Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think seclusion is a ridiculous behaviour management policy?

187 replies

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:29

Now I know In some circumstances it's necessary, but as a general behaviour management tool it's awful.
DS is in yr7. He unfortunately had his first experience of seclusion today after being involved in an incident last week. No fights, malicious behaviour etc, just some silliness that went too far. Now I totally accept that he should be sanctioned and take his punishment.
But a whole day in a room with just a work sheet to fill in, missing 7 lessons including a graded test?
Why not just send them to the seclusion room at breaks/ for lunch for example? For DS, it's not part or a pattern of behaviour or an escalation. So a whole day of education missed for what?
Yes of course I'm hoping it will help him realise what is not acceptable behaviour so will behave better in future.
But really? Surely there's a better way than this unless its the only option left?
Help me accept this is the way it is at secondary please!

OP posts:
doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 23:34

@HereBeFuckery you have to trust me that I did not respond like that when the teacher called me!

OP posts:
Peaseblossum22 · 24/11/2021 23:34

@Clymene

He missed a day of learning? Good! You're disappointed and it's impacted him. That's what a punishment should do.
I genuinely don’t understand this. In my day you would have been given extra work not less work as a punishment. Being made to do nothing for a day is just weird .
FinallyHere · 24/11/2021 23:33

I genuinely don't think in this case the punishment doesn't fit the crime.
You'll just have to take my word for it, butt if I'm sure most won't!

Wasn't it Mandy Rice-Davies who said 'well, they would say that, wouldn't they '

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 23:31

@Confusedteacher

And by the way, “silliness” for a Y7 is telling fart jokes or stealing someone’s pencil case. What your son did was dangerous and I hope you have told him that.
Oh yes believe me we have. We've made it crystal clear. Believe me, much as I hate this sanctions im also very very disappointed with his behaviour too
OP posts:
Clymene · 24/11/2021 23:30

He missed a day of learning? Good! You're disappointed and it's impacted him. That's what a punishment should do.

HereBeFuckery · 24/11/2021 23:29

I'm a secondary teacher. Today after school I made five calls home to parents, all of Y7 students, all in one class - of the five classes I've taught today - and that's quite a light day for calling home for me.

We lost 50% of our lesson today to the behaviour of those students. That's not an exaggeration, btw, we had eight slides of material to cover, we just about finished four. Due to 'silliness'.

Wandering around the classroom, chatting, shouting out random things/insults, shouting answers when another student was trying to answer and I was trying to support them, throwing empty bottles around while I was trying to write on the board, waiting until I gave a warning that we were nearly at the end of a task to declare 'I don't have a pen Miss' and then turn to smirk at friends. Nothing major. All silliness. 50% of my time wasted entirely. 50% of my students time, wasted entirely. Through silliness.

I had the following replies from parents:
'Are you sure, that doesn't sound like my child?'
'My child is very grumpy at the end of the day, they can't help it.'
'I will check they are okay after you told them off then. They will be upset, I hope you are pleased about that.'
'I am sorry, that is bad, I will speak to my child.'
And one parent whose English was too broken to have a conversation with.

Do I think it's fair on the 24 students who behaved well and worked hard, that five pupils thought 'it's just silliness, what does it matter?' No. I think it's fundamentally flawed thinking.

Do I think those 24 students should have their learning obstructed by students who have not yet learned acceptable social behaviours and cannot control themselves in a secondary school classroom? No.

Do I think that those 24 students should be subjected to that behaviour, and have it repeated lesson after lesson after lesson? No.

Can those 24 students make up the missed lesson time? No. The school day is not elastic.

So, yes, if 'silliness' has an impact on others - and it does - then yes, I think it should be treated as seriously as physical or verbal bullying, and should be given an appropriate sanction.

This is every day. Very little behaviour I see is dangerous, almost all is 'silliness' and as a result, I encounter students in y11 with a pre-secondary reading age, students who cannot write effectively enough to be legible, students who consistently do not even attempt exam questions because they have not learned any skills with which to approach the task.

Were my school's behaviour policy to allow it, would I have excluded those five students to seclusion? In a heartbeat. They are behaving in a way which shows they are not in a place to learn. I need to focus my energies on those who are. I cannot force them to stop 'being silly'. Believe me, I have tried. I keep on trying. I am not with those children at home, I do not have time in lessons to explicitly teach basic manners, respect, how to interact with others in an acceptable way. I am not the parent of those children. All I can do is work with those who do want to learn. That's my job, and I'm trying to do it.

Treat this as a wake up call. YOU can make a change here for your child. Please please please do not underplay this, do not 'take your child's side' and sympathise with them about how mean the teacher is. Please give your child a fighting chance of a decent education.

P.s. Bet you can't guess what face I was making during three of those calls...

Clymene · 24/11/2021 23:29

It strikes me he's going to learn that physical assault is not acceptable at secondary school. I think that's probably a good thing.

Look, he might be a weedy 11 year old now but believe me, weedy 11 year olds grow into strapping 13 year olds in the blink of an eye. And physical stuff post the age of criminal responsibility is no longer childish larks. He needs to learn not to join in, to think, to know when to not follow the crowd.

It's a harsh lesson now which will hopefully avoid a much worse one later.

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 23:28

@JurgensCakeBaby

Also who was the target of the bundle? Would you be ok if that had been your son?
No, and I'm really not condoning his behaviour. He knows we're all really disappointed with him and that his behaviour was reckless. I support him being disciplined for it. I honestly do. The problem with the seclusion is not thar he's had a day of "sensory deprivation" so to speak, it's that he's missed a day of learning. Take away his breaks for a week, stop him from going to sports clubs for a week or whatever. Make him sit on his own at the back of the class.
OP posts:
JurgensCakeBaby · 24/11/2021 23:24

@MichelleScarn there was a phase of this at my school which was essentially boys all rushing each other or targeting Anne poor unsuspecting kid in the same way, yelling bundle and then all diving on top of the first one to fall. It culminated in the incident I described above with one of the year 7 girls getting caught in the middle and being injured. There were suspensions at my school for that and one boy got expelled but for him it was the draw that broke the camels back I can't even remember how many times he'd had internal exclusion and suspension by that point in year nine.

Confusedteacher · 24/11/2021 23:23

And by the way, “silliness” for a Y7 is telling fart jokes or stealing someone’s pencil case. What your son did was dangerous and I hope you have told him that.

MichelleScarn · 24/11/2021 23:23

Ah, what we'd call a 'pile-on' bloody stupid and could end up with really bad injuries.

ThuMuClu · 24/11/2021 23:22

arguments !!

ThuMuClu · 24/11/2021 23:22

I know there are objections to internal exclusion as a principle, and a regiments for and against but in a school where it is used, your son’s actions would warrant it. They have low tolerance for anything physical in my sons school so in this case it is something your DS just needs to take the lesson from.

JurgensCakeBaby · 24/11/2021 23:21

Also who was the target of the bundle? Would you be ok if that had been your son?

Confusedteacher · 24/11/2021 23:21

So this is where they all pile on top of each other, right? Which could be frankly terrifying for some and very dangerous. It sounds like they are trying to stamp down on dangerous behaviour in the playground and making an example of this group of kids. I think it’s a fair punishment tbh. It’s one day, and he won’t do it again!

JurgensCakeBaby · 24/11/2021 23:20

A girl at my secondary school had her head gashed open and needed stitches following a 'bundle'. What he did wasn't just silly it was dangerous, you need to be making that clear to him. There's a reason the punishment was as it was, to send a very clear message to all involved and other students, that kind of behaviour is not acceptable.

MichelleScarn · 24/11/2021 23:20

So according to DS, and the teacher that spoke to me, he was part of a group that did a "bundle" in the playground
I.have no idea what that is so looked it up, urban dictionary says 'a bag of heroin' Shock
Am assuming not!

starrynight21 · 24/11/2021 23:16

My son went into seclusion once, and it was for really bad, disruptive behaviour which was causing the other kids distress.

If this is what your son was doing ( and in FIVE posts you still haven't said), then yes he needed to be in seclusion.

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 23:15

So according to DS, and the teacher that spoke to me, he was part of a group that did a "bundle" in the playground. (According to the teacher) he wasn't the ringleader, no one got hurt. The teacher used the word "silliness". that he got caught up in.
It seems to be the risk of what could have happened that got him into so much trouble.
DS says these things happen in the playground all the time, but it's the first time the teachers have come down on those involved.
DS tells me (now I know he could be lying) that no he's not usually involved in them.
So yes it was a stupid thing where someone could have got hurt, not constant low level disruption or bad behaviour.
DS was really stupid to get involved, he knows that now.
But I still think missing a day of education was not a useful.

OP posts:
Confusedteacher · 24/11/2021 23:00

I also know the same behaviour in year 6 would have been a quick chat with a parent after school.

I am a secondary teacher, and I am not condoning this necessarily as I have worked in schools where I do think the behaviour policy is overly harsh. However, you realise a “quick chat with the parents after school” doesn’t happen in secondary, right? I see over 300 kids a week! There needs to be a system in place that is seen to be fair to everyone- we don’t do cosy chats at the classroom door!

Nootkah · 24/11/2021 23:00

@doggieflooflove Im generally against isolation as anything other than a last resort. However, unless you explain what he did, its impossible to say. Being disruptive throughout all lessons in a day isnt "low level silliness", its seriously disruptive and disrespectful. At my sons secondary, theres a warn, move (within the classroom), remove (to seclusion, for the duration of that lesson only). To miss a full day the behaviour would have to have continued after the initial short seclusion.

WHAT DID YOUR SON DO?

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:59

@coffeerevelsrock

Well if you won't explain what he did I'm not sure how you expect people to agree or disagree that the punishment was ridiculous. If you're saying it's a ridiculous punishment in all circumstances, are you actually saying that you think disruptive students should always remain in lessons, even if they're wrecking them?
And that's exactly what I didn't say in my OP. I can see how it could be needed.
OP posts:
doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:58

@whatstobecomeofus

Perhaps he'll learn to behave in the future then. Let this be a lesson to him.
I really hope so. It's exactly what I've said to him.
OP posts:
whatstobecomeofus · 24/11/2021 22:57

Perhaps he'll learn to behave in the future then. Let this be a lesson to him.

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:54

@Frazzled50yrold

Presumably the exclusion policy is explained to them so he knew what the implications of his behaviour would be.
He's gutted He's only just turned 11, he's trying really hard. Clearly he had a really bad day. But he's also struggling to see how what he's been told warranted thee we sanctioned fits in with what his perception. Now that's not why I'm cross. Of course an 11yo is going to say "no note sir". I'm not stupid. I also know the same behaviour in year 6 would have been a quick chat with a parent after school. Which I honestly never had.
OP posts: