Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you get a birthday present?

114 replies

Nippyintheair · 24/11/2021 20:17

Off your Dh/Dp & parents?

I rarely get from either, just wondering if this is normal..

Birthday a couple of days ago, card from parents with them writing inside that they owe me a present, usually give my money when they see me (I live abroad)

Dp got me a card and cake. Doesn’t organise or ask if i want us (and toddler) to go out or what I want for dinner. It’s more or less another, normal day.
For him, I plan what to buy a month or so before, cards, usually bake a cake with toddler Dd, or order a specially made one, never the same old one I receive from the supermarket. I put balloons up and usually cook something nice if it’s during the week or plan a nice lunch or at least a takeaway etc.

He knows how much it bothers/upsets me, some years he has a present, others not. I’ve spoken to him about making more effort now we have Dd and maybe including her in things..it never changes.
It’s not about what the present is, I can buy myself something if I like, it’s 100% the thought and effort.

As it was, I planned and went out for lunch with Dd and have planned to meet friends at the weekend. Always so embarrassing when they ask what he planned/what I got too.

Is this normal?

OP posts:
WildStallyn · 25/11/2021 09:34

DH is really thoughtful. Always a well chosen gift, and he takes the DC out to choose me a little something too. And we usually get a babysitter and go to a gig with a meal beforehand.

My parents always buy me gifts too.

ddl1 · 25/11/2021 09:33

Honestly if my DP ignored/forgot/couldn’t be arsed it would be a complete dealbreaker for me.

Well, if mine insisted on making a fuss of my birthday, after I'd made it clear that I want it totally forgotten, it would be a complete dealbreaker for me! Everyone's different, and people, especially partners, should respect and try to accommodate to each other's wishes, once they know them. Which it sounds as though OP's dh isn't doing.

ddl1 · 25/11/2021 09:29

Well, I think you are both a bit extreme. Even if he is not a birthday person, he should listen to you when you say it's important to you to have yours acknowledged. On the other hand, when you say that 'This just ruins all my enthusiasm and joy for life' - either you're focussing on just one symptom of a problematic relationship, or if your joy in life really DOES depend on celebrating people's birthdays, then that is very intense and extreme. You can demand that others who are close to you acknowledge your birthday in a thoughtful way, out of respect for its importance to you; but you cannot demand that they share your enthusiasm for birthdays as such. Maybe you need to have a frank discussion with your dh, where not only do you re-emphasize the importance of your birthday to you, but you ask him to tell you just what he wants for his: it may be that 'nothing at all' would be fine with him.

lastqueenofscotland · 25/11/2021 09:27

Yes. Honestly if my DP ignored/forgot/couldn’t be arsed it would be a complete dealbreaker for me.

dottiedodah · 25/11/2021 09:27

I think to say outright that you would like some cards ,pressies ,outings whatever . Is he a good dh the rest of the time? Maybe tell him some things you would like.many people seem to not celebrate bd as they are adults .it seems a shame .

gannett · 25/11/2021 09:26

Two other aspects...

DP and I spoil each other fairly frequently throughout the year. Little treats, thoughtful gestures etc. That's probably a reason neither of us put much stock in actual birthdays. Does your husband make you feel special generally?

Also, if you have a DD then you've presumably had many birthdays as a couple. Did you tell him early on how you felt about birthdays? After a few years of this low-effort approach why did you think he'd change?

BloodyAlarms · 25/11/2021 09:20

We don't do valentines or anniversaries but we give expensive (£250 ish) gifts to each other for Xmas and birthdays (but don't give cards).

I always get gifts from my parents - usually chocolate, flowers and a voucher.

FlickyCrumble · 25/11/2021 09:16

Take the energy you put into his birthday and use it for your own. If he only gets you a card then do the same. So he will notice? fine tell him the truth.

For your birthday i wouldn't do the martyr thing of cooking my own meal. Order your own take out. Take your dd for slap up lunch.

My point is don't wait around for him to change he won't. Is he the same at christmas?

Nippyintheair · 25/11/2021 09:14

Also, I involve Dd in it more, we’d put a few balloons up, I’d get her to bring the cake with me and she gets all excited, he doesn’t do any of that

OP posts:
Nippyintheair · 25/11/2021 09:11

@1u1a That sounds amazing 💜that’s more the sort of thing I’d plan or expect to, even half of that would be nice

OP posts:
Dogscanteatonions · 25/11/2021 09:11

We spoil each other for birthdays. Weekend away and presents and meal out on the actual day if it's not the weekend

Nippyintheair · 25/11/2021 09:10

The thing is, asking me what’s wrong? He knew fully what was wrong and then seemed almost angry with me for not looking happy/appreciative! 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Waxonwaxoff0 · 25/11/2021 08:59

I'm single but I get presents from my mum. I'm an only child and we are close, she likes to treat me on my birthday and vice versa.

1u1a · 25/11/2021 08:53

OP, it was my birthday the other day. At 7am, DH came in with a massive cake with candles in it and all 4 kids and they were playing the Stevie Womder, Happy Birthday song. I had a mimosa in bed! He hardly knows his to use the coffee machine, but he’s made a coffee (of sorts) and crumpets and fruit. They had all written me cards. I had lovely flowers and a diamond bracelet to match the ring he gave me last year. Plus other things from Ortigia from the kids. We went for lunch and a lovely Autumn walk down the Thames. The night before we had been into town to a restaurant he’d booked. He’s also booked afternoon tea for me and some girlfriends at the coming weekend.

This is normal. Most couples enjoy spoiling each other. Why not?

The kids love birthdays - their own and mine / his. I always made a big deal of their birthdays so it’s normal for them to want to reciprocate - they get excited and enjoy it. My husband grew up with not a lot, but he realises these things are important since he met me and had children so he makes an effort. It’s really not that hard to grasp.

I think in your position I would kick up such a stink it would be literally make or break. I feel angry in your behalf because you deserve so much better.

gannett · 25/11/2021 08:49

We don't usually do birthday presents, we take each other out for a fancy restaurant meal. Established very early on that this is what we both prefer to give and prefer to receive. Over the years this isn't even tied to the birthday date any more, my dinner was two months after my birthday this year (I was snowed under with work in my birthday week and on the only free day a friend organised a leaving party) and I'm three months overdue with DP's (a lot of life stuff has been happening and he said he'd prefer a raincheck when it's all sorted).

We give each other smaller presents for Xmas, sometimes just cheap in-jokey things. Rarely anything huge - both DP and I are the sort who like to make our own decisions about, or at least have input into, substantial/expensive things.

That's just being compatible though. I think I'd find it very hard work to go out with someone who expected a big song and dance made about them, or who used phrases like "ruins all my enthusiasm and joy for life" about a birthday.

EmeraldShamrock · 25/11/2021 08:47

They're not very thoughtful I'd be upset in your shoes.
It depends on our finances from DP, we're good with that.
Always from siblings and parents when parents they were here, I buy for them all too.

RoyKentsHairyBack · 25/11/2021 08:40

My family is a birthday family - bit of a fuss, pressie and cake.

DHs family less so - phone call and card.

DH expects no fuss but gets a small one (coffee in bed, taken out for lunch and a small sock based present).

DH then makes sure I get the same type of fuss as well because he knows I value it. He probably still couldn't tell you the date of my birthday despite having been together for 20 years mind.

Nippyintheair · 25/11/2021 08:34

Dp asked what was wrong with me and if I was ok, he knew full well, but still he continues. One card from the card shop from both of them and the fuss he made over her being the one to choose it. I honestly think he thought that was a good enough effort. As I said, not concerned about cost etc, but all in all was probably about £7 spent

Dd will notice more as the years go on, how does that look?

OP posts:
Nippyintheair · 25/11/2021 08:32

The worst thing was that even my Dd, 3, asked where my presents were and asked when I’m going to open my presents. What could I say? Dp said ‘Well she hasn’t got any yet’ implying I’d get some or something..but of course, I didn’t

OP posts:
Nippyintheair · 24/11/2021 23:29

@Sceptre86 Yes I’m the same and about others birthdays too, I love to make special touches for DD’s birthday and for him, or at least, I did. This just ruins all my enthusiasm and joy for life, which sounds dramatic, but it’s true

OP posts:
Nippyintheair · 24/11/2021 23:27

By the way, nothing wrong with shop bought cakes, in the U.K. there are lots of lovely ones, just not really where we are. It’s inevitable that I nearly always receive the same small, flat chocolate cake with sprinkles on

OP posts:
Nippyintheair · 24/11/2021 23:25

@Babdoc That’s my problem, he’s not too fussed so a card and a cake would be fine for him. The only way to have real impact would be to do nothing at all, don’t know if I can actually do that and with Dd witnessing that too now

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 24/11/2021 23:24

Your issue is your partner but is this something you would leave him over? Being inconsiderate, lazy even? For me birthdays too are more special than other events and my dh knows that as I've made it quite clear. I am almost child like in my excitement for my birthday and whilst not massively fussed about my present I always want to go for dinner out or a weekend away. This year we couldn't go away as I had a baby 3 weeks before my birthday but dh cooked, ordered cake and made a special card from the kids. I didn't need to lift a finger which was very much appreciated. We all got dressed up and had a fun day at home.

My dh doesn't much care for his birthday but I still do things to make it special to show effort and care. He always shows his appreciation.

LitCrit · 24/11/2021 23:09

[quote Nippyintheair]@LitCrit Yes, he can be. It’s honestly like he either just doesn’t get it or cba[/quote]
Then that's your real problem and the birthday is a red herring, I reckon. I don't think men like this change unfortunately, and although lots of women stay because they don't want that to be true, they end up wasting years of their lives.

felulageller · 24/11/2021 23:09

I think your right to be upset with DP about this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread