Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

No thank you, no more gifts

257 replies

SaturdaySummer · 25/11/2021 16:33

I have given around 10/11 big bags for life FULL of John Lewis and Next clothes, toys, a play mat, a bath seat, an inflatable chair etc. To someone my dad works with. The lad is early 20s and on an apprentice wage and his gf is a student so they would struggle to get everything on such limited income. All the clothes were excellent condition, some with labels on still. I washed and ironed everything. These were things my son had outgrown and we are lucky to have been able to afford everything he needed so I didn't mind helping someone else out. My friend also gave them more items - about 4 bags for life with again, clothes with labels on etc. I didn't give these things expecting anything in return but the couple have not even sent a thank you card of text - they have literally had thousands of pounds worth of stuff. AIBU to give things to charity in future now instead of this couple as I really feel they have been incredibly rude and ungrateful to not even acknowledge what they have been given

OP posts:
Pigeoninthehouse · 26/11/2021 09:43

@JurgensCakeBaby

Lots of people don't send thank yous anymore, I'm not one of them and luckily neither are my friends. Not always a card but a call/text, or now DS is older we quite often do a little video message with him with the item so he can say thank you directly, I think it's teaching him an important message and he's not old enough to write yet. Having said all of that I gave a big bag of similar quality, excellent condition stuff to a colleague whose young daughter has just had a baby and I know she and her partner are on low income. My colleague said thank you very sincerely and came in a few days later and said she loved the stuff, her daughter could contact me on FB or get my number from her mum, but really it's not necessary I have so much baby stuff I can't even give it away our local baby bank is overwhelmed, so actually it's doing me a favour to get rid. Thank you was said at the point of handover and that's plenty for me, so if the male said thanks to your dad they might assume he'll pass that on.
But you were still thanked, sometimes you don't realise how much it matters until it doesn't happen. And the op is venting on an anonymous forum, she hasn't gone round the lads house demanding a thank you. She seems to have just wanted a simple thank you, not a carefully crafted missive explaining how the couple are eternally grateful.
parietal · 26/11/2021 09:34

YABU

Why on earth did you give them so much stuff in the first place? When the boy said they wanted a few things, he probably imagined 4 babygrows and a playmat. Not 15 bags worth to sort through. It is a lot of work to sort & organise that kind of gift, and takes away all the joy of choosing your own baby things, even if that is only the value-packs from tesco.

don't offload your junk on people who haven't asked for it. Even if you think it is nice, they clearly don't.

JurgensCakeBaby · 26/11/2021 09:29

Lots of people don't send thank yous anymore, I'm not one of them and luckily neither are my friends. Not always a card but a call/text, or now DS is older we quite often do a little video message with him with the item so he can say thank you directly, I think it's teaching him an important message and he's not old enough to write yet.
Having said all of that I gave a big bag of similar quality, excellent condition stuff to a colleague whose young daughter has just had a baby and I know she and her partner are on low income. My colleague said thank you very sincerely and came in a few days later and said she loved the stuff, her daughter could contact me on FB or get my number from her mum, but really it's not necessary I have so much baby stuff I can't even give it away our local baby bank is overwhelmed, so actually it's doing me a favour to get rid. Thank you was said at the point of handover and that's plenty for me, so if the male said thanks to your dad they might assume he'll pass that on.

Pigeoninthehouse · 26/11/2021 09:20

@Fomofo

Lizziesiddal, if someone off loads something on me that I did not ask for how is it 'fucking rude' not to write them a thank you card? Your post was pretty rude mind
Read the ops posts. She was asked for them. She doesn't expect a thank you note. A thank you text would have been ok.
Fomofo · 26/11/2021 09:18

Lizziesiddal, if someone off loads something on me that I did not ask for how is it 'fucking rude' not to write them a thank you card? Your post was pretty rude mind

Pigeoninthehouse · 26/11/2021 09:10

@CaMePlaitPas

Don't worry about me *@Pigeoninthehouse*, my self esteem is just fine thanks. It's nice to have enough self awareness to not be the arsehole who believes that people I help are indebted to me in some way.
Expecting someone to say thank you for your something given with good intentions, is not about self awareness.That's just basic good manners and the basis of a civilised society. Self awareness comes in understanding that the problem is with them, not you. The op has asked for a simple thank you, not sure where you are gtting indebted from. Lots of very defensive people on this thread, makes me wonder if they have poor manners too.
LucySullivanIsGettingMarried · 26/11/2021 09:08

Poor fuckers having all those bags and bags of stuff dumped on them is all I can say! I had someone do the same to me (totally unasked for!) when I had my first and it was awful; bags full of shit everywhere!

LizzieSiddal · 26/11/2021 09:00

Don't worry about me @Pigeoninthehouse, my self esteem is just fine thanks. It's nice to have enough self awareness to not be the arsehole who believes that people I help are indebted to me in some way.

Expecting some to say Thank you is not the same as feeling someone is “indebted” to you. It’s basic manners which we teach our children from the very beginning. Although going by this thread I’m learning that many people do not think it’s basic manners. If you’re not teaching your kids to say a simple thank you, you’re doing them a major disservice.

SequinnedShawl · 26/11/2021 08:59

I hated being given bags of baby stuff. Felt like I was obliged to take them. Especially when if I gave the bags back as requested once I had been through and taken out anything I found useful, I was then interrogated as to why I didn't want: nursing bras, sleepsuits with the feet cut out, cardigans with the buttons cut off (”you can easily sew buttons on and I wanted those ones”) and many more delights. Hmm

The young couple probably feel that they're being used as a dumping ground for all your old toot.

girlmom21 · 26/11/2021 08:57

@BridgetWhyNot

Not everyone has had the upbringing to know how to say thank you or give thank you cards.
Bollocks. Every functioning adult knows how and when to say please and thank you.
Pigeoninthehouse · 26/11/2021 08:51

I think it's odd that he did - given that he doesn't actually know @SaturdaySummer - he works with her Dad. How does that conversation go? "Does your daughter have any leftover stuff from her kids I might be able to use? I know she's kind of rich ... and I'm not
Her dad may have thought he was being helpful volunteering his daughters stuff to this young man and its got a bit out of hand. Especially if her dad is much senior to, the lad may have just found it difficult to refuse.
Still think the op should have been thanked for her effort though and totally understand the ops disappointment.
Absolute BS all the posters saying they don't expect thanks for their effort.

CaMePlaitPas · 26/11/2021 08:49

I don't ask for gifts @JinglingHellsBells what a strange comment. I'm not 4, I don't expect presents at Christmas.

CaMePlaitPas · 26/11/2021 08:48

Don't worry about me @Pigeoninthehouse, my self esteem is just fine thanks. It's nice to have enough self awareness to not be the arsehole who believes that people I help are indebted to me in some way.

Dishhh · 26/11/2021 08:37

@hidinginquote

For people saying that they didn't want want to be given peoples hand me downs when they were pregnant with irrelevant, the OP said they specifically asked if they had anything! The OP did and passed on a lot of stuff, I think that certainly warrants at least a thank you text!

I have friends who I went out of my way to help out with baby stuff (that they wanted and ask for help with, not clothes but things like baby swing, isofix car seat and base, barely used) and they were ungrateful and it was honestly quite hurtful!

I think it's odd that he did - given that he doesn't actually know @SaturdaySummer - he works with her Dad. How does that conversation go? "Does your daughter have any leftover stuff from her kids I might be able to use? I know she's kind of rich ... and I'm not ..."

Pigeoninthehouse · 26/11/2021 08:32

@CaMePlaitPas

You don't give things expecting to be thanked OP.
Really? You have very low expectations for yourself don't you, I would work on that.
JinglingHellsBells · 26/11/2021 08:23

@CaMePlaitPas

You don't give things expecting to be thanked OP.
Do you mean you don't? @CaMePlaitPas

It's normal, decent behaviour to thank someone for a gift.

Are you going to be following your own moral compass this Xmas? Not thanking anyone for a gift they give you?

CaMePlaitPas · 26/11/2021 08:04

You don't give things expecting to be thanked OP.

Thisbastardcomputer · 26/11/2021 08:04

Off topic but when I moved house I gave my nephew and his girlfriend £1.5k worth of wooden blinds, sent £50 via my sister when the baby was born.

Not a word of thanks and actually turned away from me recently at my mum's funeral.

It won't happen again.

LizzieSiddal · 26/11/2021 08:03

Fomofo
I'm not sure I'd send a card for 2nd hand stuff, I'd think I was doing the giver a favour by accepting it

Really? How fucking rude.

hidinginquote · 26/11/2021 07:42

For people saying that they didn't want want to be given peoples hand me downs when they were pregnant with irrelevant, the OP said they specifically asked if they had anything! The OP did and passed on a lot of stuff, I think that certainly warrants at least a thank you text!

I have friends who I went out of my way to help out with baby stuff (that they wanted and ask for help with, not clothes but things like baby swing, isofix car seat and base, barely used) and they were ungrateful and it was honestly quite hurtful!

Mol1628 · 26/11/2021 07:31

I wouldn’t expect a thank you card for passing on items I had finished with. Just a standard thank you to whoever passed it over would be fine.

Eeyoresideyestigger · 26/11/2021 01:11

Don't give them anything more. Ungrateful buggers

Giver your hand me downs to a real friend or sell them elsewhere

and next time they ask your dad say " not bloody likely"

It literarily takes seconds to send a text to thank someone or write a card or note . They can't even bothered? You can't be bothered...,

Peach01 · 26/11/2021 01:03

Did the couple just grab the bag without thanking the person who handed it to them?
I wouldn't expect a thank you. I would rather know the clothes were going straight to a family who needed them and would feel happy enough about that. Plus getting them out of the house is doing a favour.

If it's causing you any upset then give the clothes to a charity next time.

nomoneytreehere · 26/11/2021 00:55

Oh god, when I was having my last baby I specifically told people I didn't want their stuff. What's perfect condition to you isn't necessarily to someone else, and seriously how much stuff does a newborn need. Also, first babies you get so so many gifts. My parents neighbours children (who I had never met) bought me stuff! Just because they are on low income doesn't mean they want your old stuff! And just because you paid £1000 for it - I'm afraid it's worth a pittance now. My sons newborn wardrobe was pretty much all from the white company. I gave it all to the baby bank. You might have found they were grateful if you had picked out a few really nice pieces rather than treating them like the nearest charity shop.

BridgetWhyNot · 26/11/2021 00:20

@Fomofo

I'm not sure I'd send a card for 2nd hand stuff, I'd think I was doing the giver a favour by accepting it
This.