Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU in wanting my DP to lose weight?

158 replies

OneforTheTeamo · 26/11/2021 04:23

I've been with my DP for close to five years. He had a bit of a tummy when I met him but at over six foot he could carry it off.
Since then he has gradually put on at least 2 stone, all round his stomach and if I'm being honest I hate it. He moves like a fat man now, breathes heavily and snores like a train. He struggles to get up from the sofa and I feel embarrassed for him when we are out sometimes. He doesn't care and makes a joke about his size.
We both love cooking and eating but I'm more into healthy things and keep myself very fit and in shape. I'm older than he is but would guess I'm a lot healthier.
I've tried literally everything, gentle encouragement, suggestions of different diets, cooking healthily or making lovely salads but he will eat that then later go and make a bowl of noodles.
He thickly spreads butter on bread and eats several slices with a meal. He'll eat large slices of cheese whilst cooking, so basically has zero interest in losing weight. He insists on full fat coke and gets cross if I buy diet.
It's got to the stage now where his clothes are xxl and won't fit on the drier. Sex is just uncomfortable and though I love him and he's fabulous in other ways I don't want to stay with him in his current state.
I've ended up losing it with him then hating myself as I can't be tactful anymore plus I see his total disregard of my thoughts about his health and lack of attractiveness as a sign of not caring enough about me.
What can I do? Am I being unreasonable in giving him an ultimatum?

OP posts:
theleafandnotthetree · 26/11/2021 11:12

@OneforTheTeamo

Marvellousflowers It's not appalling, he's a gorgeous looking man with a fantastic personality and I love him very much but his fat takes away from his looks. I'm guessing you're on the large side to be so defensive? It's not all about me It's about his self respect and more importantly his health, both now and long term. I'm not shallow, fat is unattractive and that is a fact, but we aren't supposed to fat shame but instead watch overweight people gorge themselves and make excuses. I know losing weight is tough but there's no doubt slim is both healthy and sexy. Yes I can see now that saying I'd give him an ultimatum is draconian and unrealistic, I love the guy! I just want him to get back to his former weight for his health's sake.
OP, I'm pretty much with you on this but you are going to get your arse handed to you on a plate with this post, honestly. On a broader level, I find it terrible how as a wider society we have almost accepted that eventually we'll all end up fat and unhealthy. How we are now is a blip in terms of human evolution, the size your partner is and hos seeming indifference to it would have been considered highly unusual and note-worthy even 30 or 40 years ago but no, you're the bitch for not being DELIGHTED with him. I sometimes think we've lost our collective self respect. I feel the same about people going around perpetually in slobby clothes and pyjama like atire but that's a whole other thread!
Marvellousflowers · 26/11/2021 11:11

@OneforTheTeamo

Marvellousflowers It's not appalling, he's a gorgeous looking man with a fantastic personality and I love him very much but his fat takes away from his looks. I'm guessing you're on the large side to be so defensive? It's not all about me It's about his self respect and more importantly his health, both now and long term. I'm not shallow, fat is unattractive and that is a fact, but we aren't supposed to fat shame but instead watch overweight people gorge themselves and make excuses. I know losing weight is tough but there's no doubt slim is both healthy and sexy. Yes I can see now that saying I'd give him an ultimatum is draconian and unrealistic, I love the guy! I just want him to get back to his former weight for his health's sake.
Hey, You are making everything conditional on him being the weight you want or prefer. What if he suddenly was paralyzed, went blind, had a disability - would you be as judgemental then?

I'm not at all defensive merely pointing out the appalling way you see your partner. For the record I'm at my normal weight, run, swim every week and generally healthy but guess what even if I was not my partner would still be there for me and still love me as I was. Even your comment about me shws hat you will readily resort to using weight as a shaming tool to get what you want.

His self respect and his health are exactly that - his. So if you dont want to accept that maybe you should find someone thinner and move on? You dont want him to be healthy, you want him to be thin, like you want.

Did you ever think that maybe some of his emotional eating could be triggered by being with a controlling and shaming partner? Appalling. he sounds like he would be better off single.

Stellaris22 · 26/11/2021 11:11

Being slim or skinny isn't a sign of being healthy though. I've been in spin classes where very slim people have given up after five minutes, but the individuals OP would label as fat (so unhealthy) have powered through and are amazing.

I wonder how OP would feel if her husband was fit but in her eyes, still overweight.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 26/11/2021 11:10

@OneforTheTeamo

Marvellousflowers It's not appalling, he's a gorgeous looking man with a fantastic personality and I love him very much but his fat takes away from his looks. I'm guessing you're on the large side to be so defensive? It's not all about me It's about his self respect and more importantly his health, both now and long term. I'm not shallow, fat is unattractive and that is a fact, but we aren't supposed to fat shame but instead watch overweight people gorge themselves and make excuses. I know losing weight is tough but there's no doubt slim is both healthy and sexy. Yes I can see now that saying I'd give him an ultimatum is draconian and unrealistic, I love the guy! I just want him to get back to his former weight for his health's sake.
Well you've contradicted yourself there.

"his fat takes away from his looks" & "fat is unattractive"

vs

"I just want him to get back to his former weight for his health's sake"

OneforTheTeamo · 26/11/2021 11:08

NightmareSlashDelightful

It just figures...excuse the pun. From my experience people who get hot and bothered about comments regarding size are usually taking it personally.

OP posts:
NightmareSlashDelightful · 26/11/2021 11:04

I'm guessing you're on the large side to be so defensive?

Charming!

OneforTheTeamo · 26/11/2021 10:55

Marvellousflowers
It's not appalling, he's a gorgeous looking man with a fantastic personality and I love him very much but his fat takes away from his looks. I'm guessing you're on the large side to be so defensive?
It's not all about me It's about his self respect and more importantly his health, both now and long term.
I'm not shallow, fat is unattractive and that is a fact, but we aren't supposed to fat shame but instead watch overweight people gorge themselves and make excuses.
I know losing weight is tough but there's no doubt slim is both healthy and sexy.
Yes I can see now that saying I'd give him an ultimatum is draconian and unrealistic, I love the guy! I just want him to get back to his former weight for his health's sake.

OP posts:
Goatinthegarden · 26/11/2021 10:51

@DontGetYourKnickersInATwist
That's fine, and if you felt you couldn't be with someone who wasn't in your view taking care of their health, that would be completely fair enough! However, they don't owe you a healthy body. They are allowed to do what they like without their dp saying "but what about MY feelings"? Because it's his body. You don't get to tell him what to do with it. You can leave him though. That's up to you (I'm assuming this is a hypothetical though). Fwiw, I couldn't be with someone completely unhealthy either. It wouldn't just be about weight. But op can't make the issue all about her feelings on his body. That's not right.

I totally agree that someone doesn’t owe me a healthy body. I would never force someone to change for me.

For me it is not just about weight either, I have a friend who is very slim but has become really inactive and I have found our friendship waning recently because we no longer enjoy the same social activities and move around at different paces.

It is hypothetical, but I think I would end up resenting someone who made no effort to join me in the lifestyle that I feel is important to lead. I have no problem with other people wanting to live their life however they desire, but I wouldn’t want to be in a relationship with someone who’s outlook was so different from mine.

Much in the same way I might not want to be with someone who suddenly changed their political views, or started believing in something I didn’t agree with.

Marvellousflowers · 26/11/2021 10:42

@OneforTheTeamo

I've been with my DP for close to five years. He had a bit of a tummy when I met him but at over six foot he could carry it off. Since then he has gradually put on at least 2 stone, all round his stomach and if I'm being honest I hate it. He moves like a fat man now, breathes heavily and snores like a train. He struggles to get up from the sofa and I feel embarrassed for him when we are out sometimes. He doesn't care and makes a joke about his size. We both love cooking and eating but I'm more into healthy things and keep myself very fit and in shape. I'm older than he is but would guess I'm a lot healthier. I've tried literally everything, gentle encouragement, suggestions of different diets, cooking healthily or making lovely salads but he will eat that then later go and make a bowl of noodles. He thickly spreads butter on bread and eats several slices with a meal. He'll eat large slices of cheese whilst cooking, so basically has zero interest in losing weight. He insists on full fat coke and gets cross if I buy diet. It's got to the stage now where his clothes are xxl and won't fit on the drier. Sex is just uncomfortable and though I love him and he's fabulous in other ways I don't want to stay with him in his current state. I've ended up losing it with him then hating myself as I can't be tactful anymore plus I see his total disregard of my thoughts about his health and lack of attractiveness as a sign of not caring enough about me. What can I do? Am I being unreasonable in giving him an ultimatum?
Imagine if a male poster put this post up.

''My wife is fat, I'm embarrassed for her. I keep trying to make her thinner, I even cook for her, skinny things like so that she can be thin, like I want her to be. I dont want to stay with her in her current state...'''

Your post OP is appalling and you have managed to centre his weight difficulties as being all about you. Ultimatum - um yes, then maybe he will be free to eat and be what he wants.
As an aside you could read the 'why we eat too much' book and learn about weight set points and how a lot of weight gain is really not affected by diet.

DontGetYourKnickersInATwist · 26/11/2021 10:28

@Fluffycloudland77

He doesn’t owe you a sexy bod, that’s true. You can’t help it if you find it unattractive though.

Men would get lynched if they said this, it follows that they feel like this too.

Exactly what I said. You don't have to find him attractive or even to love him at every size. But he hasn't wronged you by gaining weight. That is ridiculous. I wouldn't stay with someone who had no regard for their own health either. But the argument that "if you loved me you'd be thinner" is gaslighting bullshit.
authenticforgery · 26/11/2021 10:19

You don't have to stay with anyone you're not attracted to. There's this weird idea on mumsnet that you have to stay even if your partner gains 20 stone because you must love the person inside and appearance is irrelevant.
If someone doesn't care enough about themselves or you to make changes then the relationship is dead. I don't say this as a skinny person either. I'm overweight overweight I'm changing it. I want to feel and look better for myself and my husband.

Fluffycloudland77 · 26/11/2021 10:12

He doesn’t owe you a sexy bod, that’s true. You can’t help it if you find it unattractive though.

Men would get lynched if they said this, it follows that they feel like this too.

theleafandnotthetree · 26/11/2021 10:11

@CurzonDax

Wow. Imagine if a man had said this about a woman. The responses would be, "Every woman is beautiful and come in all shapes and sizes", or he'd be accused of body shaming and superficial for only being attractive to slim girls.

For the record, I would agree with all those kind of comments - a man should be ashamed of himself for body shaming any woman.

But the same standards also need to apply in reverse. I feel sorry for the OP's partner.

Well those wouldn't be my responses, just saying. Not everyone is beautiful and perfect whatever size they are in the eyes of everybody, what a bizarre notion.
theleafandnotthetree · 26/11/2021 10:07

@Gettingthereslowly2020

I wouldn't stay with someone overweight if they weren't willing to do something about it. And yes, I'd say the same to a man posting about an overweight wife. You're not obligated to have a sexual relationship with someone you're no longer attracted to just because you signed a piece of paper years ago.

If you're not physically attracted to your spouse then you're just friends who live together aren't you? I have plenty of overweight friends, people come in all shapes and sizes but I wouldn't get into a romantic relationship with someone overweight because I don't find that attractive.

You've tried being supportive and encouraging but nothing is changing. You either leave or accept that this is your life now.

Yep, that's about the size of it as far as I'm concerned too. But we may be in a minority on this board
Iamsocold888 · 26/11/2021 10:06

I think just let him find someone who loves him as he is and leave him to find someone you’re attracted to as you clearly won’t accept him like this in the long-term

LuaDipa · 26/11/2021 10:00

My dh has gained a lot of weight over the years. I’d like him to lose weight for his health but I know that’s up to him so I would never nag him. I still love him and find him attractive as he is still very handsome. He hasn’t changed, he’s just bigger.

My weight has been up and down too, and if it’s affected how he views me he has never let me know. He has always told me that I’m beautiful even when I’m not at my best. That’s what marriage is.

thebear1 · 26/11/2021 09:55

If your love for him is conditional on his body size best leave him so he can find someone who loves him as he is.

Dentistlakes · 26/11/2021 09:48

Unfortunately you can’t force someone to lose weight. The more you pressure and push him into a corner, the more resistant he will become. It sounds like he needs to overhaul his attitude towards food and exercise, a complete lifestyle change. That needs to come from his desire to change.

DontGetYourKnickersInATwist · 26/11/2021 09:48

@Goatinthegarden

I think attraction is only a small part of the issue.

I want to be married to someone who takes care of their health. We cannot predict the future, but if I’m investing in a lifetime with someone, I want them to take care of their body so that we have a stronger chance of enjoying our future together.

I eat well and exercise, not just so that I stay an ‘ideal’ weight, but so that my body is as fit, strong and as full of energy as I can make it. I find life more enjoyable that way and I would find it hard to be with a partner who didn’t share that motivation.

That's fine, and if you felt you couldn't be with someone who wasn't in your view taking care of their health, that would be completely fair enough!

However, they don't owe you a healthy body. They are allowed to do what they like without their dp saying "but what about MY feelings"? Because it's his body. You don't get to tell him what to do with it. You can leave him though. That's up to you (I'm assuming this is a hypothetical though).

Fwiw, I couldn't be with someone completely unhealthy either. It wouldn't just be about weight. But op can't make the issue all about her feelings on his body. That's not right.

Goatinthegarden · 26/11/2021 09:43

I think attraction is only a small part of the issue.

I want to be married to someone who takes care of their health. We cannot predict the future, but if I’m investing in a lifetime with someone, I want them to take care of their body so that we have a stronger chance of enjoying our future together.

I eat well and exercise, not just so that I stay an ‘ideal’ weight, but so that my body is as fit, strong and as full of energy as I can make it. I find life more enjoyable that way and I would find it hard to be with a partner who didn’t share that motivation.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 26/11/2021 09:40

You have to be realistic. 63% of people in the UK are overweight or obese. Higher for older people. If you are in a long-term relationship spanning decades, not a few years, the chances are your partner will be overweight or obese. Not ideal but realistic.

I'm not saying you should stay with him. You could leave him then try to find someone who doesn't become overweight or obese in older age, this becomes increasingly unlikely over time as we get older.

I like trim well-kept men like I'm sure most women who like men do- but I'm quite realistic in middle-age about whether that is possible. I'm equally kind to myself about being a few pounds overweight.

I would feel very frustrated with your husband eating crap basically, and not caring at all. I do fight the good fight but still am not slender in my mid-life, even with healthy food and the odd bit of exercise- it becomes a life project for most people to stay slimmer once you get over a certain age.

It would be lovely if he would see the light and eat healthier, join you with exercise, ultimately he doesn't sound up for discussing it if he won't even stop drinking full fat coke, and I guess you do have to decide how much you can tolerate yourself and what your chances are of finding a similarly minded slim exercise-focused man in the future who has all of his good qualities. You might, you might not.

DontGetYourKnickersInATwist · 26/11/2021 09:20

@ANameChangeAgain

I see his total disregard of my thoughts about his health and lack of attractiveness as a sign of not caring enough about me. If a man wrote this he would be hung, drawn and quartered.
Sort of agree. He doesn't owe you a sexy bod. You don't have to find him attractive, but he hasn't wronged you by being less attractive or even by being less healthy. That's overstepping boundaries massively imo, whether you're male or female.
ANameChangeAgain · 26/11/2021 09:15

I see his total disregard of my thoughts about his health and lack of attractiveness as a sign of not caring enough about me.
If a man wrote this he would be hung, drawn and quartered.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 26/11/2021 09:15

If you genuinely love him, then help him to be happy

@HotelCaliforniaOnRepeat what about OP’s happiness? Why shouldn’t her DP take action to address his issues if HE genuinely loves HER?

DontGetYourKnickersInATwist · 26/11/2021 09:13

@DontGetYourKnickersInATwist

Oh x post - did you name change fail? So he is not healthy in other ways. Sad

I can definitely see why this is an issue op. It could be down to his depression. I think I'd tackle that first, but again, he can only deal with that when he wants to.

Oh sorry, no, that's another poster!
Swipe left for the next trending thread