Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The first poster is the angriest or nastiest

59 replies

wobblywinelover · 25/11/2021 01:32

I know i've given the answer to the question already, but does anyone else find that on any mumsnet thread in response to a question however innocent it is there tends to be someone jumping in with a nasty judgemental unhelpful response.. like they were dying to see a thread they could be nasty on next kind of thing? It always seems to be on the first couple of responses. It's a pattern on here i've noticed. Then it tends to be a few neutral posters, then someone finally with a bit of empathy, a bit of to and fro which is normal. . There often seems to be a massive debate or argument about seemingly innocent things. Has anyone else noticed this? I'm expecting so many responses now saying i'm insecure, this is mumsnet etc, what did you expect, you are massively overthinking etc, the usual responses. Really weird I think

OP posts:
SimpsonsXmasBoogie · 25/11/2021 08:37

There are some very nasty people on here. However, there are also some really lovely people. I think MN has a diverse mix.

dropitlikeitsloth · 25/11/2021 08:34

I have noticed there is always a weird comment in the first few responses but I think that’s just due to averages and the amount of different personalities on here.

It might not be nasty but just contrary such as:

OP: I was just mowed down on the pavement by a cyclist.
Weird post: Cars injure more people than cyclists
Confused

This is so common on Twitter too. Like, ok yes but that’s not what we are discussing here, cycling on a pavement is illegal first of all you can’t compare it to a car driving legally on a road.

It’s like they’ve got such a bee in their bonnet about X issue (I.e cyclists Vs drivers) that they just trot out weird soundbytes. Anything to derail the discussion.

Like someone might respond, ‘cycling is good for the environment’ Hmm yeah ok… never mind some poor woman has got knocked down by an illegal cyclist but thank you for that weird ecological point. Cars weren’t even mentioned. It’s mad.

dropitlikeitsloth · 25/11/2021 08:29

@OhGiveUp

I've noticed that posters who post about struggling with something domestic related tend to get the most of the vitriol. For example... My DP is in hospital recovering from having both his legs amputated two days ago. We have 18 month old twins and I'm 7 months pregnant. I'm really struggling to keep on top of everything. I have no family or friends to help and I don't drive so it's a struggle to visit him on public transport with the kids. AIBU to just visit him twice a week?

The responses vary from
learn to drive,.
why did you have kids with this man?
Why did you have here kids, don't you care about the planet?
So he gets to lay in bed while you do everything, he's a selfish prick! Can't you ask someone to take you / look after the kids?
And of course...LTB.

Yes this!

The learn to drive thing especially annoys me, the issue is urgent and current issue but oh yes you can just have an hour lesson and be legal and then on your way. Grin I commented once that this might help OP in a years time and got a snarky response back saying I was nasty Confused

In fact this happens quite a bit, if you call someone out for being nasty it never ends well. I called out a poster for being really vicious once and then she was like dog with a bone, even to the point she’d follow me to another thread and hassled me there too. I ended up changing my name because I felt hounded. It’s no surprise though that rude people seem to generally have a victim mentality and dish it out but then can’t take it. It’s a shame MN don’t do anything about this.

Sorrynotsorry2 · 25/11/2021 08:22

People don't read the posts properly either.
An op can clearly state " please don't suggest xy and z "

First response. "Why don't you try zy and z"

Or "please don't suggest I ltb , I cant right now "

First response. " ltb"

MintyGreenDream · 25/11/2021 08:17

It wasn't the first poster but i commented on the dh beard thread the other day and told the tale of my df who got her exdh to wear a paper bag during sex as she hated the beard so much.
"That didn't happen" was the reply from a charming poster.Yes it fucking did actually.People are too nasty and suspicious on here sometimes .

Platax · 25/11/2021 08:15

@FreeBritnee

Someone wrote once Thant the first poster sets the tone for all other replies. I thought that was very well observed.
Yes, but you can turn it round. People tend to be like sheep, but if one or two brave souls put their heads above the parapet and disagree, others start to follow them. As they're usually the ones who have managed to read the OP properly and think it through, with any luck they prevail because the hostile types are so illogical.
UselessASD · 25/11/2021 08:13

I agree about the tone being set in the first few threads. I sometimes feel like linking another thread with the same question but a completely opposite response.

Also a derail can happen pretty fast into spelling/grammar, an argument between two posters or nitpicking on a word OP used.

Mostly I think it’s pretty harmless, but hate a pile on of someone that is obviously struggling badly (whether or not others would cope with their 2 year old, friend problem or neighbours)

Platax · 25/11/2021 08:10

Yes, you're right. It's particularly bad at night time, I don't know if it's because they know MN won't be watching so closely or it's just people feeling bored on night duty or bad-tempered because they can't sleep.

thepeopleversuswork · 25/11/2021 08:06

@OhGiveUp

I've noticed that posters who post about struggling with something domestic related tend to get the most of the vitriol. For example... My DP is in hospital recovering from having both his legs amputated two days ago. We have 18 month old twins and I'm 7 months pregnant. I'm really struggling to keep on top of everything. I have no family or friends to help and I don't drive so it's a struggle to visit him on public transport with the kids. AIBU to just visit him twice a week?

The responses vary from
learn to drive,.
why did you have kids with this man?
Why did you have here kids, don't you care about the planet?
So he gets to lay in bed while you do everything, he's a selfish prick! Can't you ask someone to take you / look after the kids?
And of course...LTB.

I think the LTB thing is quite specific: a lot of women on MN have been through abusive or generally bad relationships and find it frustrating and a bit triggering to hear other women making excuses for and tiptoeing around shit, no mark men because they haven't reached the inevitable conclusion, which is that they just need to be binned.

It's a bit like watching a pantomime and wanting to shout "It's behind you!". We all know its heading towards LTB except the poster, who is still blinded by romance, and we just want to speed things up towards the inevitable conclusion.

Sometimes that is brusque but it comes from a good (and usually correct) place. Nine times out of ten when people say LTB they are right.

Why did you have kids with this man? on the other hand, is really horrible. It's a stealth way of saying "I'm more attractive/smarter than you and I was better at ensnaring a proper, high quality man".

AuntieStella · 25/11/2021 08:05

We used to have a 'you're all bitches' troll.

Not saying that OP isna reincarnation, but there was a definite agenda then to stop women being frank. We were meant to be nice and kind all the time.

I think it would be utterly wrong if MN went in that direction. Women absolutely need an escape from the perpetual pressure to be nice.

If you think a poster has gone too far, then take it up on the thread in question. If it's gone far too far, the report it.

But denigrating MN, or rather a few unspecified posts on MN, also goes too far. And we know from history that there is at least one troll who gets off on this sort of thing, and probably many others who enjoy seeing women limit their range of expression

PicassoInAtoolbox · 25/11/2021 08:03

I rarely if ever start a thread these days, unless it's on a totally non emotional issue like quilting or something. I started a couple of threads in the past and some of the posters really put the boot in. It was so bizarre, like a sport; they twisted things, misrepresented what I'd said and filled in the gaps with their own made up narrative. Then if you try to put them straight you're "drip feeding". And yes, it was as you observed OP, in the first few replies, then some balance was restored. one poster even claimed someone who posted supporting me was actually me with a name change - more proof of how weird I am. They did eventually apologise to the other poster, but not to me.

TulipCat · 25/11/2021 08:03

It's really irritating when people jump in with their criticism without reading the OP. Prime examples are with children's school years, eg "I am preparing my Year 5 son for 11+ exams. He does half an hour a day, is that about right?" and someone immediately jumps in with "He is 5 years old FGS, how dare you pressure such a young child" 🤦‍♀️

OhGiveUp · 25/11/2021 07:59

I've noticed that posters who post about struggling with something domestic related tend to get the most of the vitriol.
For example...
My DP is in hospital recovering from having both his legs amputated two days ago.
We have 18 month old twins and I'm 7 months pregnant. I'm really struggling to keep on top of everything. I have no family or friends to help and I don't drive so it's a struggle to visit him on public transport with the kids. AIBU to just visit him twice a week?

The responses vary from
learn to drive,.
why did you have kids with this man?
Why did you have here kids, don't you care about the planet?
So he gets to lay in bed while you do everything, he's a selfish prick! Can't you ask someone to take you / look after the kids?
And of course...LTB.

cherrytree63 · 25/11/2021 07:53

Yes I've seen it a lot. And also the Chinese whispers evolution, one poster completely misinterprets something from the OP, then the following posters add there bit on, until it goes from OP "my neighbour puts her rubbish in my bin" to "you should let her and stop moaning" to "buy her a spa day" to "I think you should leave your husband so he can be happy".

thepeopleversuswork · 25/11/2021 07:53

@TroysMammy

Yes, usually the first reply is "you don't seem to like them much". Probably making the OP feel bad because they dared to use an anonymous online forum to get their head around someone's disagreeable behaviours and not necessarily the person.
Yes this.

Also "she's not a friend", whenever there's any evidence of any disagreement with a friend.

ie

OP: "my friend hasn't responded to a text message from two days ago and I've got the hump about it."

MN: "She's not your friend. Block, deleted, move on."

It's so melodramatically hardline its ridiculous. All of my friendships would have died a death by now if I had to cancel people because they were late responding to a text message.

TheViewFromTheCheapSeats · 25/11/2021 07:49

What gets me possibly more is the disregard for any basic level of reading comprehension. I feel like I’m trapped in a year 2 class at times, where the children have not developed the ability yet to interpret what they read but magically have the ability to write at length. It’s deliberate, a disregard for the need to focus on any details, as otherwise the posters have perfectly normal literacy skills.

I had a post recently where someone went on and on criticising post after post and then admitted they had misunderstood wildly. Every other poster found it easy to grasp, it was written pretty plainly, yet in their eagerness to criticise and get annoyed they’d just imagined an entirely new situation.

It just really bugs me the reactions when the OP over and over explains the same basic things whilst angry posters make up unrelated posts. Eg ‘my son has never been in trouble at school before’, cue a million posts about how no one can learn around him with his constant behaviour problems and the school is justified in coming down hard on persistent behaviour issues like his.

Rummikub · 25/11/2021 07:47

@FreeBritnee

Someone wrote once Thant the first poster sets the tone for all other replies. I thought that was very well observed.
Yes I agree with this.

And posters that don’t read the thread..

JustLyra · 25/11/2021 07:45

@MarbleQueen

I think some people are so eager to be horrible they don’t even bother reading things properly.
This is so true.

There’s one poster in particular (they were downright nasty in a thread I posted a couple of years ago so I tend to notice their posts) who I’ve seen say almost the exact opposite on two very, very similar threads. Both times they were putting the boot into the OP.
I’m pretty sure if someone posted saying “It’s Thursday today” they’d find a way to disagree and have a pop.

Silvercatowner · 25/11/2021 07:38

@FreeBritnee

Someone wrote once Thant the first poster sets the tone for all other replies. I thought that was very well observed.
Yes I've noticed this time and time again. And then another poster will come along commenting "I think you are getting a hard time OP".
dontwannasaymyjob · 25/11/2021 07:32

Hehe!
I don't think it's the first person as that's about timing when the thread shows up to who sees it. Some first replies are really supportive. It comes in waves as someone else may post and turn the tide.

It does set the tone, but you're right- there's always someone mean who can't wait to nitpick misinterpret and be vicious to OP. I wonder if it is an outlet for them, what they can't say to the people they're really angry with (for different reasons) in real life? Or they're just horrid personalities with a nasty side.

It's sad as it puts people off posting or chases OP away from their own thread. When most of MN are lovely and supportive and offer so much help and peer support.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 25/11/2021 07:25

I was really hoping the first reply on this thread would be 'No, they fucking aren't. What a fucking stupid thing to say!' or similar Grin.

I don't think it's always the first poster but I agree that on any popular thread, sooner or later a goady or angry type pops up.

TroysMammy · 25/11/2021 07:24

Yes, usually the first reply is "you don't seem to like them much". Probably making the OP feel bad because they dared to use an anonymous online forum to get their head around someone's disagreeable behaviours and not necessarily the person.

ineedsun · 25/11/2021 07:23

Aww, am I the only person who expected to open this thread and see the first response being totally OTT angry and nasty as a joke?

SusannaQueen · 25/11/2021 07:16

I tend to think there's almost a consensus that follows after the first reply. If the first reply is negative others then pile on and stick the boot in. But the same query could be posted another day and if the first post is helpful, others will be too, then the occasional spiteful reply gets buried.
Sometimes people almost seem to make up what they've read in the original post, I'm sure there are people who do this deliberately.

Meatshake · 25/11/2021 07:16

Or they'll latch on to something irrelevant and do a deconstruction of the poster's grammar and idioms and colloquialisms and end up with a comment like...

"Umm you said KIDS instead of children. Who does that? That's so weird. Is it a working class thing? I bet you're working class OP. Amirite, guys? I bet she doesn't even shop at Waitrose!"