Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think seclusion is a ridiculous behaviour management policy?

187 replies

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:29

Now I know In some circumstances it's necessary, but as a general behaviour management tool it's awful.
DS is in yr7. He unfortunately had his first experience of seclusion today after being involved in an incident last week. No fights, malicious behaviour etc, just some silliness that went too far. Now I totally accept that he should be sanctioned and take his punishment.
But a whole day in a room with just a work sheet to fill in, missing 7 lessons including a graded test?
Why not just send them to the seclusion room at breaks/ for lunch for example? For DS, it's not part or a pattern of behaviour or an escalation. So a whole day of education missed for what?
Yes of course I'm hoping it will help him realise what is not acceptable behaviour so will behave better in future.
But really? Surely there's a better way than this unless its the only option left?
Help me accept this is the way it is at secondary please!

OP posts:
lazylinguist · 25/11/2021 16:59

They're locked in, even the fire exit is locked

Really? Shock I think that's very unusual tbh. I've been in multiple inclusion rooms and they've never even been closed, never mind locked!

lazylinguist · 25/11/2021 16:57

I'm a teacher and I'm often a bit baffled why some MNers get so fraught about kids being put in the inclusion room. Have you ever been in one? It's a normal room. It's not like being in solitary confinement in a prison fgs. There is a teacher in there for starters, and usually other kids (sometimes in separate booths, but still in the same room), so the child is not actually isolated. There is the audible usual hustle and bustle of school going on outside, the door is usually open. Work is set (so kids aren't 'missing a day of education').

Some kids deliberately misbehave because they fancy chilling out in the inclusion room instead of being in lessons. It's true that the more generally well-behaved kids tend to take being put in inclusion more seriously, but that is kind of the whole point. In any case, it's one day out of the gazillions of school days he'll have. It really won't do him any harm.

Peaseblossum22 · 25/11/2021 16:55

Those in isolation are occasionally set work but not often. Some staff members make them just sit there and do nothing at all, others might let them read a book or use a laptop. (My son watched YouTube last time he was sent to isolation 🤦‍♀️) They're locked in, even the fire exit is locked. They have to complete 6 full lessons, plus any breaks, plus an hour after school.

This is appalling, are you sure that they lock the fire escapes ?

Tal45 · 25/11/2021 16:50

I think they had no choice but to come down hard because of how dangerous it was. I don't think isolation is a good tool because it puts those with bad behaviour further behind which may be a cycle - child is behind, is disruptive because they feel they can't do the work, is isolated and given a worksheet so misses all teacher input and TA support, child falls further behind, child is disruptive in class because they can't do the work....and so on. As they weren't disrupting class or distracting others in this instance (in which case isolation might be required for the benefit of the rest of the class) I think detentions would have been more appropriate.

drpaddington · 25/11/2021 16:43

DS's school use isolation for lots of things- from violence and rudeness to talking, not completing homework, or arriving to a lesson without all the correct uniform and equipment. It doesn't seem to be much of a deterrent because they know they can be sent for very minor things- it loses any impact.

The idea is to make sure those left in class can carry on learning without disruptions. Although that doesn't really make sense when the child's 'crime' isn't always disruptive 🤷🏻‍♀️

Those in isolation are occasionally set work but not often. Some staff members make them just sit there and do nothing at all, others might let them read a book or use a laptop. (My son watched YouTube last time he was sent to isolation 🤦‍♀️) They're locked in, even the fire exit is locked. They have to complete 6 full lessons, plus any breaks, plus an hour after school.

Platax · 25/11/2021 16:30

Interesting article here on the legalities

Platax · 25/11/2021 16:28

[quote Sherrystrull]@MrsLargeEmbodied

Why do you think it's ok to throw a pencil in class? It's disruptive and dangerous and silly. [/quote]
She didn't say it was OK. She just indicated that it was daft to describe it as throwing equipment around. And there's a good case for saying it's less dangerous that subjecting children to potential psychological damage by isolating them for hours on end.

Platax · 25/11/2021 16:26

The British Psychological Society is clear that use of isolation rooms as punishment should be banned - www.bps.org.uk/news-and-policy/use-isolation-booths-schools-should-be-banned-says-british-psychological-society

MoreAloneTime · 25/11/2021 16:19

To be honest I'm glad it's being used for people that persistently disrupt lessons. I do think it makes sense to have a sliding scale of punishment though.

As for bundles, best stick to doing them when there are no teachers around in my experience.

Sherrystrull · 25/11/2021 10:33

@MrsLargeEmbodied

Why do you think it's ok to throw a pencil in class? It's disruptive and dangerous and silly.

Goatinthegarden · 25/11/2021 09:41

Seclusion works for the majority. Many pupils only need the threat of seclusion to help them maintain their behaviour. Some pupils may need to go once or twice before they realise it’s not worth messing around.

From experience, those who have parents backing the school up, tend to get the message a little quicker. When parents disagree with a school on behaviour management, pupils very quickly get the message that they can behave badly at school because their adults at home disagree with their teachers.

Seclusion cannot be good for pupils who end up there regularly, whether because of SEN or challenging behaviours. However, I assume that at a point a child is frequently removed from class, the school’s behaviour team would then look at how to further support the pupil to obtain their education.

Makingnumber2 · 25/11/2021 09:31

My school moved seclusion room to a room with computers this year precisely so students in there can join their lessons from Teams and don't miss learning. Staff are sent the list of those booked into seclusion first thing so they can send out Teams links to their students and any who join the room during the day, an email is sent direct to their teachers asking for links for rest of the day. It isn't the same as being in the lesson in person, but it's definitely better than them missing learning. Perhaps suggest this to your school OP? If the pandemic showed us anything in education it's that technology can and should be used to prevent students unnecessarily missing lessons wherever possible.

ChloeCrocodile · 25/11/2021 09:29

It just gets the nuisances out of the way to let the other children learn. But the issues are never addressed.

It addresses the issues of the other children who want to learn. Why should their education be ruined because of the "nuisances"? I've had well behaved kids in tears because they can't cope with the constant disruption from other students when all they want is to pass GCSE maths. Their wellbeing matters too.

Also, in a good school there is a record of how many times each child reaches the isolation stage of the behaviour management policy, and strategies put in place for students who end up there often. Failing to deal with "low level" disruption doesn't help the students causing the disruption in any way.

Cheerychirpy · 25/11/2021 09:26

I went to a rough school. Over half of the class still wanted to get on and learn. Constantly disrupted by other kids pissing around. So, so irritating.

Your son got off lightly. The fairest thing to do with kids that persistently piss around is to keep sending them home until they get the message. That’s considered too extreme for the delicate little flowers though so they get seclusion instead.

30whatacrock · 25/11/2021 09:20

So basically he and some others piled on another child who could have been injured. It’s irrelevant that he was t the ring leader. You are doing your son no favours by minimising his bad bad behaviour. If your son had been bundled what sanction would you have expected, probably not a little word of advice in his ear.

My best advice would be stop sugar coating your child’s poor behaviour and decision making and support the school in disciplining him.

sillysmiles · 25/11/2021 09:12

How many parents further sanction their child for their misbehaviour in school?

sashh · 25/11/2021 09:11

There are much better ways of hitting where it hurts than potentially putting him behind in his classes.

Well yes they could have called the police and your DS could have a criminal record for assault at the least, possibly ABH and if the bundle had gone badly GBH.

The whole point of exclusion is to remove the child so the one being bundled can walk around school without fear.

I assume the others involved in the 'bundle' have also got the same punishment, if they haven't then you might have a point.

Your child took part in a violent assault, he has been punished and got off quite lightly.

No I'm not exaggerating, that is what he did.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 25/11/2021 09:11

It sounds as if the teacher was trying to reassure you that they don't think your DS is a delinquent but: bundles are dangerous, the school needed to put a firm stop to them especially if they are starting to catch on as a craze, he wont be the only one in isolation for the same thing, and if he's upset about it then it's having exactly the right effect. He'll think twice before doing dangerously silly things.

he's missed a day of learning.

He had a worksheet to do. And if you and he have figured out that being in the classroom and learning along with the others are privileges that can be lost, then that's a good thing.

Make him sit on his own at the back of the class.

Really? You want the whole group sitting at the back of the classroom all day? How does that work?

There are much better ways of hitting where it hurts than potentially putting him behind in his classes.

By one day? That's a bit precious. Maybe he'll have to work a bit harder for the next few days to catch up.

I'm hoping it's the metaphorical firework up his arse.

I hope so too!

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 25/11/2021 09:03

@VitalsStable I'm so sorry this happened to your son. I've never heard of bundling and had no idea what it was until I read this thread.

Joystir59 · 25/11/2021 09:00

I think you should home school your son

VitalsStable · 25/11/2021 08:59

The school haven't made your son miss a day of learning, it was his silly behaviour that caused him to miss a day of learning, back the school up wholeheartedly and maybe take him to play kids rugby, get him involved in a scrum and let him experience what it feels like to have a whole load of bodies land on you when you're expecting it, then ask him how it would feel if you weren't expecting it and what the risks could be.

Imagine the fury of a parent who has to take their kid to the hospital after someone has pulled a stupid stunt like this, they miss work, has to arrange someone else to pick up their other kids, there's follow up appointments, more school and work missed and the potential for long term injury, one day of missed education for your son pales into insignificance when you look at what could be the implications.

(Can you tell that it's my DS who has had this done to him and that the outcome was pretty serious).

TrashyPanda · 25/11/2021 08:56

@MrsLargeEmbodied

ds got in trouble for throwing equipment in year 7

it was a pencil

Why was he throwing things around?

He was more than old enough to know this was unacceptable behaviour.

Confusedteacher · 25/11/2021 08:53

The problem is, what punishments can schools hand out then? There is another thread running where people are expressing outrage at after school detentions Hmm

In reality, the main problem is 30 kids in a class is too many. It is hard enough to give them all the attention they need to learn in a class of absolute angels- when kids start acting up, even if it is ‘only’ throwing a pencil or chatting to a friend it is impossible. There is a ripple effect- once one of them is seen to ‘get away’ with something more and more will start. Isolation may seem unfair to those who get taken out but it works- and leaves you able to teach the 25 who actually want to learn.

However, in my school they are only isolated for one lesson- I have worked in schools with a more ‘zero tolerance’ attitude where 2 warnings for anything means isolation for a whole day.

Peaseblossum22 · 25/11/2021 08:53

I agree it’s serious , a friend of mine was permanently scared on the face by someone throwing a pencil when we were at primary but what is wrong with ‘pencil’

Soontobe60 · 25/11/2021 08:50

[quote MrsLargeEmbodied]@Soontobe60
lighten up,[/quote]
Do you really believe throwing a pencil in class is ok? Judging by your response ‘it made me snigger’, you probably do. Should they have used ‘stationary’, ‘writing implement’, ‘small sharp piece of wood’?
Maybe try teaching a class of 30 twelve year olds whose parents think throwing stuff around is ok.