Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Copycat Friend

214 replies

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 12:19

Can't believe I'm writing this in my 30s as it seems incredibly petty but here I am anyway!

My friend and I have known each other since we were 4 and have always been good friends but not best friends, I.e. see each other maybe once a month and text weekly.

I now have a 6 month old and she has a 2 month old. The issue (petty though it is) is that she is copying a lot of my sons things and it's driving me nuts. Since the babies have been here, we've been seeing each other much more for walks/ coffee etc. She had really bad baby blues and I like to think I've supported her with it as best I can by having a listening ear etc. She is now feeling well again. The things she is copying are clothes, snowsuits, some of his toys. I don't know how she knew where they were from as I specifically never told her. I could cope with this- they grow out of them so quickly that I don't really care as they're into something new quickly. However she has now escalated and has picked the same nursery wall paper and furniture (the furniture has little silver cross badges on, I specifically didn't tell her where it was from).

AIBU to find this annoying and if so, how can I bring it up without ruining our friendship?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
G5000 · 27/11/2021 15:17

I mean sure if it looked like Single White Female territory, it would be a bit unnerving. But some clothes and same nursery set is probably not too psycho.

Kanaloa · 27/11/2021 15:08

@G5000

Of course in your case with some matching clothes you don’t see why it would bother someone.

But would it really not perplex/bother you if you went round to your friend’s house, stepped into the living room, and found that their carpet, couch, coffee table, television stand, right down to the art on the walls, was all the same as your living room? I don’t think many people wouldn’t be uncomfortable or annoyed with that.

G5000 · 27/11/2021 15:02

I'm not sure why it doesn't bother some people

Because I honestly don't understand why it should. Whenever someone says that they like something I have, I'm happy to tell them where I got it from. And of course I wouldn't then be surprised if they got the same. With some friends we actually buy matching clothes for our kids on purpose, they look cute. I guess the only situation where I would be bothered was if someone for example bought the same dress to wear to the same event, knowing they look way better than me in it Grin

Or do you mean the friend claims the items are not inspired by your choices and they just accidentally found and bought all the similar stuff?

Fabellini · 27/11/2021 14:09

I’d be irritated if I’m honest. Of course she may well be struggling, she might have no imagination, she might think you’re the oracle of good taste…and everything everyone else has said.
It’d still bug me though if I was you!

NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 14:04

[quote Knickynackynoo]@NearlyThereMum I think its because they haven't experienced it, this thread really got me thinking last night as I haven't seen the friend who used to do it in a long while to me. It honestly is really unsettling. This is how it started with me and I found it mildly annoying but it really escalated to the point of weirdness.

And, I think people are using the wrong examples other friends and I have loads of similar/same things we're we've recommended them to on another or I've asked they've asked. But what is nearly always the case here....as someone mentioned up thread is that the copier never says 'oh that's nice' ',that's lovely, do ypu mind of we get one' this friend I'm talking about never once complemented me, my home but ended up looking and buying things which were identical.[/quote]
Sorry I have replied to your other comment by accident 😂 too much going on!

OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 14:02

[quote Knickynackynoo]@Penistoe snowsuit in winter, furniture, pretty necessary I would say.[/quote]
Plenty of shops with plenty of items to choose from I would say

OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 14:02

[quote Knickynackynoo]@NearlyThereMum I think its because they haven't experienced it, this thread really got me thinking last night as I haven't seen the friend who used to do it in a long while to me. It honestly is really unsettling. This is how it started with me and I found it mildly annoying but it really escalated to the point of weirdness.

And, I think people are using the wrong examples other friends and I have loads of similar/same things we're we've recommended them to on another or I've asked they've asked. But what is nearly always the case here....as someone mentioned up thread is that the copier never says 'oh that's nice' ',that's lovely, do ypu mind of we get one' this friend I'm talking about never once complemented me, my home but ended up looking and buying things which were identical.[/quote]
That's it, I think you've hit the nail on the head there. People like to think they would be 'above' this perceived pettiness but as someone who takes time to choose things and. It rush into purchases, this is really annoying. She's done it with other things too- her dad got a new car and was so proud of it, was showing it off (he is my neighbour) and said he had been wanting one for a while and finally bit the bullet etc. Honest to god my friend came round two weeks later with the exact same car (same colour) and I can't help thinking it must have hurt her dads feelings

OP posts:
Knickynackynoo · 27/11/2021 13:42

@NearlyThereMum I think its because they haven't experienced it, this thread really got me thinking last night as I haven't seen the friend who used to do it in a long while to me. It honestly is really unsettling. This is how it started with me and I found it mildly annoying but it really escalated to the point of weirdness.

And, I think people are using the wrong examples other friends and I have loads of similar/same things we're we've recommended them to on another or I've asked they've asked. But what is nearly always the case here....as someone mentioned up thread is that the copier never says 'oh that's nice' ',that's lovely, do ypu mind of we get one' this friend I'm talking about never once complemented me, my home but ended up looking and buying things which were identical.

Knickynackynoo · 27/11/2021 13:35

@Penistoe snowsuit in winter, furniture, pretty necessary I would say.

NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 10:17

@ForcedOut123

I have a friend who does this. Actually, her and her husband do it. I don’t even want to invite her over anymore because she literally gets everything the same and passes it off as ‘her ideas’. She keeps up with the Joneses which is more to do with her lack of confidence so I empathise but it feels disingenuous. I think you either do friendships like that or you don’t. I don’t. She is being false and that’s the bigger issue for me. And also, get your own style!
I think there are quite a few people in the same boat. I'm not sure why it doesn't bother some people, the bigger items really annoyed me at the time. I'm thinking I would be better meeting her somewhere other than my house and being careful what I post online if it's going to be something I'd be annoyed about her copying
OP posts:
ForcedOut123 · 27/11/2021 10:14

I have a friend who does this. Actually, her and her husband do it. I don’t even want to invite her over anymore because she literally gets everything the same and passes it off as ‘her ideas’. She keeps up with the Joneses which is more to do with her lack of confidence so I empathise but it feels disingenuous. I think you either do friendships like that or you don’t. I don’t. She is being false and that’s the bigger issue for me. And also, get your own style!

NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 10:07

@SarahBellam

I don’t understand why you would be annoyed. Is it because you think people will notice you have the same stuff and compare you?
No I just find it annoying when numerous things I've chosen are then being copied. I'm not kidding the amount of stuff is unreal. Clothes etc I wasn't overly fussed about but the wallpaper and furniture were what I would consider bigger purchases and so really annoyed me. They will be used for a long time whereas clothes and toys are Quickly grown out of
OP posts:
SarahBellam · 27/11/2021 10:05

I don’t understand why you would be annoyed. Is it because you think people will notice you have the same stuff and compare you?

NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 09:54

@Penistoe

You probably own multiple things you have seen other people have. This is why all the unnecessary things you have for your child was sold to you. Its capitalism.
You're very judgemental and your assumptions are based on nothing. I'm assuming you live off the land and make all your own clothes?
OP posts:
Penistoe · 27/11/2021 09:06

You probably own multiple things you have seen other people have. This is why all the unnecessary things you have for your child was sold to you. Its capitalism.

NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 09:00

@Marvellousmadness

It would make me raise my eyebrows i guess But maybe try a different approach and just embrace it and feel flattered. Otherwise it might ruin your friendship and i dont think thats worth it

But maybe try asking her? Casually i mean

I think I'm just going to try and let it go. We've been friends a long time and it would be a shame to lose that, just feel a bit hacked off though
OP posts:
NearlyThereMum · 27/11/2021 08:59

@Kanaloa

The clothes wouldn’t bother me because kids clothes generally look similar but I would be weirded out that she’s chosen the exact same wallpaper and furniture for her baby’s room, so her child’s room is an exact copy of yours. I would just find it odd, and it’s obviously not coincidence like having the same snowsuit from next would be.

I don’t think you can really say anything though without making it really uncomfortable so I would just shrug it off. Maybe compliment some of her own things as she must be feeling insecure to copy someone else to such extremes.

That's a good idea, I'll compliment her own stuff. Maybe she is just feeling insecure and looking for a safety in numbers type of reassurance.... thanks
OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 27/11/2021 07:07

It would make me raise my eyebrows i guess
But maybe try a different approach and just embrace it and feel flattered. Otherwise it might ruin your friendship and i dont think thats worth it

But maybe try asking her? Casually i mean

LoveGrooveDanceParty · 27/11/2021 06:58

Exactly. Copying one or two things - no big deal.

But when it becomes an noticeable pattern, that’s different.

Not saying the OP should say anything, as I said upthread. But it’s OK to find it annoying.

Kanaloa · 27/11/2021 06:54

@G5000

I still don't get why it annoys you. If it's a design you came up with, it's your business, and someone copies it and sells it as their own - yes fair enough. But it's a generic shop bought snowsuit. Your friend takes a look and says 'good choice, I like it too'. Why is that a bad thing?
The snowsuit is one thing, it’s from a shop and to be expected that others may have the same. But I think anyone who says they would find it totally normal if a friend came over, looked at their home, then replicated it exactly with the same wallpaper and furniture is lying to be honest. It is unusual behaviour to copy everything in someone else’s child’s bedroom.
Kanaloa · 27/11/2021 06:52

The clothes wouldn’t bother me because kids clothes generally look similar but I would be weirded out that she’s chosen the exact same wallpaper and furniture for her baby’s room, so her child’s room is an exact copy of yours. I would just find it odd, and it’s obviously not coincidence like having the same snowsuit from next would be.

I don’t think you can really say anything though without making it really uncomfortable so I would just shrug it off. Maybe compliment some of her own things as she must be feeling insecure to copy someone else to such extremes.

Muchmorethan · 27/11/2021 04:37

That's really insightful into the other side of this, thank you for sharing and hope you're better now

DS is 18yrs now ..... that's a whole different strain on the mental health Grin

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 22:26

[quote lmnoh]@Ticksallboxes I'm wondering if I'm that friend 😂[/quote]
😂😂😂

OP posts:
lmnoh · 26/11/2021 22:21

@Ticksallboxes I'm wondering if I'm that friend 😂

NearlyThereMum · 26/11/2021 22:10

@Kinko

I'm in an NCT group and we all go and buy the same stuff. As soon as someone says - 'we just bought xyz and it's great', we all run off to get it.

OK the wallpaper is a bit odd, but I bet you that it's nothing more than a 'Jane Doe has this wallpaper in her nursery and it looks great, I will get that one'.

I wouldn't worry about it, especially with toys. Everyone has the same development toys. My friend bought a toy for her baby, same age as mine and I was like - that looks good and she was like, yeah it's great you can get it from amazon. Immediately ordered one.

Also, I don't know about anyone else, but my ability to make a decision has been seriously impaired since having a baby. It's noticeable, even to me! Apparently this is a very real symptom of baby brain, so maybe she's genuinely struggling with that, so it's just easier to buy stuff that she knows worked for you, rather than make her own decisions :-)

Have never heard this about decision making! Good to know, thanks
OP posts: