Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to voucher instead of Christmas night out

84 replies

Askinforabaskin · 26/11/2021 18:33

Basically I have agreed to arrange the night out for my team at work. We have a budget of £35 per head every year. Usually if you don’t attend your money just gets put into the kitty for drinks for everyone else.

Obviously last year we didn’t have a night out due to covid. So everyone got a bottle (tbh it could have been anything they wanted from the supermarket) in place of that.

This year we are having a day out (meal followed by drinks, in the afternoon so people can still get train home). Obviously due to the nature of these things not everyone can make it due to other commitments so I have had a few people say they can’t attend.

But today I had a pretty shitty phone call from a guy saying he disagreed with the night out and he didn’t want to catch covid and was demanding a voucher instead. Although I am organising it, I have no control over the money (I have purely just been contacting the venue). Unfortunately the manager who is in control of the money is off just now as his poor wife is very ill. I tried to explain the situation to the guy and that basically it wasn’t my call to make and he was rather nasty about the manager. I managed to palm him off but no doubt he’ll be back in contact soon.

OP posts:
WomanStanleyWoman · 27/11/2021 03:53

@Whichcatthatcat

Thats just silly. The party is open to all, if you decide not to go, fair play, just politely refuse the invite. Just like any other social event.

I often put cakes in the staffroom on a Friday. I get an alternative for those with allergies. If someone told me they didn't fancy a cake but could I give them the £2 cash equivalent I'd tell them to take a running jump!

Unless you own the company, that’s your choice.
Whichcatthatcat · 27/11/2021 03:45

Thats just silly. The party is open to all, if you decide not to go, fair play, just politely refuse the invite. Just like any other social event.

I often put cakes in the staffroom on a Friday. I get an alternative for those with allergies. If someone told me they didn't fancy a cake but could I give them the £2 cash equivalent I'd tell them to take a running jump!

SpinachIsAGatewayDrug · 27/11/2021 03:33

@WomanStanleyWoman

I've never known any to offer cash/alternatives if you don't go to he Christmas party, summer ball, Halloween bash, or any of the other seemingly endless socials they put on.

Neither have I - but I’m not arrogant enough to think it never happens.

I didn't?
WomanStanleyWoman · 27/11/2021 03:20

I've never known any to offer cash/alternatives if you don't go to he Christmas party, summer ball, Halloween bash, or any of the other seemingly endless socials they put on.

Neither have I - but I’m not arrogant enough to think it never happens.

WomanStanleyWoman · 27/11/2021 03:18

@gofg

Yeah it does which says I won’t take shit off a crap company . If Every employee is asked to go to a works do that’s paid for and they have a decent excuse why they can’t go then yes they should get their portion back. Thank god I’ve worked for decent companies clearly.

I've been around a very long time, and have known dozens of people who, for one reason or another, don't wish to attend a works do. Not one of them has ever felt they were entitled to a voucher instead. A company not paying people who don't attend a works do most certainly does not make them a "crap company". I can't believe the level of entitlement of some people. You get paid to do a job, your employer offers something extra, you choose not to avail yourself of the opportunity, then tough luck.

I wouldn’t be boasting about being around a long time’ if I were you. You just sound a bit old-fashioned.
SpinachIsAGatewayDrug · 27/11/2021 03:12

@gofg

Yeah it does which says I won’t take shit off a crap company . If Every employee is asked to go to a works do that’s paid for and they have a decent excuse why they can’t go then yes they should get their portion back. Thank god I’ve worked for decent companies clearly.

I've been around a very long time, and have known dozens of people who, for one reason or another, don't wish to attend a works do. Not one of them has ever felt they were entitled to a voucher instead. A company not paying people who don't attend a works do most certainly does not make them a "crap company". I can't believe the level of entitlement of some people. You get paid to do a job, your employer offers something extra, you choose not to avail yourself of the opportunity, then tough luck.

Gottta say this is my experience. I've been lucky enough to work for some fairly fab companies. High ranking in top places to work. The kind where when I tell people the perks they take the piss because they are so outlandishly generous. I've never known any to offer cash/alternatives if you don't go to he Christmas party, summer ball, Halloween bash, or any of the other seemingly endless socials they put on.

Genuinely never come across it. That might well be because the variety of perks was such that people didn't worry too much if they didn't get their share of 'this one' but I don't think that alone marks them out as a good company or a bad one.

Marvellousmadness · 27/11/2021 03:07

Tell him to take it up to management if he wants
But how rude is he. Demanding a voucher and getting shitty about it. Pff

violetbunny · 27/11/2021 03:00

My workplace provides coffee but I don't drink it, should I ask them to top up my salary by £5 a week to cover it?Grin

Honestly, some people...

maddening · 27/11/2021 01:06

No to anvoucher anyway as it is a cash equivalent imo.

Shamoo · 27/11/2021 00:05

Good grief, I cannot believe the number of people who think they should get to decide not to go to the work Christmas party and just get the money instead. 😂😂😂😂😂😂

A Christmas party is intended as a thank you, but also an opportunity for team building etc. They are tax deductible engagement activities. They should never be compulsory, but you don’t get to just pick the cash instead. My old work place did an annual ski trip, should I have got the cash equivalent the year I didn’t fancy it?! It’s threads like this that make me think MN is truly bonkers. Probably the same people who thought work should pay for their heating and electricity during Covid while they saved hundreds on their usual commute.

OP, the vast majority of work places won’t be offering a voucher to the people who decide not to go to their Christmas party! Yes some will, which is fine, but if your company don’t then you will be aligned with many others - don’t worry.

Also, he sounds like a total dick generally.

TokenGinger · 26/11/2021 23:16

He was an arse to handle it the way he did but I do see his point of view.

I think a festive treat should be accessible to all or to none. I exhaust all of my childcare options just to enable me to work, so going out in an evening isn't a possibility for me. I'd feel a bit gutted that my only chance of receiving a token gift is if I gave up my personal time and paid for a babysitter. I think it would be a very nice gesture for those unable to make it to be given a gift from the money that was set aside for them on the first place.

Kite22 · 26/11/2021 23:15

I think it depends.
Say there are 20 of you in your Team, and you've been told "there is £700 to pay for a Christmas Meal / party", then obviously if someone chooses not to go, then they just miss out on that little perk.
OTOH, if the company have said "there is £35 per head for a Christmas 'treat' / 'bonus' {call it what you like}", then I think he has a fair point. I mean there is no reason to be rude to the poor sod who has been landed with the thankless task of organising it, but the point is right..... if the company are giving £35 to each person then it should reach each person.

Pianojazzy · 26/11/2021 23:08

Well at my company they’ve given us all the money and it’s our choice whether to spend it on a night out with colleagues or pocket it. This is to recognise that we’re in a pandemic and not everyone would feel comfortable going out during the busy festive season.

So I totally get his point….but he sounds like a d*ck so I’d just be sure to enjoy drinking his allowance!

Smartiepants79 · 26/11/2021 23:07

@DrManhattan

Ah! The enforced fun of the work Christmas party
It’s not enforced though is it? Not for the majority. Just don’t go. In the kind of job where attending this kind of thing might actually impact on your career prospects these kind of networking events are common and just part of your job.
minionsrule · 26/11/2021 23:01

Our very large organisation has always had £35 kitty for Xmas do, if you decide not to go thats up to you, you don't get the money if you choose not to attend..... why would you?
Last year because it wasn't possible to have a do they put it to the vote of a voucher for everyone or donate the money to charity.
I have declined to go this year because its a crap venue but I don't expect the money in lieu

QualityChecked · 26/11/2021 22:45

Whenever an employer tries to do something nice for staff there's always someone who makes you wish you hadn't bothered!

DrManhattan · 26/11/2021 22:42

Ah! The enforced fun of the work Christmas party

gofg · 26/11/2021 21:49

But the Christmas party is not a right it is a perk

Exactly what I said! This voucher business, where does it end. Person C doesn't want a meal, or a voucher, but asks for something else! You either take the perk which is offered or you go without.

5foot5 · 26/11/2021 21:22

@Beachbabe1

I agree with him in afraid. Why should his £35 xmas treat go towards others if he doesn't want to go? He should be given a gift or voucher for the £35. You should suggest to management a meal or gift voucher alternative. Very unfair otherwise.
But the Christmas party is not a right it is a perk. I would guess that a company gets a better deal with a venue the more people are going. So if they budget say £35 per head for 100 people that might give a particular meal, amount of drink etc. If only 50 decide to go the price per head might go up. If the people who don't go still expect the equivalent in money then it all costs more surely?

Also, as mentioned I think lots of people see it as also being a team building idea. If someone is asking for money instead this is kind of the opposite. I don't want to spend time with you give me the money and I will stay away.

I have worked in places where I always went to the Christmas do and some where I didn't but it would never ever have occurred to me I should get an alternative gift if I stayed home. Sounds massively entitled to me

TractorAndHeadphones · 26/11/2021 20:54

@Burnmyhousedown

I think it’s something to do with tax isn’t it? If you pay for a do up to a certain amount and invite all employees then no income tax payable. I think if you say gave everyone vouchers then the employer/ employee income tax would be payable.
I’m not tax lawyer but looked it up online. A party for employees is tax- free. The £35 a head obviously to estimate the cost per employee and not that each employee will receive exactly £35 worth.

By contrast gifts over £50 and vouchers are taxable.

The company could of course offer a gift instead but I’m sure plenty would complain about that too

DriftingBlue · 26/11/2021 20:44

He should not have been rude about it and he probably should not have said anything at all, but I agree with the employee that arranging an event just for the workers that feel safe socializing in a crowd is really insensitive. Management is potentially alienating dedicated employees with this event and that is never wise.

Beautiful3 · 26/11/2021 20:39

I agree with him. Those who can't go should be given a voucher instead of supplementing others alcohol bill.

Burnmyhousedown · 26/11/2021 20:28

I think it’s something to do with tax isn’t it? If you pay for a do up to a certain amount and invite all employees then no income tax payable. I think if you say gave everyone vouchers then the employer/ employee income tax would be payable.

Beachbabe1 · 26/11/2021 20:22

I agree with him in afraid. Why should his £35 xmas treat go towards others if he doesn't want to go? He should be given a gift or voucher for the £35. You should suggest to management a meal or gift voucher alternative. Very unfair otherwise.

PooWillyNameChange · 26/11/2021 20:13

Gosh how petty. I work for a wonderful company who treat me really well and wouldn't expect a voucher. The whole idea is to get the team together to build rapport, surely? If someone has annual leave on a day we get cake or a free lunch we don't post them a meal deal Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread