Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to ask how well you get with SILs/BILs?

112 replies

FreeAsAByrd · 27/11/2021 09:56

Thought triggered by some recent posts. Our extended family will spend a good bit of time together over the holidays, and it is not something I especially enjoy.

-> One SIL I really don't get on with. We have very little in common, and I'm always struggling to have a conversation with her. It's just so boring (she'd probably say the same about me though!)

-> Two BIL that are very career orientated. To an extent I am too, but don't need to talk about it the whole time.

DH and his Dad really enjoy this time together, and I know how much it means to them. For me, it's often a mild form of torture :)

AIBU - YES - I get on well with SIL/BIL
AIBU - NO - I really don't get on well with SIL/BIL

OP posts:
Snuggledupforwinter · 27/11/2021 12:55

My Dsis seems to have partners with issues she hopes to fix. Only keep in touch via text with 1 of the exes who is now in rehab and more sociable.
On inlaws side PIL both have died and were very different but very fond of DH and DS. DstepFIL sends Xmas cards but havent seen him in years as he now lives abroad. DBIL also died, and DSIL has a "sense of humour" based on sneering or jokes at others expense (especially towards my DH) so we are LC despite living 15 mins away.

Clovacloud · 27/11/2021 12:51

SIL has the most chaotic life of anyone I have ever met, we aren’t close. But we can be polite for the one time a year we are in the same room.

BIl is alright, but he’s 20 years younger than me so we don’t have a lot in common other than DH.

I do envy people that have nice in-laws as friends.

Christmas1988 · 27/11/2021 12:48

I get on well with my husbands sister, my brothers wife has become one of my best friends but my husbands brothers wife I don’t dislike we are just very different! So two out of three I like.

DramaAlpaca · 27/11/2021 12:47

DH's siblings are great. They are wonderful people who welcomed me into the family and treat me as another sister, and their spouses are lovely too. I'm very lucky.

BurnedToast · 27/11/2021 12:46

And she's a shit Aunt to my children , when I've been a very good one to her children.

BurnedToast · 27/11/2021 12:42

I se her once a year and that's enough for me. She's self centred and constantly whipping up a cloud of gloom around herself like a bloody dementor.

CorvusPurpureus · 27/11/2021 12:40

I'm close to the SIL who was married to xh's dB. (So doubly an xsil now I suppose!)

We always got on really well superficially, but only bonded properly after we both dumped our hs (brothers).

My ex banned bil & sil from ever contacting me again when we split; bil was quite happy to go along with this, & sil couldn't face the WWIII that would have resulted in staying in touch, so she distanced herself too. That hurt, tbh.

A couple of years later she ditched bil for being a controlling twat, & in the aftermath got in touch with me to apologise for ghosting me. We - warily - met for lunch, & three bottles of wine later, we'd laughed till we cried & realised how much we genuinely liked each other.

We've been really good mates ever since - despite living in different countries now, we get together every chance we get for a day out/weekend away & stay in touch regularly online.

(The fact that the ghastly Brothers Narcissist, our respective xhs, pare baffled & fumingly irritated by this is also a bonus...Grin).

My other sil, xh's dsis, I haven't spoken to since the split - she obeyed the 'ban' on me. She quietly sends the occasional discreet, friendly 'say hi to Corvus' message via my dc, to whom she's an amazing aunt, but she's too nervous of upsetting her dB to contact me openly, so I'm happy to keep my distance & not drop her in the shit with her family.

As for my own db's dw, she's pleasant enough, & would probably say the same of me, but we have absolutely nothing in common. 10 minutes of small talk about our respective teens & we're all out of conversation! But she & dB adore each other so it's all good.

thelegohooverer · 27/11/2021 12:39

We all get along well enough, without any major issues or problems. But if we weren’t family I don’t think we’d have naturally gravitated to each other but I enjoy their company when we get together.

I think one of my sil’s finds me quite hard work so I have to make a bit more effort with her. She’s a good sort though. I do envy people who are friends with their in laws as I feel I lost my db who used to me much closer.

MrzClaus · 27/11/2021 12:33

I really liked my BIL until he got with his current partner (I hate using SIL as IMO she is nothing to bloody do with me!) and she's ruined the relationship we had, the relationship he had with my DP (his brother) and she's working on ruining his relationship with his parents. He used to stay with us regularly, come for meals and days out etc him and my DP used to play sports together, go on days out / weekend away and it was in general really amazing - like having a brother!

Unfortunately his new partner - she's horrible, snipey, rude, mean, so so impolite and just generally a nasty person who thinks doing drugs is okay. She unfortunately got pregnant (on her terms without my BIL being aware) quickly and now they have a child. We see their child only when he's with BIL, as she won't see the wider family. She's put a wedge between BIL and PIL by being so so rude to their faces that it's just unbelievable, we were all so close before. She's got her friends and family and she's openly said that's enough, she doesn't need more family. I hope for BILs sake he wakes up soon, he moans about her to all of us and it's so hard to hear, but he thinks he won't see his child if he leaves.

It's horrible, I hope it fixes itself soon!

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 27/11/2021 12:27

Love mine and get on so well. As do the kids. Just wish they didn’t live in Australia as we haven’t seen them in SO long and I don’t know when we will 😢

ChristmasScrooge · 27/11/2021 12:25

One SIL we have nothing to do with. To put it frankly, she's a evil psychopathic cow.

The other SIL we have a good relationship, but I was friends with her before I got with DH. Smile

Sn0tnose · 27/11/2021 12:19

On my side, I don’t like my BiL. It’s completely mutual and over the years we’ve just developed a veneer of politeness. Never met my other BiL. I absolutely adore my sil. We’re pretty close and I consider her to be my sister.

On DH’s side, I get on fine with both of them but don’t really know them beyond a surface level because we’ve always lived so far away. Same for one of DH’s step brothers. The other I get on quite well with and we’ll catch up by text every month or two.

AuntieMarys · 27/11/2021 12:11

Not at all. They have massive chips on their shoulders and wish it was 1970.

OhGiveUp · 27/11/2021 12:06

I get on fine with them all. They're all very nice people who are easy to get on with.
We see each other as family.

Powaqa · 27/11/2021 11:51

I have never met one BIL or his wife and we have been married 13 years. There were some issues re their DC and my PILs are now the DCs legal guardians.
We don't have a relationship with the other BIL and SIL. They are arseholes and we haven't spoken to them in 12 years.
There are no family meals at Christmas

CorpusCallosum · 27/11/2021 11:50

I love DHs sis, we had our first babies at the same time and bonded. We live far apart so aren't in each other's pockets at all but we get on. She will have our DC if anything happens to us.

My brothers wife is lovely but we're not on the same wavelength. She's brilliant for my DBro though so I love her for that.

KarenofSparta · 27/11/2021 11:32

The two blood-related to my Ex-H were awful for many varied different reasons. The two non-blood related BIL & SIL were fab, kind, interesting: I often think now that that contrast should have been a clue that my marriage was doomed.

RampantIvy · 27/11/2021 11:27

My BIL is a self absorbed, lazy, selfish arsehole, but we are civil towards each other.

My SIL takes the view that no-one is good enough for her family and isn't close to her son in law or daughters in law. She actually told me this herself. Then she wonders why her sons don't visit as often as she would like them to.

MIL noticed that SIL was quite frosty with me and ws quite cross about that.

VienneseWhirligig · 27/11/2021 11:17

Only 3/6 are still alive (late DH's siblings) and then my sister has a partner.

My sister's partner is great. I love her like another sister, the pair of them have been on holiday with us loads and we are very close.

DH's siblings: one SIL is very reclusive and while we get on fine we don't see each other beyond funerals and weddings. The other SIL is lovely and since DH's death has made a real effort to include me in family events and keep in touch. BIL is recently widowed himself and has deteriorated, he's now an alcoholic who has stopped managing his diabetes because he is heartbroken. I've tried to help him but he's not receptive. So I am there if he wants to talk, which he does often, but his health is his business. He has grown up children who are estranged from him (and DH used to be close to him but then stopped seeing so much of him a few years back) so he is very lonely.

CurbsideProphet · 27/11/2021 11:17

My sibling's husband is very nice, we get on well. He's easy to get along with.

DH's sibling and their spouse are difficult. Not conversational and just different to me. They threatened to never speak to DH again during our first cycle of IVF. He was looking after me and not available to see them every weekend to lavish praise on their ability to procreate without medical assistance. I just "grey rock" them all now as it's easier.

Kitkat151 · 27/11/2021 11:17

3 of my sister in laws are like I would imagine a sister relationship to be....li have known them 35 years and we are very close( I’ve only got brothers) ....the other 2 SILs I have no time for .....i last saw one of them 10 years ago and the other one 6 years ago .....and if I never see them again that’s fine by me.

saraclara · 27/11/2021 11:16

I've always got along okay with my SIL, but after my DH's death we've become much closer. Our kids are similar ages and all get on too. So it's all pretty nice and comfortable.

Dogsaresomucheasier · 27/11/2021 11:15

My husband’s brothers can be utter dicks. Their wives and I have our own support group.

SquarePeggyLeggy · 27/11/2021 11:14

Not really, but we are both polite people so it’s fine!

Kendoddsdadsdogsdadsdead · 27/11/2021 11:13

Oddly, I view my siblings in-laws as family and love them. My in laws on my husbands side, I like them, and get on with them, but they aren't my family and while I enjoy spending time with them, I'm not their mates and wouldn't do anything individually with them, as I would with my siblings partners.