Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in wanting my DP to lose weight?

158 replies

OneforTheTeamo · 26/11/2021 04:23

I've been with my DP for close to five years. He had a bit of a tummy when I met him but at over six foot he could carry it off.
Since then he has gradually put on at least 2 stone, all round his stomach and if I'm being honest I hate it. He moves like a fat man now, breathes heavily and snores like a train. He struggles to get up from the sofa and I feel embarrassed for him when we are out sometimes. He doesn't care and makes a joke about his size.
We both love cooking and eating but I'm more into healthy things and keep myself very fit and in shape. I'm older than he is but would guess I'm a lot healthier.
I've tried literally everything, gentle encouragement, suggestions of different diets, cooking healthily or making lovely salads but he will eat that then later go and make a bowl of noodles.
He thickly spreads butter on bread and eats several slices with a meal. He'll eat large slices of cheese whilst cooking, so basically has zero interest in losing weight. He insists on full fat coke and gets cross if I buy diet.
It's got to the stage now where his clothes are xxl and won't fit on the drier. Sex is just uncomfortable and though I love him and he's fabulous in other ways I don't want to stay with him in his current state.
I've ended up losing it with him then hating myself as I can't be tactful anymore plus I see his total disregard of my thoughts about his health and lack of attractiveness as a sign of not caring enough about me.
What can I do? Am I being unreasonable in giving him an ultimatum?

OP posts:
MarleneDietrichsSmile · 26/11/2021 07:23

Yabu regarding ultimatum

You can’t change someone

If he does not want to change, that’s that. You will have to decide if it’s a dealbreaker

Darkpheonix · 26/11/2021 07:22

@CurzonDax

Wow. Imagine if a man had said this about a woman. The responses would be, "Every woman is beautiful and come in all shapes and sizes", or he'd be accused of body shaming and superficial for only being attractive to slim girls.

For the record, I would agree with all those kind of comments - a man should be ashamed of himself for body shaming any woman.

But the same standards also need to apply in reverse. I feel sorry for the OP's partner.

See this to me doesn't make sense.

Not everyone woman is attractive to every person on the planet. Neither is every man. I find that most people will be beautiful or attractive to someone. But not everyone.

Are all people beautiful? That depends on what you mean. I believe we can find something beautiful in most people. That doesn't mean you want to make a life with them or have a sexual relationship with them.

No one is obliged to want to have sex with someone else. No one is obliged to find someone attractive.

Which is what I think when the posts are the other way round.

Op, isn't obliged to find her attractive or be guilty of body shaming her partner.

If its got the point that people are using 'body shaming' towards people who don't fancy someone, then it's not OK.

Stellaris22 · 26/11/2021 07:18

@Silvercatowner

I’ve sent mine for a health screen

Its like you are talking about your hamster, not your husband.

That was my reaction too! It's like that poster is talking about an animal they're sending to the vet.
Silvercatowner · 26/11/2021 07:16

I’ve sent mine for a health screen

Its like you are talking about your hamster, not your husband.

AnxiousPixie · 26/11/2021 07:09

I can understand you. I'm in the same position. Although I still fancy him and love him and it didn't make me want to end my marriage I work so much for his health in the long term and wonder if it will 'ruin' our retirement together. That makes me sad. 😥

Beautiful3 · 26/11/2021 07:05

Try talking to him about it. Tell the truth, that you're not attracted to him when he's over weight. Offer to go jogging with him.

CurzonDax · 26/11/2021 07:04

Wow. Imagine if a man had said this about a woman. The responses would be, "Every woman is beautiful and come in all shapes and sizes", or he'd be accused of body shaming and superficial for only being attractive to slim girls.

For the record, I would agree with all those kind of comments - a man should be ashamed of himself for body shaming any woman.

But the same standards also need to apply in reverse. I feel sorry for the OP's partner.

Capferret · 26/11/2021 07:02

My dh put weight on for a few years when he was suffering with depression.
I was a bit naggy at times because I found it a real turn off.
Luckily his work circumstances changed and he lost the weight and is back to doing his sport and keeping fit.
I am mindful that dh had to do it himself though, my input didn’t help at all.

TheWitchersWife · 26/11/2021 06:52

I see his total disregard of my thoughts about his health and lack of attractiveness as a sign of not caring enough about me.

I'm the one who has put on alot of weight in my relationship. If my DH felt like that I would be fuming, I know its annoying you and you care about his health and clearly also how he looks. But its so self centered its unreal, you are making it all about you. If you are unhappy then leave him. No amount of guilting someone to eat healthier is every going to work. I absolutely hate being fat, I was basically starving myself to be slim when I met my DH.
I do hate myself, I have low self esteem, anxiety, I can't hear someone laughing in the street without assuming they are laughing at me.
But in no way us any of that affect how much I care and love for my husband.
If he believed there was a correlation between me struggling with my weight and how much I love him, I'd tell him to get a grip.
And even as much as I hate my body, I still pick at cheese, order takeaways, overeat. I wish it was as easy as just stopping.

(As an aside I have been healthy eating and exercising for 2 weeks now, I do try, it just never really sticks).

Antsgomarching · 26/11/2021 06:51

It’s up to you, my DH have been together through fat and thin (we switched around i used to be a lot thinner and now the tubby one, he used to be tubby and now thin). It’s just not the most important thing to either of us.

But ultimately if it’s important to you then it may not work out. You can’t force him to lose weight.no-one is owed a relationship and no-one is owed sex, you can leave a relationship for any reason. But you were really awful to “lose it with him”. He’s not being fat to piss you off.

Often when men are complaining about a wifes weight its in the context of having had children, not lifting a finger or taking on the load and then complaining she’s not exercising and eating right when she’s overwhelmed.

But yeah either accept it or leave, but don’t have a go at him, that’s definitely not going to help.

HugeAckmansWife · 26/11/2021 06:51

There is a world of difference between middle aged women putting on weight due to pregnancy and menopause and possibly the difficulty of fitting in exercise and healthy eating alongside juggling work and the domestic mental load and a man who is eating extra calories just for the hell of it as the op describes. In the former situation, I would expect a partner to help in a supportive way and understand the challenges around that woman losing weight. In the latter, the op is cooking healthily, offering support and he's just ploughing on regardless. I think she it NBU to explain how she feels and yy to the idea that his approach and attitude is the problem more than the actual weight.

hotcrossedbums · 26/11/2021 06:49

If he is over 40 then book him an NHS well-being check at the GP. I do these daily for patients. We discuss alcohol, smoking, height/weight/bmi and do finger prick test for cholesterol and diabetes risk. Sometimes the results can be shocking enough to get people to really rethink.
We can also refer to intervention services. He may not like it at the time but often patients say to me after that they subconsciously think back to the results and have made small, maintainable changes.

Southernbellenot · 26/11/2021 06:46

You could be speaking about my ex.

It got to the point it was uncomfortable during sex and he was sweating on me.

I lost respect for him and stopped having sex with him. He then suggested counselling as apparently I had damaged his self esteem by not sleeping with him.

We didn't split up because he was fat, although it was his weight that disintegrated our relationship.

Gettingthereslowly2020 · 26/11/2021 06:42

I wouldn't stay with someone overweight if they weren't willing to do something about it. And yes, I'd say the same to a man posting about an overweight wife. You're not obligated to have a sexual relationship with someone you're no longer attracted to just because you signed a piece of paper years ago.

If you're not physically attracted to your spouse then you're just friends who live together aren't you? I have plenty of overweight friends, people come in all shapes and sizes but I wouldn't get into a romantic relationship with someone overweight because I don't find that attractive.

You've tried being supportive and encouraging but nothing is changing. You either leave or accept that this is your life now.

VienneseWhirligig · 26/11/2021 06:40

Maybe it's the nagging that is doing it? To be honest, if I had someone trying different ways to do anything that I was finding hard to motivate myself to do, I would also dig my heels in and be stubborn, regardless of how I felt about that person, to mask the fact I was finding it hard and was too proud to ask for help. It's a real problem with me and I find it utterly frustrating but can't stop myself doing it - and food is one of those areas where I do it. Every time my mum says something about dieting, I reach for the cheese and self sabotage.

It's a tricky one. I found myself still attracted to DH when he was heavier, because I loved him dearly and he was willing to put up with me at my heaviest too, and still find me attractive and love me. I am not sure I would feel that way about anyone else, but then I'm not with anyone so it's easy for me to say that. In the end, you like what you like, and if for you that is someone slimmer and healthier, then that is what you are attracted to and it then has to be a decision about whether you love him enough to overlook the lack of attraction. And it isn't an easy decision. Those who say that a man saying the same about a woman are right in a way, but the point is, it isn't always a shallow decision. Sometimes the person does agonise over it, but doesn't tell anyone else, so it appears shallow.

LoveComesQuickly · 26/11/2021 06:37

It's a cliche but it's true: it has to come from him. Nothing you say or do will work if he's not motivated to do it for himself.

Frazzled50yrold · 26/11/2021 06:36

The op didn't say if they have children. I've been in a similar situation and made all the excuses re it was his prerogative, he needed to be ready to diet himself etc. Meanwhile he peaked at around 25 stone and developed heart and pancreatic issues. It's very difficult to teach children healthy eating habits when their father guzzles 6 litres of coke per day.He had to leave work and be financed by myself whilst most of his time is spent attending clinics. Not an attractive lifestyle and I'm putting that mildly.

ShinyMe · 26/11/2021 06:34

This bit stuck out for me:
I'm more into healthy things and keep myself very fit and in shape. I'm older than he is but would guess I'm a lot healthier.

Don't guess. Body shape doesn't tell you a whole lot. For decades, my dad was outwardly healthy looking. Didn't drink, didn't smoke, slim as anything, very physically active. Me and my mum were (are) fat and less active, drank a bit, didn't eat as well. For decades he nagged us "you're unfit, you're going to have a stroke, you're going to have a heart attack, you should lose weight" etc etc. Then he had a massive stroke because it turned out he had super high cholesterol and blood pressure which he assumed he didn't have because he was thin and active. He's now severely disabled. When my mum and I got checked out after that, our blood pressure and cholesterol was excellent and the GP said our health was fine. My dad was really grumpy about that.

Jabvribt · 26/11/2021 06:30

I don’t think an ultimatum is the answer; I do think you can tell him that it’s effecting your relationship because of the sex side and you worry about his health. Be direct rather than tactful or annoyed.

Cacee3029 · 26/11/2021 06:27

Your feelings are valid but I feel it it was a man talking about a female there would be an uproar... also, you are probably affecting his self esteem if you keep mentioning. Being overweight isn't something he can fix overnight! He needs to be in the right mindset too!

I can see both sides but I feel you would be damaging his self esteem.

TractorAndHeadphones · 26/11/2021 06:21

But an ultimatum…no…

TractorAndHeadphones · 26/11/2021 06:20

You need to be direct.
Fat around the stomach is harmful and increases the risk of heart disease
I’ve sent mine for a health screen - let the doctor tell him
I know he struggles with impulse though so might get him more paid help

sjxoxo · 26/11/2021 05:40

@romdowa

Yabvu, you don't have to fancy him for what ever reason but once you start issuing any ultimatum then the relationship is over. Strange to see the replies here though , if a man wrote this about his female partner .... Well it would be a whole different kettle of fish.
I don’t see the similarities in this person who perhaps is struggling with motivation or self care, and a woman going through the menopause. I expect that the weight gain or lack of self care is a symptom of another issue; eg depression/stress rather than a biological change. You can be menopausal or a ‘laid back’ character and still enjoy looking after yourself or keeping healthy- I don’t think the two scenarios are comparable xo
TopCatsTopHat · 26/11/2021 05:37

I totally understand that this is off putting, I'd feel the same. In my relationship I'm the one who has put a bit of weight on, combination of reasons. My dh doesn't criticise but will encourage supportively if the topic comes up which is the best approach if the reasons are contextual as they are for me, and once my situation improves I intend to improve my figure for health reasons. I'm lucky in that my weight gain hasn't gone so far that dh has stopped finding me attractive but I wouldn't blame him if that halterneck I wouldn't fancy him if he was too fat either (though I'd still love him obviously).
The real problem here is that your dh has student outlook to health and diet. If its not depression (and if it is your attitude will not be helping at all) and he just doesn't believe staying healthy is necessary /worth doing then it's like any issue in life where two partners have wildly different priorities - you have to try to understand each other to see if it's a deal breaker.

PheonixGlitterRepublic · 26/11/2021 05:36

You can’t issue an ultimatum though!

Swipe left for the next trending thread