Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very very petty - sibling warfare/binned post

119 replies

Yesiknowhowpettythisis · 26/11/2021 13:25

I have NC for this because it really is extraordinarily petty and I’m a little bit ashamed of myself but still want to ask the question (just not to be associated with my normal username!):

For context, my older brother is the golden child and really is a very nasty, nasty piece of work. He gets away with murder. We haven’t spoken in nearly 2 years because of a fight we had when I was heavily pregnant and he got drunk and bullied me quite badly and verbally attacked my husband. Despite this when my son was extremely ill with sepsis I reached out to him for familial support. Nothing. So I’m pretty finished with him and frankly I am furious. His girlfriend goes along with all of this.

Anyway, we used to rent the same flat they are currently in. We moved 2 years ago. Our postal redirection ran out a year ago and they have just been binning our post (Which my mother refuses to accept as he’s the golden child).

We did not change the address the car is registered to as we just didn’t realise. 100% our fault - lesson learnt. DH received a speeding ticket and due to this and the post being binned, it’s now a court summons. Which we only realised because another neighbour saw some of our post in the bloody communal bin and brought it round!!!!

I know it’s ultimately our fault but MN I hate him so much now and I just want to know if I can be the pettiest person alive and somehow get him into trouble for binning our post. Yes, I’m awful.

OP posts:
PheasantsNest · 26/11/2021 15:17

100% your fault. No sympathy at all. It's infuriating getting other people's post. You just couldn't be arsed to sort it out.

fabricfanatic · 26/11/2021 15:14

It's amazing to me that anyone is defending your brother in this situation. Of course he should have given your mail to your mother! You're not some random stranger, and it wouldn't have taken much effort for him to do the right thing.

He's annoyed to be receiving your mail? Understandable, but tossing it in the bin won't fix the situation. Sending a message through your mum, on the other hand, would! It seems clear enough that he did this to be deliberately spiteful.

I don't think there's anything you can do about it, though. Don't let it eat away at you, if you can help it. You already hate him and have cut him out of your life; this is simply another confirmation that you're better off without him.

EIIa · 26/11/2021 15:10

Well I bin post now after two years of faffing about.

You should have updated your details by now!

PinkWednesdays · 26/11/2021 15:08

I’m pretty sure you’re not supposed to bin someone else’s post though if I can get my brother in trouble somehow then bonus

You have lost any sympathy votes with this and in fact, judging by your pettiness, I suspect there is a lot more to the story.

lockdownalli · 26/11/2021 15:07

YABU - you should have done the mail redirect.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 26/11/2021 15:05

YANBU - If you see an official letter for someone you know, even if you dont speak to them, you have to be a complete a-hole to bin it. If it is official and you dont want to get in touch with them, you write not at this address and stick it in the post box. It is not hard. The fact your brother is an arse is bad enough, but the constant defence of his by your DM is awful. Sorry.

Yesiknowhowpettythisis · 26/11/2021 14:51

Why are you talking to your mother about this at all?

I don’t understand this question.

@Chasingaftermidnight

We are going to raise it we are happy to accept a fine or similar as it’s our mistake; DH wants to explain to them that we haven’t deliberately avoided paying but thst we didn’t change the address/didn’t realise. If we get in trouble then we get in trouble - our fault. I’m pretty sure you’re not supposed to bin someone else’s post though if I can get my brother in trouble somehow then bonus.

OP posts:
Chasingaftermidnight · 26/11/2021 14:46

It’s really annoying and he’s an arsehole for binning it. But equally you did commit an offence by not updating the address (and this is why it’s an offence!) So if I were you I would really wouldn’t try to take this any further because you’re likely to come off worse.

3scape · 26/11/2021 14:42

Yeah it's annoying. But it's consistent . If you'd moved and forgotten then any other new tennant would have done the same. Your brother has already demonstrated there's no connection there. A shame, but I wouldn't be even raising it with someone who's not part of my life in that way

Beckert · 26/11/2021 14:41

He sounds horrible op. He should have given it to your mum but he didn't. Make sure your admin is in order now to stop him doing anything like this again. And have nothing more to do with him.

diddl · 26/11/2021 14:38

To a point your mother has created this by setting the two of you against each other.

He's not a decent person though so can't really be surprised that he bins your post.

unname · 26/11/2021 14:34

Why are you talking to your mother about this at all?

julieca · 26/11/2021 14:33

Oh for god sake I wouldnt dump a strangers mail in a communal bin never mind a relatives. I would put it back in the postbox with not known at this address.
MN has shown me how horrible a lot of people are.

emmathedilemma · 26/11/2021 14:30

@Dozer

YABU. You went no contact - fair enough - but still want him to ‘be there for you’ in times of need and to do you favours.

Your and your H’s admin: your responsibility.

this!!
AnFiadhRua · 26/11/2021 14:26

No it's not the same! You want your brother to treat you like his sister and thats not unreasonable.

People saying but would you expect a stranger to do that miss the point. If a stranger owes you nothing and gives you nothing, it doesnt HURT.

My brother and I arent speaking but if some post of a legal nature came to my house, id pass it on. WouldNT send biscuits with it though. or a note.

PerfectlyUnsuitable · 26/11/2021 14:26

@lanthanum

Step back from it being your brother who lives there. If it had been anyone else, they would probably have binned the post too.
Nope I woud never have binned the post. After two years, I would have either send it back to sender or send it to the person if I knew where bthey were. At the evry least, I'd have told them they were still receiving suff.

I think binning the posts would have been petty for anyone. Binning the post when iuts a family memebre is taking revenge and trying to hurt the person in any way possible.

@Yesiknowhowpettythisis, I'd reset a 6 months redirect from that address and review what you are receiving. Check again that you have made all the changes you need.
And do NOT in any shape or circumstances rely on your dbrother to behave like a decent person.

Yesiknowhowpettythisis · 26/11/2021 14:22

@AnFiadhRua

Gaslighting is the word!

OP posts:
Yesiknowhowpettythisis · 26/11/2021 14:22

you had 12 months to change your postal address. So yabu

We changed it absolutely everywhere else. For everything else. We genuinely just didn’t realise about the car as we had changed our licence addresses and thought that was it! Ignorance isn’t an excuse but we weren’t being lazy or doing it on purpose.

OP posts:
Yesiknowhowpettythisis · 26/11/2021 14:20

@Collaborate

I’m sorry that’s really really awful. It’s amazing what people can’t push to the side when there is illness or emergencies.

OP posts:
Yesiknowhowpettythisis · 26/11/2021 14:19

If your tenant wasn't your brother they'd likely have binned it too

I think it’s hard though because although we aren’t talking the tenant was my brother. It’s hard to just pretend he wasn’t/it’s the same. It’s not the same!

OP posts:
AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 26/11/2021 14:15

@SelfHelpPlease

You had 12 months to change your postal address. So yabu.
I agree.
Theunamedcat · 26/11/2021 14:13

My ex husband is an offender he is also very offensive nasty spiteful and mean I have to have contact with him due to our children he did not change the address of his licence he got caught for driving offenses the letter came to my address the first one I handed to him telling him to change his address the second I called him and told him again to change his address (it was almost five years after he left) he yelled down the phone at me screaming abuse saying he would do it when he could be bothered so I gave the police his mum's address his nans address and his girlfriends address

He changed his address

The only ones I've ever thrown away have been specsavers

And I loathe him

Collaborate · 26/11/2021 14:11

My sister went NC with me for some imagined slight. I won't go in to the details but it involved her pointedly ignoring me on the rare occasions our paths crossed. No amount of family persuasion would change her view, And that was nearly 10 years ago.

4 years ago mum was showing signs of dementia. I reached out to sister and suggested we cooperate to as to help our parents (without either of us having to bury the hatchet - it would just involve us parking our issues to the side). Her response was to speak to my mum (of all people) and tell her why she wasn't going to reply to my letter. I found this unforgivable and there is absolutely no way back from this for me.

Doubtless my sister thinks I'm in the wrong. I certainly think she's in the wrong, but she's been dead to me now for too many years for me to ever contemplate having anything to do with her. So I'd say YABU for having unreasonable expectations of someone who you have effectively cut out from your life.

JustLyra · 26/11/2021 14:03

I think you need to split the two issues apart.

The post was entirely your fault. You should have changed your address. If your tenant wasn't your brother they'd likely have binned it too - or if they'd got pissed off they could have informed the DVLA that you didn't live there and you'd be facing another fine for not changing your address.

Your mother defending your brother regardless of what he does is going to be a constant issue if you don't deal with it.
He's not going to change and neither is she. The only thing you can change is how you deal with it.
As someone who is NC with multiple people because of my eldest brother, his behaviour and their way of dealing with it (pandering) I can tell you that the best decision I ever made was to forget about my brother.

I don't ask about him. I don't want to know. When people told me stories I politely stopped them and told them I wasn't interested. Eventually most people stopped. It's great, I don't have to hear any of his shit anymore.
The people who continually tried to talk to me about him or who didn't respect what I wanted I got to a point where I had to decide if they were bringing anything positive to my life. The ones that were had a final conversation about not bringing him up. The ones who weren't, or who still harp on about him, I'm no longer in contact with.

Don't get tied up in petty revenge. Just cut his toxicity out of your life.

AnFiadhRua · 26/11/2021 13:55

@Yesiknowhowpettythisis

I think this situation hasn’t been helped by my mother repeatedly denying he has binned my post despite the evidence to the contrary eg the neighbour fishing it out of the bin and us not receiving what I imagine were several warnings.
Yeh, the gaslighting that goes on in these situations.

My parents weren't speaking to me, and my brother went over to their house and sat around talking about how awful I was but then he told me that they weren't stonewalling me. Confused

It sounds like he was trying to get you in serious trouble. He is really invested in to remaining the golden child isn't he? The worse you look the better he looks and he's an adult now with a wife (or gf) but he is NOT letting go of that identity of golden child at all!