Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to ask how well you get with SILs/BILs?

112 replies

FreeAsAByrd · 27/11/2021 09:56

Thought triggered by some recent posts. Our extended family will spend a good bit of time together over the holidays, and it is not something I especially enjoy.

-> One SIL I really don't get on with. We have very little in common, and I'm always struggling to have a conversation with her. It's just so boring (she'd probably say the same about me though!)

-> Two BIL that are very career orientated. To an extent I am too, but don't need to talk about it the whole time.

DH and his Dad really enjoy this time together, and I know how much it means to them. For me, it's often a mild form of torture :)

AIBU - YES - I get on well with SIL/BIL
AIBU - NO - I really don't get on well with SIL/BIL

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 27/11/2021 11:13

SIL and I both make an effort to get on, but we really have very little in common with each other. I loved my late MIL. She was like a second mother to me.

User5252727 · 27/11/2021 11:13

I get on brilliantly with my siblings' spouses - I consider them (along with my siblings) to be my best friends, and I love spending time with them. The christmases that we are together are a riot.

I get on fine with my husband's brother, but we aren't close and never will be. He's a few years younger than us and a very different person. No objections to him at all, he's perfectly nice and I don't mind being in his company at family events, but we wouldn't socialise outside them and we don't have anything in common. His girlfriend also seems fine, but she hardly ever comes to family things so I barely know her. It's all friendly and drama-free, though.

My PIL are wonderful, I love them to pieces.

nillynally · 27/11/2021 11:10

My sister in law is a 30 yo with the maturity age of a 14 yo. It's literally like being in the room with a young teenager. Everything's an innuendo, she has no social awareness, she can be very tactless, she's highly competitive and a real show off. She often climbs in or on the children's toys to prove she's small enough to still use them and nothing goes in her mouth until she's satisfied everyone knows she's earned this, because she's been to the gym. She's really hard work but I think everyone else is starting to see it.

crackersforcheese · 27/11/2021 11:08

My sil is my best friend which so many people find strange. But we love it as our children are very close too x

Pbbananabagel · 27/11/2021 11:05

I’ll caveat that though, my sister’s husband is the brother I always wanted. We have tonnes in common and he and my husband really get on too and often go out for drinks

BeyondMyWits · 27/11/2021 11:02

Husband's brother thought it was ok 3 Christmases ago to look at porn videos on his phone whilst sat next to my 17 year old daughter. He has not been in my house since.

Burgerqueenbee · 27/11/2021 11:01

It's a mixture, I'm one of 6 and DH one of 5 so there are a lot of bil/sil.
Only one would I like to never see, one of my bil's partner. She is an odd character and rubs most people up the wrong way, a real shame as that bil was my absolute favourite but he has now changed to be a bit like his DP.

Pbbananabagel · 27/11/2021 11:01

I don’t have a tonne of stuff in common with my SIL/BIL’s but I love them and enjoy spending time with them when we all get together, moreover- I love that my children have them as Aunties and Uncles. We don’t really have the kind of relationship where we’d just get together independent of my husband other than for special occasions eg my hen do, but I look forward to getting to that in the future, we’re family now.

Bellfor · 27/11/2021 10:59

@nettytree

My husbands sister is a bitch who slags me and my kids off. I refuse to call her sil as that assumes we have some kind of relationship.

@nettytree Your SIL would get on well with mine.

Darkpheonix · 27/11/2021 10:57

I dont speak to my brother or his wife after his wife told me (a working mother) that working mothers should be infertile and not allowed children if they won't be a sahp.

Dps sister is my best friend and she introduced us.

Don't have any Bil.

SquigglePigs · 27/11/2021 10:56

I have one SIL (DH's sister). We get on really well. Not a lot in common so probably wouldn't be friends without the family connection but we have fun together when she comes to stay or we're all together at my PILs. We live at opposite sides of the country so get together a few weekends a year (more now we have a DD for her to visit!).

RemorselessNorsemen · 27/11/2021 10:54

Not spoken to her for near on ten years. Very self centred, selfish woman.
Happily for me she doesn't live near us, although she does still attempt to message DH with her demands for MIL's care (things like demanding DH only take her for a certain brand of covid vaccine for one). She never calls him, only FB Message or text and only when she wants something.

DH sees through her now, it took him a while, but the demands, coupled with the complete disinterest in her adult Niece and Nephew (no contact at all, not even a Christmas card and they now don't bother sending her) have lifted the blinkers somewhat.

Greenandcabbagelooking · 27/11/2021 10:48

I really like my SIL (wife of brother). We have quite a lot in common, and she knows when to offer advice and when to just sympathise. We'd probably be friends if we had met randomly.

MrTumblesEyebrows · 27/11/2021 10:48

Husband's sister is a brat who tried her best to spoil our wedding. If the aliens come, I hope they abduct her first.

My brother's wife is nice but they live abroad so we're not close.

sonjadog · 27/11/2021 10:48

I get on fine with my SiL on the surface. She lives far away from me so we don't have much contact. My SiL has some mental health issues which include her being paranoid and overanalyzing every word said to try to make out that you have insulted her in some way. So these days I try to keep conversation to a minimum. She has tried to get into fights with me about this but I refuse to engage as I won't cut off contact with my brother.

WahWahWahs · 27/11/2021 10:44

On reflection, I think I like them more than my/DH’s own siblings Grin

My SiLs are both amazing (DB’s wife and BiL’s wife). They are like sisters to me now and I would choose them as friends.
My BiL and I have less in common, but he is absolutely lovely.

They probably have a WhatsApp group about the family they married into (they bloody should do)

Irishfarmer · 27/11/2021 10:44

My DH's sibling are grand. A lot older than me 15+yrs) we just chat about "easy" things weather, work.

My siblings partner/ spouses I mostly get on with very well. One SIL I have to be wary of, she can snap and turn for no apparent reason. A few of my family say they walk on egg shells around her just to make sure they can see the kids/ keep the peace. Although she was lovely at the last family party we had so maybe we have all mellowed!

sugarapplelane · 27/11/2021 10:41

My SIL is very hard work, always bitter, resentful and full of the woe is me's!!!! Everything is hard for her and you sure as hell know it.

She has to run every decision through her Husband, even down to the tiniest thing, which makes me wonder what their relationship is like behind closed doors.

She's done some pretty mean and spiteful things in the past and hasn't always been in her best behaviour.

I don't like spending time with her at all.

Sh05 · 27/11/2021 10:39

Oh and my husband's sisters are all different but with age we have all learned to get along. The eldest and youngest are completely different than the middle sister who was harder to get along with, very opinionated and gossipy but I don't see her as often anymore so we get along fine.

MrsToothyBitch · 27/11/2021 10:38

My BiLs are really lovely. Sweet, thoughtful, good fun and kind. Love them both

I do like my SiL and she can be nice if she's getting something out of it... but we get tired of her constant need for competition with DP- her eldest brother. She recently had a shit fit because DP didn't tell her he was going to propose to me before he did it, then asked some extremely patronising and insulting questions of DP that are not her business. SiL didn't apologise but has since tried to insert herself into our planning with constant offers to "help". She only messages DP about it though, despite getting silence back. She seems to have forgotten the bride might have some input/want some creative control, lol. She might get engaged herself soon- it's all just attempts to get info, undermine and meddle because it's really all about a one sided sibling rivalry she self perpetuates and having to win.

winnie19 · 27/11/2021 10:37

Me and my SIL have a good relationship but don't talk every week or spend time together really unless it's a family thing, we used to be very good friends who used to hang out a lot just us a few years ago and go on holiday just us two but she went travelling, Covid hit and we slightly drifted x

Sh05 · 27/11/2021 10:36

I get on fine with my brother's wife, we're the same age and had similar upbringings. My bil's wife is very nice person, we meet twice a year she is alot younger so interests and stuff are different and when we meet we get along fine.
(Why doesn't the English language have different terms for different sil's?!)

SineOfTheThymes · 27/11/2021 10:34

I get on OK with SILs. It's a superficial relationship though, and without the extended family aspect I can't imagine we'd be in contact due to locations, interests, etc.

BIL made a pass at me one drunken night many years ago. I was sober enough to push it off, and as a result I totally avoid him (I'm actually very very attracted to him, but wouldn't go there)

MrsPleasant · 27/11/2021 10:33

I don't find it easy to form close relationships with people so for me, my ex 'SIL' was just a random my brother lived with. I was obviously nice to her, and she was fine, but above that she wasn't really anything to do with me.

KnotKnot · 27/11/2021 10:28

My DH has two brothers, and I get on very well with them. They are all very similar in mannerisms, hobbies (the same sport), work in same broad industry, etc. In fact I sometimes think I could have ended up with any of them!! They are a very close family.