Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think taking a baby to Parliament is ridiculous?

364 replies

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 16:33

Stella Creasy MP taking her baby to the Commons - I think it is utterly ridiculous.

Everyone else has to find childcare. Labour have lost the plot and don’t seem to care what people think (I say this as a life long Labour vote who cannot stomach voting for Labour as it now is). Parliament even have a nursery! www.parliament.uk/about/working/nursery/

OP posts:
APurpleSquirrel · 24/11/2021 18:52

@sashagabadon

I agree she is not doing women on may leave particularly any favours. Mat leave is for resting and bonding with your baby not commuting into central London with baby in a sling to work. We should be discouraging women bringing their babies to work not encouraging them. Especially women with privilege or employers will see a nice loophole for less privileged women that can’t choose so easily. I would have hated to have the expectation on me that I “ can bring my baby to work”. No thank you. I was getting phone calls at home the day after I gave birth to my second child, that was bad enough. I think Stella has got this wrong
But that's not the point she's making. She's trying to highlight the fact that for MPs, whether on mat leave, off sick etc there is no facility for them to carry on their duties or find adequate cover. If she took the 6 months mat leave offered, she would not be able to represent her constituents for the duration of the leave. She would need to arrange a Proxy Vote companion which can be difficult to arrange & has been renegaded on before (as I understand). The law prevents her from employing someone else to cover her duties & her staff can only do so much - they can't vote for example. If she wishes to continue voting on her constituents behalf or speak in the HoC she has to attend therefore she is working & not on mat leave. & she has a tiny baby who is breastfed. The same applies to those MPs off sick etc in that they can't represent their constituents unless they attend the HoC. However during the pandemic MPs were allowed to vote remotely. But this has been removed & until Sept several MPs have brought babies into the HoC including a male MP without incident, & it's only because of a recent changes to their rule book that children have been prohibited. Considering there have been many cases of mostly male MPs either asleep or drunk in the HoC I think implying Stella can't do her job/pay attention etc whilst carrying a sleeping baby is laughable.
Ajl46 · 24/11/2021 18:50

@iawbuwes

It is unreasonable for elected representatives not to be given maternity leave - they are elected as individuals. But if they are speaking in parliament they can surely find childcare for that time period. And maybe your term in parliament is not the ideal time to have a baby, give that your focus is meant to be on your constituents.
Excluding representation of a significant portion of the country (working mothers) from Parliament is a massive step backwards. We need greater diversity amongst our elected representatives, not less.
wincarwoo · 24/11/2021 18:50

@Pinkandpink

wincarwoo

iawbuwes
On a basic salary of £81,932 she can afford a bloody nanny!

No. She couldn't.
Bookmark

Why not? People on a fraction of that wage have to cough up for childcare.

Not a nanny.
julieca · 24/11/2021 18:46

@NeverForgetYourDreams I am sorry you had to, that must have been hard.

Pinkandpink · 24/11/2021 18:46

wincarwoo

iawbuwes
On a basic salary of £81,932 she can afford a bloody nanny!

No. She couldn't.
Bookmark

Why not? People on a fraction of that wage have to cough up for childcare.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 24/11/2021 18:46

@iawbuwes

@ BewareTheBeardedDragon yes but she wasn’t breastfeeding!
Imagine the hoo har if she had been. I didn't mean physically in the house - I assume she is ebf and that is why she has child with her in sling. I would expect that she knew her baby would sleep on her but would raise Merry hell with someone else - my daughter used to be like that. Reliably silent in her sling, predictably loud and distressed outside it. Perhaps I'm wrong. But I trust that as a mother she knew what was best for her child, and that it would work alongside effectively doing her job, which it appears to have done.
VladmirsPoutine · 24/11/2021 18:45

I haven't read the whole thread but there practically next to zero workplaces in which it would be practical to bring a baby.

SomePosters · 24/11/2021 18:45

In your own opinion maybe

NeverForgetYourDreams · 24/11/2021 18:42

[quote julieca]@TalkToTheHand123 her baby is three months old and she is breastfeeding. Would you leave a 3-month old in a nursery? I wouldnt.[/quote]
I had to .....

gogohm · 24/11/2021 18:42

The issue is that whilst on maternity leave their constituents would have no mp - you cannot take part in debates virtually, though you can vote by proxy, there's no budget for maternity cover. Babies under 6 months especially if breastfed need to be with their mother, if it's good enough for the prime minister of New Zealand at the un, why not in parliament! It's not a normal job. I'm sure she will use the nursery (assuming there's a space) once her baby is older

sashagabadon · 24/11/2021 18:39

I see it is all part of a “feminist” agenda that pregnancy, birth and babies are not important, so easy that you can bring them into work the minute they are born. It’s all a breeze! No pregnancy, birth and babies are hard hard work for many and this time is sacred and should be respected. Leave mums alone! Let them enjoy their mat leave in peace. I am a working mum of two and had 6 months both times and I loved it.
We work for years, let’s not normalise spending our mat leaves at work Confused

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 18:34

@sashagabadon

I agree she is not doing women on may leave particularly any favours. Mat leave is for resting and bonding with your baby not commuting into central London with baby in a sling to work. We should be discouraging women bringing their babies to work not encouraging them. Especially women with privilege or employers will see a nice loophole for less privileged women that can’t choose so easily. I would have hated to have the expectation on me that I “ can bring my baby to work”. No thank you. I was getting phone calls at home the day after I gave birth to my second child, that was bad enough. I think Stella has got this wrong
Good point
OP posts:
sashagabadon · 24/11/2021 18:33

I agree she is not doing women on may leave particularly any favours. Mat leave is for resting and bonding with your baby not commuting into central London with baby in a sling to work. We should be discouraging women bringing their babies to work not encouraging them. Especially women with privilege or employers will see a nice loophole for less privileged women that can’t choose so easily.
I would have hated to have the expectation on me that I “ can bring my baby to work”. No thank you. I was getting phone calls at home the day after I gave birth to my second child, that was bad enough.
I think Stella has got this wrong

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 18:32

@ wincarwoo if she was really trying to do her job she would have a nanny to take her child when she is in the chamber. But that is not a good photo opportunity..

OP posts:
Dishwashersaurous · 24/11/2021 18:32

And just to say again. This issue isn't just about maternity leave. It's about MP who can't get to parliament for multiple reasons- cancer treatment or other sickness.

There needs to be a system in place to accommodate people temporarily being away. And during covid there was and it worked well

mbosnz · 24/11/2021 18:31

I'd like to ask where is the actual evidence that she is less effective at her job with a sleeping baby strapped to her front, as opposed to the assumption?

Now, I know about all the what if's, but the baby didn't cry, as far as I know, or in any other way impact her performing her duties - and she was awake, and engaged and focussed on what she was doing, as opposed to far too many MP's, far too often.

Ardern has managed to run a country while having a baby and breastfeeding, and numerous MP's in NZ have had babes sleeping on their chests while the house was sitting - indeed the speaker has held a sleeping babe in his arms in NZ while the house was in session. It's only an issue if you want it to be an issue. It can actually be the norm, and a functional one.

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 18:31

@ Tal45 have the baby but don’t make a show if it. Makes people less likely elect younger women, whatever we may wish. She has put us back years

OP posts:
wincarwoo · 24/11/2021 18:30

@iawbuwes

@ wincarwoo thanks for you concern but I do - I realise that the cause is not won by this type of self indulgent symbolism that just again marks women as ‘only’ mothers. She is doing us no favours. I say this from a number of years experience across govt, academia, charitable and private sectors.
How is she "only" a mother (nothing wrong with that btw) when she is at work and trying to do her job.
Krii · 24/11/2021 18:30

There should be better maternity options for MPs. It's not professional to take a baby, but there's a lot of stuff in the hoc that falls into that catagory.

CactusFlowers · 24/11/2021 18:29

@Dishwashersaurous

1. She can not get maternity cover to do a vital part of her job.
  1. Therefore she has to do that vital part of the job.
  1. In order to do that she needs to physically bring the tiny breastfeeding baby with her to do it.

The actual issue is that there is no mechanism to allow part of the job, in many ways the key part, without it being the physical presence of the MP.

That's why for key debates people have been brought in on the back of ambulances too ill to Stan in order to vote.

During COvid there was a facility to speak and vote remotely.

All that is required is to maintain that facility MPs who needed it, whether on sick leave, family leave or any other reason.

I agree.
iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 18:29

@ sst1234 totally agree

OP posts:
Tal45 · 24/11/2021 18:28

@DartmoorChef

Nobody forced her to be an MP, and nobody forced her to have a baby either. They were her choices and I don't believe that having a potentially crying child in the house of commons is professional.
Goodness you are right nobody forced her to be an MP and have a baby, it would be so much better if MP's didn't have babies, we need more professional people to be MP's, ones that don't have to bother with babies....like.......men. Yes!! only men should be MP's because there's no need for them to be worrying about childcare or what to do with their breast feeding baby at 3 months because they have women for those things.

Men are much better suited to important roles like being MP's because they are more professional and don't have babies. This is also true of almost all high powered jobs so they should also be men only. Silly women thinking they could ever be professional enough when they do rash things like give birth.

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 18:28

@ wincarwoo thanks for you concern but I do - I realise that the cause is not won by this type of self indulgent symbolism that just again marks women as ‘only’ mothers. She is doing us no favours. I say this from a number of years experience across govt, academia, charitable and private sectors.

OP posts:
wincarwoo · 24/11/2021 18:27

@Drumshambo

The whole thing is utterly embarrassing. She could get Childcare like everyone else. It's an attention seeking stunt!
Really? How is it embarrassing. I'll assume you've been calling for BJs resignation for years
sst1234 · 24/11/2021 18:27

@Drumshambo

The whole thing is utterly embarrassing. She could get Childcare like everyone else. It's an attention seeking stunt!
Exactly. It’s an ‘ooh look at me. Aren’t I progressive in paving the way for women’. Perfect for Instagram. Women like her are embarrassing and diminish the achievements of other women who do things rather than pull stunts.