Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think seclusion is a ridiculous behaviour management policy?

187 replies

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:29

Now I know In some circumstances it's necessary, but as a general behaviour management tool it's awful.
DS is in yr7. He unfortunately had his first experience of seclusion today after being involved in an incident last week. No fights, malicious behaviour etc, just some silliness that went too far. Now I totally accept that he should be sanctioned and take his punishment.
But a whole day in a room with just a work sheet to fill in, missing 7 lessons including a graded test?
Why not just send them to the seclusion room at breaks/ for lunch for example? For DS, it's not part or a pattern of behaviour or an escalation. So a whole day of education missed for what?
Yes of course I'm hoping it will help him realise what is not acceptable behaviour so will behave better in future.
But really? Surely there's a better way than this unless its the only option left?
Help me accept this is the way it is at secondary please!

OP posts:
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 26/11/2021 11:37

@Platax

Please don’t think he’s students aren’t being helped; they really are but it’s sometimes impossible to at the very moment of distress.

The students in their with mental health crisis are kept at a separate end to the ones in there for behaviour and they are the same 10 kids a day so they do know they aren’t there for behaviour. Also the ones in there for behaviour are in booths doing work. Mental health needs are usually reading a book/fidget you/mindful colouring/:breathing exercises/ doing their class work from the lesson they needed to leave

The kids with uniform issues in there don’t have sensory issues- usually they won’t remove their nose piercing or have dyed their hair bright pink, wearing fake nails, wearing red trousers when should be in black- that kind of thing.

Those that miss the PE bus are usually kids who don’t want to do PE- I agree this needs to be addressed- are they self conscious getting changes etc

Sherrystrull · 26/11/2021 09:53

@Platax

No one is suggesting these problems aren't addressed. But they cannot be addressed by a teacher standing infront of 30 children trying to get through a curriculum.

There is not enough money for support. It breaks my heart every day that I cannot do more for the children in my care but I cannot split myself up anymore and the support has to be prioritised. It's shit for everyone.

LolaSmiles · 26/11/2021 09:53

Platax
So what do you propose happens in a school where a child cannot be in lessons, needs to be supervised, the mental health team is full and can't be with the child at that point?

Do they force the child into the classroom?
Do they leave a child unsupervised?
Do they wave a magic wand and find a spare member of staff for every child who might need someone (because believe me even schools like mine with an amazing SEN base, a team of pastoral staff trained in mental health, an on site counsellor and a team of mentors don't have this magic wand and spare staff)?

Because in all seriousness, for all your criticisms of isolation you don't seem to have explained how much disruption you think hundreds of students should have to experience in order to keep people in the classroom, or how much verbal abuse teachers should have to put up with in order to keep everyone in the classroom, how much victims of bullying should have to be around the perpetrators in order to keep everyone in the classroom, and now you're objecting to children who need space away from the classroom being appropriately supervised by a member of staff and making flippant comments about nobody delaung with the issues when another poster has quote clearly said the mental health team is full.

It's quite clear you have absolutely zero interest in realising that behaviour in schools is complicated because you're only interested in 'isolation is awful' black and white thinking.

Platax · 26/11/2021 09:41

@OnceuponaRainbow18

Our inclusion/isolation room usually has about 10 kids in there a day who are having a mental health crisis and can’t cope in the lesson and the mental health team are full to capacity.

Then about 4 kids in there who won’t put on school uniform

2 who have missed multiple detentions

2 for fighting

3 for refusing to go to their lessons

2 missed the PE bus

1 who is self harming on site

That's an interesting illustration of the problem: it's a punishment room, but it's being used for the children with mental health issues who may therefore perceive that they are being punished. There are also a number of others who may well have SEN issues: the children who won't put on uniform may have sensory problems, the lesson refusers may well have anxiety, the self-harmer clearly has MH difficulties, those who missed the PE bus may have dyslexia/executive functioning problems, the fighters may have been being bullied, those who have multiple detentions may be acting out due to unmet needs. And of course, some or all may simply be misbehaving children. But let's chuck them all in isolation and give them worksheets, rather than address any problems.
HarrietsChariot · 26/11/2021 09:39

When I was at school there was a problem with boys giving other boys "wedgies" on their birthday. (Yanking their underwear upwards is the best way I can describe it.) This was going on for years and dismissed by the teachers and parents as "a bit of silliness" until a new headteacher arrived and several of the people involved were suspended for "aggressive homosexuality". It largely stopped happening after that.

That's the thing with harsh punishments - they are to set an example as much as anything else. If your son's day of isolation means someone isn't seriously injured or worse by a group of young thugs like him, surely that's a good thing? Or would you rather they brought back the cane?

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 26/11/2021 09:32

Our inclusion/isolation room usually has about 10 kids in there a day who are having a mental health crisis and can’t cope in the lesson and the mental health team are full to capacity.

Then about 4 kids in there who won’t put on school uniform

2 who have missed multiple detentions

2 for fighting

3 for refusing to go to their lessons

2 missed the PE bus

1 who is self harming on site

LolaSmiles · 26/11/2021 09:29

Is the real reason for these rooms that schools have to take on pupils they can't cope with but there isn't any other sort of provision for them?
No, a lot is linked to a change in parental attitudes to behaviour and rules, as well as society attitudes to schools and teachers.

When I was at school, I'd be bothered about a teacher calling my Mum. I'd know that if school had to speak to my Mum, Mum's response would be to ask me what I was playing at and to get on with my work. Now there is a sizable minority of parents who actively undermine the school, think that their child doesn't have to follow any rule that they don't like, and will sit in front of their child and be aggressive, confrontational and outright lie to staff in order to defend their child.

When I was at school we had a simple uniform that was strictly followed. Now schools have to deal with situations where simple things like "no trainers" mean some parents go and spend over £100 on a pair of branded trainers, and then come into school complaining that they're not made of money and can't afford more shoes because school have said that "no trainers" means no trainers. Or they'll tell you their children's skirt was definitely knee length when they left the house in a morning (knee length wasn't our rule BTW because we appreciate girls have different bodies and different leg lengths, we just don't want to see pupils' underwear) when you are all sitting in a room with the student and the skirt quite clearly was never mid thigh, let alone knee length. Why the parent lied to our faces in front of the child is beyond me, but as you can imagine the student knew their parents would always back them. It will comr as no surprise that those students found themselves in isolation at times because parents have told them they don't have to follow rules.

Then add in the minimising of disruptive behaviour (eg my child was given a detention for asking a question vs my child was given a detention for repeatedly talking when told not to, the teacher said if anyone needs help to raise their hand, their child turned round to talk again and after 4 warnings they were removed from class and given a detention). When this happens several times in a day or a pattern emerges, the student has time in isolation because several hundred other children's learning come before one child's desire to disrupt and talk to their friends.

Then add in parents who claim schools can't give their child a detention, they don't consent and their child doesn't have to attend. The child doesn't attend so school move through the policy, and the child goes to isolation.

If a student is in isolation then they are in school, are seen by staff who can check welfare, they've got work to complete, and are continuing with their education. Because of some of the parental attitudes above, a fixed term exclusion would mean a trip to the shops, chilling on their xbox etc, or for some students being in potentially dangerous situations or engaging in behaviour that could put them in trouble with the police.

As with any initiative, it can be used effectively, used ineffectively and needs to be reviewed regularly, but it's a much more complex issue than some of the anti-isolation people would like to present.

Plumbear2 · 26/11/2021 09:27

Isolation is perfect and sends to right message. For far to long in primary school stickers/star of tbe week was given to kids who behaved badly and where good for one day. My son saw this and saw tbe injustice in this when he was always well behaved and always worked hard and always had lessons dispruted by these kids. It's great now he knows these kids will be taken out the classroom. Rewarding them in primary obviously didn't work, they need the reality shock now that these behaviours will not be tolerated. These kids are in high school now, how dare they disrupt the class for everyone ekse.

MoreAloneTime · 26/11/2021 08:56

Is the real reason for these rooms that schools have to take on pupils they can't cope with but there isn't any other sort of provision for them?

user3876483 · 26/11/2021 08:29

@MichelleScarn

So according to DS, and the teacher that spoke to me, he was part of a group that did a "bundle" in the playground I.have no idea what that is so looked it up, urban dictionary says 'a bag of heroin' Shock Am assuming not!
Lmao!! Love this.

I think it's when a group all jump on top of one person

Pyewackect · 26/11/2021 08:29

Well , hopefully, he’ll learn not to do whatever he did again.

dancinfeet · 26/11/2021 08:25

Kids who are being silly are often playing to an audience (of their peers). Taking the audience away seems like a suitable punishment to me, I don’t agree with putting kids in seclusion for their parents not being able to afford immediate replacements for items like broken school shoes I do not agree with on the other hand.

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 26/11/2021 07:57

Whether or not seclusion is sometimes misused or over-used, as far as I'm concerned this was an appropriate time to use it. If the staff knew that the boy who was the victim of your son's bundle had initiated a bundle first then I hope he was put in seclusion too. Your son sounds full of excuses for his own behaviour and you should not be supporting that.

If they were all being dangerously stupid then they all need a serious consequence, and a day in isolation would be about right.

AntiMaskersAreTwats · 25/11/2021 23:27

@Platax

And yet we have the highest number of children going on to university and successfully getting degrees. How do you explain that?

Lack of proper thought about university courses. There are too many courses which are prepared to take students with quite low A level grades, and children get steered towards them when they would really be much better off taking vocational qualifications. At the end of their course they end up all too often with, at best, a low level degree in a subject no employer is interested in, and massive debt.

This is true. I worked briefly in a crap University College that took absolutely anyone as long as they coughed up the tuition fees. I used to read first drafts of essays that my 9 year old could have written better. Some couldn’t string a sentence of English together. One trip to ‘study support’ and it was passable Hmm having basically been rewritten for them. They were a collage connected to the University of Birmingham and so some actually left with UofB degrees. I was ashamed to work there and left but that is another scandal of our time just waiting to be exposed.
BoredZelda · 25/11/2021 22:58

My takeaway from that article is that the BPS doesn't agree with their use. So my views appear to be the same as theirs.

Seems you are reading what you want to from it, confirmation bias.

It specifically mentions vulnerability. Is your child vulnerable? Is not then that link is irrelevant to your son’s situation.

Mookie81 · 25/11/2021 22:52

Not you OP.
Another poster who had one child sent for throwing a pencil and another for uniform.

MargaretThursday · 25/11/2021 22:45

As you're concerned about the lessons he's missed, then I'm sure you'll make sure he borrows a book off a friend and copies it all up and you check he's understood it, just like we had to do if we missed lessons for any reason when at school.
Then you can't complain he's missed lessons.

As for isolation my ds, who can be very silly, asked his teachers if he coukd have a desk on his own facing the wall when he was in year 7 because he recognised he worked much better like that without distractions.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2021 22:43

The answer to that, which you've artfully failed to mention, @LolaSmiles, is that the students should be working in the classroom. Particularly the children with SEN who form far too high a proportion of those sent off to these spiffy desks
There's no artful anything Hmm

How many times do you believe it's acceptable for 29 other students to have their learning disrupted a day?

I outlined how many disruptions to learning would happen in my school before a child is removed from a lesson. Each step of the way there is an opportunity to make positive choices, and we have an excellent SEN base and SEN team.

What people who are flat out anti-isolation never seem to explain is how much learning hundreds of students should miss in the name of their cause. They claim to care about lost learning, but never for the 29 other children in the room How many children are you happy to miss out on the grades and education they deserve in order to keep a minority of students in the classroom based on nothing more than an ideological objection to students working in a study room at a single study desk for a short period of time?

How many victims of assault and bullying should have to remain in class with the perpetrators in the name of keeping everyone in the classroom?

How many times should staff accept being threatened, verbally abused and assaulted in the name of keeping students working in the classroom?

(And again, it goes without saying if isolation is being used inappropriately it should be challenged, but that is totally different to thinking students should be kept in the classroom)

lazylinguist · 25/11/2021 22:21

The answer to that, which you've artfully failed to mention, @LolaSmiles, is that the students should be working in the classroom.

Not being in the classroom for a day is really not the end of the world. The excluded student should be given proper work to do by the teacher. That's what happens in the schools where I work.

And it's not always as simple as 'the students should be working in the classroom'. If they've just massively disrupted tge classroom, behaved abusively towards classmates or the teacher, then no they shouldn't be in the classroom.

There is no reason why exclusion rooms should be traumatic places of sensory deprivation, and I find it very hard to believe that a significant number of them are.

Exclusion rooms don't need to be banned, they just need to be set up and used appropriately.

Awalkintime · 25/11/2021 22:01

He won't be behind in his classes, he has the duty to catch up. Find out what the learning was and make him do it over the weekend then he is up to speed.

Why are you letting him fall behind in his learning because of this day - be a parent and make him do the work in his own time.

Platax · 25/11/2021 21:58

Opponents: of course any poor practice should be investigated, but why are you trying to ban students from working on individual desks in a study room?

The answer to that, which you've artfully failed to mention, @LolaSmiles, is that the students should be working in the classroom. Particularly the children with SEN who form far too high a proportion of those sent off to these spiffy desks.

LolaSmiles · 25/11/2021 21:49

To be fair OP, the BPS are not teachers, nor are they school leaders, nor do they have any experience running schools or designing and implementation behaviour policies in large organisations.
They released that statement after a specific case around the same time Ban The Booths was going on, and never quite seemed to demonstrate much awareness of what isolation is in typical school or how it's used.

I'm one of the first to question inappropriate use of isolation and very quick to talk about SEN support, but the BPS responding to a specific case by making generalised comments of a sector that isn't their own doesn't really hold much weight.

doggieflooflove · 25/11/2021 21:38

@BoredZelda

From that link The use of isolation booths locates ‘the problem’ within the child and fails to recognise the links between disability special education needs, poverty, inequality, lower wellbeing, poor mental health and children’s behaviour in school. We need to see a cultural shift on how schools support vulnerable children

Does your child fit in to any of these vulnerable categories OP? If not, the BPS’s concerns about isolation don’t apply to him.

The link makes it clear they are concerned these are used for the wrong children, not that they potentially harm NT children who think it is OK to pile on another child in the playground.

No I disagree with you there. It talks about the impact of isolation in children with SEND, but also says that there may be support for their use for teacher / pupil safety and should be taken on a case by case basis. My takeaway from that article is that the BPS doesn't agree with their use. So my views appear to be the same as theirs.
OP posts:
Lougle · 25/11/2021 21:26

It can work well. I know a child who was put in the 'hub'. They had to copy work from a random text book. All day. They said that they got more done in that day than they ever do in class, but they left absolutely determined to never get 'hubbed' again.

I think that if a child gets 'hubbed' repeatedly, they really need to think about whether that child has additional needs.

BoredZelda · 25/11/2021 21:22

From that link The use of isolation booths locates ‘the problem’ within the child and fails to recognise the links between disability special education needs, poverty, inequality, lower wellbeing, poor mental health and children’s behaviour in school. We need to see a cultural shift on how schools support vulnerable children

Does your child fit in to any of these vulnerable categories OP? If not, the BPS’s concerns about isolation don’t apply to him.

The link makes it clear they are concerned these are used for the wrong children, not that they potentially harm NT children who think it is OK to pile on another child in the playground.