Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The first poster is the angriest or nastiest

59 replies

wobblywinelover · 25/11/2021 01:32

I know i've given the answer to the question already, but does anyone else find that on any mumsnet thread in response to a question however innocent it is there tends to be someone jumping in with a nasty judgemental unhelpful response.. like they were dying to see a thread they could be nasty on next kind of thing? It always seems to be on the first couple of responses. It's a pattern on here i've noticed. Then it tends to be a few neutral posters, then someone finally with a bit of empathy, a bit of to and fro which is normal. . There often seems to be a massive debate or argument about seemingly innocent things. Has anyone else noticed this? I'm expecting so many responses now saying i'm insecure, this is mumsnet etc, what did you expect, you are massively overthinking etc, the usual responses. Really weird I think

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NeverDropYourMooncup · 25/11/2021 18:49

@Sorrynotsorry2

People don't read the posts properly either. An op can clearly state " please don't suggest xy and z "

First response. "Why don't you try zy and z"

Or "please don't suggest I ltb , I cant right now "

First response. " ltb"

For the second category of threads, that's invariably because the OP has just described her boyfriend abusing her children and she only wants to hear 'Oh, he's just misunderstood, of course you're right to want to stay with him, it'll all work out and you'll live happily ever after when baby number 4 arrives, it's not as if cocaine is any worse than a cup of coffee, all my MC friends do lines on a Saturday night as part of winding down from our north of £100k jobs'.
BoredZelda · 25/11/2021 18:27

I always think the posters who are judgemental and unkind must be either doing it on purpose for the laugh or they are in some kind of unhappy situation for them to be so narrow minded and thoughtless.

Oh the irony.

Magicalwoodlands · 25/11/2021 12:43

It’s true, and I think @Pheasantlysurprised has perhaps surmised why.

The Chinese whispers thing is so true as well. I’ve actually nodded along with a lot of this thread. My feeling is that MNHQ should do a lot more to quell it. More often than not, if a thread is too nasty, they just pull the lot.

WellLarDeDar · 25/11/2021 12:38

I think you're right OP, there are MN users that come on here deliberately to be as nasty as possible because there's not really any consequences in their really lives. There are some really really nasty people on here. I've seen a lot of users twisting other people's words to turn relatively sane statements into really awful narratives.

smellyolebum · 25/11/2021 12:34

Love the ones that say "Why are you posting on an internet forum"

2Gen · 25/11/2021 12:18

I've noticed this too since I've started going on MN! I've lost count of the amount of times I've thought " Haven't you READ the feckin' post?"
The world is full of those who like to put others down though, so it's no surprise, just a sobering reminder that not everyone has good intentions nor a kind heart!

BigYellowHat · 25/11/2021 11:56

A YANBU thread will generally be solved by the first poster. This is mostly because 15 pages in most people haven’t even read most of it and are just going with the majority 😂

Pheasantlysurprised · 25/11/2021 11:50

and dont forget tho 'crew' who follow on to defend it.

excusing it with gusto because everyone else is too woke or over sensitive. classic bully trash.

Pheasantlysurprised · 25/11/2021 11:49

i think there are some very lonely people, possibly undergoing an existential crisis, a loss of confidence, wfh and bored out of their tits.

they hover in the wings waiting for new threads so that they can flex their necks out with sharp little put-downs that possibly allow them a brief, if anticlimactic sense of relevance in a world which confuses and often shuns them.

percythewitch · 25/11/2021 11:45

Also, a lot of "angry" or "nasty" responses are nothing of the sort - they're just a straight answer to the situation. Sometimes posters don't want to hear the truth.

Spot on. Then you get people coming on and urging you to "be kind".

DaisyandSimeon · 25/11/2021 11:43

You are so right!

Skysblue · 25/11/2021 11:40

There are a looooooot of trolls on Mumsnet

I reckon actual mums are in the minority

Our local mums Facebook group has a recurring problem with teenage boys joining under fake profilea because they think it’s hilarious to wind up mums. Probably something similar here…

HarrietsChariot · 25/11/2021 10:13

It's often quicker to fire off a harsh response. If you've read the OP and they've missed some obviously crucial information, or the solution is clear, or they are being hypocritical, why not jump in and say so?

If the problem is more complex or you are concerned for the OP's state of mind it needs a more carefully considered reply. This takes longer than answering "My neighbour wants me to stop blocking them in on their drive but I only do it when my DH's car is already on our drive so I can't park there. AIBU?"

Also, a lot of "angry" or "nasty" responses are nothing of the sort - they're just a straight answer to the situation. Sometimes posters don't want to hear the truth.

dropitlikeitsloth · 25/11/2021 10:08

I have literally posted on a thread about ‘dated fashion’ that if I saw someone wearing 70s clothes I’d think they were cool as I like 70s fashion and someone has already responded saying they don’t believe me 🤣🤣🤣 Do I just attract these people?!

Marvellousmadness · 25/11/2021 10:05

It's really irritating when people jump in with their criticism without reading the OP. Prime examples are with children's school years, eg "I am preparing my Year 5 son for 11+ exams. He does half an hour a day, is that about right?" and someone immediately jumps in with "He is 5 years old FGS, how dare you pressure such a young child" 🤦‍♀️

@TulipCat
I understand why, because the "year 1/2/3/4/5/6 "system is not used in a lot of other countries outside the UK. A lot of countries use terms like "grade" or "group".

So that makes the term "my year 5 kid" sound like a kid that is 5 years old 😅 (to a non UK/aussie person I mean) hence the confusion.

wobblywinelover · 25/11/2021 09:25

@Chasingaftermidnight

I’ve noticed the same, and I think it’s probably not a coincidence - I think there’s a type of poster who spends a lot of their time constantly refreshing AIBU in order to get gratification from posting their next nasty response (which is why they’re usually first). Then more normal people turn up.
This has crossed my mind too, I think you're right
OP posts:
vodkaredbullgirl · 25/11/2021 09:13
Hmm
Tal45 · 25/11/2021 09:13

I find people are like sheep, if the first post totally disagrees with the OP and lays into them then there will be lots more following aggressively taking the same view (even if unreasonable). It's like that first post gives everyone else permission to lay into the OP and nobody really cares who's right or wrong as long as they can get their dig in.

whatstobecomeofus · 25/11/2021 09:06

There are some right tricky people on here who seize upon the most innocuous element in a thread and then beat you to death with it. I honestly don't know what their thinking is. Why bother? You can challenge people without being downright nasty and perverse.

ineedsun · 25/11/2021 08:59

@ArblemarchTFruitbat

I was really hoping the first reply on this thread would be 'No, they fucking aren't. What a fucking stupid thing to say!' or similar Grin.

I don't think it's always the first poster but I agree that on any popular thread, sooner or later a goady or angry type pops up.

Not just me then 😂😂
dropitlikeitsloth · 25/11/2021 08:57

I also hate the obsession with ‘drip feeding’. Like if you don’t give every single detail that could possibly be seen as related to the situation (plus several paragraphs that have nothing to do with it but just in case) in the first post, and have to add or clarify something later, then you’re dripfeeding/ clearly lying. That’s just not how conversations work though!

Oh my gosh yes! Imagine you’re meeting someone for the first time and you didn’t give your life story and then next time you meet up you tell them something else and you’re accused of drip feeding/lying. So weird 🤣

Chasingaftermidnight · 25/11/2021 08:57

Why did you have kids with this man? on the other hand, is really horrible. It's a stealth way of saying "I'm more attractive/smarter than you and I was better at ensnaring a proper, high quality man".

I hate that response for the same reason. It’s also pure misogyny because a) it blames women for male behaviour and b) ignores that realities that women are under time pressure to have kids and abusive men often don’t show their true colours until after kids arrive.

Plus it’s not a useful comment - it’s not as if the OP can hop in a time machine!

Chasingaftermidnight · 25/11/2021 08:53

I’ve noticed the same, and I think it’s probably not a coincidence - I think there’s a type of poster who spends a lot of their time constantly refreshing AIBU in order to get gratification from posting their next nasty response (which is why they’re usually first). Then more normal people turn up.

AliasGrape · 25/11/2021 08:52

I hate the replies that make out like the OP is impossible to understand or just so so weird and out there when, with just the tiniest bit of reading comprehension/ emotional intelligence it’s clear what is going on. There was one recently where the OP clearly had a very abusive family background (said as much) and indications were her husband was either using it against her to make her feel shit or maybe going the same way - honestly did not take any kind of genius code breaker to work that out - cue post after post of ‘what?!!! Lol that’s so weird I can’t even understand what you’re saying lol lol that’s such a weird post, like I couldn’t even BEGIN to understand it hahahahaha’ - ok so you don’t understand it - so either ask questions to clarify or just move the fuck on rather than making a poster talking about very difficult things feel even worse.

I also hate the obsession with ‘drip feeding’. Like if you don’t give every single detail that could possibly be seen as related to the situation (plus several paragraphs that have nothing to do with it but just in case) in the first post, and have to add or clarify something later, then you’re dripfeeding/ clearly lying. That’s just not how conversations work though! And it leads to lots of unnecessary long and detailed OPs that then get met with ‘too long didn’t read’, ‘I couldn’t possibly get through that massive wall of text OP but you sound obsessed/controlling’

PureBlackVoid · 25/11/2021 08:37

The ones that piss me off the most, are the ones that come back later and post the ingenuous, gaslight-y ‘who do you think has been nasty on the thread, OPConfused?’ when the OP questions it.

It really annoys me more than it should, because although the nasty posts don’t clearly call the OP a dick/pathetic/whatever else in black and white, you can quite clearly sense the tone. Especially when you see the username.

Swipe left for the next trending thread