Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my SIL and BIL have been insensitive?

358 replies

IviSable · 25/11/2021 20:04

Hi everyone,

I'm looking to get some perspective from kind strangers.

Before I get into, here's a bit of context about my situation. My DH and I have had a hellish couple of years trying to start a family. We got pregnant naturally last year but this tragically ended in me having a termination for medical reasons quite far along into the second trimester. We have since undergone IVF, which very sadly ended in a chemical pregnancy. We're now looking to go into a second round of IVF asap.

Last year when we lost our baby, my SIL and BIL, who didn't at that time have any children, were supportive and appeared to understand how devastating this event was for us. After we lost the baby, DH and I put the wheels into motion to do IVF. We had a long 6 month wait before we could start our treatment. Early on into that 6 month period, I discover that my SIL and BIL are also going to do IVF, but as this is not something we discussed I didn't know the timescales for their IVF treatment.

At this point I started to worry about how my SIL and BIL would handle things if my SIL got pregnant before me, so I decided to contact SIL (who I wasn't on bad terms with but am not that close with either) to explain that should we find ourselves in that situation we'd need the matter to be dealt with sensitively and that I may need space from them. DH also had a similar discussion with his DB. Both my SIL and BIL said they understood and would be sensitive to us.

Fast forward a couple of months and I accidentally find out that my SIL is pregnant. This was completely unintended, but without going into too much detail (it's a bit long winded and I wouldn't want to give away too many of the details for fear of being identified) I found this out due to the carelessness of SIL and BIL. I was angry that they'd been so careless with our feelings despite knowing all we'd been through, so I cut contact with them both, only messaging on birthdays and to congratulate them when they finally publicly announced they were having a baby. DH didn't want me to tell them that we'd found out she was pregnant before they announced it, so we said nothing and I made my excuses and avoided them. This may seem extreme, but leading up to this I'd already started to strongly suspect that my SIL may be pregnant because of unusual behaviour by them - for example, SIL took a call on speaker phone from her family when we were all out together one day and immediately said to them that she was out with DH and I. It was apparent to me that she didn't want them saying something in front of us.

Fast forward another couple of months and SIL and BIL announce they're pregnant. Not long after this I get wind that SIL has been complaining that she feels no one on DH's side of the family is that excited for them. I found this out because my BIL told DH. This made DH feel guilty and so he approached me to say he was going to buy SIL a present for the baby. Now, I have no issue with DH doing this, but what I do take issue with is my BIL saying this to DH given the heartbreaking loss we had last year. SIL and BIL were aware at this point that we were going through IVF and that we'd already been through a lot. It was a massive kick in the teeth to hear that SIL was complaining about people not being excited for her pregnancy that was going well, and when she knew we were still going through IVF and all the anxiety that brings with it.

The final nail in the coffin was that they threw a baby shower with the whole family (not just women, which I thought was the norm but everyone) but me, given they know I wouldn't go. This to me was extremely poor taste under the circumstances. I have no issues with normal baby showers (SIL of course has every right to be excitement and celebrate), but to have a family party with both men and women was IMHO OTT and extremely insensitive.

SIL also never messaged me to say she understands why this may be difficult for us given all the loss we've had over the past couple of years. Had she acknowledged this just once to me, it would have gone a very long way, but there was nothing.

AIBU to feel they've been insensitive in light of our situation?

Thanks very much for any responses!

OP posts:
Chocolatewheatos · 26/11/2021 08:28

I'm really sorry for what you've been through and I understand that it's hard. But you talk alot about how they should understand how you feel and be compassionate of you but you're kind of ruining this for them by making it about you. You know how precious this is to them, its not been easy for them. But at every turn they're expected to remind themselves of your loss and to carefully plan every moment to not hurt you. I don't think that's fair. Their memory of this precious time is going to be marred by your behaviour, making them feel guilty for their struggle to conceive not lasting longer than yours.

pollyroo · 26/11/2021 08:22

It appears that SIL & BIL aren't entitled to 'any' sort of happiness or celebration of any kind due to your loss.

YABVU indeed. Cut them some slack.

This comes from someone who has been told fertility issues are apparent on both sides ( me & DP ) and it's looking likely we will need IVF too.

Although I appreciate that this is an awful time for you & you have been through a lot, you sound extremely spiteful & hard work.

It's time for you to stop dictating what SIL & BIL should/ shouldn't be doing & to be happy for someone else.

Sending Thanks

anon12345678901 · 26/11/2021 08:15

@Franca123

I think under the circumstances it was insensitive of them to expect presents and excitement pre the birth. Also, they shouldn't have had a baby shower with the family. It would have been no hardship to them at all. This must be extreme difficult for you I'm sure. I'm so sorry. Only thing I would say, try not to destroy your relationship but do take the space you need. Hopefully in time you can take joy in being an Auntie. Be gentle to yourself. I went through ivf and this sounds like a nightmare situation for you to be in. Best of luck.
So if OP gets pregnant, I take it they also can't have a baby shower or celebrate. Because you couldn't say it's fine for OP but not fine for the SIL to celebrate a baby.
LethargicActress · 26/11/2021 08:11

OP, they didn’t leave whatever it was that confirmed their pregnancy on purpose, it was a mistake. They clearly didn’t intend to hurt you and were probably mortified when they realised. While you are working through all the feelings you have around this, you need to try to forgive them.

Same for the baby shower. Typical baby showers can be a bit tacky and awkward, they probably just wanted to celebrate with their families without all that. They could have made a different choice, but they didn’t want to, and it’s not fair to expect them to not to celebrate in the way they wanted.

ShaneTheThird · 26/11/2021 08:01

Sorry for your loss but you are deeply unreasonable. They have done nothing wrong and have had a tough time themselves getting pregnant only to be basically cut off and berated by you.

Notonthestairs · 26/11/2021 07:56

I think you are trying to take control of a situation where you dont have any.

I know the success rates for IVF are tough and the process is horrible. You are already struggling with grief and loss.

Dictating what your SIL does and doesn't do is an easy fix.

But by creating a set of boundaries for someone else to abide by I think you are making yourself feel worse.

It doesnt really matter about the baby shower does it? It doesnt impact your outcome.

Let these things go. Just dont fixate on them. It cant be undone and there are no words anyone can give you to stop your losses hurting.

By all means keep a bit of distance but when the baby comes you must do your best to celebrate them - its a new member of your extended family, and honestly you will love them. And its easier when they arrive because they are flesh and blood.

I know IVF is a terrible blackhole to fall into. I had miscarriages after successful IVF treatment. Just dont redirect your pain on to others.

MichelleScarn · 26/11/2021 07:54

As to SIL being upset DH's side of the family weren't excited, this was just her opinion. DH's side of the family believe they were excited about her pregnancy and that they showed this. But in hindsight maybe she felt this way because I had withdrawn and this made her feel awkward about her own pregnancy.

This update wants me to hug your SIL. it reads like you have been in deep discussion regarding her pregnancy with the family and want them all on 'your side'.
So this couple who have also been through difficulties which won't go away even though she's currently pregnant probably feel like they now can't be supported by his family, especially if you've made your displeasure well known re the baby shower.
How will you feel if/when you are in the same situation that no one wants to talk about it or celebrate your pregnancy or will you expect it to be a huge focus for family and friends?

Franca123 · 26/11/2021 07:50

I think under the circumstances it was insensitive of them to expect presents and excitement pre the birth. Also, they shouldn't have had a baby shower with the family. It would have been no hardship to them at all. This must be extreme difficult for you I'm sure. I'm so sorry. Only thing I would say, try not to destroy your relationship but do take the space you need. Hopefully in time you can take joy in being an Auntie. Be gentle to yourself. I went through ivf and this sounds like a nightmare situation for you to be in. Best of luck.

Figgygal · 26/11/2021 07:45

So they can have a baby shower but not that type of baby shower
They can celebrate with family but not that way
Honestly you say about needing space how much space do you need? You’ll find the baby stage hard, the toddler stage I think unless you make peace with their situation soon and work through your feelings by the time you’re ready to re-engage with them the relationship will be irretrievable anyway
You don’t want to isolate yourself within your dh family

anon12345678901 · 26/11/2021 07:41

Even with your updates, you're still unreasonable in this situation. Its awful you didn't get your baby yet, but that doesn't mean SIL cannot be happy and have the shower they want. You wouldn't have been happy with any shower from the sounds of it because you aren't happy she's pregnant first. They have been sensitive, and as you say they didn't know you found out before they told you, they obviously have no idea they left something at your house. It was an honest mistake. I feel for your SIL, she must really feel she isn't able to truly celebrate her baby because of you.

Howshouldibehave · 26/11/2021 07:33

I found this out due to the carelessness of SIL and BIL. I was angry that they'd been so careless with our feelings despite knowing all we'd been through, so I cut contact with them both

So in the early days of pregnancy brain-when you can’t think straight-she/they left something accidentally at your house ‘proving’ they were pregnant. I can only think it was a pregnancy test/pregnancy notes/letter/medication or something along those lines.

And you got so angry, you cut contact with them??

Please go and see a doctor-I think you need some serious help to manage these feelings. Maybe even some medication.

EdgeOfTheSky · 26/11/2021 07:31

Oh, OP, I am sorry you had such a devastating loss and this is such a tough process to be going through.

In the end, there is nothing your SIL and BIL can do that changes the reality if the situation you are in. You are struggling,, and that is understandable and if your pain doesn’t ricochet off your ILs it will be something else.

Whatever happens (snd I wish you luck) you DH still needs his brother.

Your ILs fortune is not connected with your loss and difficulty: they have not taken anything from you. They accidentally left something at your house… accidents happen. They had a baby shower that broke sexist stereotypes, it wasn’t a dig at you.

OP: I am thinking about the way you and your DH actually anticipated how you would feel if ILs IVF was successful before your own. You had actually decided that this would be tough rather than joining them on the IVF journey, supporting each other, and then waiting to see how you felt.

Maybe to some extent you wrote your own script and are now trapped in it.

Suppose, just for an hour, you live as if you are pleased to know that IVF can be successful. Be happy for your SIL. Just trying it out, for an hour: acting as if you felt that way, I know you can’t actually suddenly feel that way, but ‘acting as if’ sometimes helps us loosen entrenched reactions to our feelings.

You haven’t done anything wrong, BIL and SIL haven’t done anything wrong. You are hurting from loss snd struggling with fear, and it isn’t easy.

Offmyfence · 26/11/2021 07:12

Your grief is obviously so raw OP, I'm sorry for your loss and ongoing issues.

Have you accessed counselling for your feelings?

Bananarama21 · 26/11/2021 07:09

Even with your update op your bil and sil have done everything to be sensitive to your struggles they were very much entitled to have a family celebration. I imagine poor sil feels this time is being spoilt and she can't enjoy her pregnancy the comment about not having a big shower demonstrates that. What will happen when she does have the baby if this behaviour continues when he's born it could cause unrepairable damage. Are they not allowed to do christening or birthday party's. You don't know for sure if they have tried naturally and had a lost. I've had a miscarriage and not told family members you don't know what's gone on within their relationship.

Comingup · 26/11/2021 06:58

I know your pain, been through it as so many people on here have. OP please for your own sake and those around you, seek some help. You cannot carry on like this. Unfortunately falling pregnant is largely out of your control and trying to shift that control onto you SIL life and how she handles being pregnant is going to drive you mad. You just can't. You were going to be angry and take offence at whatever they did, they can't do anything right as they have done the ultimate wrong haven't they by getting pregnant in the first place.
Your MH sounds at rock bottom. What happens when baby comes? Will they be expected not to be excited, not to put cards up, only to show people when you deem it's acceptable?? You can't live this way and neither can they. Look after yourself and focus on getting the help you need.

lboogy · 26/11/2021 05:47

Im sorry for your losses. As someone who has been through ivf following 5 years of infertility, I think you're being massively unreasonable. You've let your emotions cloud your judgement and are being really unfair to sil.

Yes it hurts she's pregnant but she's entailed to be happy. She probably didn't invite you to the baby shower because she knew you'd make it a miserable experience.

I wish I could give you a big hug and give your head a wobble at the same time.

Please get some counselling because it doesn't sound like you're coping and loosing all sense of perspective.

SD1978 · 26/11/2021 04:28

Sorry- but whilst understandable who have and are being extremely unreasonable. She had to hide her pregnancy from you both, accidentally didn't, and is dating to celebrate and you think it's all against you.........you are both going through IVF and it could have been either one of you. Whilst it's really hard, juts for one minute, imagine all you wrote is what SIL said about you, if it was the other way round. You must know you're wrong, and whilst I do understand that trying to conceive can be very difficult, this is all on you, not them.

Darkpheonix · 26/11/2021 04:02

@IviSable this jumped out at me

As to SIL being upset DH's side of the family weren't excited, this was just her opinion.

Do you see the irony? You express your feelings and expect everyone to acknowledge them and plan their lives around them.

She ezpreases hers and its just an opinion and then go on to explain how she is wrong.

You can nor expect everyone to live around your emotions, validate them unquestioningly then say that their feelings are wrong. It's hypocritical and shows that you are so immersed in your own grief, that you can't acknowledge other people have perfectly valid feelings. Its like you believe they are not people in their own right. They are side characters in your story. A story you are writing where you get to dictate their feelings, actions and responses.

You feel they should have only had the baby shower you think they should so your dh didn't feel he should go. You want them to plan everything around you with your feelings as the priority.

You asked for space then complain she didn't approach you. How would she know you were ready for her too or wanted her to. Maybe she wanted to, maybe she didn't. But she respected your request for space. But again, she doesn't have to act in a way you feel comfortable with if she doesn't.

My personal opinion is that if person A asks person B for space, it's up to person A to let B know when they have had enough space. B should respect the request for space and can't possibly know when A is ready.

Also, when asking for space, A needs to accept that while B may give them space, there will come a point where B can not live waiting for A to decide all is well again. B needs to live their own life. Not spending it wondering if A will be happy with their actions, hoping if their actions are 'right' enough A will end the period of space. Not trying to guess what A thinks is the right thing to do. That's just wrong and quite cruel of A.

That cruelty may come from an understandable place of immense pain and may not intended to be cruelty. It may be intended to be self preservation. But its cruelty to the other person, all the same. Even if that's not the intent.

ReggaetonLente · 26/11/2021 03:57

I feel for you, but it sounds like what you are really angry about is that they dared to get pregnant before you did. And that is VU.

CheekyHobson · 26/11/2021 03:30

It may be helpful to consider this more from a framework of 'boundaries' rather than 'sensitivities'.

For example, you told your SIL that you may need to take some space if she became pregnant because of your own sadness. This is fair enough and although she may have been disappointed you would not be there to share her pregnancy happiness with her, she understood it could be upsetting for you, so she respected your boundary about needing space.

You also said you could not come to her baby shower. Again, although she may have been disappointed that you were not there to celebrate her pregnancy, she understood it could be upsetting to you, so she respected this boundary.

However to say that she should have had a different kind of party to the one she did is moving outside your own boundaries and into controlling her life. You decided you couldn't be there for her celebration because of your own sadness, and that's fair. But to think you should be able to have a say in how she celebrates her happiness is controlling.

It would be like a sister who was disappointed she hadn't gotten married telling her brother that he's not allowed a big wedding because it hurts her feelings.

Your sadness is real, but it can only affect other people's lives up to the point where you are not there for them. It is nothing to do with how they choose to live their own lives.

HippoRaine · 26/11/2021 03:09

@Bloodybridget

In case anyone is wondering who on earth pressed YANBU, my finger slipped!

I am however very sorry for your situation, OP.

You can change your vote if you want to, just click on the right bit
Bloodybridget · 26/11/2021 02:54

In case anyone is wondering who on earth pressed YANBU, my finger slipped!

I am however very sorry for your situation, OP.

ThousandsOfTulips · 26/11/2021 02:50

Wow, OP. I'm so sorry for your struggles but you're massively projecting onto them. It sounds like they did everything you asked. What will you do when the baby is born, demand that his uncle (your husband) doesn't see him?

I know you are in pain. But you should have empathy tok, if you've been through similar struggles. If you were finally having a baby would it be fair for someone to say you shouldn't celebrate it with family and friends and be over the moon about it?

This isn't about you. I do think you are being very unreasonable.

tallduckandhandsome · 26/11/2021 02:23

DH and his DB did agree that his DB would tell my DH if they got pregnant and that he would then tell me. That unfortuneatly didn't happen as I found out two months before I was meant to.

That said, I've had friends tell me about their pregnancies in as nice a way as possible and I've felt fine about those.

This was an accident, but it could have been completely avoided.

OP, it’s clear that you’re in a lot of pain, and the sense I got from your posts is that there is a script in your head of how these announcements should go i.e. you finding out 2 months before you’re meant to, and your friends telling you about their pregnancies ‘in as nice a way as possible’. It’s good that friends and family are being gentle with you, but you have to make allowances for people, they will make mistakes. That’s also why an accident can’t really be avoided, otherwise it wouldn’t be an accident. It sounds like you’re surrounded by people who car for you and have never wanted to hurt you.

goawaystormy · 26/11/2021 02:04

I had just hoped they'd tread a little more carefully around us given the discussions we'd had with them early on, which they were very amenable to.

They have treaded carefully around you though! Your SIL announced she was with you on that loudspeaker phonecall to protect you! They didn't expect you at the babyshower because they were being respectful of YOUR feelings. Your SIL never messaged you because YOU said YOU wanted space and she didn't put the burden on you of even trying to fake being happy for her.

You're angry that you 'got wind' that your SIL had been complaining. She's just as entitled to her feelings as you are. It would be insensitive if she complained to you about it but shes entitled to share her feelings with other people and can't be blamed for you 'getting wind of' or 'finding out' or 'suspecting' anything.

You don't just want them to tread carefully around you, you want them to change their whole lives and response to this pregnancy, even in ways unrelated to you (babyshower) because of your loss and feelings. I understand it must be so so hard for you but it doesn't mean their whole lives, even the parts not directly in contact with yours, should change.