Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think seclusion is a ridiculous behaviour management policy?

187 replies

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:29

Now I know In some circumstances it's necessary, but as a general behaviour management tool it's awful.
DS is in yr7. He unfortunately had his first experience of seclusion today after being involved in an incident last week. No fights, malicious behaviour etc, just some silliness that went too far. Now I totally accept that he should be sanctioned and take his punishment.
But a whole day in a room with just a work sheet to fill in, missing 7 lessons including a graded test?
Why not just send them to the seclusion room at breaks/ for lunch for example? For DS, it's not part or a pattern of behaviour or an escalation. So a whole day of education missed for what?
Yes of course I'm hoping it will help him realise what is not acceptable behaviour so will behave better in future.
But really? Surely there's a better way than this unless its the only option left?
Help me accept this is the way it is at secondary please!

OP posts:
EllaVaNight · 25/11/2021 20:56

I'm in my twenties now but I remember being dragged by my hair out of school by an ex boyfriend making us late for school. A teacher witnessed me getting dragged back in and walked past when he had me pinned up against a wall. I was put in isolation due to being late. He wasn't. Personally I'm happy to see the children causing potential injuries being punished rather than the victims.

I am not saying your son is like my ex. But the injuries he could have caused by this "silly" behaviour could have been so much worse.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2021 20:50

doggieflooflove
The BPS were responding to a specific situation in a specific special school, that if I remember correctly was a huge safeguarding issue and children were either unsafe or harmed, but BPS somehow decided off the back of that they knew what was best on how to run schools nationwide.

When they made that release it was challenged quite a lot from a range of voices in education, but natural the Ban The Booths type activists seemed to think it was a trump card. Of course they also argue that study desks with desk dividers are 'deep confinement booths' and think that working independently in a study room where staff expect them to work during lesson time instead of taking to others is sensory deprivation.

Where there's poor practice, it should be challenged, but I find it bizarre that there's seriously adults out there who think that it's wrong to expect students to work at a study desk during lesson time without having a gossip to the other students who have also been removed from lessons due to behaviour. I'd genuinely like to see them run a school.

Plumbear2 · 25/11/2021 20:46

My son is pleased this happens in high school. He had so many lessons disputed in primary he is pleased he can now work and concentrate because disruptive behaviour is not tolerated and they will get moved. Rightly so. Why should my child's education be ruined my others kids who should know how the behave by now?

doggieflooflove · 25/11/2021 20:39

@nosyupnorth

You can use whatever minimising language you want but your son and a group of his peers deliberately cooperated in an unprovoked assault on another child, in a way that could have caused serious injuries, for fun. Of course the teachers seperated him rather than letting him hang out with his mates to plan their next attack.

It's mad that people have this attitude that physical assaults are acceptable as 'bundles' and 'boys will be boys' at eleven and yet wonder why they escalate to knifing each other as teens.

I his defence, the child who bundled had initiated one on another child first. Not saying it's right or acceptable but I do know (from the teacher) that was the case. No one has come out of this well!
OP posts:
doggieflooflove · 25/11/2021 20:37

"Snidey"!

OP posts:
doggieflooflove · 25/11/2021 20:37

@Mookie81

If I had 2 children who were sent to the isolation room, I wouldn't be getting snidey with strangers Hmm. There aren't enough staff or resources, and there isn't enough money to deal with behaviour issues. It's swimming against the tide.
What two children and who's getting sundry?
OP posts:
doggieflooflove · 25/11/2021 20:36

[quote Platax]The British Psychological Society is clear that use of isolation rooms as punishment should be banned - www.bps.org.uk/news-and-policy/use-isolation-booths-schools-should-be-banned-says-british-psychological-society[/quote]
That's really interesting, and it's bit the first time I've seen a call for it to be banned from a group with an understanding of child development.

I hope people on here can see the difference between me not being supportive of the school or that DS didn't deserve a reasonably serious sanction, and me agreeing that the school were right to sanction as DS did indeed deserve it, but just not overall agree with use of isolation (unless in specific circumstances).

You have to trust me when I say that DS knows full well I side with the school re his behaviour.

He does also know, historically, that I don't agree with seclusion as a discipline technique as this was part of our discussion about secondary schools from when we started to look at them in year 5.

OP posts:
Mookie81 · 25/11/2021 20:22

If I had 2 children who were sent to the isolation room, I wouldn't be getting snidey with strangers Hmm.
There aren't enough staff or resources, and there isn't enough money to deal with behaviour issues. It's swimming against the tide.

BoredZelda · 25/11/2021 20:20

I think seclusion has its place. They should be given classwork to do though.

nosyupnorth · 25/11/2021 20:07

You can use whatever minimising language you want but your son and a group of his peers deliberately cooperated in an unprovoked assault on another child, in a way that could have caused serious injuries, for fun. Of course the teachers seperated him rather than letting him hang out with his mates to plan their next attack.

It's mad that people have this attitude that physical assaults are acceptable as 'bundles' and 'boys will be boys' at eleven and yet wonder why they escalate to knifing each other as teens.

gogohm · 25/11/2021 20:00

I get what you are saying, but if your child was subjected to the bundle then you would probably want a tougher punishment. Seclusion is used these days where in the past you were suspended - bullying in the playground (that's what bundling is) was 1 day suspension at my school

echt · 25/11/2021 19:55

If there was a school available to us that didn't use isolation as part of its behaviour policy, then it would have been high up on my list. But they all do so it's really an illusion of choice, not me actively choosing a school because it has that policy. Two local schools were discounted by me because isolation appeared to be their go-to management strategy

There were no seclusion rooms when I started teaching 40+ years ago. Children were sent home and their parents bore the brunt of their misbehaviour. That was apparently not OK, so the internal suspension model of having the pupil in school but not having the nice bits, i.e. socialising with friends was brought in.

The dramatising of this is into some quasi- torture mode is beyond silly.

Sherrystrull · 25/11/2021 19:33

@Platax

Pencils are equipment. They are needed to access the lesson. I'm not sure why you are saying they aren't.

And quite honestly a sharp pencil being lobbed around the room is dangerous and encourages others to throw other things. Teachers need to think about the safety of all children.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2021 19:14

You keep saying that to lose a day of education is unfair.

If a child were injured and had to stay home from being bundled do you think that would be fair? I think you need to suck it up, at the very least, your son will keep away from bundles and not join in again. Lesson learnt.
You don't understand. Schools who think children should be safe at school and able to learn are the worst. It's absolutely preferable to brush off pile ons in the playground, allow endless warnings and disruption to everyone's education and generally prioritise the students who seek to get involved in physical altercations, be verbally abusive to staff, and systematically disrupt the learning of hundreds of students rather than have students working on individual desks in a study room supervised by a member of staff.

There was a whole campaign around Ban the Booths than ended up being hilarious to follow because it went something like this:
BtB: Ban the Booths!!
Opponents: what's wrong with study rooms with individual study desks with dividers
BtB: we aren't talking about that. We are talking about deep confinement booths... sensory deprivation...
Opponents: we've done a quick search for these deep confinement booths and nothing comes up. Do you mean individual desks with dividers between them so that students aren't distracted by each other? What's your problem with students in a study room on individual desks working through work?
BtB: but this school did something we didn't like so all booths should be banned...
Opponents: of course any poor practice should be investigated, but why are you trying to ban students from working on individual desks in a study room?
BtB: ... silence... (campaign goes quiet).

Many people involved in that movement are the same people who seem to think restorative conversations where perpetrators can explain to their victims why they've bullied and targed and assaulted them is the solution and not at all open to victim blaming in a way that centres the perpetrators, and that if a student is disrupting learning for everyone then they need a hot chocolate with a senior member of staff where they can slag the teacher off.

Nootkah · 25/11/2021 18:39

@doggieflooflove

Now that youve explained what it was, I agree with you seclusion is not appropriate. However, depending on the school's behaviour policy on how tonrespond to violence in the playground, it may be proportionate. What you're describing is a physical assault by a group of young men on a single person. Yes it was at school, and yes nothing bad happened... But it could have.

The behaviour policy in my sons schook for physical violence woukd probably see those involved miss the reat of that day, and then ned to engage in restirative work during their break times fir the rest of the week... Which would pribably look like individual and group discussions about what happened , why they got involved, how they could make different choices next time, and why it is being treated as a serious incident due to what could have happened.

Ericaequites · 25/11/2021 17:26

Teachers can’t smack, shout, or send children to stand in the corridor with their face to the wall. Seclusion is one of the feel disciplinary tools they have. In nearly all cases, parents need to back the school, and help enforce school discipline at home. Trouble at school should mean trouble at home. Too often, parents don’t want their child to face consequences, and the results can be heartbreaking.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 25/11/2021 17:21

At my school kids want to try send to the isolation room 😱

Peaseblossum22 · 25/11/2021 17:19

@cansu to be fair to the OP she seems to have taken a very firm line with her ds, it was the teacher who called the behaviour ‘silly’ .

BluebelllsRosesDaffodills · 25/11/2021 17:16

Sorry, OP, you do sound a bit precious.

It’s not as if he’s been caned!

cansu · 25/11/2021 17:13

If you want your kid to go to a school where teachers teach and kids make progress you need to stop minimising crap behaviour. Calling a bundle silly is minimising. Kids throwing equipment and calling out and talking while the teacher is teaching are all symptomatic of poor learning behaviour and poor outcomes. Sitting around deciding for yourself whether the punishment is tailored to his needs or personality is missing the point. He broke rules he gets a sanction which impacts on him and to some degree you as you are meant to have some influence on him. Most parents think sanctions are great for other peoples kids. To the poster who says her dd needs nurturing how would a teacher nurture a kid who is passing about while trying to educate 25 other kids? Seriously the reason why schools are finally getting serious about removing kids from lessons is to try and reassert the notion that schools are about education and qualifications.

Platax · 25/11/2021 17:12

@lazylinguist

I'm a teacher and I'm often a bit baffled why some MNers get so fraught about kids being put in the inclusion room. Have you ever been in one? It's a normal room. It's not like being in solitary confinement in a prison fgs. There is a teacher in there for starters, and usually other kids (sometimes in separate booths, but still in the same room), so the child is not actually isolated. There is the audible usual hustle and bustle of school going on outside, the door is usually open. Work is set (so kids aren't 'missing a day of education').

Some kids deliberately misbehave because they fancy chilling out in the inclusion room instead of being in lessons. It's true that the more generally well-behaved kids tend to take being put in inclusion more seriously, but that is kind of the whole point. In any case, it's one day out of the gazillions of school days he'll have. It really won't do him any harm.

You are making the mistake of assuming that all isolation rooms are the same. Some really impose sensory deprivation - the child is made to sit facing blank walls with nothing to do and not allowed to turn around. It can have very serious consequences, as in the case where it was found to be being used as an opportunity for abuse, and as in this case - www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-kent-47817000.

And since when did supplying worksheets amount to education? If teaching was that easy, we wouldn't need schools.

Its around 2,260 school days that children have, not "gazillions". If missing one school day is so trivial, why bother with fining parents if they cause a child to miss a day?

clarepetal · 25/11/2021 17:07

You keep saying that to lose a day of education is unfair.

If a child were injured and had to stay home from being bundled do you think that would be fair? I think you need to suck it up, at the very least, your son will keep away from bundles and not join in again. Lesson learnt. Wine

Icimoi · 25/11/2021 17:05

I came across a case where a school was regularly sending a child with ASD to isolation, where he largely left unsupervised and was told to produce spreadsheets on a computer. It rebounded on them when Ofsted turned up, had a look at what he was doing and discovered he'd hacked into the school's system and was having a good time reading the staff's emails and changing all his records.

Peaseblossum22 · 25/11/2021 17:01

Not sure who Jane is, that should read have

Peaseblossum22 · 25/11/2021 17:00

But it’s clearly not like this in all schools, Jane you read drpaddingtons description. That is wholly unacceptable