Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say fuck it and give them picnic food?

207 replies

Blahdyblahbla · 25/11/2021 17:47

My dc are a nightmare at home in relation to food. They eat well at the childminders house, but with me and grandparents they just refuse anything vaguely like a hot meal (unless of course its nuggets and chips).

I'm losing the will, I plan and cook nutritious meals without too much repetition, half killing myself to make the said meal available throughout the evening to accommodate everyone's activities.

Most meals get rejected, they'd rather starve than try something they don't like the look of.
They both will reliably eat packed lunch/ picnic type food.

AIBU to say sod it and let them have a spread every evening for the next few months, just so I can drop the evening meal from my mental load? Or will it just make things worse?
They are 2 and 5.

OP posts:
PinkSyCo · 25/11/2021 22:58

Chips and nuggets are pretty much a comfort food

What/who makes them a comfort food?

PinkSyCo · 25/11/2021 22:57

Well quite but actually that is familiar and non challenging for a hangry,tired little one rather than having a battle over something new during the witching hour.

If nugget and chips are the only foods familiar to *OP’s children then that’s a problem.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 25/11/2021 22:43

Chips and nuggets are pretty much a comfort food so far easier to face when you’re tired and hangry.

StEval · 25/11/2021 22:41

They’re not too tired to eat nuggets and chips though

Well quite but actually that is familiar and non challenging for a hangry,tired little one rather than having a battle over something new during the witching hour.
Sometimes its about surviving and being kind to yourself as a parent.
Knocking yourself out cooking fancy stuff for tired, crabby young DC is setting yourself up to fail.
There is so much pressure on mothers these days Brew

fuckyourpronouns · 25/11/2021 22:41

Ah @Blahdyblahbla I can sympathise. I have a 4&5yr old and have the same battles.

We have a strict, this is what is for dinner. We all eat the same. You don't have to eat it but you do need to try it. There is nothing else. And we stand firm.

There are occasions where it might be a bit spicy or they've tried a bit of everything and said they don't like it and I've given them a banana or toast. But generally I stand firm.

Of course they have a preference for familiar foods. But who is responsible for making food familiar?

Going without dinner for a few days won't make them starve. They will have a bigger breakfast the following morning and probably a bigger lunch. Eventually they will come round.

lisaandalan · 25/11/2021 22:38

Could you not send last nights dinner you make to the childminder and ask her could she just warm it in the microwave and give it to them half and hour before you are due to arrive, to see if they will eat it for her. Obviously she can still give them their packed lunch ect during the day.
Then may you can just give them a sandwich or something before bed if you feel they need it. X

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 25/11/2021 22:32

I did this loads when mine were little, DH was away a lot and we did numerous after school activities. Not always picnic but food that I could "assemble" rather than cook. So, also things like soft boiled eggs with soldiers and veg sticks. Jacket potatoes, wraps with different fillings, crumpets or pizza bases with toppings, decent sausages on hot dog rolls or with frozen mash. Mine would also always eat pasta and pesto - used to make my own sometimes and add in spinach for a bit extra veg - and egg fried rice with frozen peas and sweetcorn thrown in.

They are older now and eat a normal variety of different foods.

josssie · 25/11/2021 22:28

What don't they like about your food? Do you add herbs, stock, is it full of flavour?
Mine hated processed foods and always wanted what I'd cooked.
I've always believed they won't starve, if you keep giving in they know they have the upper hand.
Maybe involve them in making dinner?
Good luck

PinkSyCo · 25/11/2021 22:21

I always found my very small DC ate well at breakfast and lunch and due to tiredness it tailed off a bit in the evening, hence feeding them a high tea at 5ish rather than expecting them to eat with us later.

They’re not too tired to eat nuggets and chips though. Grin

PinkSyCo · 25/11/2021 22:11

Why would the picnic food the OP has described be unhealthy?

Yes I thought someone might question this. I didn’t really mean healthy as in nutritionally, but couldn’t be bothered to go in to the importance of them practicing eating with cutlery and also learning that they can’t always have exactly what they want food wise.

StEval · 25/11/2021 22:10

@PinkSyCo

Interesting that they eat what they’re given at the child minders but not for indulgent parents and grandparents isn’t it? Saying that, if they’re eating healthily once a day with said childminder I think picnic food in the evening is fine. 🤷🏻‍♀️
I always found my very small DC ate well at breakfast and lunch and due to tiredness it tailed off a bit in the evening, hence feeding them a high tea at 5ish rather than expecting them to eat with us later. I wonder if part of it is tiredness Op? Expecting a 2 and 5 year old to wait until adult dinner time might be part of the issue ? In fairness you havent said what time they eat.

I remember it being a rush to get mine to eat as DS2 ( age 3/4) would face plant onto his plate sound asleep if it was too late Grin

Perhaps partly tiredness/ partly hangry- quick, familiar, comforting food fits the bill.

anothermamaa · 25/11/2021 22:04

[quote Blahdyblahbla]@regularbutnamechangedd mine would too, they have wills of steel!
Is a sandwich, bit of fruit, lump of cheese, a bit of hummus any less valid than a spag bol I wonder? It just feels "wrong" and not what I know to eat a picnic for every meal, and I can't really explain why Blush[/quote]
I give my two year old a plate like this most days because I know he'll eat it. As long as they're getting nutritious food I don't think it matters what form it comes in

JunoMcDuff · 25/11/2021 21:50

@PinkSyCo

Interesting that they eat what they’re given at the child minders but not for indulgent parents and grandparents isn’t it? Saying that, if they’re eating healthily once a day with said childminder I think picnic food in the evening is fine. 🤷🏻‍♀️
Why would the picnic food the OP has described be unhealthy?
PinkSyCo · 25/11/2021 21:43

Interesting that they eat what they’re given at the child minders but not for indulgent parents and grandparents isn’t it? Saying that, if they’re eating healthily once a day with said childminder I think picnic food in the evening is fine. 🤷🏻‍♀️

stupiduser · 25/11/2021 21:34

Our best low effort meal was an idea from here. Savoury pancakes. 3 tablespoons of milk, 3 tablespoons of flour and an egg and then the kids get to choose what yo put in them, they often like ham cheese sweet corn etc. It makes three small thick pancakes. Lovely and takes5 minutes tops. And best of all the kids can do it themselves very easily

Squiz81 · 25/11/2021 21:30

I feel your pain. Will they eat porridge? I’ve been doing that for my youngest, I figure it ticks the box of hot meal and is nutritious. He will have a banana with it

elbea · 25/11/2021 21:29

Solid Starts has great advice, they really recommend ‘picnics’, a board in the middle with lots of choices. ‘Safe foods’ you know they’ll like and one or two more challenging foods.

If you look at their Instagram story reels, they have a five year old with severe picky eating (would only eat eight foods) and shows how they are working to change this. They employ leading professionals to that specialise in childhood eating, some from Stanford.

It has helped our family immensely and our daughter has gone from being under the care of the dietician at the hospital for weight loss as a result of picky eating to thriving and eating all sorts of foods.

DukeofEarlGrey · 25/11/2021 21:24

Go for it, OP. The things that count here are a) nutrition and b) your sanity and it sounds like both could be helped by picnic food. No reason why what you've described can't be just as nutritious as a hot meal.

BikeMyCycle · 25/11/2021 21:20

Follow Kids Eat In Color on Instagram, I love the ideas on there.

YukoandHiro · 25/11/2021 21:08

Are you me? You are certainly describing my life (with added allergies to contend with here).

I do picnic tea at least once a week sometimes twice when I can no longer stand the whingeing

SnowSurprise · 25/11/2021 21:07

plan and cook nutritious meals without too much repetition,
Is this maybe the problem? That it's different every time. Mine definitely prefer the same, known "safe" meals over and over. I can get away with one or maybe two different/new meals a week but it will take several repetitions for them to accept them without moaning. And then they beg for their favourites for the next few weeks.

Luredbyapomegranate · 25/11/2021 21:05

[quote Blahdyblahbla]@regularbutnamechangedd mine would too, they have wills of steel!
Is a sandwich, bit of fruit, lump of cheese, a bit of hummus any less valid than a spag bol I wonder? It just feels "wrong" and not what I know to eat a picnic for every meal, and I can't really explain why Blush[/quote]
It's fine. It has the same nutritional value, and I know lots of people who feed their little children like these, because they are happy with it. I am all for fun finger food..

julieca · 25/11/2021 21:00

I think it will make it worse and you could be doing this for many years.

Loopyloulou007 · 25/11/2021 20:48

Mine started to be picky eaters and I was sick of it. Try a plain margarita pizza and then have lots of bowls of other things and let them build it themselves. Mexican taco's with all the dips. Give them the job of beating, squishing the life out of advocacy for the quacamole. Warm up the bread wraps, just before you dish up. Let them pick and build it themselves and then eat it. It's messy, but fun. My kids ate if they enjoyed the process. Apple crumbles were a hit. Then move onto, getting them to assist helping make something with you. Chicken strips, let em dunk it in the egg, bread crumbs etc. you fry it, then just work your way along. Mine all eat absolutely anything now and will give anything a go. But they always join in. My boy is now 8 and uses one of those choppy machines, that cuts things like onions, by whacking it down, tiring for him, but it's helping me at the same time. Get em involved it's not as time consuming as you will think.

Tothemoonandbackx · 25/11/2021 20:42

One of my best memories growing up, was my dad packing the table with bowls full of different veggies all chopped/diced/sliced, cheeses, (and before I became vegetarian) meats and just plonking a loaf of bread on the table and telling us to make our own sandwiches, we used to make all sorts of odd ones, but loved doing it and because we could make our own, we always used to eat them Smile x