Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that he's dated someone else at the same time??

83 replies

mumhana · 25/11/2021 11:24

Been married for 5 years and just found out that my DH dated someone else at the same time he was dating me, it was in the early stages and He stopped seeing her 3/4 months into our dating time.
AIBU for being annoyed? He says we weren't in a relationship then and were just dating but I am shocked!
In those 3 months we were going for dates every week. He always came across as such a trustable guy.

OP posts:
dabbydeedoo · 26/11/2021 13:54

I absolutely loathe modern dating culture from America and this is why.

It used to be a no brainer that once you were seeing someone regularly, it was exclusive. There was no need to ask or have a chat because it was just expected. Now, thanks to this shitty American culture where it's acceptable to multi date, you can't just 'see where it goes' and relax. If you care about your sexual health at all, you need to have a talk and ask if you're exclusive. It takes away the natural flow and forces an awkward, unpleasant conversation.

I think the idea of being sexually active with multiple people and not being open about it is deplorable and I hate how so many people now think it's normal. It's disgusting and dangerous.

Frannyhy · 26/11/2021 13:43

I’d bet money that he ghosted the other woman.

girlmom21 · 25/11/2021 22:20

@BigYellowHat

Why is he bringing it up now? That’s what I’d want to know.
He didn't...
BigYellowHat · 25/11/2021 19:59

Why is he bringing it up now? That’s what I’d want to know.

Skysblue · 25/11/2021 19:58

Yanbu. This whole idea has come over from America that it’s absolutely fine to date and even sleep with several partners at the same time, without mentioning it to any of them that this is happening, unless some kind of formal chat has been had where the words are said “we agree to be exclusive”.

Weird.

I don’t think that idea has ever been widely adoped in UK, in none of my twelve relationships did we ever discuss whether or not we were ‘exclusive’ or ‘just dating’ or what. As soon as we started flirting/kissing/ calling each other girlfriend etc, that meant no one else was on the scene. Otherwise it’s cheating, using, stringing someone along, etc etc.

I’d be looking at DH slightly differently. And the fact that your DH concealed this from you for 5 years shows he knows it wasn’t ok.

strivingtosucceed · 25/11/2021 17:38

I think unless you've confirmed exclusivity then you can't really be too upset if the other person isn't exclusive, there's no lying involved in this case.

I don't know how close you were after 4 months or how often you saw, but i'd agree that it's probably a bit longer than most people would need to decide on whether they wanted to be exclusive with someone or not. But I realise that guys have very different ideas about this than women do.

sandy354 · 25/11/2021 16:11

My view is that multi-dating is common (particularly with OLD) these days and nobody should Assume they're exclusive without it being agreed.

I'm only recently single after 20 years so this was new to me but his reaction sounds as though he didn't think he was doing anything wrong at all, which ties up with it being "the norm"

mumhana · 25/11/2021 15:55

@sandy354

2 questions from me:
  1. How did your DH react when his friends mentioned it? I think this will give you good insight as if he genuinely thought he wasn't doing anything wrong and that 'it's just how the world of dating works' then he would assume it wasn't a big revelation. Did he assume you already knew and had also been dating other people during this period? Or was it more of "oh shit I've been caught out and mumhana is going to be upset/angry?

  2. how has he reacted to your upset since you did find out? Has he been apologetic and reassuring or does he not understand why you're feeling the way you are?

He wasn't angry about his friend mentioning this to me. He was there and wasn't shocked at all. They (his mates) were all sharing their stories about multi dating etc He isn't apologetic about it at all. Says that's who he was and that's what people do as we weren't in a relationship. He said that if he knew then that we would end up working out and getting married etc he would've ended any contact with the other one but he didn't know that at the time and it's whats happened and "everyone does it" 🤨 I think I'm over it as it was 8 years ago and ultimately it doesn't matter anymore. Just wish I knew then ..
OP posts:
sandy354 · 25/11/2021 15:42

2 questions from me:

  1. How did your DH react when his friends mentioned it? I think this will give you good insight as if he genuinely thought he wasn't doing anything wrong and that 'it's just how the world of dating works' then he would assume it wasn't a big revelation. Did he assume you already knew and had also been dating other people during this period? Or was it more of "oh shit I've been caught out and mumhana is going to be upset/angry?

  2. how has he reacted to your upset since you did find out? Has he been apologetic and reassuring or does he not understand why you're feeling the way you are?

Gottahavehighhopes · 25/11/2021 15:36

@HarrietsChariot

If you have a second date with someone then it's "exclusive" unless everyone agrees otherwise.
Thats not a universal rule, it might be your rule but its unfair to assume everyone would know that
HunterHearstHelmsley · 25/11/2021 15:31

To me, the dating itself isn't an issue. Even if you didn't know until after... But finding out after so long is weird. His friends all keeping it "secret" is weird.

Honestly, when I first opened the thread, I rolled my eyes. Its just dating etc. But as I read further it made me feel a bit odd.

Pedalpushers · 25/11/2021 15:26

I'd be fine with a month or so of overlap but after 4 months my DH and I were pretty close (I think I met his parents around 4-5 months?) and I'd have been a bit upset as well. After 8 years though, I think you should try and let it go. It was crossed wires about what you both expected at that time, not being untrustworthy.

Notyouraveragecupofcoffee · 25/11/2021 15:23

I can totally understand why you're annoyed by it, but equally understand why it would have happened if you hadn't spoken about exclusively seeing each other.

Previous posters are totally right, with online dating (although that's not how the two of you met), there's often cross overs.

I was seeing 2 guys at the same time, and although nor for as long as your DH, I never felt bad about it, as we'd never said we were exclusively dating each other.

After a while I realised I was way more interested in one over the other, we clicked better, so I stopped seeing the other one.

Sounds like that's exactly what happened with your DH, though why it took him that long to realise you were better matched is anyone's guess.

Bookworm20 · 25/11/2021 15:19

@mumhana

I always thought that once you've had a few dates with someone (exclusive or not) and you get on etc. Plan future dates, talk everyday... I thought you shouldn't date someone else.. and if you do then tell me. Maybe I'm being dramatic but I don't like the thought of being picked out of the 2 Oh I'm scared to ask if he was sleeping with her too .. I think I know the answer
Thats how I'd think too. Hate this having to ask to be exclusive shit. If I invest more than a couple of dates in someone and theres potential there, I don't expect him to be also sticking it to someone else. how is that building a relationship?

And a few months in is pretty shitty of him, especially as he'd of known surely that you thought it was just the 2 of you. And you were sleeping together. And why did it take him so long to get rid of the other 'potential'?
I'll bet she actually got rid of him when she found out they were not exclusive either!

And No i don't think you should have to just get over it.
Its something I don't think I'd get over at the drop of a hat. He was cheating on you basically. Until he'd made up his mind. What a head fuck.

mumhana · 25/11/2021 15:11

@XiCi

How did you find out OP? Not a nice thing to hear. I think it would change the way I felt about my DH tbh
One of his friends mentioned it on a night out after many drinks. (So all of his mates who were ushers at our wedding knew ) apparently they all did it at some point and "it's the only way to find love" these days 🙄
OP posts:
mumhana · 25/11/2021 15:07

@KrisAkabusi

This thread, with the same situation and almost the same wording, from an OP with no previous posts, has come up at least three times in three weeks. If it's not you, I apologise.
Oh not me. But good to know I'm not the only one 😂 I just wanted to know how would other feel about this situation
OP posts:
mumhana · 25/11/2021 15:06

@SergeantCatFlap

But what is there to gain by continuing to let this bug you? You seem to have a healthy relationship. So why not try to let this go? I fail to see any upside of choosing to hold onto this as an issue, wasting energy worrying about something from 8 years ago that has had no impact on your current relationship.
Yes you are right. There's nothing to gain. I definitely need to let it go. Maybe he can treat me to a date every week for the next 3/4 months to make up for it 😂
OP posts:
XiCi · 25/11/2021 15:06

How did you find out OP? Not a nice thing to hear. I think it would change the way I felt about my DH tbh

KrisAkabusi · 25/11/2021 14:57

This thread, with the same situation and almost the same wording, from an OP with no previous posts, has come up at least three times in three weeks. If it's not you, I apologise.

CherryBlossomPink · 25/11/2021 14:56

I don’t think he did anything wrong to be honest. If you wanted exclusivity then you should have had a conversation to discuss! I’ve been dating for the past 12 months and have dated more than 1 person at a time, when I met my now boyfriend in August, after a couple of weeks chatting online (there is a physical distance between us) we had our first date where he made it clear he wanted it to be exclusive from that point and it was a dealbreaker for him. I liked him a lot so was happy to agree but we did at least discuss it!

SergeantCatFlap · 25/11/2021 14:48

But what is there to gain by continuing to let this bug you? You seem to have a healthy relationship. So why not try to let this go? I fail to see any upside of choosing to hold onto this as an issue, wasting energy worrying about something from 8 years ago that has had no impact on your current relationship.

3scape · 25/11/2021 14:35

I'm guessing the other one dumped him then. Ouch.

mumhana · 25/11/2021 14:16

@KrisAkabusi

Are you going to ask this every week until you get the answer you want?
?
OP posts:
mumhana · 25/11/2021 14:12

@Returnoftheowl

*Thank you. That's exactly how I feel. He said I should get over it as he liked me better and cut contact with her and that was years ago*

For me it would be the fact it apparently took 3 to 4 months for him to decide he actually liked me better...

Haha can't wait to point this out to the cheeky bugger once he's home from work. He probably thinks I'm over it by now. I knew I liked him after our 1st date 🤪
OP posts:
Returnoftheowl · 25/11/2021 13:58

Thank you. That's exactly how I feel.
He said I should get over it as he liked me better and cut contact with her and that was years ago

For me it would be the fact it apparently took 3 to 4 months for him to decide he actually liked me better...