Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think taking a baby to Parliament is ridiculous?

364 replies

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 16:33

Stella Creasy MP taking her baby to the Commons - I think it is utterly ridiculous.

Everyone else has to find childcare. Labour have lost the plot and don’t seem to care what people think (I say this as a life long Labour vote who cannot stomach voting for Labour as it now is). Parliament even have a nursery! www.parliament.uk/about/working/nursery/

OP posts:
NamechangeApril21 · 25/11/2021 10:09

@forinborin

A woman should not be forced into giving up breastfeeding. Especially for a 3 month old baby. Especiallg while supposedly on maternity leave. Especially when there is a workable solution, I.e. voting by proxy or online - a solution prevailed of by men when it suited their circumstances. Welcome to the real world. Women also should not be forced to place their children into childcare; not find any time to spend with them, exhausted from work; feed them quick ready meals instead of wholesome home-cooked meals etc. But all those are quite standard compromises in the life of a working mother. I can't understand the faux outrage about the topic. A woman's career will always be at some expense of her children. And I am saying it as a woman with children and a career.
So because you suffered, future women must also? What about men's careers, are they at the expense of their children?

We need more mothers of young children in Parliament to represent us working mothers, to tackle these issues, and Stella is campaigning to remove unnecessary barriers that are keeping them out of politics.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 10:09

@Neveragain990

Plus, it is quite possible to work flexibly writing documents around baby’s naps or late into night. Flexible working is key to keeping women in the workplace so we begin to see more women aged 40/50+ in white collar jobs. A little flexibility goes a long way to helping women.
This is not flexible working. This is, effectively, working two full time jobs at the same time.
Neveragain990 · 25/11/2021 10:06

Plus, it is quite possible to work flexibly writing documents around baby’s naps or late into night. Flexible working is key to keeping women in the workplace so we begin to see more women aged 40/50+ in white collar jobs. A little flexibility goes a long way to helping women.

Neveragain990 · 25/11/2021 10:04

There will always be haters where politics is concerned. I didn’t say it only involved that but we are talking about sitting in the actual House with a very young baby.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 09:58

Why shouldn’t she take her child, just because she gave birth and is a woman, why should she not be able to do her job which involves sitting down and voting?!
Her job does not involve only sitting down and voting.
Kate Middleton can do her job with a baby on her, as her main duty is being a poster woman for the cause, a baby is not an impediment to that - maybe even an asset. An MP actually has to work (read, analyse, write, communicate), not just sit, smile and push buttons.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 09:55

[quote AudacityBaby]@forinborin The best way to tackle all of those issues is to ensure that people experiencing them can work as elected representatives in charge of law-making. Like Stella Creasy.[/quote]
I was just expressing my view as the (presumed) target audience and no, I don't feel that Ms Creasy is actually furthering the cause with her actions. Quite the opposite, I strongly feel that she's actually destroying the credibility of working mothers, I explained earlier why. And judging from the thread, I am not the only one.

Neveragain990 · 25/11/2021 09:52

I am livid about the reactions to this. Why shouldn’t she take her child, just because she gave birth and is a woman, why should she not be able to do her job which involves sitting down and voting?! The House is known to be out of touch and anti-women. Look at how Theresa May was treated. But the most depressing thing is how women are hating on women because their own lives have been hard! Wake up, your life is hard because of the system e.g. main earner was always male! This is exactly why we should do everything we can to support women to the fullest, not to necessarily bring babies to all workplaces, but to give women options. To empower women! We are fighting every day against discrimination, against the demands of being the multi-tasker who can meet children’s needs as well as our own earning needs. Until we start supporting EVERY woman, we will be held back. And not all men like it, but it is time we stood up for each other, starting here with Stella Creasy.

AudacityBaby · 25/11/2021 09:51

@forinborin The best way to tackle all of those issues is to ensure that people experiencing them can work as elected representatives in charge of law-making. Like Stella Creasy.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 09:49

A woman should not be forced into giving up breastfeeding. Especially for a 3 month old baby. Especiallg while supposedly on maternity leave. Especially when there is a workable solution, I.e. voting by proxy or online - a solution prevailed of by men when it suited their circumstances.
Welcome to the real world. Women also should not be forced to place their children into childcare; not find any time to spend with them, exhausted from work; feed them quick ready meals instead of wholesome home-cooked meals etc. But all those are quite standard compromises in the life of a working mother. I can't understand the faux outrage about the topic.
A woman's career will always be at some expense of her children. And I am saying it as a woman with children and a career.

AudacityBaby · 25/11/2021 09:44

@wtaf37 She is campaigning for proper maternity leave in all work environments. It makes the point a lot better than campaigning by "making alternative arrangements".

wtaf37 · 25/11/2021 09:39

And yes, the sight of a baby at work may be offensive to some people for any number of reasons.
Many people would like to bring their pets to work, but can't because others find them offensive
Or aged parents...
(that was a joke btw)

NamechangeApril21 · 25/11/2021 09:39

@forinborin

Disgusting remark. Ehhh? What is disgusting about it? I stopped with both of mine. All my friends did. It is impractical when you need to be out of the house for 10+ hours. Not ideal, yes, but not the end of the world.
A woman should not be forced into giving up breastfeeding. Especially for a 3 month old baby. Especiallg while supposedly on maternity leave. Especially when there is a workable solution, I.e. voting by proxy or online - a solution prevailed of by men when it suited their circumstances.
wtaf37 · 25/11/2021 09:37

@ABCeasyasdohrayme

Why was it ridiculous?

She was doing her job, the baby was asleep on her. Nothing was disrupted. Is the mere sight of a baby in a workplace somehow offensive?

It may have been asleep at the time, but may not have stayed that way for the duration. Appreciating that we should be campaigning for maternity leave in all work environments, in places where it does not exist due to tradition or bloody-mindedness, parents should be making alternative arrangements
AudacityBaby · 25/11/2021 09:35

I'm extremely sensitive to the MN version of feminism that's really about mothers, not women, and to workplaces that deify parents at everyone else's expense - but this is not that, OP.

The baby is a red herring. Stella's constituents need to be represented in a vote. Stella can have mat leave but she cannot have mat cover. She has to either turn up with the baby, or not do her job. She chose the latter, and if I were her constituent I'd be really glad she did. The rules need to be changed to allow people with different life circumstances - not just maternity, things like disability, illness - to become representatives. It is the only way to achieve a democratic elected body that represents the electorate as a whole, not just the wealthy men with SAHM wives and no health conditions.

I don't know how a feminist can't see this.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 09:28

Disgusting remark.
Ehhh? What is disgusting about it? I stopped with both of mine. All my friends did. It is impractical when you need to be out of the house for 10+ hours. Not ideal, yes, but not the end of the world.

NamechangeApril21 · 25/11/2021 09:27

@forinborin

A 13 week old breastfeeder can't just be left with a nanny for the day, unless you are suggesting a wet nurse? And again, nannies won't help MPs on sick leave. She can afford formula, I'd imagine. Most of mothers returning to work stop breastfeeding. Not ideal, but not terrible either - some compromises must be made.
Disgusting remark.
forinborin · 25/11/2021 09:23

A 13 week old breastfeeder can't just be left with a nanny for the day, unless you are suggesting a wet nurse? And again, nannies won't help MPs on sick leave.
She can afford formula, I'd imagine. Most of mothers returning to work stop breastfeeding. Not ideal, but not terrible either - some compromises must be made.

Dishwashersaurous · 25/11/2021 09:20

It's also a feature of the voting system that we have with individuals in individual constituency. If we had a PR type system, like for the EU parliament or indeed the London assembly then there would be other people to cover her responsibilities so she could have her maternity leave

forinborin · 25/11/2021 09:14

@Notonthestairs

"But you know what people (of any sex) do if their chosen career suddenly does not fit well with parenting responsibilities, and does not pay enough to cover adequate childcare? Well, they quit and someone else suitably qualified takes the job and does it without bringing small babies to work. Even if they are a neurosurgeon or a firefighter. Or an MP."

Or they could just get involved in debates and voting via Teams/online platforms.

I don't think those options are open to firefighters etc.

My point was more about arguments along the lines "but who will look after her constituents, will be they thrown to the wolves?". The same as with the neurosurgeon and the firefighter, if they resign due to family responsibility conflict, other qualified people will come and fill the vacancy. I cannot understand why posters on the thread try to make it that she's in a uniquely difficult situation. Self-employed mothers are in the same position. Most of high-flying career professional women are in the same position.

I am not represented by anyone in the UK as don't have voting rights, but if I were, I wanted my MP not only to press the voting button and dial into debates on Teams, but actually spend her working day analysing, reading, listening to different sides of the story and making an informed judgment.
Is it possible whilst caring for a 3 month old baby in parallel? No. Both are full-time occupations.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/11/2021 08:11

She is paid £82k a year. She has a stand in who does most of the work. All she has to do is appear in the chambers every so often. She can easily afford childcare! All she is doing is displaying her privilege. Most working mothers don’t have the privilege of keeping their salary when they are on leave. They have to either take the reduction in maternity pay or go back to work and arrange childcare

Its nothing to do with maternity pay, it is to do with maternity cover and ensuring her constituents get what they, as tax payers, are paying for - representation.

I find incredible that we could have proxy and remote votes for MPs moonlighting for the BVI whilst on HoC property and that was deemed acceptible but the boys club sez "no" to use of remote or proxies for MPs on chemotherapy, recovering from surgery or in 4th trimester.

A 13 week old breastfeeder can't just be left with a nanny for the day, unless you are suggesting a wet nurse? And again, nannies won't help MPs on sick leave.

Everyone saying "she shouldn't be there" and "Women with children shouldn't be in the House" is simply reinforcing boys club rules when we should be looking at the structures and how they work, not still trying to be mini-men with padded shoulders and power suits.

Notonthestairs · 25/11/2021 08:09

And?

Why shouldn't online voting for nursing mothers/disabled etc be utilised?

NamechangeApril21 · 25/11/2021 08:09

How do you think things for "most working mothers" will change without working mothers in politics?

wincarwoo · 25/11/2021 08:01

@Notonthestairs

"But you know what people (of any sex) do if their chosen career suddenly does not fit well with parenting responsibilities, and does not pay enough to cover adequate childcare? Well, they quit and someone else suitably qualified takes the job and does it without bringing small babies to work. Even if they are a neurosurgeon or a firefighter. Or an MP."

Or they could just get involved in debates and voting via Teams/online platforms.

I don't think those options are open to firefighters etc.

I'm sure I don't need to point out why an MP wouldn't give up her position mid-term.
Athrawes · 25/11/2021 07:57

Was the baby limiting her or anyone else's ability to do their job. If not then what's the issue?
Once the baby gets big/loud/stops sleeping and feeding most of the time, it's an issue.
But a tiny baby basically in the 4th trimester. Not an issue.
I took my baby to work at that age, in a sling, taught teenagers. Breastfed whilst walking and talking and they didn't even notice. Small babies are fairly inconspicuous for short periods of time.

Notonthestairs · 25/11/2021 07:50

Her replacement can't vote which I imagine is a big part of the job. It's not like for like cover.

She can't vote electronically (which they managed over the pandemic).

And she's not representing most working mothers who are employees. She is not an employee. She asking for adaptations for women in politics. Do we want women of childbearing age in politics or not?