Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GPs leaving the UK

130 replies

Traveller3367 · 25/11/2021 23:40

DP is a HCP with lots of doctor friends.
In less than 2 years, 6 GPs have left the UK to work abroad (or are imminently leaving).
I read in the papers that 1 GP can care for upto 2000 patients so that's 12000 patients who have lost out.
AIBU to think there must be something about job that's driving them away?
The papers make it out to be easy and well paid but clearly not easy/well paid enough for some to stay and do it!
How can we keep our GPs in the UK to help us?

OP posts:
BoPeeple · 26/11/2021 14:24

@Darkstar4855

I’m a doctor and no amount of money would be high enough to make me want to work as a GP.

The pressure of the job, the unreasonable expectations a lot of people have, the constant hatchet jobs being done by the press and the way the government are using GPs as scapegoats to cover up their mismanagement of the NHS… no thanks. No wonder they’re all leaving.

Do you think people have unrealistic expectations?

I would expect, for example, my GP to be able to diagnose an infection, or perimenopause, or to care enough about symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis to do some blood tests. I would expect to see my doctor within a month of asking for an appointment, or for the surgery to contact me about blood test results if there are abnormalities.

I don’t think patients are asking the world.

Darkstar4855 · 26/11/2021 14:10

I’m a doctor and no amount of money would be high enough to make me want to work as a GP.

The pressure of the job, the unreasonable expectations a lot of people have, the constant hatchet jobs being done by the press and the way the government are using GPs as scapegoats to cover up their mismanagement of the NHS… no thanks. No wonder they’re all leaving.

user1497207191 · 26/11/2021 14:02

@Octavia174

GPs need to refer for specialist treatments... imagine demanding to see a Neurologist, just because Dr Google told you that headache was in fact a Brain tumour.... the system would collapse.

For some things, yes, a referral from "someone" is required, but not for the really simple things like hearing aids, ingrown toe nail removal, x-rays for suspected fractured fingers/toes. You don't need a gp referral for a dentist appointment or a pair of spectacles, so why do you need one to get NHS hearing aids or NHS glasses at Specsavers?

Only a couple of weeks ago, my OH (cancer patient), mentioned a very sore foot to his haematologist, thinking it may be neuropathy caused by chemotherapy (something he was warned about when treatment started). Haematologist suspected it was a fractured bone in the foot, but was unable to send him for an x-ray, so told him to get a GP appointment, for the GP to send him for an x-ray. Took many attempts to get a GP phone appt, then had to explain symptoms etc for GP and relay what haematologist had said, only for GP to say she had to see the foot before she could send him for x-ray, so took yet another F2F appointment for the GP to "look" at the foot, so she could do the x-ray referral. That was 2 GP appointments just to do a bit of paperwork to refer to x-ray, even after the haematologist had already looked at it and said it needed an x-ray.

It's that kind of waste of resources that's causing the GP appointment shortage, i.e. 2 "wasted" gp appointments just to get an x-ray that a consultant wanted.

It's exactly the same inefficiency/waste of resources, when the haematologist notices abnormalities in his blood tests (that he has 2/3 times per month for the chemo treatment). Sometimes it's low iron, sometimes low calcium, latest time was low vitamin D. Every time, the haematologist tells OH to contact the GP to ask for prescription for iron/calcium/VitD tablets. Every single time, the GP receptionist insists on making an appointment with the GP and won't just pass the message on. Every single time, a wasted GP appointment, just for my OH to tell the GP what the haematologist has said, every single time, GP says she can't see the hospital blood test results and needs her own, so OH has to make an appointment at the GP surgery for a blood test (increasingly difficult), then follows another message from surgery asking for OH to make a phone appt with GP, only for GP to say she'll issue a prescription. Why the hell can't the haematologist either just issue the prescription himself (along with the other bag of drugs prescribed every month) or just email the GP to ask the GP to issue the prescription, with a note of the blood test result?

The whole thing is far too fragmented, no one talks to eachother directly, leaving the poor sod of the patient with the task of the ever increasing difficulty of contacting the GP themselves. How about a bit of joined up thinking and NHS staff liaising directly between themselves. We often say it must be nigh on impossible for the elderly and confused people to navigate the NHS if they have major health issues. My OH is in his 50s, fully compus mentis, with a managerial/professional job and he finds it exhausting trying to navigate all the obstacles put in place by the NHS to try to manage his condition.

happydramatic · 26/11/2021 13:42

@BoPeeple

DH works a three day GP week, and he does a 2 day a week (poorly paid but heart is in it) youth worker job and an evening at out of hours walk in centre. With these jobs needed overtime, he works around 6/6.5 days a week.

happydramatic · 26/11/2021 13:38

BoPeeple

He works a three day GP week, and he does a 2 day a week (poorly paid but heart is in it) youth worker job and an evening at out of hours walk in centre. With these jobs needed overtime, he works around 6/6.5 days a week.

Octavia174 · 26/11/2021 13:23

@ILoveAllRainbowsx

I don't think that we should recruit more GPs, I think that we need to totally change the system.

People want A&E and Urgent Care Centres 24 hours a day. We don't need GPs to refer us for treatment, lots of countries allow patients to refer themselves and it works fine.

We need specialist mental health practitioners dealing with mental health problems, not GPs.

We need to change the whole system. GP practices don't work.

We've less GPs, Nurses, MH specialists, AHP, Beds, Scanners etc than comparable EU countries.

The pandemic and brexit has highlighted this - look how our healthcare system has completely fallen apart, 6m (and growing) people waiting for hospital treatment.

Of course people need 24hr AE and Treatment centres, what on earth are you on about?

GPs need to refer for specialist treatments... imagine demanding to see a Neurologist, just because Dr Google told you that headache was in fact a Brain tumour.... the system would collapse.

The GP system is quite brilliant but like our hospitals, it cannot work unless it is funded/staffed to a sufficient level.

Traveller3367 · 26/11/2021 13:09

@Tabbacus Funny that @user1497207191 isn't answering that question
Typical self entitled culture that's draining our public services imo
The idea that everyone has to be willing to give up their lives to serve me but I won't bother to put the effort / cost in

OP posts:
Tabbacus · 26/11/2021 13:03

@A8mint

Easy. Before they start medical school we maje them sign a contract that they have to pay back all the publuc money invested in their training if they go to work abroad.
And I suppose we are going to reimburse the money other countries have spent on training healthcare staff we now employ?
user1497207191 · 26/11/2021 13:01

@BoPeeple

None of the doctors at my surgery works more than three days a week. It takes a month to get an appointment. Between my close friends and family this year we have had three misdiagnoses, two of which have only been correctly diagnosed having self-referred to a private specialist. Not weird stuff, just general health problems that should have been dealt with by the GP. In each case the GP dismissed the symptoms and didn’t listen.

I don’t know what it is but something’s going very wrong.

There's been a growing trend for doctors to want to work "family friendly" hours for a couple of decades, particularly female GPs.

It's blindingly obvious that you need to train twice as many GPs if most only work half weeks, yet neither successive governments nor the BMA put in the place the additional medical schools/training places that were blindingly obviously going to be needed.

In fact the BMA voted to restrict places at medical schools and for a complete ban on new medical schools. www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

user1497207191 · 26/11/2021 12:58

@SockQueen

Asking 18 year olds to sign binding contracts about something 5+ years into the future? Can't see what would go wrong with that...

Err...Most Uni students sign binding contracts to get student loans which take 30 years to pay back. Lost of trainees on training contracts sign contracts binding them to pay back costs of their training if they leave employment within certain period of time. It's entirely reasonable when huge amounts of money are being spent on their training/education.

BoPeeple · 26/11/2021 12:51

None of the doctors at my surgery works more than three days a week. It takes a month to get an appointment. Between my close friends and family this year we have had three misdiagnoses, two of which have only been correctly diagnosed having self-referred to a private specialist. Not weird stuff, just general health problems that should have been dealt with by the GP. In each case the GP dismissed the symptoms and didn’t listen.

I don’t know what it is but something’s going very wrong.

BoPeeple · 26/11/2021 12:49

@happydramatic

Hmmm. Some dubious information on this post.

DH is a GP. It's a horrible job. Less than 60k for 3 days a week, some days he works 8am-1am. Treated like a pretend doctor as not a specialist, 10 minute appointments, constantly extra patients or home visits squeezed in. It's impossible. If there were any financial alternative for him to quit he would. Possibly to retrain in A&E.

Yeah- big career mistake he would say.

Why does he work 3 days a week?
Traveller3367 · 26/11/2021 12:09

@A8mint
So would the UK government repay the government's of foreign doctors who work here?

OP posts:
SockQueen · 26/11/2021 12:08

@A8mint

Easy. Before they start medical school we maje them sign a contract that they have to pay back all the publuc money invested in their training if they go to work abroad.
Asking 18 year olds to sign binding contracts about something 5+ years into the future? Can't see what would go wrong with that...

And will we be asking all the doctors who've come to the UK from abroad to pay back their own countries' investments?

oneglassandpuzzled · 26/11/2021 12:02

@Bagamoyo1

OP you only have to spend 5 minutes on MN to see why GPs are leaving. Everyone hates us. I’m working harder than I’ve ever worked but it’s still not enough. I’m leaving as soon as I can.
We really don’t. 💐 It is sad that we have come to this.
A8mint · 26/11/2021 12:01

Easy.
Before they start medical school we maje them sign a contract that they have to pay back all the publuc money invested in their training if they go to work abroad.

Traveller3367 · 26/11/2021 11:58

@SockQueen
It's probably not going to get any better now that hospital follow ups are being curtailed
amp.theguardian.com/society/2021/nov/25/plan-to-scrap-tens-of-millions-of-nhs-appointments-could-put-patients-at-risk

OP posts:
Traveller3367 · 26/11/2021 11:55

@user1497207191 If patients had direct access to specialists then what happens when specialist A washes his/her hands as it's not caused by their area, then same with Specialist B and C etc. Eventually these patients will have noone to turn to.
With increasingly complex patients, there is a need for a general view
I recall watching a TED talk about this a while ago where a relative described how each specialist looked after their own part of that patient's body but what the patient needed was a general doctor to put all the pieces together.

OP posts:
Tabbacus · 26/11/2021 11:54

More admin staff would probably help. I had an appointment last week for something, I phoned first thing in the morning to cancel as I had been vomiting all night and it was face to face; was told oh you have to leave your cancellation message with the designated answer machine we can't take cancellations over the phone even if they're late cancellations. Said okay fine, phoned and left a message, had a call a few hours later from a really annoyed doctor asking why I hadn't turned up. Said I have tried to cancel, done as advised and she said they don't have the staff to be checking the inbox more than a few times a week?! I get why she was annoyed so that's fine, but I'd spoken to a human, then gone by procedure and still wasted an appointment.

SockQueen · 26/11/2021 11:49

I'm a senior registrar in a hospital specialty, about 1 year off becoming a consultant. I am in my late 30s and still working nights and weekends. I do procedures every day that could easily kill people, and I deal with the sickest patients in the hospital. By the time I complete my training it will have been almost 20 years since I started medical school (admittedly slowed down a bit by having two kids and working part time). If I had gone down the GP route, I could have qualified as a GP in 2014, and been working independently since then, no nights or weekends if I didn't want. I'd have finished training before having my kids, so my career wouldn't have stalled so much.
And yet I wouldn't do it for any money.

A lot of my friends who are GPs are miserable at the moment. This is not the job they envisaged. They want to be seeing patients, giving them the time they deserve. They don't want to be snowed under with ever-increasing demand, having to deal with things on the phone that would be easier to see F2F (I think they all agree that telephone consultations are appropriate for some things but it's not most people's preferred method of working). They don't want to have so many patients to see that there is no time for admin in a normal day, meaning they regularly stay late to finish all that. They don't want to have to start half their consultations apologising for themselves.

Things have changed so much in the last few years. The expansion of ANP/similar roles means that a lot of the mentally "easier" appointments like pill checks, medication reviews etc, are no longer in the GPs remit. So they only have the complex stuff - the elderly patients with multiple comorbidities, the patients with mental health problems and terrible social situations, the ones who've been bounced around multiple clinics and nobody can quite work out what to do. Lots of complex patients that would normally be managed by a hospital clinic are now sent for "shared care" or just discharged back to the GP, who has to work out what to do for them. This is not the fault of the hospitals, who are under huge pressure to cut clinic numbers as well, as they can't keep up with seeing all the new patients. There's no mental "breathing space" in a day. And the government and the press whips up more hatred every week. GPs are going off sick with stress and MH problems more and more frequently, which only increases the pressure on those left behind.

It's not about the money. The pay is decent, considering the amount of training and the skill required for the job, but it's not amazing. I think a majority of the people who leave, do so for better working conditions, not for the money itself.

Traveller3367 · 26/11/2021 11:49

Interesting array of opinions
Wish I could respond to each individually but many points repeated

Those that say "good riddance" to the ones doing it for the money, have you thought of an alternative? The current system is a mix of those who love patients and those who love money. If we lost a chunk of those who do it for the money, would you be happy to wait an extra 2-3 weeks for an appointment?
IMO as long a doctor provides me a professional and competent service then I don't care what his/her motivations are for doing the job. Caring alone doesn't guarantee the best patient care. I think the days of vocations are coming to an end with increasing value on work life balance and mental health.

Secondly yes there are many reasons for poor lifestyle choices and addictions which massively impact health. But there is also a significant role for society/ community / family / friends for these people. It seems as though some patients expect the GP/NHS to replace all these support systems and then feel hard done by and unsupported. Even most mild/moderate mental health problems can be managed better with healthy living, exercise, social interaction etc

Also re jobs abroad. I have heard of jobs being advertised with unimaginable perks. I've heard of a few people off to Qatar / Dubai for £100K+ tax free jobs, free housing, free medical care, free private schooling, free flights. Seems like other countries (ME, Oz, NZ, Canada etc) seem to value the hard work it takes to become a doctor more than the UK.

Regarding the concept that those trained in the UK need to stay here and repay the tax payer. Such a fallacy. Doctors are trained on the job so the doctor treating you in A and E, and getting paid for it, is usually still training. What the taxpayer pays for is time for learning/ teaching but I've heard many doctors complain about how they aren't given that time to attend teaching sessions. Add in all the extra hours they do and I think you'll find the tax payer owes the doctors money and not the other way round!

Those stating GP is an easy role, why are you not training to become one? Clearly if they are getting paid for playing golf then most people would be training to become one?
Sad to see these highly trained professionals being so undervalued. Most have been working hard and studying since very young and seems a shame they are being run out of the country they wanted to serveSad

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 26/11/2021 11:47

@ILoveAllRainbowsx

I don't think that we should recruit more GPs, I think that we need to totally change the system.

People want A&E and Urgent Care Centres 24 hours a day. We don't need GPs to refer us for treatment, lots of countries allow patients to refer themselves and it works fine.

We need specialist mental health practitioners dealing with mental health problems, not GPs.

We need to change the whole system. GP practices don't work.

I fully agree. The GP system is an antiquated concept and it's time to scrap it and replace with a modern "fit for purpose" system. We've come a long way since the 60s/70s where the GP would deal with virtually everything, i.e. local emergencies, such as road accidents, births, etc. GPs have basically become deskbound "gatekeepers". Patients need direct access to more treatment options, such as, as you say, urgent care centres, and local "clinics" akin to what they have in mainland European countries that deal with all manner of issues, particularly minor injury treatments and prescriptions.

People are calling for the GP system to be "fixed", but in reality, it needs scrapping.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 26/11/2021 11:38

I don't think that we should recruit more GPs, I think that we need to totally change the system.

People want A&E and Urgent Care Centres 24 hours a day. We don't need GPs to refer us for treatment, lots of countries allow patients to refer themselves and it works fine.

We need specialist mental health practitioners dealing with mental health problems, not GPs.

We need to change the whole system. GP practices don't work.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 26/11/2021 11:18

Absolutely with the heart sinkers. Since social care has been cut so much they are coming into the surgeries more often and asking for help that the GP can't give them. You cannot fix the NHS without fixing social care as well.

MissyB1 · 26/11/2021 11:12

@Fairylights25

I am truly past caring. Really. I don't care. I am so tired of the endless whinging.
That’s fine as long as you don’t want to access any healthcare for you or your family. Bet if you do need it you will be the one whinging!!
Swipe left for the next trending thread