Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think seclusion is a ridiculous behaviour management policy?

187 replies

doggieflooflove · 24/11/2021 22:29

Now I know In some circumstances it's necessary, but as a general behaviour management tool it's awful.
DS is in yr7. He unfortunately had his first experience of seclusion today after being involved in an incident last week. No fights, malicious behaviour etc, just some silliness that went too far. Now I totally accept that he should be sanctioned and take his punishment.
But a whole day in a room with just a work sheet to fill in, missing 7 lessons including a graded test?
Why not just send them to the seclusion room at breaks/ for lunch for example? For DS, it's not part or a pattern of behaviour or an escalation. So a whole day of education missed for what?
Yes of course I'm hoping it will help him realise what is not acceptable behaviour so will behave better in future.
But really? Surely there's a better way than this unless its the only option left?
Help me accept this is the way it is at secondary please!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Glittertwins · 30/11/2021 09:25

@FallonCarringtonWannabe
Maybe a focus on the bottom line is what is needed

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 29/11/2021 18:45

@Glittertwins

Just from the other point of view, our DS was the unfortunate "victim" of a silly bundle. It resulted in a call from school to take him to A&E because he hit his head on the ground. He lost most of the school day, DH and I lost the same time from work waiting in shifts with him at the hospital between us. That's a heck of a lot more hours lost of education and working than a child learning in isolation
Perhaps op would prefer to be billed for you and your dh’s loss of earnings? And also the cost of a tutor for half a day.

And maybe parents would prefer to be billed for damage caused by their children, too, instead of a punishment that doesnt actually solve the issue of things needing paying for out of already stretched budgets.

The child does not return to school until all bills are paid.

FrippEnos · 29/11/2021 18:20

@MrsLargeEmbodied

ds got in trouble for throwing equipment in year 7

it was a pencil

We had a child throw a rubber. We because of that we also had a child that is blind in one eye.

It wasn't done on purpose but that was the outcome.

From bundles we have had bruises, cuts, broken arms, ribs and legs.

Its very similar to why kids are no longer allowed to play bulldog at break.

JustLyra · 29/11/2021 17:35

I do think this is quite indicative of what schools face a lot of the time.

There’s a new, dangerous, thing becoming a problem so they come down hard on it… and get shit from parents for doing so.

Glittertwins · 29/11/2021 16:58

Just from the other point of view, our DS was the unfortunate "victim" of a silly bundle.
It resulted in a call from school to take him to A&E because he hit his head on the ground. He lost most of the school day, DH and I lost the same time from work waiting in shifts with him at the hospital between us. That's a heck of a lot more hours lost of education and working than a child learning in isolation

sillysmiles · 29/11/2021 14:21

If he fails his exams for one day of seclusion - he was never going to pass anything anyway.

It's one day.

I think it is important to note that in secondary school environment - your child is not a beautiful and unique snowflake and no one has time to truly understand the deeper meaning of his misbehaviour.
Plan silly games win silly prizes.

bangonandupwego · 27/11/2021 17:09

@IWentAwayIStayedAway

Would love to know what you'd be looking done if it was your child bullied in the playground. Hope he is spending weekend with no tech catching up with school work and writing a letter of apology to the child in question. Thats what my child would be doing
The child being"bundled" had done the bundling first so no one is coming out of this well.
IWentAwayIStayedAway · 27/11/2021 13:53

Would love to know what you'd be looking done if it was your child bullied in the playground. Hope he is spending weekend with no tech catching up with school work and writing a letter of apology to the child in question. Thats what my child would be doing

Larryyourwaiter · 27/11/2021 13:04

The thing is a rule is a rule. It doesn’t matter if this was the first time your child did this or the tenth. It’s a rule.

I work in a school where isolation has been suspended to staff shortages and it’s a fucking nightmare. Lots of these children are now being housed in the student support room and disrupting those students instead.
Lots of silliness is dangerous and upsetting for others.

To be honest the main issue has been the amount of staff time lost with no isolation room. It was a sharp shock for some and now it’s having a huge knock on in staff sorting out issues and managing students, rather than them being in one room.

JustLyra · 27/11/2021 12:15

No-one was missing out on learning because of OP's child. The incident leading to this was in the playground.

Someone would have missed out on learning when they got hurt

Branleuse · 27/11/2021 11:52

@Skyll

I’m sorry but you’re minimising what your son did.

I hope he has learnt from this.

11 year old boys doing a bundle in the playground. Hardly outrageous.
Embracelife · 27/11/2021 09:27

If he doesn't want seclusion he needs to walk away from trouble and silliness
Lesson learnt
He was doing work sheets.
He may have learned something

Somebodylikeyew · 27/11/2021 09:04

Your son was involved in a physical bullying incident.

The punishment sounds ENTIRELY reasonable to me, and I’d be grateful to the school for taking such a strong position.

Skyll · 27/11/2021 08:39

I’m sorry but you’re minimising what your son did.

I hope he has learnt from this.

LolaSmiles · 27/11/2021 08:34

No-one was missing out on learning because of OP's child. The incident leading to this was in the playground

Children have the right to be safe on the school site at break and lunch.
These bundles are dangerous and are a harm risk.

Why should children feel unsafe in school and on edge in case others pile on them for a laugh?

RoseAndRose · 27/11/2021 08:13

One day in internal detention is not going to wreck his education.

Indeed, if it stops him from further physical bullying that risks real harm to the person picked on who is at the bottom) it might even help it in the long run. Because he might not then need repeated sanctions for threatening behaviour

Platax · 27/11/2021 07:39

@SandraOhh

Why should other children miss out on learning because of your child? Seclusion/isolation are used in lots of schools for this very reason.
No-one was missing out on learning because of OP's child. The incident leading to this was in the playground.
SandraOhh · 27/11/2021 00:28

Why should other children miss out on learning because of your child? Seclusion/isolation are used in lots of schools for this very reason.

JustLyra · 26/11/2021 23:54

I his defence, the child who bundled had initiated one on another child first. Not saying it's right or acceptable but I do know (from the teacher) that was the case. No one has come out of this well!

So there were two serious incidents in a short space of time - that'll be why the school cracked down hard and fast on those involved.

One of my children's best friends ended up with two broken wrists and stitches in their head after one of these 'bundles'. Another child in the same incident had bruised ribs.

They're not jolly japes - they're really bloody dangerous.

Branleuse · 26/11/2021 22:38

I dont think either detention or isolation work great as punishments, but what else do teachers have? Not allowed to throw board rubbers at them anymore or whack their knuckles with a ruler.
It is hard for year 7s when they get this for the first time

oviraptor21 · 26/11/2021 22:34

Not in the least difficult - if anything, it's easier to organise in a secondary school where you have more staff and space, and frequently have staff with specific responsibility for behaviour. The school just has to arrange a detention room for each day's miscreants, and a rota for staff to cover it.

Have fun wasting lots of time getting the miscreants to turn up each break time for a week.

esloquehay · 26/11/2021 19:40

Were the other kids involved in the bundle sent to seclusion as well?

BoredZelda · 26/11/2021 19:21

It was mentioned on the school Facebook parents group, lots of parents asked their children and they all said yes they're locked and the teacher has to use a key card to open them in the same way as the internal door. So not locked as in can't be used at all, but can only be opened by someone with a key card.

Important to note, a fire escape or fire door cannot legally be locked, unless linked to a building management system which will auto unlock these doors in the event of the fire alarm sounding.

doggieflooflove · 26/11/2021 18:12

@drpaddington

This is appalling, are you sure that they lock the fire escapes ?

It was mentioned on the school Facebook parents group, lots of parents asked their children and they all said yes they're locked and the teacher has to use a key card to open them in the same way as the internal door. So not locked as in can't be used at all, but can only be opened by someone with a key card.

I imagine it works on an internal warning system, so that if the fire alarm is activated the doors will open / unlock automatically, much like the fire doors that are held open magnetically but the close automatically when the fire alarm goes off.
OP posts:
drpaddington · 26/11/2021 17:29

This is appalling, are you sure that they lock the fire escapes ?

It was mentioned on the school Facebook parents group, lots of parents asked their children and they all said yes they're locked and the teacher has to use a key card to open them in the same way as the internal door. So not locked as in can't be used at all, but can only be opened by someone with a key card.