Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think taking a baby to Parliament is ridiculous?

364 replies

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 16:33

Stella Creasy MP taking her baby to the Commons - I think it is utterly ridiculous.

Everyone else has to find childcare. Labour have lost the plot and don’t seem to care what people think (I say this as a life long Labour vote who cannot stomach voting for Labour as it now is). Parliament even have a nursery! www.parliament.uk/about/working/nursery/

OP posts:
Cheshirewife · 25/11/2021 11:50

Certain jobs are inevitably all encompassing. I would never dream of standing as an MP while intending to have a child during the relevant parliamentary term, just as I wouldn’t accept a role as CEO or non-exec director of a large company or certain other jobs.

The reality is that you can’t do everything, so life requires some degree of compromise.

I deliberately declined a promotion until my children were a bit older, as I knew I couldn’t devote time to them and give the new role the time and focus my colleagues and the wider business deserved. To do otherwise would have been massively selfish. I’d be similarly disappointed if my MP decided she wanted to take maternity leave or to take a child to her work.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/11/2021 11:49

That's exactly the point I am trying to make - no, showing to work with a baby strapped to her to do her job is not furthering the cause of women in the workplace.
Of course it is. It shows that becoming a mother doesn't mean you can't do your job.

...I don't want this to gradually become the new normal.
It is already quite common with self employed mothers. And some fathers.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 11:46

@Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss

Maternity and illness have the same outcome - long term absence. It’s disingenuous to pretend that most women in UK put 13 week olds in nurseries. They just don’t in the vast majority and for good reason. We also have protections which mean most women don’t have to in order to keep their job. MPs should be able to take maternity leave and have proper cover. She isn’t asking for special treatment. She is asking for the same as everyone else in the country. This policy would then apply to any absence for necessary reasons such a long term illness.
She is in the same position as any self-employed mother really. Not "everyone else" in the UK has a well paid maternity leave. She's actually in a very privileged position compared to most.
Cornettoninja · 25/11/2021 11:44

I don't want this to gradually become the new normal

Then may I suggest that you’re focussing on the wrong thing.

The argument isn’t about whether women should be able to bring a small baby to a workplace but about how to support them to continue their careers without impacting either their baby or their role responsibilities. The solution isn’t, or shouldn’t be, pick one - baby or career as you seem to be suggesting.

Mrsjayy · 25/11/2021 11:44

She was on Lorraine Kelly today, she was saying others had brought babies in she didn't see it as a huge issue baby was in sling just 13 weeks and she had constitute business she wanted to address and wouldn't dream of taking her toddler to the HoC. As I and others have said she doesn't have a regular job she isn't working in an office or supermarket she doesn't have cover to attend parliament for her.

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 25/11/2021 11:38

Maternity and illness have the same outcome - long term absence.
It’s disingenuous to pretend that most women in UK put 13 week olds in nurseries. They just don’t in the vast majority and for good reason. We also have protections which mean most women don’t have to in order to keep their job. MPs should be able to take maternity leave and have proper cover. She isn’t asking for special treatment. She is asking for the same as everyone else in the country. This policy would then apply to any absence for necessary reasons such a long term illness.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 11:38

@TooBigForMyBoots

She can afford formula, I'd imagine. Most of mothers returning to work stop breastfeeding. Not ideal, but not terrible either - some compromises must be made. Not in this case. She turned up to work and did her job. No cost, no fuss, no disruption, no compromises needed. Furthering the cause of women in the workplace is the opposite of the race to the bottom that you seem to be proposing *@forinborin*.
That's exactly the point I am trying to make - no, showing to work with a baby strapped to her to do her job is not furthering the cause of women in the workplace. There's a vet (outside of the UK) who recently got celebrated for doing her job (including operating on animals) with a newborn baby in a sling. I don't want this to gradually become the new normal. After the lockdown it already is assumed that it is ok to work full time and home-school full time in parallel, women complained of course but eventually just did it.
Notonthestairs · 25/11/2021 11:34

Really there is no opportunity for full cover for maternity leave for MP's. So any attempt to draw parallels with employed working mothers falls down.

In which case online debate/voting should be considered for specified circumstances - particularly as this will also benefit those suffering with ill health/disabilities.

NamechangeApril21 · 25/11/2021 11:31

@forinborin

She is not insisting she can do it all, is is highlighting the need for appropriate cover when MPs can not attend, including but not limited to maternity leave, illness, surgery, chemo etc. Are you being deliberately obtuse? The point has seemingly gone over your head on multiple occasions and not once have addressed the actual issue. I am sorry if I sound obtuse because I cannot see what is stopping her from dropping her baby off in the nursery and present for her job just as any other mother does instead of bringing a baby along. It is not that she cannot attend, it is that she does not want to. And fair enough, it is hard to put a small baby into a nursery. Many women quit at this point, and it's quite understandable. There's no magic solution, unfortunately.

Illness and chemotherapy I agree, there has to be a solution, or solutions - I'd imagine that they would be different for a long-term sick leave and a one off absence. But it is a completely different topic, no?

There is a solution, apologies its not magical but boringly straightforward. Allowing voting by proxy or online which has been previously allowed when it's suited men.

Maternity leave is a long term absence.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 11:23

She is not insisting she can do it all, is is highlighting the need for appropriate cover when MPs can not attend, including but not limited to maternity leave, illness, surgery, chemo etc. Are you being deliberately obtuse? The point has seemingly gone over your head on multiple occasions and not once have addressed the actual issue.
I am sorry if I sound obtuse because I cannot see what is stopping her from dropping her baby off in the nursery and present for her job just as any other mother does instead of bringing a baby along. It is not that she cannot attend, it is that she does not want to. And fair enough, it is hard to put a small baby into a nursery. Many women quit at this point, and it's quite understandable. There's no magic solution, unfortunately.

Illness and chemotherapy I agree, there has to be a solution, or solutions - I'd imagine that they would be different for a long-term sick leave and a one off absence. But it is a completely different topic, no?

Cornettoninja · 25/11/2021 11:17

I think MPs should have maternity / paternity leave and pay, and then arrange proper childcare, like everyone else

But that’s the point isn’t it? MP’s can have maternity leave but with that their constituents are left without representation.

TooBigForMyBoots · 25/11/2021 11:13

She can afford formula, I'd imagine. Most of mothers returning to work stop breastfeeding. Not ideal, but not terrible either - some compromises must be made.
Not in this case. She turned up to work and did her job. No cost, no fuss, no disruption, no compromises needed. Furthering the cause of women in the workplace is the opposite of the race to the bottom that you seem to be proposing @forinborin.

notanothertakeaway · 25/11/2021 11:12

@forinborin

I am a working mother. I don't understand the point she's trying to make. I don't like the message that a full-time job with lots of responsibility can be done in parallel to looking after the needs of a 3 month old baby without any childcare. Because it cannot, and this message doesn't help working mothers at all.
Agree with @forinborin

I think MPs should have maternity / paternity leave and pay, and then arrange proper childcare, like everyone else

Working FT while caring for a baby is not feasible

NamechangeApril21 · 25/11/2021 11:04

@forinborin

So because you suffered, future women must also? What about men's careers, are they at the expense of their children? We are specifically discussing women here, no? But everything is equally applicable to men. I of course don't want women to suffer but I want them to be realistic. Bringing a baby to work and insisting you can do it all simultaneously is not a solution. I absolutely cannot see what is to be applauded here.
She is not insisting she can do it all, is is highlighting the need for appropriate cover when MPs can not attend, including but not limited to maternity leave, illness, surgery, chemo etc. Are you being deliberately obtuse? The point has seemingly gone over your head on multiple occasions and not once have addressed the actual issue.
CounsellorTroi · 25/11/2021 11:02

*Locum

CounsellorTroi · 25/11/2021 11:02

@Dishwashersaurous

And actually it is not just maternity leave. There should be a process for MRS on long term sick leave, or compassionate leave or any other reason away from work.

There should be a process for ensuring that the work is done and the constituents represented.

She had a locus MP to cover her constituency work.

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-49922613

MrsColon · 25/11/2021 10:53

@youvegottenminuteslynn

As a "radical feminist" you think its incompatible for women of children bearing age and mothers of young children to be elected representatives?

This. OP you're having a bit of an identity crisis if you think you're a radical feminist.

This with bells on!

There's a lot more to radical feminism than being gender-critical y'know. Hmm

forinborin · 25/11/2021 10:49

[quote Notonthestairs]@forinborin what's wrong with giving her maternity leave a vote and the same pay? [/quote]
I'd imagine the vote thing is because they are not elected democratically, and don't hold the mandate. The pay have no idea, in the industry maternity cover jobs are usually higher paid than the original job itself, so it must be an issue very specific to this situation.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/11/2021 10:39

@Neveragain990

I am livid about the reactions to this. Why shouldn’t she take her child, just because she gave birth and is a woman, why should she not be able to do her job which involves sitting down and voting?! The House is known to be out of touch and anti-women. Look at how Theresa May was treated. But the most depressing thing is how women are hating on women because their own lives have been hard! Wake up, your life is hard because of the system e.g. main earner was always male! This is exactly why we should do everything we can to support women to the fullest, not to necessarily bring babies to all workplaces, but to give women options. To empower women! We are fighting every day against discrimination, against the demands of being the multi-tasker who can meet children’s needs as well as our own earning needs. Until we start supporting EVERY woman, we will be held back. And not all men like it, but it is time we stood up for each other, starting here with Stella Creasy.
^ This. And I'm a man.
Notonthestairs · 25/11/2021 10:36

@forinborin what's wrong with giving her maternity leave a vote and the same pay?

forinborin · 25/11/2021 10:32

That's exactly the opposite of what she's doing. She's bringing her baby into Parliament to highlight that this isnotsustainable, and that the rules need to be changed to allow proper maternity cover as well as maternity leave. She's not campaigning for women to bring babies into workplaces!
But there's already a system she can use. Called childcare. Every other mother in a situation similar to hers uses it. She's in a much better position than most of them as she gets fully paid 6 months of maternity leave, and she has an on-site nursery where she can drop in as often as she likes.
What is wrong with the system as it is?

Notonthestairs · 25/11/2021 10:28

If she could have cover that could vote and be paid the same I don't suppose she'd have been in Parliament at all.

Still don't understand why anyone would resist remote debating & voting for MP's in specified circumstances.

AudacityBaby · 25/11/2021 10:24

@forinborin

So because you suffered, future women must also? What about men's careers, are they at the expense of their children? We are specifically discussing women here, no? But everything is equally applicable to men. I of course don't want women to suffer but I want them to be realistic. Bringing a baby to work and insisting you can do it all simultaneously is not a solution. I absolutely cannot see what is to be applauded here.
That's exactly the opposite of what she's doing. She's bringing her baby into Parliament to highlight that this is not sustainable, and that the rules need to be changed to allow proper maternity cover as well as maternity leave. She's not campaigning for women to bring babies into workplaces!
Russianmax · 25/11/2021 10:20

@AudacityBaby

I'm extremely sensitive to the MN version of feminism that's really about mothers, not women, and to workplaces that deify parents at everyone else's expense - but this is not that, OP.

The baby is a red herring. Stella's constituents need to be represented in a vote. Stella can have mat leave but she cannot have mat cover. She has to either turn up with the baby, or not do her job. She chose the latter, and if I were her constituent I'd be really glad she did. The rules need to be changed to allow people with different life circumstances - not just maternity, things like disability, illness - to become representatives. It is the only way to achieve a democratic elected body that represents the electorate as a whole, not just the wealthy men with SAHM wives and no health conditions.

I don't know how a feminist can't see this.

You are very right @AudacityBaby

I'm a constituent of Stella Creasy. I've been annoyed lately that everything she's spoken up about has been about her and her own issues rather than the many many other concerns that we have in our borough. But I suppose a lot of the time she's been in parliament when she shouldn't have been. She should really have been on maternity leave.

I think what you say is right. Of course it is. 100%.

But I think there is also a balance with Stella. What she is standing up for is part of everything you mention. But she doesn't mention any of that other stuff. You do. She doesn't.

Stella needs to bring in this part: The rules need to be changed to allow people with different life circumstances - not just maternity, things like disability, illness - to become representatives. It is the only way to achieve a democratic elected body that represents the electorate as a whole, not just the wealthy men with SAHM wives and no health conditions. of the discussion to make what she is standing up for now credible and relevant to the rest of us.

forinborin · 25/11/2021 10:12

So because you suffered, future women must also? What about men's careers, are they at the expense of their children?
We are specifically discussing women here, no? But everything is equally applicable to men.
I of course don't want women to suffer but I want them to be realistic. Bringing a baby to work and insisting you can do it all simultaneously is not a solution. I absolutely cannot see what is to be applauded here.