Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my SIL and BIL have been insensitive?

358 replies

IviSable · 25/11/2021 20:04

Hi everyone,

I'm looking to get some perspective from kind strangers.

Before I get into, here's a bit of context about my situation. My DH and I have had a hellish couple of years trying to start a family. We got pregnant naturally last year but this tragically ended in me having a termination for medical reasons quite far along into the second trimester. We have since undergone IVF, which very sadly ended in a chemical pregnancy. We're now looking to go into a second round of IVF asap.

Last year when we lost our baby, my SIL and BIL, who didn't at that time have any children, were supportive and appeared to understand how devastating this event was for us. After we lost the baby, DH and I put the wheels into motion to do IVF. We had a long 6 month wait before we could start our treatment. Early on into that 6 month period, I discover that my SIL and BIL are also going to do IVF, but as this is not something we discussed I didn't know the timescales for their IVF treatment.

At this point I started to worry about how my SIL and BIL would handle things if my SIL got pregnant before me, so I decided to contact SIL (who I wasn't on bad terms with but am not that close with either) to explain that should we find ourselves in that situation we'd need the matter to be dealt with sensitively and that I may need space from them. DH also had a similar discussion with his DB. Both my SIL and BIL said they understood and would be sensitive to us.

Fast forward a couple of months and I accidentally find out that my SIL is pregnant. This was completely unintended, but without going into too much detail (it's a bit long winded and I wouldn't want to give away too many of the details for fear of being identified) I found this out due to the carelessness of SIL and BIL. I was angry that they'd been so careless with our feelings despite knowing all we'd been through, so I cut contact with them both, only messaging on birthdays and to congratulate them when they finally publicly announced they were having a baby. DH didn't want me to tell them that we'd found out she was pregnant before they announced it, so we said nothing and I made my excuses and avoided them. This may seem extreme, but leading up to this I'd already started to strongly suspect that my SIL may be pregnant because of unusual behaviour by them - for example, SIL took a call on speaker phone from her family when we were all out together one day and immediately said to them that she was out with DH and I. It was apparent to me that she didn't want them saying something in front of us.

Fast forward another couple of months and SIL and BIL announce they're pregnant. Not long after this I get wind that SIL has been complaining that she feels no one on DH's side of the family is that excited for them. I found this out because my BIL told DH. This made DH feel guilty and so he approached me to say he was going to buy SIL a present for the baby. Now, I have no issue with DH doing this, but what I do take issue with is my BIL saying this to DH given the heartbreaking loss we had last year. SIL and BIL were aware at this point that we were going through IVF and that we'd already been through a lot. It was a massive kick in the teeth to hear that SIL was complaining about people not being excited for her pregnancy that was going well, and when she knew we were still going through IVF and all the anxiety that brings with it.

The final nail in the coffin was that they threw a baby shower with the whole family (not just women, which I thought was the norm but everyone) but me, given they know I wouldn't go. This to me was extremely poor taste under the circumstances. I have no issues with normal baby showers (SIL of course has every right to be excitement and celebrate), but to have a family party with both men and women was IMHO OTT and extremely insensitive.

SIL also never messaged me to say she understands why this may be difficult for us given all the loss we've had over the past couple of years. Had she acknowledged this just once to me, it would have gone a very long way, but there was nothing.

AIBU to feel they've been insensitive in light of our situation?

Thanks very much for any responses!

OP posts:
saraclara · 25/11/2021 22:26

They have done everything right and been really sensitive to your feelings.

Yes. They genuinely could not have done more. Short of denying the pregnancy to themselves as well as their families, there's nothing they could have done that you would have accepted, OP.

Please, please get some counselling. If you are genuine and not the SIL writing a reverse, then you really do need help, or you and the wider family are going to be destroyed, especially when the baby arrives.

Cheeseandlobster · 25/11/2021 22:26

@blubberyboo

And I really can’t accept that this women who has had to go thru IVF herself should have to ring you up and acknowledge that her pregnancy is going to be difficult for you!

Just no!

No pregnant women should have to apologise to anyone for being pregnant!

This. But I call reverse or journo trying to provoke responses for a story.
IviSable · 25/11/2021 22:25

Thanks for the honest replies so far.

I completely agree that they're entitled to start a family of their own and share that news with their family. Also, I'm completely aware that what's happened hasn't been in any way been malicious or intentional, and that maybe our struggles have clouded my judgement. I had just hoped they'd tread a little more carefully around us given the discussions we'd had with them early on, which they were very amenable to.

I also agree with those who've said they're in an impossible position. There's no easy way with situations like this and they probably couldn't do right for doing wrong. However, (and sorry I didn't say this above) DH and his DB did agree that his DB would tell my DH if they got pregnant and that he would then tell me. That unfortuneatly didn't happen as I found out two months before I was meant to. I've not explained the details of this here but I can say that that I found out because of something they did. This was an accident, but it could have been completely avoided.

I should add that SIL and I have had IVF for similar reasons. Anyone who's been through IVF will know it's not the easiest thing to go through. It's even harder when you've experienced a loss. We were the unlucky ones in that our treatment ended in a very early loss and they were lucky that theirs did work. Of course no one is to blame for this. It's just the way things go sometimes. They shouldn't have to feel guilty because their treatment worked and ours didn't. But I'd expect someone who's gone through this themselves to be even more aware of why this is a difficult situation. Though I think it's been hard for them to know exactly how to approach things.

@StylishMummy I'm not trying to be a dick about their pregnancy, but I understand why you'd think that. I decided to cut contact (for as long as I feel I need to) because I felt I couldn't be around them while this was going on. Baby bumps can be extremely upsetting for people who've experienced loss or are struggling to have a family, and it's very common for women in my shoes to avoid baby-related situations or pregnant women for a while. I did congratulate them when they announced it and I have messaged on other occasions. DH is very close with his DB and I'm well aware that me having hardly any contact with his DB will be difficult for him. DH also found their baby shower quite difficult for obvious reasons, but he put on a brave face. I didn't feel I could do that. Putting on a brave face is sometimes the hardest thing of all to do, and I just don't have to emotional energy to do it at this point in time.

@chocolatepudandchocolatesauce I know many people do spend years trying to conceive or go through some truly difficult situations before they move to IVF, but they knew they'd need IVF from the beginning and so went to IVF before trying to conceive naturally.

@Mostlylurkingiam I completely agree this is not their fault and you make a fair comment that I may be seeing insensitivity everywhere given what we've been through. Also, I agree that they probably didn't know what to do given I completely backed off and said I'd need space. That said, I've had friends tell me about their pregnancies in as nice a way as possible and I've felt fine about those. I've been to a few baby showers but obviously never to a modern one, which is perhaps why their baby shower seemed so different to me.

@Freddiefox sorry I didn't explain myself very well in my original post. I didn't have a problem with not being invited to their baby shower as I wouldn't have gone anyway and they knew that. I was upset that they couldn't have just had the usual sort of baby shower (I've never been to a baby shower like theirs before and I've been to a few). DH went to the shower and, though he's not the sort to talk about his feelings too much, he admitted it was difficult for him. In my opinion, his DB who he's close to should have been more mindful of this. It's probably easy for me to say this, but had the shoe have been on the other foot I don't think we'd have had as big of a shower.

@Lasair I'm sorry to hear about your loss. That must have been awful. I know it's not their fault, just a very difficult set of circumstances. I did congratulate them when the announced, but I'm not strong enough to be around their pregnancy and all the baby talk. I know some people can put on a brave face, I also know many people who can't and don't. I obviously fall into the latter category. I have had a couple of counseling sessions and am considering having more.

@CampagVelocet I can understand your point of view, but me finding out was due to a very avoidable although unintentional mistake they made.

@Amberflames we know exactly why they needed IVF and they know exactly why we did to. Sorry if you think that of me, but you're entitled to your opinion and I appreciate your perspective.

@Jayaywhynot I completely agree that the world doesn't stop just because we're struggling. They're absolutely entitled to have a baby when they want. They shouldn't have to wait and it'd be ridiculous for us to expect that. What I did expect, perhaps unreasonably so, is for them to tread a little more carefully around us. We politely requested this and they were very happy to be supportive at the time. I did congratulate them when they announced and did try to put a game face a couple of times before they knew I knew they were pregnant, but I found this too difficult. It might sound strange to some, but it's very common for women in my shoes to avoid baby-related situations.

OP posts:
5keletor · 25/11/2021 22:24

It sounds awful, what you've been through, but I think YABU in this situation. It sounds like you've been quite difficult, but they've still bent over backwards to try to accommodate your wishes.

blubberyboo · 25/11/2021 22:16

And I really can’t accept that this women who has had to go thru IVF herself should have to ring you up and acknowledge that her pregnancy is going to be difficult for you!

Just no!

No pregnant women should have to apologise to anyone for being pregnant!

Maybe83 · 25/11/2021 22:14

@yikerspipers thank you. Its probably my greatest hope now in life that I can make peace with what has happened to us. Grief is utterly exhausting emotionally and physically at times.

NYNYNYNYNYNYNYNYNYNYNYNYN · 25/11/2021 22:08

I'm sorry about your loss, I really am BUT your behaviour about your SIL is ridiculous.

You need to seek help to support you to managing your feelings. This is not normal behaviour

blubberyboo · 25/11/2021 22:02

I’m really sorry for you as you have suffered a terrible tragedy but you are making a great mistake in thinking that you can dictate anything about how these people announc, talk about or celebrate their own pregnancy.

One of the hardest things about any type of loss is the realisation that although time has stopped for the loved one lost, the rest of the world keeps turning, old life is replaced by new life and people are not preoccupied with your loss.

You really should never have approached them at all when they started IvF as you really just made the whole thing much more awkward for everyone and these people have ended up trying to Pussy foot around you , which is impossible to do as they simply cannot hide their child!

Please stop this and grieve for your child yes but don’t make it about other people as this is your grief. Celebrate the new life that is coming as really when you think about it the whole world is going to go on having babies so why shouldn’t your SIL and BIL be allowed that joy?

They have done nothing wrong and I suspect it is all rubbing off on the whole family as they now feel bad about having their baby based on the muted reactions. Also men can and do go to baby shower/ celebrations there is no rule book.

Legoisaws8om · 25/11/2021 21:58

You really need to seek some help to grieve over this but it isn't fair to expect your SIL and BIL to not be happy. I was pregnant and due same time as SIL but we had a missed miscarriage. Whilst at first I found it hard, and I am going to at key trigger points and be reminded when their baby arrives that mine should have done, I know i can't hold strong feelings against them. It's not their fault you had to lose your baby remember that. I really hope you can find some help and then celebrate your new niece or nephew.

KaycePollard · 25/11/2021 21:54

YABU.

In fact I think you’re the one who I’d being insensitive. Nowhere in your post do you express any feeling or understanding or empathy for your SiL and BiL.

Grapewrath · 25/11/2021 21:47

Yabvvu
Sorry for your losses, however sil has also clearly struggled through the IVF process and has every right to celebrate her pregnancy. Her own happy news shouldn’t be over shadowed by your unreasonable requests

Marvellousmadness · 25/11/2021 21:46

Its sounds like yabu . You need to stop focussing on them and focus on you instead. Your bil and sil sound very understanding and thoughtful. Yes it will be hard for you but you cant make everyone else be miserable because you are.
Plus: they needed ivf. That wouldnt have been easy
Have some heart for others.
And babyshowers with women and men are the best. Isnt it about celebrating a new life. Why would that be for just women. Not all baby showers involve rediculous games etc. Some involve some good food and drinks and people wishing other people well

yikerspipers · 25/11/2021 21:41

@Maybe83 I am so sorry for your loss. Your post is so lovely and sensitive and I hope you find peace. I hope the OP reads it for her own sake.

Cocomarine · 25/11/2021 21:40

YABU. You can have it every which way. You went directly to them to ask for sensitivity, then didn’t like it when they told other family privately before you. How were they supposed to know what to do?
Interesting that you went to them to ask for sensitivity, rather than to ask them to bear with you if you needed space.

I’m very sorry for the loss of your baby, and hope this current IVF works for you.

You need to not take out your hurt and anger at the difficult hand you’ve been given on them, though.

motherofthelittlescreamingone · 25/11/2021 21:35

I suspect SIL and BIL are doing what they think you want to do and giving you space - no talking about it, no invitation to baby shower, just keeping quiet. That is probably what they thought you meant by stepping back - lots of people tend to be wary in the face of grief, lest they trigger something, so they avoid where they can (which can make it worse).

I think you probably need to accept that there is an element of transferring your pain and anger on to them. They have had a tough time trying to conceive via IVF too and they are probably trying to do their best, even if it feels clumsy to you.

Startrooper · 25/11/2021 21:34

What you have been through is devastating and it is colouring your judgement with regards to your SIL and BIL’s pregnancy. They can’t do right for doing wrong.

Please consider getting professional support before you destroy your relationship with your in-laws forever. And please don’t stop your DH from seeing his new niece or nephew if he wishes to do so - that wouldn’t be kind, regardless of how you feel.

GrumpyLivesInMyHouseNow · 25/11/2021 21:33

So sorry to hear about your losses op. I completely understand what you are going through, I had similar with my best friend.

I think you are being slightly unreasonable though. Your sil and bil have abided by your wishes and kept the pregnancy low key as you asked them to. They've held off telling you (it's not their fault you found out), they also didn't invite you to the baby shower, I'm sure you'd have felt bad if they had - so they really are damned if they do and damned if they don't.

You need to do what's right for you, and if that's distancing yourself from them, then so be it, but also try and remember they've been through a rough ride, IVF isn't easy and they must have had lots of disappointment themselves to get to this point, so they have every right to celebrate and enjoy their pregnancy and baby. I know you are only seeing things from your own perspective, but not everyone sees it as you do.

Maybe83 · 25/11/2021 21:28

I'm in the exact same situation. My in laws had a baby same gender as mine a week after my due date.

I'm still in the first year. I havent met the child and have no intention of doing so until I know my mental health can take it. I dont attend anything they do because nobody really knows what to say or do with me and to be honest I know I will bawl my eyes out. Until I am confident I won't, I won't be around them because as my dh points out our grief has nothing to do with them. Their child being born had absolutely nothing to do with our child dying. Also their child deserves the space in my dh family to grow up with the same love and attention as the other grandchildren and not in my child's shadow.

Having said all that logically I know this but emotionally I'm not there yet. I see my priority at the moment my mental health and relationships and keeping as well as I can for those. My inlaws life isn't impacted by me stepping out of theirs but my 100% will be by putting myself into the middle of family situations at the moment.

The anger, rage and jealously is pouring off your post and that is what it boils down to. They have what you and your dh desperately want. Have you had counselling? I found it has helped but its a process you have to move through and I try every day to choose not to feel like that or when I do to acknowledge it and then let it go. I dont want my child's passing to end up turning into a bitterness that stays with us forever. It's the complete opposite of the love we feel for them.

Your bil and sil have been as sensitive as they possibly can in horrible circumstances.

maggiemuff · 25/11/2021 21:26

If you had been the one to be pregnant would you have made sure to hide yourself away, not be seen, not mention your baby and not have a shower?? (Which we don't have here in the UK but I get the idea)

maggiemuff · 25/11/2021 21:23

You are being very unreasonable. I understand that you are upset at what happened to you, and that is fully understandable and I sympathise, but that does not mean that other people can not be pleased or announce their own news. To take away your SILs joy would be cruel and selfish.

PinkSyCo · 25/11/2021 21:22

I’m sorry for what you have been through but to put it bluntly not everything is all about you, and you made it all about you as soon as you found out your poor SIL was going to start IVF, without a single thought as to what she may have suffered before making that decision. Stop putting stress on her and blaming her for everything. If you found out your SIL was pregnant before she announced it that’s not her fault. If she chooses to have men at her baby shower that’s up to her. She also has a right to feel miffed that family aren’t showing excitement (probably because you’ve disallowed it) about her pregnancy. I think you’re being very selfish but wish you luck with the IVF.

NeverTheHootenanny · 25/11/2021 21:22

I can’t see anything that they have done that’s insensitive. I’m curious, if your IVF had been successful and not theirs, how would you have handled the situation to be sensitive to them?

I’m sorry for what you’re going through though and hope you get your baby. If and when you do you will want family around you, don’t alienate them now.

Jujujuly · 25/11/2021 21:21

Sorry OP. I’ve had several miscarriages (though all first trimester) and I can see you are still grieving and hurting. That isn’t your in laws fault though and I don’t think they’ve done anything wrong.

It sounds like there was quite a gap between you finding out and their pregnancy announcement, so either you found out quite early (in which case no wonder they didn’t tell you straight away, they were probably terrified it wouldn’t work out given it was IVF and they’ve likely struggled and/or had previous losses) OR they waited a long time to formally announce it, again likely because they were anxious about it, and possibly also to spare your feelings.

It’s not surprising that she’d confide in her own family that she’s in the early stages of pregnancy but not tell you about it. The speaker phone thing was her maintaining her own privacy and probably protecting you too.

After presumably struggling to conceive I’m sure they wanted to celebrate. You can invite whoever you want to a baby shower. It wasn’t done to spite you and even if it had been female only you wouldn’t have gone so I don’t see what your problem is there.

I think you need to take a step back and try to feel happy for them. When your own baby is here you might find you have a different perspective on this.

ColintheCrow · 25/11/2021 21:20

I'm very sorry for your circumstances, having had a late termination and a child die at 2, although it might pang that family members were having successful pregnancies, maybe you should celebrate them.

RusholmeRuffian · 25/11/2021 21:14

YABVU. You are making their situation all about you which is very unfair. You're not thinking straight. Maybe get some counselling.