ViceLikeBlip · 27/11/2021 11:27

If it works for you, then it's absolutely fine. You can never "spoil" a baby or child with too many cuddles- I never messed around with any sleep training or self settling, it was easier for me just to go down the path of least resistance. None of mine would happily go to bed by themselves and sleep all the way through until about 2.5 years though, and I know some people can't cope with that. But that worked fine for us, and they all sleep well now.

happyboobs · 27/11/2021 11:15

You've all made me feel so much better. Thank you.

Mumsnet is amazing!

OP posts:
ladycarlotta · 27/11/2021 11:09

If it's working for you, you're fine. The ability to self sooth is a developmental stage, you do not need to 'teach' a child to sleep or to be emotionally independent from you since that is what they are hardwired to learn under their own steam. I understand that it's different if you need your child to manage without you, for whatever reason, but trust that your kid is going to pick up these skills anyway if you are raising them in a generally functional manner. I'd say that includes creating a secure attachment by being there for them when you can in infancy. 11 months is still little.

I never did any kind of sleep training with mine and she just naturally moved away from needing me. She's been sleeping through in her own cot since age 1, and I can see on the monitor that she is able to settle herself easily when she wakes.

UnaOfStormhold · 27/11/2021 10:59

There have been a few studies where they put movement trackers on babies before and after sleep training. The parents were reporting improved sleep (and the studies are often used as part of arguments for the benefits of sleep training, but going by the trackers the babies actually slept the same or less.)

evolutionaryparenting.com/helping-baby-sleep/

WTF475878237NC · 27/11/2021 10:53

Nope! You're doing great just as you are.

Sarah Ockwell Smith has some great stuff about all this.

mumsneedwine · 27/11/2021 10:50

Never did with mine. Never let them cry. They both slept through eventually. And are now at Uni doing well so no long term effects.
You do you. I always say listen to all the advice, ignore 95% of it snd do it as you want. They are your kids and it's your life.

CloseThePackWithAClickClack · 27/11/2021 10:47

The people I know who never taught their children to sleep still have non sleepers who are 5+! I couldn’t cope with that personally. It’s up to you and how you want to live.

It gets harder as they get older.

MBM18 · 27/11/2021 10:35

I breastfed DD3 until 2.5 ish (she would've continued but I'd had enough and was fairly easy to stop so in my eyes she was ready).
I co-slept and then started putting her to sleep in her cot whilst I sat in the room with her when she was around 18 months, would spend hours doing this, now I let her fall asleep in my bed with me next to her and move her to her bed once she's asleep. She does wake around 5am to get back in our bed for another couple of hours sleep but I'm fine with that, I know I could work on getting her to fall back asleep in her bed but to be honest I really can't be bothered yet lol.
But my point is I believe they do change and things get easier when they're ready for it.

Fet2021duejuly2022 · 27/11/2021 10:34

I’m the same I always hated the idea of leaving my baby to cry. The idea of self soothing is really cruel IMO. Go with your instincts op. I always soothed my baby and fed her to sleep. She’s so happy and content and she sleeps without me fine now at home and at nursery. I have a friend who was obsessed with the idea of self soothing her baby from such a young age (like 3 or 4 months). I always felt sad for her baby crying and no one coming to soothe her. (She’d leave her for up to 30 minutes crying). I have to say my friends daughter doesn’t seem in any way affected by this so I think perhaps there’s no right or wrong just go with what feels good for you.

MagpiePi · 27/11/2021 10:34

I co-slept and BF both of mine and as they got older we moved to an arrangement of beds side by side (we had a big bedroom!) I don't think this went on for very long, and the two DCs moved into a shared bedroom when they were toddlers.

I stopped night feeds by having DP offer a drink of water instead of the boob, this took about two or three nights I think.

I tried the leaving to cry themselves to sleep method with DS1. It was horrendous for me and him and lasted one night. IMO, all it teaches is that they will be abandonded and ignored.

Both were really good sleepers and we never had problems when they were toddlers and beyond with waking in the night or anything like that.

Carry on with what you are doing if you are happy and it works for you and your DD.

madmomma · 27/11/2021 10:29

Never taught any of mine. They're L absolutely grand. Co slept with all of them whenever they wanted to. Don't see the big deal whatsoever. I actually think it's jolly good for a child's mental health to know that they can snuggle with mum or dad whenever they need to, even in the middle of the night. Certainly it makes for close bonding. Of course a bedtime routine and sleep hygeine is also important by the time they're in school, but I can't see anything bad about snuggles. There should be more snuggling!

Swipe left for the next trending thread