Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Thanksgiving

101 replies

1967buglet · 25/11/2021 01:46

I’m American, my partner is British, and we live in the UK. Tomorrow is Thanksgiving. For the past several years, we haven’t celebrated because we have had to work. Fair enough. This year, though I went part time as I am retiring soon, and I said can we make a day of it and can you book one day off from work. Yes, sure, he said.

Well, he took off Friday, not Thursday (Thanksgiving) as I thought he would. He said we could have a nice tea on Thursday night then, and then have a long weekend. I may have gotten some crossed signals about which day he took off, so OK, fair enough. The tea is steak and frites (nice), but I’d like to have done the traditional feast. However, when I have in the past, he picked at the turkey and then disapproved when I had leftovers later. He doesn’t eat leftovers…each meal must be made from scratch. So, this was another reason I stopped celebrating it, because he let me know he didn’t enjoy the turkey much. It was well prepared…his mum ate the lot off the plate. I brined it and went to some trouble to prepare it well because he told me he thought turkey was dry, so his reaction was a little frustrating.

I don’t go back to America very much (twice in past 15 years, once for my dad’s funeral, once for work) as I don’t have close family. I don’t do anything much reflective of my culture …. No Halloween celebration, no American sports (only cricket for him), Christmas dinner is British, we eat British food almost entirely. I cook the Christmas lunch British style for him and his mom…they usually want ham because they like the way I make it, so I’ll fix that for them with sprouts and the rest traditional British sides, with roast potatoes, Christmas pudding, etc. I might get a few American sweets at Christmas, like Hershey’s chocolate, but that’s about it, so I don’t make him do/eat anything American.

AIBU that I’d like DH to have a proper Thanksgiving meal with me once a year? I guess I’m figuring it is one day I can be American a little bit and do something I grew up with. I miss it.

OP posts:
PrincessNutella · 25/11/2021 03:15

I feel for you, OP. I am American and my husband has been dry brining a 22 pound turkey since Sunday, and we've got a full house of relatives coming with everybody bringing the same dishes they bring every year. I don't know if non-Americans can understand what it means to us, that it can be even more important than Christmas because--just because it is. I don't think you are being at all unreasonable to expect your husband, having married someone from another country, to celebrate a single holiday of her country once a year with her in a gracious and appreciative manner, OP. Sending a gravy boat of good thoughts your way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread