Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think taking a baby to Parliament is ridiculous?

364 replies

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 16:33

Stella Creasy MP taking her baby to the Commons - I think it is utterly ridiculous.

Everyone else has to find childcare. Labour have lost the plot and don’t seem to care what people think (I say this as a life long Labour vote who cannot stomach voting for Labour as it now is). Parliament even have a nursery! www.parliament.uk/about/working/nursery/

OP posts:
emeraldcity2000 · 24/11/2021 22:14

@Heidipi

“Maybe your term in parliament is not the ideal time to have a baby, give that your focus is meant to be on your constituents.”

You’re quite right OP, women of childbearing age should not be MPs. There is plenty of time before the age of 16 and after the age of 45 to pursue a political career. I wonder if Stella could consider voluntary work instead - baking, sewing, a committee or two - when her baby is old enough of course. Leave it to the chaps for now, eh love?

JFC.

Agree totally. We should probably go back to the good old days when women gave up work once they married let alone had children.
Eleganz · 24/11/2021 22:14

The problem here is lack of maternity cover and that is the point she is making. She should be able to ensure that her 90,000 constituents are adequately represented in parliament whilst she is on maternity leave. Currently that isn't the case and if she were to take maternity leave her constituency would be unrepresented for the duration and her party would be down a vote for the duration. That is really not a way to encourage women who want to start a family into politics. Of course she doesn't really want to be there weeks after giving birth with a bf-ing baby but she feels she has no choice.

PinkMochi · 24/11/2021 22:08

@NamechangeApril21 she earns £82k

“Kizzy Gardiner, an ex-charity worker and local Labour party member, stood in for Creasy everywhere but the Commons chamber (which, as an unelected person, she couldn’t lawfully enter). The arrangement worked well but Creasy felt guilty that her stand-in wasn’t paid anywhere near an MP’s rate, so after she got pregnant again last autumn, she applied for another locum on closer to her £82,000 salary. Ipsa refused to authorise more than £60,000”

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/politics/2021/oct/30/stella-creasy-lonely-maternity-cover-battle-women-should-be-able-have-kids-do-politics

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2021 22:02

Why doesn't Parliament simply provide for nursing mothers or those suffering with ill health by giving them an opportunity to join debates and vote online? It can be done.

The Times reported a broad spread of support for reconsidering current rules - Johnson was quoted as being in favour of a review.

MP's are not employed by Parliament. Employers are not going to suggest employees should behave like MP's any more than they will offer on site tea rooms, bars and expenses for lunch.

TooBigForMyBoots · 24/11/2021 21:46

AFAIK, Stella Creasy isn't doing it alone, but on this occasion she needed to be there and was. Women of childbearing age are amongst our best and brightest we need them in the workplace. I am astounded at the flack SC has received from some women for doing her job.Shock And I am ShockShockShock at the negative reaction from posters who claim feminist credentials.

Heidipi · 24/11/2021 21:13

“Maybe your term in parliament is not the ideal time to have a baby, give that your focus is meant to be on your constituents.”

You’re quite right OP, women of childbearing age should not be MPs. There is plenty of time before the age of 16 and after the age of 45 to pursue a political career. I wonder if Stella could consider voluntary work instead - baking, sewing, a committee or two - when her baby is old enough of course. Leave it to the chaps for now, eh love?

JFC.

Moonwatcher1234 · 24/11/2021 21:07

@forinborin

I am a working mother. I don't understand the point she's trying to make. I don't like the message that a full-time job with lots of responsibility can be done in parallel to looking after the needs of a 3 month old baby without any childcare. Because it cannot, and this message doesn't help working mothers at all.
This ten-fold. Our bosses will just think, well if an MP can carry on working with a baby in tow, why can’t the rest of them. Counter-productive and unhelpful.
SickAndTiredAgain · 24/11/2021 20:26

@disconnected101

Wasn't there a recent case of an M.P. in England, perhaps London, who was going to have to resign after she had a baby because she wasn't entitled to maternity leave. Did that not lead to a change in the rules in Westminster?
Yes, the attorney general. I think because she was a minister there were slightly different rules and she would have had to resign as attorney general.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-55933388.amp

CountessLovelace · 24/11/2021 20:24

@mbosnz

Given the childish behaviour of far too many of the elected representatives in the house (including eating and sleeping, and playing games on their phone, in between their temper tanties and verbal attacks on other members) I feel the baby and its mother were pattern cards of rectitude in comparison.

Perhaps the 'honourable' members should take note, and seek to model their behaviours on the mother and the child, actually showing up to do her work, and both behaving appropriately, while there.

We live in a world where a woman can be Prime Minister, have a baby, and continue to work effectively, while breastfeeding. Shouldn't we be embracing this?

In contrast to a Prime Minister whose what number wife had what number child and went MIA for how long during a fucking pandemic?

Well said.
disconnected101 · 24/11/2021 20:20

Wasn't there a recent case of an M.P. in England, perhaps London, who was going to have to resign after she had a baby because she wasn't entitled to maternity leave.
Did that not lead to a change in the rules in Westminster?

C8H10N4O2 · 24/11/2021 20:20

Westminster is still a boys club with boys club rules.

The problem here is nothing to do with maternity pay but the boys club rules which don't allow women on maternity or sick MPs receiving treatment to employ a proxy or vote remotely. There is no creche on site which takes babies of 13 weeks (even if you have one of the few places) and a creche wouldn't address the issues in the past of MPs on chemotherapy also being unable to employ a proxy.

However I'm mightily entertained by the radical feminists who think the solution to a problem created entirely by a boys club rule, is to keep women out of the club. In my day we used to campaign to get women into the club in the hope of better overall representation, not lobby to keep them out and meekly comply with rules created by men.

disconnected101 · 24/11/2021 20:19

Oops forgot to add link
www.carolsmyth.co.uk/breastfeeding-resources/posts/2016/july/open-letter-to-sammy-wilson/

disconnected101 · 24/11/2021 20:18

I'm in N.I.
This was written by an IBCLC from here after Sammy Wilson's 'voyeurism' and 'exhibitionism' comments about breastfeeding in parliament from about 5 years ago.
I think it hits the nail on the head around this issue.
I hope it's ok to post it here, as it is an open letter shared on her online blog which is available for anyone to read.

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 20:14

@mbosnz

Well, I've known two lawyers, one a senior associate, the other a partner, who took their babies to work with them. There was a cot in the corner of their office.
In what country?
OP posts:
FindingMeno · 24/11/2021 20:03

She's breastfeeding and if she is in a situation where she is required to fulfill duties/ responsibilities , this need should be accommodated.
Surely we can accept this?

NamechangeApril21 · 24/11/2021 19:56

@PinkMochi

Imagine earning over £80k a year and moaning about having to pay for childcare.
Well she isn't so there's that.
PinkMochi · 24/11/2021 19:53

Imagine earning over £80k a year and moaning about having to pay for childcare.

supermoonrising · 24/11/2021 19:50

@rossclare
Boris hasn’t taken his baby in to the commons in a sling
Which is a shame as if he did he’d actually be making a positive contribution to society, something he’s really struggled at in his professional roles.

VestaTilley · 24/11/2021 19:49

I agree. Parliament now has a nursery on site and the rest of the country isn’t allowed to take their baby to work.

TooBigForMyBoots · 24/11/2021 19:45

It is not about noise or disruption it is the fact that she makes working mothers look like fools.

How?Shock She took her baby to work to vote. No noise or disruption from the baby. She was a new mother, capably doing the job she was elected to do.

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 24/11/2021 19:45

You’re totally missing the point. Most people don’t or can’t leave their tiny baby (hers isn’t even 4months old!). She has to because otherwise her constituents won’t be represented in parliament because of antiquated rules. Basically MPs can’t really go on proper maternity leave. That’s why she’s bringing her baby in. She’d much rather be at home with her baby for 6 months but she can’t nominated anyone else do this for her.

NamechangeApril21 · 24/11/2021 19:34

@cunningplan101

I really don't get people who argue -

"She can only do this because she has privilege. I mean, I had to put my baby in a nursery as soon as it took its first breath. Straight out of the labour ward and over to the nanny. Who does she think she is?"

Because, if you resent that you had to put a very young child into nursery during what was is essentially its fourth trimester, who on earth do you think has the power to change that? Who can bring in laws to get women better rights and conditions? Or even legislation to bring down UK childcare costs so they're not among the most expensive in the world?

Bloody MPs!

And what life experience might make an MP more likely to empathise with and prioritise the rights of mothers?

Hm, perhaps recently giving birth?

But you want to make it more difficult for young women to become MPs. Because that'll help improve women's lot.

This.
mbosnz · 24/11/2021 19:29

@LunaTheCat

I cannot believe that another woman would think or voice these thoughts about another woman! Of course she should bring her very young baby! The baby should be with its Mum!
Sadly, far too many people staunchly seem to believe a woman's place is in the wrong. Including far too many women.
LunaTheCat · 24/11/2021 19:27

I cannot believe that another woman would think or voice these thoughts about another woman!
Of course she should bring her very young baby! The baby should be with its Mum!

JustLyra · 24/11/2021 19:26

@Dishwashersaurous

She doesn't want to take her baby to work!

She wants there to be a locum or remote arrangement to provide cover for Mps who are on leave, whether sick, maternity, paternity or compassionate leave.

What she is highlighting is that because there isn't a system in place she has to bring her baby with her.

And if she can't bring her baby. There is no alternative system. Then her constituency is not represented which isn't fair.

Also she is highlighting that there was a system last time and it’s been removed.