Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think seclusion is a ridiculous behaviour management policy?

187 replies

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:29

Now I know In some circumstances it's necessary, but as a general behaviour management tool it's awful.
DS is in yr7. He unfortunately had his first experience of seclusion today after being involved in an incident last week. No fights, malicious behaviour etc, just some silliness that went too far. Now I totally accept that he should be sanctioned and take his punishment.
But a whole day in a room with just a work sheet to fill in, missing 7 lessons including a graded test?
Why not just send them to the seclusion room at breaks/ for lunch for example? For DS, it's not part or a pattern of behaviour or an escalation. So a whole day of education missed for what?
Yes of course I'm hoping it will help him realise what is not acceptable behaviour so will behave better in future.
But really? Surely there's a better way than this unless its the only option left?
Help me accept this is the way it is at secondary please!

OP posts:
videobaby123 · 25/11/2021 07:39

Kids will be kids tbh. People in the comments act like he's a grown man who purposely tried to hurt someone. Kids always do dumb stuff that results in consequences.

Seclusion is one of them and it isn't going to kill him. He was there for a day not multiple days/one week. It may seem extreme but not being able to walk to lessons with your friends in the corridor or not being able to have lunch with them is shit at that age.
I'm sure he'll think twice before doing anything silly again

DrSbaitso · 25/11/2021 07:35

It seems to be the risk of whatcouldhave happened that got him into so much trouble.

Yes, sounds about right to me.

wavingwhilstdrowning · 25/11/2021 07:34

you are only thinking about your son here, his loss of learning, his isolation. What about the other hard working children in the class who are sick of 'silliness' and 'high spirited behaviour'?

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2021 07:33

In general it does sound like seclusion is used a lot by schools these days. I only remember it being used for serious incidents and it was called internal suspension. Did the authorities tell schools they had to limit how many kids got suspended so they just came up with another name?
It's used more because schools have correctly identified that learning can be disruption for all by a range of persistent behaviour that is a lower level than a serious incident.

At my school before a student is removed from a lesson:

  1. Informal warning
  2. First formal warning
  3. Second formal warning and a move of seat or spoken to out the room
  4. Moved to another classroom close by
  5. Removed by behaviour team

If 1 student does that 5 lessons a day then that 1 child has disrupted learning 25 times. If your child is in a class with 4 students doing that, their learning could be interrupted 100 times in one lesson. That's a lot of learning time taken up dealing with what someone people say is low level or silly behaviour.

Our school set trigger points for going into central detention and isolation because lesson disruption is considered a problem. We generally have very calm lessons.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2021 07:25

He was part of a dangerous physical altercation and the sort of thing that can unsettle classes for the day whilst those involved go into classes and repeatedly discuss how funny it was. The school have shown they don't tolerate dangerous physical behaviour. Your son will learn.

Isolation rooms have high sided desks that are rather similar to some of the study spaces in my university library. It's not sensory deprivation to sit at a desk and work independently, and that kind of hyperbole makes it harder to establish where there are very real concerns about settings.

maddy68 · 25/11/2021 07:17

Teacher here. It works. They hate being away from their friends

I'd love some of these parents to spend a day in a school managing behaviour.

One person's silliness is disrupting anothers education

Thatsplentyjack · 25/11/2021 07:12

No, OP I agree, that incident doesn't warrant seclusion for an entire day. That's ridiculous.

angstridden2 · 25/11/2021 07:09

Re the possibility of going into isolation being a’cry for help’, possibly true in a few cases but in this one being part of a bundle seems unlikely to say the least.

DeepaBeesKit · 25/11/2021 07:06

Schools use isolation because there are plenty of teens who care about little except their friends, separating them from them can be one of the only consequences they actually pay attention to.

Bigassbeebuzzbuzz · 25/11/2021 06:51

I think schools are often too quick to isolate pupils and often dont look at the reasons behind it.
I use myself as an example I used to actively try to get put isolation because the bullying was that bad so I was able to get away from it there. I'm not saying its every child but sometimes it is a cry for help.

Mosschopz · 25/11/2021 06:50

I don’t know what you’re trying to gain by asking everyone if YBU or not. Some will say yes, some no. Do you plan to take this thread to the head and complain? Or ask for recommendations on schools which support your views?

MoreAloneTime · 25/11/2021 06:47

We always had the odd bundle in my day but is it happening too much at your son's school? Are they trying to stamp it out with harsh sanctions

In general it does sound like seclusion is used a lot by schools these days. I only remember it being used for serious incidents and it was called internal suspension. Did the authorities tell schools they had to limit how many kids got suspended so they just came up with another name?

PaulaTrilloe · 25/11/2021 06:40

Ancient history here but I remember being put in isolation when I was 13-14 due to being bullied. I would come to school late and leave early to minimise risk of being beaten up or attacked on way to/from school. I just got on with my work in the head teachers office and as an introvert I quite liked the quiet calm safe space. My classroom usually had disruption and kids chucking chairs and shouting it was like a prison under siege

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 25/11/2021 06:35

They are not denied a day of education nor do they suffer sensory deprivation in an isolation room at school ffs.

He would have spent the day independently learning. Most likely the same work he would have been doing in class.

coffeerevelsrock · 25/11/2021 06:15

@AledsiPad

Absolutely nowhere in real life, bar prison, isolates human beings and denies them education for poor choices. Least of all ones who are children - 11 ffs - and still learning.

Seclusion is a fucking awful way of ‘behaviour management’ and a sign of a school that is failing at a base level to understand their children.

I despise it. I despise most things about secondary school in this country to be honest. It absolutely fails to set children up for college/university/life.

Please tell me that either you don't have children or you do and they are being home-schooled.

It's amazing isn't it, given how crap schools are, that the vast majority of people who go to college and uni are successful there and arrive at them having been through the school system. I'll bet most of those who do fail have had parents backing them up and stepping in to 'protect' them whenever school tried to instil some discipline or respect for rules.

doggieflooflove · 25/11/2021 01:01

@Charmatt

Presumably by sending him to school you are accepting the behaviour policy. If you don't like it, move him.

He's learnt from it - if he has anything about him, his behaviour will change!

If there was a school available to us that didn't use isolation as part of its behaviour policy, then it would have been high up on my list. But they all do so it's really an illusion of choice, not me actively choosing a school because it has that policy. Two local schools were discounted by me because isolation appeared to be their go-to management strategy and all sign of dissent however small is jumped upon. That's not an environment I want for my child. Nor do I want him to get away with bad behaviour. But no one will convince me that seclusion is the right sanction other than in certain appropriate circumstances. We will have to suck this up and hope that he doesn't mess up and end up there again. I'm hoping it's the metaphorical firework up his arse. We shall see.
OP posts:
Charmatt · 24/11/2021 23:51

Presumably by sending him to school you are accepting the behaviour policy.
If you don't like it, move him.

He's learnt from it - if he has anything about him, his behaviour will change!

AledsiPad · 24/11/2021 23:50

Absolutely nowhere in real life, bar prison, isolates human beings and denies them education for poor choices. Least of all ones who are children - 11 ffs - and still learning.

Seclusion is a fucking awful way of ‘behaviour management’ and a sign of a school that is failing at a base level to understand their children.

I despise it. I despise most things about secondary school in this country to be honest. It absolutely fails to set children up for college/university/life.

Peaseblossum22 · 24/11/2021 23:42

@Clymene

It is extra work *@Peaseblossum22* - he will have to catch up in his own time.
Good point but surely hard work and industriousness is to be valued. Being made to sit idle with no stimulation is firstly a waste of time and secondly reminiscent of CIA torture methods for criminals rather than 11 year olds who perhaps could write an essay reflecting on their misdemeanours and how they might impact others .
HereBeFuckery · 24/11/2021 23:38

[quote doggieflooflove]@HereBeFuckery you have to trust me that I did not respond like that when the teacher called me![/quote]
Thank you! You will have made that teacher smile! Grin

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 23:37

@Clymene

He missed a day of learning? Good! You're disappointed and it's impacted him. That's what a punishment should do.
There are much better ways of hitting where it hurts than potentially putting him behind in his classes.
OP posts:
HereBeFuckery · 24/11/2021 23:36

Posted before you revealed what his behaviour had been.
Being part of a physical altercation (call it a bundle if you like, but I guarantee someone in the pile of kids got hurt) is dangerous. It causes ripples through a class, and will have led to disruption in classes that followed on from lunchtime. Adrenaline in teens goes hugely up and down and has a massive impact on learning.

Taking away breaks will do zero to stop this. Other kids won't see that there was a strong sanction imposed and will take that as free reign to copy. There's a reason sanctions are things that are fairly public.

Lack of self control around getting involved in a physical altercation is very worrying at such a young age.

Also, he has not 'missed' learning. He has been set approximately the same work as was done in class, but he was deprived of teacher input due to his choices.

Clymene · 24/11/2021 23:36

It is extra work @Peaseblossum22 - he will have to catch up in his own time.

timetimetickingonme · 24/11/2021 23:35

If bundles are happening all the time then you’ve probably got kids who are anxious and worried seeing/being the target of them, not to mention the risk of someone getting physically hurt. Your son was in isolation for one day. He’s in year 7. Missing one day of lessons and doing work elsewhere is hardly going to make him fail his GCSEs but it might make other pupils feel a bit safer in school if it puts a stop to it.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 24/11/2021 23:34

The only time I find inclusion helpful is when the child is disruptive to others education.

Ds2 school tried to suspend him for 3 days due to inappropriate use of social media, he had no involvement in the incident that took other than his friend making him admin on school group page.

Fortunately the head teacher seen sense and we received a letter of apology as we refused to allowed our son to be “made an example off” as his head of year stated.

I agree muddles can be dangerous and they need to be stopped however I personally don’t feel a child missing a full days education is warranted or beneficial.