Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think seclusion is a ridiculous behaviour management policy?

187 replies

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:29

Now I know In some circumstances it's necessary, but as a general behaviour management tool it's awful.
DS is in yr7. He unfortunately had his first experience of seclusion today after being involved in an incident last week. No fights, malicious behaviour etc, just some silliness that went too far. Now I totally accept that he should be sanctioned and take his punishment.
But a whole day in a room with just a work sheet to fill in, missing 7 lessons including a graded test?
Why not just send them to the seclusion room at breaks/ for lunch for example? For DS, it's not part or a pattern of behaviour or an escalation. So a whole day of education missed for what?
Yes of course I'm hoping it will help him realise what is not acceptable behaviour so will behave better in future.
But really? Surely there's a better way than this unless its the only option left?
Help me accept this is the way it is at secondary please!

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 25/11/2021 08:46

@MrsLargeEmbodied

why arent you teachers teaching?
I teach part time. What’s your point?
sillysmiles · 25/11/2021 08:42

But no one will convince me that seclusion is the right sanction other than in certain appropriate circumstances.

What circumstances would you accept?

He, among others, did something that is potentially dangerous. He was sanctioned for it. If the worksheets were subject relevant that'd be great. But maybe the school have let this bundling happen for a while and now they are trying to stamp it out quickly so the sanctions have to be tough enough that boys stop doing it.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 25/11/2021 08:40

i am not a teacher

Confusedteacher · 25/11/2021 08:37

why aren’t you teachers teaching? Hmm I’ve got Covid. Why aren’t you working?!

MrsLargeEmbodied · 25/11/2021 08:32

why arent you teachers teaching?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 25/11/2021 08:30

it was the phrase "equipment" which made me snigger

Sirzy · 25/11/2021 08:30

I actually think there is a place in schools to come down hard like this at the start to make a clear message to the Child and their peers “this will not be tolerated”

Too much wishy washy leads to boundaries not being clear

Confusedteacher · 25/11/2021 08:30

“ds got in trouble for throwing equipment in year 7

it was a pencil”
Your point is?

^ THIS in spades! Of course throwing a pencil is throwing equipment- it is also disruptive and dangerous.

Platax · 25/11/2021 08:28

And yet we have the highest number of children going on to university and successfully getting degrees. How do you explain that?

Lack of proper thought about university courses. There are too many courses which are prepared to take students with quite low A level grades, and children get steered towards them when they would really be much better off taking vocational qualifications. At the end of their course they end up all too often with, at best, a low level degree in a subject no employer is interested in, and massive debt.

Platax · 25/11/2021 08:25

There are serious issues around the way some schools over-use isolation. They do have a legal duty to educate children, and obviously giving them worksheets to fill in is not education. It may not be so bad for a one-off, but these rooms are regularly used for children with SEN who end up in them for days on end. The government promised three or four years ago to issue some official guidance, but has never done it.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 25/11/2021 08:21

@Soontobe60
lighten up,

Zenithbear · 25/11/2021 08:18

Yanbu
Isolation is lazy and useless.
Most teens need inclusion techniques, can't just sit there and reflect on their behaviour. It rarely works. Hence why the same kids end up back in. It just gets the nuisances out of the way to let the other children learn. But the issues are never addressed. So it repeats because it does not work. Children thrive with input.

ufucoffee · 25/11/2021 08:18

It's a lesson learned for him. Consequence for his behaviour. That's all.

Soontobe60 · 25/11/2021 08:14

@MrsLargeEmbodied

ds got in trouble for throwing equipment in year 7

it was a pencil

Your point is?
Soontobe60 · 25/11/2021 08:12

@AledsiPad

Absolutely nowhere in real life, bar prison, isolates human beings and denies them education for poor choices. Least of all ones who are children - 11 ffs - and still learning.

Seclusion is a fucking awful way of ‘behaviour management’ and a sign of a school that is failing at a base level to understand their children.

I despise it. I despise most things about secondary school in this country to be honest. It absolutely fails to set children up for college/university/life.

And yet we have the highest number of children going on to university and successfully getting degrees. How do you explain that?

My 27 year old DD used to misbehave in lessons so she could get sent to isolation where she much preferred the peace and quiet to get on with her learning. She got 12 GCSEs, 4 A levels, a first class maths degree and is now a very highly paid accountant.

If a child is ‘making poor choices’ in lessons, they’re not learning. But neither are the remaining 29 children. So what should the schools do? What do YOU thing the solution is?

Peaseblossum22 · 25/11/2021 08:11

The schools described on here by teachers sound like brutal , lord of the flies, scary and overwhelming places for many eleven year olds . It’s absolutely a systemic problem of schools just being too big. It cannot be rewarding for teachers to see 300 pupils a week , how can they get to know them as individuals . It’s just about crowd control. When I was at school most schools were between 800 and 1000 pupils max but I know from working in school finance that financially schools of this size are only viable now if in a chain.
Our schools reflect our society , how have we got to a stage where the behaviour of our young people has become so bad and relationships between school and parents so mistrustful.

Platax · 25/11/2021 08:07

A nightmare to organise. It's not like primary where you just stop them going out at playtime and supervision can be done between the teacher and the TA. He'll be with a different teacher each day, and they'll have break duties, or jobs to do, or just need the toilet. He could be told to report somewhere, but he'll take 5 minutes to get there, and may need to be allowed to go and collect books for his next lesson.

Not in the least difficult - if anything, it's easier to organise in a secondary school where you have more staff and space, and frequently have staff with specific responsibility for behaviour. The school just has to arrange a detention room for each day's miscreants, and a rota for staff to cover it.

Platax · 25/11/2021 08:05

@Confusedteacher

So this is where they all pile on top of each other, right? Which could be frankly terrifying for some and very dangerous. It sounds like they are trying to stamp down on dangerous behaviour in the playground and making an example of this group of kids. I think it’s a fair punishment tbh. It’s one day, and he won’t do it again!
But it would be much more sensible to make a clear announcement that this sort of behaviour is going to attract punishment, and then have an escalating scale of punishments. Especially when they're dealing with Y7 children in their first term.
Greenmarmalade · 25/11/2021 08:01

I agree.

My daughter’s behaviour is getting worse but isolating her is a useless response. She needs nurture not isolation.

(She has some SEN and yes- I’m working with her on behaviour as much as I can too)

MrsWooster · 25/11/2021 07:59

When I was a teacher, I felt like the teacher up thread, who values the learning of the 24 in the class, and I would have loved to IMMEDIATELY get rid of the disrupters -their behaviour should have consequences for them, not for their peers.

Now ds is in y7 and experiencing the impact of the disrupters, I feel even more strongly about it. If and when he screws up, I will expect them to drop on him like a ton of bricks and I will expect him to learn from his mistakes.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 25/11/2021 07:58

hopefully he wont join in a bundle again,
lesson learnt

lanthanum · 25/11/2021 07:55

Take away his breaks for a week,

A nightmare to organise. It's not like primary where you just stop them going out at playtime and supervision can be done between the teacher and the TA. He'll be with a different teacher each day, and they'll have break duties, or jobs to do, or just need the toilet. He could be told to report somewhere, but he'll take 5 minutes to get there, and may need to be allowed to go and collect books for his next lesson.

stop him from going to sports clubs for a week or whatever.
Only works for those who are desperately keen on sports clubs.

Make him sit on his own at the back of the class.
That relies on there being enough spare places. Most classes are full - there isn't space for that.

For dangerous behaviour, the point needs to be made - that means a heavy-handed punishment, I'm afraid.

I do think it works better where suitable work is supplied to the seclusion room - and in particular he could have done the test. But that is also tricky to organise - a message to send work down will work if the class is spending most of the lesson doing a written task, but you can't send down a discussion lesson.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 25/11/2021 07:55

dd had to go to seclusion for wearing the wrong trousers

MrsLargeEmbodied · 25/11/2021 07:54

ds got in trouble for throwing equipment in year 7

it was a pencil

Namenic · 25/11/2021 07:50

It’s 1 day of missed school. He can catch up by copying from other pupil’s work. I’d rather my kid get the isolation and learn that it’s not ok to put other kids at risk or disrupt their learning. If every kid in the year did a one-off thing like that, there would probably be not very many incident-free days in the school calendar.