Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Copycat Friend

214 replies

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 12:19

Can't believe I'm writing this in my 30s as it seems incredibly petty but here I am anyway!

My friend and I have known each other since we were 4 and have always been good friends but not best friends, I.e. see each other maybe once a month and text weekly.

I now have a 6 month old and she has a 2 month old. The issue (petty though it is) is that she is copying a lot of my sons things and it's driving me nuts. Since the babies have been here, we've been seeing each other much more for walks/ coffee etc. She had really bad baby blues and I like to think I've supported her with it as best I can by having a listening ear etc. She is now feeling well again. The things she is copying are clothes, snowsuits, some of his toys. I don't know how she knew where they were from as I specifically never told her. I could cope with this- they grow out of them so quickly that I don't really care as they're into something new quickly. However she has now escalated and has picked the same nursery wall paper and furniture (the furniture has little silver cross badges on, I specifically didn't tell her where it was from).

AIBU to find this annoying and if so, how can I bring it up without ruining our friendship?

OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 17:02

@thepeopleversuswork

I don't understand these threads tbh.

I couldn't care less if people "copied" stuff.

To be honest though no one owns the intellectual property on stuff they've brought from the shops. It's not "yours" -- it's something you have bought. Presumably along with hundreds of thousands of other people.

Life is too short to get upset about stuff like this.

Besides which she's obviously not in a great place at the moment. If you pull her up on it you will probably be contributing to her feeling generally shit about herself.

Let it go and learn to care less about stuff that doesn't matter.

You're right it doesn't matter Smile
OP posts:
1forAll74 · 26/11/2021 16:54

She probably just likes your choices of things, nothing wrong with that. Lots of people copy everything, that's why they watch influencer numpties..

thepeopleversuswork · 26/11/2021 16:49

I don't understand these threads tbh.

I couldn't care less if people "copied" stuff.

To be honest though no one owns the intellectual property on stuff they've brought from the shops. It's not "yours" -- it's something you have bought. Presumably along with hundreds of thousands of other people.

Life is too short to get upset about stuff like this.

Besides which she's obviously not in a great place at the moment. If you pull her up on it you will probably be contributing to her feeling generally shit about herself.

Let it go and learn to care less about stuff that doesn't matter.

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:43

@LouiseBelchersBunnyEars

I suppose it depends on personality… my friends and I have similar tastes - I’m more likely to ring my friend saying ‘I’ve seen x on sale that’s really nice, do you want me to pick you up one as well’ than worry if they buy it after me
I feel it's different - that would be me offering them info/the awareness of something abs that would be me choosing to do so knowing they could have the same. Copying takes the option of choicely have the same or different things away from me Completely
OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:42

@ThinWomansBrain

she may be "feeling better" in tems of holding a conversation without busting in to tears, but still be feeling really down and finding it hard to make decisions - so find it easier to pick up on your ideas. Does it really matter?
It's not I'm my top 3 worries in life but it does irk me
OP posts:
LouiseBelchersBunnyEars · 26/11/2021 16:39

I suppose it depends on personality… my friends and I have similar tastes - I’m more likely to ring my friend saying ‘I’ve seen x on sale that’s really nice, do you want me to pick you up one as well’ than worry if they buy it after me

ThinWomansBrain · 26/11/2021 16:35

she may be "feeling better" in tems of holding a conversation without busting in to tears, but still be feeling really down and finding it hard to make decisions - so find it easier to pick up on your ideas.
Does it really matter?

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:30

[quote Nootherwilldo]@NearlyThereMum most good friends are happy to share ideas etc with their friends![/quote]
But there's sharing ideas and there's flat out copying. I think they are two different things

OP posts:
Nootherwilldo · 26/11/2021 16:28

@NearlyThereMum most good friends are happy to share ideas etc with their friends!

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:27

@Sceptre86

It is annoying. I'm the kind of person who actually spends time researching products, reading reviews my sil doesn't and will openly admit she copies what I buy for my dd for her own as she knows it will be good. She bought the same cot, bedding, changing table, formula and is already asking what theme I am doing her nursery up in. It is never reciprocal, if I say I like something her son is wearing she will never say where she got it from (always a gift). I get the whole imitation being a form of flattery and all that but it gets annoying after a while. Have some originality !

Depends on how much you value the relationship . The idea to go shopping with her might be nice. if not say you find it annoying and would rather she didn't.

That's exactly it- it's not one or two things, it's quite a lot now. Thanks for understanding. Many people seem to think I'm being a sh** friend but actually I've. Or let on your her that it's annoying me and I've been really supportive of her. Hope we both get a break from the 'flattery' soon as they start to develop their own style a bit more
OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:25

[quote MollysDolly]@NearlyThereMum

I get what you mean. I had a friend, who copied everything I bought. And I'd get so pissed off. We'd meet up and she'd be wearing the same boots, same handbag and not even acknowledge it. I'd be inwardly seething thinking "ffs we're matching handbag wankers" and that people would think that we, also in our thirties, looked ridiculous.

Turns out she had crippling low confidence. She admired me and how confident I was and was trying to mirror that in the only way she could. She couldn't act the same, but she could look the same, and to her that was some form of a step forward. She was emulating what she wanted to become, in the only way she could manage because her mental health wasn't allowing her in any other.

She's moved away now, so I don't really see her, but my point is, that my thoughts and irritation shifted very quickly, when I understood the why. It must have been truly horrible for her. And there I was, glaring at our matching boots as a first world problem. Perspective.[/quote]
That's such a nice comment, thank you. I will take this on board, my friend could be feeling the same

OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:24

[quote Nootherwilldo]@NearlyThereMum I don’t think you’re justified in being annoyed. You’re the one who has set up this thing that your nursery, clothes, toys need to be unique not your friend.

My best friend and I have very similar tastes. I wasn’t even pregnant when she took me round her nursery saying oh you should get this chair I got it from X, it’s so comfortable, I got these shelves from Y they were a good price. She loved her nursery and knew that I’d want similar so she actively discussed it with me instead of being petty and trying to keep it secret or say I couldn’t have what she had. That’s the kind of friend I want to have personally.[/quote]
Glad you and your friend are happy sharing things if that's what you want to do

OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:23

[quote thebleepblop]**@thebleepblop I have actually been very supportive. I have gone round when she's phoned crying etc when she was having a rough time. She said she's feeling better. I can be annoyed and still be a good friend, the two are not mutually exclusive. I am still a person too

There is being annoyed and then there is actually thinking of telling someone, especially someone you know has been struggling, to stop 'copying' by buying the same mass produced items you do. Most people are probably minorly annoyed by their friends at some point. But most deal with it by having a moan and a laugh about it with their partner. It has to be something pretty serious to raise it with a friend. And this isn't it.

Telling your friend would be humiliating for her and would make you look weirdly possessive about mass produced commercial items.
It would also make it perfectly clear you care more about your sense of 'ownership' of those items than you do about the feelings of your friend.

However, from your replies you seem to have realised that there are bigger and better ways to handle this that are more attuned to your friend so good for you.[/quote]
There are definitely bigger problems which I have said many times but I can still feel irritated by it. She's having a hard time but I'm a person too and I do feel I've been a good friend. I have long raised it with her, I've kept my annoyance to myself but just wanted some other perspectives on it to see what others thought. Some people have given some really nice advice which I've appreciated

OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 16:21

@3luckystars

You could also put disgusting huge gold jewellery on your child and see if she falls for it.
Grin
OP posts:
3luckystars · 26/11/2021 16:11

You could also put disgusting huge gold jewellery on your child and see if she falls for it.

Chocoqueen · 26/11/2021 16:10

@Inquisitivearchitect

My friends and I absolutely love being matchy matchy.

We know another mum from school who straight up copies but she is low and she’s desperate (literally desperate) to feel like she’s part of something and have friends. And she’s our friend so we embrace it. And in fact, sometimes we copy her to give her a lift. We want to bond with her and welcome her into our friendship group.

Friendship takes compromise.

Why don’t you introduce her to Pinterest and help her find herself and her style?? Be a good mate Smile

You and your friends sound lovely.
Nootherwilldo · 26/11/2021 16:07

My friend and I have also often gone shopping and bought the same clothes as we both loved them! Neither of us cares. It’s not like we’re designed them off the rack!

thebleepblop · 26/11/2021 16:06

@thebleepblop I have actually been very supportive. I have gone round when she's phoned crying etc when she was having a rough time. She said she's feeling better. I can be annoyed and still be a good friend, the two are not mutually exclusive. I am still a person too

There is being annoyed and then there is actually thinking of telling someone, especially someone you know has been struggling, to stop 'copying' by buying the same mass produced items you do. Most people are probably minorly annoyed by their friends at some point. But most deal with it by having a moan and a laugh about it with their partner. It has to be something pretty serious to raise it with a friend. And this isn't it.

Telling your friend would be humiliating for her and would make you look weirdly possessive about mass produced commercial items.
It would also make it perfectly clear you care more about your sense of 'ownership' of those items than you do about the feelings of your friend.

However, from your replies you seem to have realised that there are bigger and better ways to handle this that are more attuned to your friend so good for you.

Nootherwilldo · 26/11/2021 16:06

@NearlyThereMum I don’t think you’re justified in being annoyed. You’re the one who has set up this thing that your nursery, clothes, toys need to be unique not your friend.

My best friend and I have very similar tastes. I wasn’t even pregnant when she took me round her nursery saying oh you should get this chair I got it from X, it’s so comfortable, I got these shelves from Y they were a good price. She loved her nursery and knew that I’d want similar so she actively discussed it with me instead of being petty and trying to keep it secret or say I couldn’t have what she had. That’s the kind of friend I want to have personally.

MollysDolly · 26/11/2021 15:58

@NearlyThereMum

I get what you mean. I had a friend, who copied everything I bought. And I'd get so pissed off. We'd meet up and she'd be wearing the same boots, same handbag and not even acknowledge it. I'd be inwardly seething thinking "ffs we're matching handbag wankers" and that people would think that we, also in our thirties, looked ridiculous.

Turns out she had crippling low confidence. She admired me and how confident I was and was trying to mirror that in the only way she could. She couldn't act the same, but she could look the same, and to her that was some form of a step forward. She was emulating what she wanted to become, in the only way she could manage because her mental health wasn't allowing her in any other.

She's moved away now, so I don't really see her, but my point is, that my thoughts and irritation shifted very quickly, when I understood the why. It must have been truly horrible for her. And there I was, glaring at our matching boots as a first world problem. Perspective.

Sceptre86 · 26/11/2021 15:52

It is annoying. I'm the kind of person who actually spends time researching products, reading reviews my sil doesn't and will openly admit she copies what I buy for my dd for her own as she knows it will be good. She bought the same cot, bedding, changing table, formula and is already asking what theme I am doing her nursery up in. It is never reciprocal, if I say I like something her son is wearing she will never say where she got it from (always a gift). I get the whole imitation being a form of flattery and all that but it gets annoying after a while. Have some originality !

Depends on how much you value the relationship . The idea to go shopping with her might be nice. if not say you find it annoying and would rather she didn't.

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 15:48

@Santaischeckinglists

Did she choose a similar name op?
She did actually!

@thebleepblop I have actually been very supportive. I have gone round when she's phoned crying etc when she was having a rough time. She said she's feeling better. I can be annoyed and still be a good friend, the two are not mutually exclusive. I am still a person too

OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 15:44

@MollysDolly

I read this, as she's struggling, she's potentially got bad PND, and doesn't know what to do or think half the time.

She sees you, as a mum who's got it together. So in quite a basic way, if she copies what you do, buys what you buy, she's getting something right, because that's what a good mum is doing.

I actually feel really sad for her. Please don't get annoyed with her, she's doing this because she doesn't know what else to do. You probably are a complete rock to her right now, just by being there to "copy". Try and imagine how her head must be, and be a good friend to her Flowers

That's very true, I've not said it to her. It's just getting annoying but understand what you're saying
OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 15:43

@Inquisitivearchitect

My friends and I absolutely love being matchy matchy.

We know another mum from school who straight up copies but she is low and she’s desperate (literally desperate) to feel like she’s part of something and have friends. And she’s our friend so we embrace it. And in fact, sometimes we copy her to give her a lift. We want to bond with her and welcome her into our friendship group.

Friendship takes compromise.

Why don’t you introduce her to Pinterest and help her find herself and her style?? Be a good mate Smile

That's a nice idea thank you
OP posts:
DingleyDel · 26/11/2021 15:36

I honestly can’t imagine worrying about this when you have 6 mo. I wouldn’t give it anymore head space. It’s not like loads of people see inside a babies nursery.