Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Help with text to end things with a nice guy - but drama last night

112 replies

Ohnowhy2 · 25/11/2021 11:19

Help me write a thoughtful but end things text with a guy I have had 4 dates with.

Had 4 dates with a really kind and thoughtful guy. Last night was the 4th date - but ended with a trip to A&E and me consoling him and his ex.

He came round for take away and it was lovely until he got a call from his alcoholic ex saying his daughter was saying she was going to harm herself so they were going to A&E.

He started to panic and couldn’t get hold of his daughter. He ex kept phoning saying she has dragged his kid in a taxi to A&E. he was getting visibly more upset. So, being nice person I am he drive him to A&e to meet his daughter. He had a drink, taxis were taking ages and I was sober.

I ended up sitting outside A&E consoling him and then his very drunk ex. His drunk ex went through stages of being abusive to me and then apologising saying I would make a better mum - wtf as not even thought of meeting his kid.

I eventually managed to leave. But kept getting calls from him for support. I did say at 1am I need to sleep as work tomorrow.

Now he has texted to say he didn’t tell me about his family issues as we were getting ti know each other but this is not an isolated incident.

So I now want to end things as I feel I can’t or want support him fully as it’s only been 4 dates and we are still in the getting to know you stage. Too much drama.

I know it’s not his fault, but I really don’t want to start a relationship with someone with this much drama. He has already called me to talk about the situation and in my opinion leaning heavily on me (4th date girl so a stranger) for support. I can see this getting worse.

How can a put this politely in a text. I feel cruel as he is having a hard time. But in the same respect, drama at the start will only get worse.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
tiktokniknok · 25/11/2021 21:18

@Skeumorph PERFECT

SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 25/11/2021 16:52

Two things going on here. 1. His family situation is complicated. It is difficult enough sometimes with blended families. This is a situation that is obviously very complicated, and likely to continue for at least some time, maybe always. 2. 4thDateMan's is obviously overwhelmed with his family situation, and has overstepped boundaries expecting you to be a crutch at 1am in the morning when you have work. This wouldn't get any better going forward IMHE. The first situation is enough for many people not to want to be involved, add in the second and life would be potentially very difficult.

Ohnowhy2 · 25/11/2021 16:39

@ChargingBuck yip it is too far. I feel for his situation, but I can’t help or want to.

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 25/11/2021 16:07

@Clymene

A few texts?

"I eventually managed to leave. But kept getting calls from him for support. I did say at 1am I need to sleep as work tomorrow."

"He has already called me to talk about the situation and in my opinion leaning heavily on me (4th date girl so a stranger) for support."

This is not a man who is boundaried. As the OP points out, she is a stranger.

@gannett I was going to reply to your previous comment, but @Clymene puts it over well, & expresses my reservations..

There was nothing wrong in either OP's or his responses in getting to A&E without delay.
He also didn't owe her an up-front analysis of the poor state of his relationship with his Ex, at only 4 dates in - the man could hardly have anticipated the emergency that happened when he was with her last night.

But continuing to phone someone, who is still practically a stranger to your life, expecting "support", until she has to finally exhaustedly extricate herself from the 1am call, is far, far too much to ask. Then he called OP again today expressly to discuss the situation.
That's a boundary too far.

Ohnowhy2 · 25/11/2021 15:57

@Tink1989 yes it is getting a bit deep.

@bubblesbubbles11 nope not saving him. No to him being attracted to my solution finding. I am just a decent human who offered a lift. It’s a simple as that.

OP posts:
YourFinestPantaloons · 25/11/2021 15:41

"I think it would be in everyone's best interest, especially your daughter's, that you just concentrated on being a dad to her right now - no distractions"

Eastridingclub · 25/11/2021 15:40

You're lovely, op.

I don't like the sound of him really. He left his little girl living with an alcoholic and couldn't get past himself last night when some getting on with things was needed. I think you'd have found him self absorbed and immature in the longer term

Tink1989 · 25/11/2021 15:38

@bubblesbubbles11

Ohnowhy2

"If I wasn’t there, no idea how he would of got there. Drive himself? but as he had a drink and taxis delayed I offered."

But by doing that you were offering to "save" him. And that type of dynamic so early on very rarely nurtures a new relationship.

As I say, I assume he is a grown adult man (he has a daughter and an ex so he must have been a functioning adult on some level for quite some time having an ex and a daughter old enough to threaten to harm herself). I would bet he has been in situations like this before and had to find a solution.

Maybe one of the things he was attracted to was the fact that he sensed you absolutely would be ready to change all plans and jump into a car with him for an unknown emergency at date 4.
And you have had something similar before.

Two questions
(1) Do you want the main thing he is attracted to about you is your ability to provide an immediate on the spot solution to a problem he would otherwise have had to solve himself?
(2) If you had been sympathetic and kinds but firm that he find his own way to A&E, do you think he would have contacted you the next day?

You are 110% within your right not to contact him again. And it sounds like you have done it kindly. But you probably know that there is a chance he is absolutely cringing that you saw all that unedited and his contact now is some desperate ungracious attempt to try to salvage something.

However as i say he was in the wrong too for accepting a lift from a potential romantic partner at date 4.

I don't understand why you are going so deep into this, OP offered to help like any decent person would, she subsequently is off put by all the drama and therefore wants to put a stop to things. I don't think it is any deeper than that and doesn't need to be psycho analysed

If more people acted like OP in the dating world and were upfront with how they felt then it would be a lot easier.

Gonnagetgoing · 25/11/2021 15:23

[quote Ohnowhy2]@Gonnagetgoing agree with you. 4th territory you are on best behaviours trying to see if you want another date. . He did say on date 1 he divorced his ex as she was an alcoholic but they are amicable for sake of child. I didn’t probe.

Understand that he had to tell me and I helped that night so understood situation. Just not appropriate to be the emotional crutch. He should of known that. If this happened 6 months down the line and was in a relationship, wouid support.[/quote]
@Ohnowhy2 - agree with all you say. Absolutely fine to state why he's divorced and the situation and equally fine and the right thing for you not to probe.

It's slightly better now you've mentioned he told you about the alcoholic ex on the first date but the unplanned drama and subsequent dragging of you into the drama (good of you to help) really wasn't on for a 4th date and he shouldn't have done that. Had he not dragged you into the drama you could've maybe given him another chance but now it's just too messy or has the potential to get too messy.

Agreed that 6 months down the line, and in a relationship with him would be the ideal time for you to support him

Ohnowhy2 · 25/11/2021 15:12

@Gonnagetgoing agree with you. 4th territory you are on best behaviours trying to see if you want another date. . He did say on date 1 he divorced his ex as she was an alcoholic but they are amicable for sake of child. I didn’t probe.

Understand that he had to tell me and I helped that night so understood situation. Just not appropriate to be the emotional crutch. He should of known that. If this happened 6 months down the line and was in a relationship, wouid support.

OP posts:
bubblesbubbles11 · 25/11/2021 15:11

Ohnowhy2

"If I wasn’t there, no idea how he would of got there. Drive himself? but as he had a drink and taxis delayed I offered."

But by doing that you were offering to "save" him. And that type of dynamic so early on very rarely nurtures a new relationship.

As I say, I assume he is a grown adult man (he has a daughter and an ex so he must have been a functioning adult on some level for quite some time having an ex and a daughter old enough to threaten to harm herself). I would bet he has been in situations like this before and had to find a solution.

Maybe one of the things he was attracted to was the fact that he sensed you absolutely would be ready to change all plans and jump into a car with him for an unknown emergency at date 4.
And you have had something similar before.

Two questions
(1) Do you want the main thing he is attracted to about you is your ability to provide an immediate on the spot solution to a problem he would otherwise have had to solve himself?
(2) If you had been sympathetic and kinds but firm that he find his own way to A&E, do you think he would have contacted you the next day?

You are 110% within your right not to contact him again. And it sounds like you have done it kindly. But you probably know that there is a chance he is absolutely cringing that you saw all that unedited and his contact now is some desperate ungracious attempt to try to salvage something.

However as i say he was in the wrong too for accepting a lift from a potential romantic partner at date 4.

Bettybantz · 25/11/2021 15:10

OP you sound very kind and level headed. It’s a good balance to strike.
I think you’ve done exactly the right thing, for yourself but also for his family.
I’ve had similar drama in my life and chosen not to date until things calm down. My kids need my full attention and a new partner would not need that level of angst.
Hopefully this chap will take a bit of time too. Good luck in your search!

Gonnagetgoing · 25/11/2021 15:00

Look - regardless of what’s happened most of us would run a mile at a drunk/alcoholic ex let alone a suicidal child in the mix too. I appreciate it’s not exactly first or second date territory but he should’ve said something before a 4th date at least. Sadly some men or women lack boundaries re bringing up this or seem to think another person they’re dating might want to be an emotional crutch when generally a lot of people really don’t want to get involved in such drama. That’s not being harsh, emotionally unkind or anything it’s just safeguarding yourself for not being an emotional cripple. (Not just my experiences, others too).

Ohnowhy2 · 25/11/2021 14:59

@bubblesbubbles11 it was killed when I found out his complicated life. As offering a lift, I stand by my decision. Regardless of friend or date, can’t let someone suffer when easy solution.

If I wasn’t there, no idea how he would of got there. Drive himself? but as he had a drink and taxis delayed I offered.

OP posts:
Yummypumpkin · 25/11/2021 14:54

Think the very first response on the thread from @Cocolapew nailed it.

Gonnagetgoing · 25/11/2021 14:53

@sonjadog

Maybe he does have friends and people to support him, but just there and then when it happened it was the OP who was beside him? I think anyone who meets someone at a moment where their life is in crisis and their emotions are high and announces that there is "too much drama" for them, is seriously lacking in empathy. You don't have to get involved, you don't have to stick around, but at least try to walk away without giving them a parting kick as you go.
@sonjadog - I actually disagree with you in your statement re someone is lacking in empathy if they’ve stated that there’s “too much drama for them” it’s not giving a kick or anything as OP has literally had this drama dumped on her 4 dates in, where she was getting to know and like the man. He could’ve told her sooner about his ex and OP could’ve made a decision whether to continue then based on that. OP is being fair and kind behaving how she’s done so far.
EmeraldShamrock · 25/11/2021 14:53

You've made the right decision.

Clymene · 25/11/2021 14:52

A few texts?

"I eventually managed to leave. But kept getting calls from him for support. I did say at 1am I need to sleep as work tomorrow."

"He has already called me to talk about the situation and in my opinion leaning heavily on me (4th date girl so a stranger) for support."

This is not a man who is boundaried. As the OP points out, she is a stranger.

bubblesbubbles11 · 25/11/2021 14:49

Ohnowhy2

Noted on your update.
So if you had not been on a date, how would he have got to A&E? Surely he would have some other means of getting there?

Look I am not trying to be antagonistic here, I just think sometimes new relationships have a better chance of working if you deliberately do not step early into a place of what a thoroughly decent and kind friend would do for someone.
Of course if it is a platonic friend (whose friendship you value) you might very well be very willing to drop everything and drive them to A&E.
If it is a brand new relationship where you are both still trying to show the best side of yourself to the other person, in some senses, sitting tight and not offering that lift might have been the better thing to do.
If he really liked you he would have found a way to get to A&E himself in whatever way (or been in touch with his ex in some other way) and would have let you have any relevant details later at a pace which gives a new relationship half a chance.

As it was you got the information out of him because he was visibly upset and then you offered to take him.
Not saying you were wrong, clearly you are a really decent person, but that kind of thing can kill something stone cold dead before it gets off the ground.
He is equally the cause of this tho by accepting your lift.

Gonnagetgoing · 25/11/2021 14:49

@bubblesbubbles11

Oh and also i agree with 1forAll74.

If it is absolutely the correct moral thing to expressly tell him she does not want to date him again, the do it face to face (as briefly as possible). Text is wrong.

@bubblesbubbles11 - after 4 dates OP is fine to dump by text, she doesn’t need to see him in person to dump. She owes him nothing!
EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 25/11/2021 14:48

I think the text you sent was perfect op and his reply was good so hopefully that's the end of it

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 25/11/2021 14:44

Read the thread- the OP sent a sensible text, he sent a sensible accepting reply. No drama here today.

sonjadog · 25/11/2021 14:43

Maybe he does have friends and people to support him, but just there and then when it happened it was the OP who was beside him? I think anyone who meets someone at a moment where their life is in crisis and their emotions are high and announces that there is "too much drama" for them, is seriously lacking in empathy. You don't have to get involved, you don't have to stick around, but at least try to walk away without giving them a parting kick as you go.

gannett · 25/11/2021 14:42

@ChargingBuck

He certainly can't help his ex's behaviour, or the A&E trip, which must have been appallingly stressful & frightening.

But he can help expecting a woman he has met just 4 times to become his 'emotional support human'. It's inappropriate, needy, & makes me wonder why he hasn't already got professional child therapists & his own good friends in place to support him.

A few texts on what sounds like an incredibly emotionally fraught night (where OP was the only person who he wouldn't have had to explain the situation to, as she was there) don't indicate a character flaw.

Entirely OP's right to remove herself from that sensitively and firmly, which she has done without assigning blame or negative character judgment on someone going through a shit time.

Kendoddsdadsdogsdadsdead · 25/11/2021 14:37

I didn't do a drama GCSE at school and I don't as a grown up

Oh my god - don't say this. Immature, cringey and mean.

Swipe left for the next trending thread