Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think taking a baby to Parliament is ridiculous?

364 replies

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 16:33

Stella Creasy MP taking her baby to the Commons - I think it is utterly ridiculous.

Everyone else has to find childcare. Labour have lost the plot and don’t seem to care what people think (I say this as a life long Labour vote who cannot stomach voting for Labour as it now is). Parliament even have a nursery! www.parliament.uk/about/working/nursery/

OP posts:
JustLyra · 24/11/2021 17:44

@GivenchyDahhling

MPs do now get six months paid maternity leave.

I don’t know why do many people don’t Google and do a basic fact check before they post.

From commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9133/

“Maternity provision for MPs
MPs taking maternity leave can apply to the Speaker of the House for a proxy vote which allows another MP to vote on their behalf. For new mothers, the duration of the proxy vote is six months.
MPs continue to receive full pay for six months whilst on maternity leave. MPs on maternity leave can also apply for funding for additional staff.”

The staff member they can apply to have funded isn’t allowed to actually be a locum and temporarily replace her representing constituents. So MPs either have to essentially be on call during their ML or leave their constituents with no representation.

There was also an issue with a paired vote the last time she had a baby.

Her point is that the current situation would be illegal if MP’s were employees and is a massive barrier to women getting into politics

MyComputerGetsSadWithoutMe · 24/11/2021 17:42

Tbh I thought it was completely fine and cute! A toddler might be more distracting though 😅

SunshineCake1 · 24/11/2021 17:42

I don't see anything wrong in taking a small baby to parliament when the child is sleeping in a sling and probably fed before hand.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/11/2021 17:41

You seriously call yourself a radical feminist. Your attitude puts feminism back 70 years!
Perhaps she does does the blue hair, not the rest of it Grin

SpinsForGin · 24/11/2021 17:41

Sorry to disappoint but I am a radical feminist

You really aren't

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/11/2021 17:40

@Dishwashersaurous

1. She can not get maternity cover to do a vital part of her job.
  1. Therefore she has to do that vital part of the job.
  1. In order to do that she needs to physically bring the tiny breastfeeding baby with her to do it.

The actual issue is that there is no mechanism to allow part of the job, in many ways the key part, without it being the physical presence of the MP.

That's why for key debates people have been brought in on the back of ambulances too ill to Stan in order to vote.

During COvid there was a facility to speak and vote remotely.

All that is required is to maintain that facility MPs who needed it, whether on sick leave, family leave or any other reason.

^This is the correct version of the issue.
SickAndTiredAgain · 24/11/2021 17:40

@Dishwashersaurous

1. She can not get maternity cover to do a vital part of her job.
  1. Therefore she has to do that vital part of the job.
  1. In order to do that she needs to physically bring the tiny breastfeeding baby with her to do it.

The actual issue is that there is no mechanism to allow part of the job, in many ways the key part, without it being the physical presence of the MP.

That's why for key debates people have been brought in on the back of ambulances too ill to Stan in order to vote.

During COvid there was a facility to speak and vote remotely.

All that is required is to maintain that facility MPs who needed it, whether on sick leave, family leave or any other reason.

Exactly.

And I don’t think her argument is for all MPs who’ve just given birth to bring their babies into parliament all the time. Her argument is for a system where this isn’t necessary, and all the work still gets done.

skodadoda · 24/11/2021 17:40

@iawbuwes

It is unreasonable for elected representatives not to be given maternity leave - they are elected as individuals. But if they are speaking in parliament they can surely find childcare for that time period. And maybe your term in parliament is not the ideal time to have a baby, give that your focus is meant to be on your constituents.
You seriously call yourself a radical feminist. Your attitude puts feminism back 70 years!
mbosnz · 24/11/2021 17:39

Given the childish behaviour of far too many of the elected representatives in the house (including eating and sleeping, and playing games on their phone, in between their temper tanties and verbal attacks on other members) I feel the baby and its mother were pattern cards of rectitude in comparison.

Perhaps the 'honourable' members should take note, and seek to model their behaviours on the mother and the child, actually showing up to do her work, and both behaving appropriately, while there.

We live in a world where a woman can be Prime Minister, have a baby, and continue to work effectively, while breastfeeding. Shouldn't we be embracing this?

In contrast to a Prime Minister whose what number wife had what number child and went MIA for how long during a fucking pandemic?

Notonthestairs · 24/11/2021 17:38

What harm actually happened as a result of her taking baby with her?

Bugger all.

I want to see women of childbearing age in Parliament. If that means there are a few extra squawks from the back benches so be it. Parliament won't sound any worse.

Dishwashersaurous · 24/11/2021 17:37
  1. She can not get maternity cover to do a vital part of her job.
  1. Therefore she has to do that vital part of the job.
  1. In order to do that she needs to physically bring the tiny breastfeeding baby with her to do it.

The actual issue is that there is no mechanism to allow part of the job, in many ways the key part, without it being the physical presence of the MP.

That's why for key debates people have been brought in on the back of ambulances too ill to Stan in order to vote.

During COvid there was a facility to speak and vote remotely.

All that is required is to maintain that facility MPs who needed it, whether on sick leave, family leave or any other reason.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 24/11/2021 17:37

If the baby doesn't cry or create any disturbance, what reason can you have to be annoyed

As I mentioned upthread I am on the side of the MP here because it was the only way she could vote, but as a general rule I don't think we should have babies in the workplace. 'If the baby doesn't cry' - where do you find these miraculous non-crying babies? Grin And even if they don't cry, babies have smelly nappies and vomit a lot - not ideal for the office.

julieca · 24/11/2021 17:36

So what do we do? Get rid of an MP or Prime Minster who has a baby? She Johnson should have gone?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/11/2021 17:35

Sorry to disappoint but I am a radical feminist.

Sorry to disappoint but you aren't.

wincarwoo · 24/11/2021 17:35

@EileenGC

And maybe your term in parliament is not the ideal time to have a baby

Do you think this every time a male MP becomes a father? Didn’t think so.

It’s women being against other women that’s the problem very often in this cases.

Tbh I have thought it about Johnson. I don't think young children and being PM is compatible on his case.
LittleGwyneth · 24/11/2021 17:32

She couldn't take maternity leave. The baby was asleep in a sling. It didn't inconvenience anyone. It's not comparable to a normal job.

If the baby doesn't cry or create any disturbance, what reason can you have to be annoyed other than 'I don't like seeing women at work with children' or 'I wasn't allowed to take my baby to work so no-one else should be allowed to'?

julieca · 24/11/2021 17:32

@MandalaYogaTapestry

Why is everybody saying "Did anyone ask that about a male MP?" Yes, male MPs have babies, including BJ, but they haven't brought them to work. Women have done though. Hence the question.
Men are not breastfeeding babies though.
ArblemarchTFruitbat · 24/11/2021 17:32

The best solution would be to allow some kind of proxy or remote voting for MPs who are on maternity/paternity leave.

Not unreasonable in itself to say 'no babies in the workplace' but it is unreasonable to make it impossible for MPs to vote by another method.

avocadotofu · 24/11/2021 17:31

Seriously? It's quite common in other (developed) countries. She doesn't get maternity leave so what should she do with such a tiny breastfed baby? I think she's setting a great example and I'm not especially keen on Labour.

iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 17:29

My comments apply equally to anyone who expects to be the primary carer of a baby during their term in parliament.

OP posts:
bakingdemon · 24/11/2021 17:28

@iawbuwes so would you rather have no women in their 20s/30s/40s in Parliament? Because if you're saying MPs shouldn't have babies while they're in Parliament you're potentially barring a very large number of people (whose experience needs to be represented) from standing for election

Grida · 24/11/2021 17:28

@iawbuwes

It is unreasonable for elected representatives not to be given maternity leave - they are elected as individuals. But if they are speaking in parliament they can surely find childcare for that time period. And maybe your term in parliament is not the ideal time to have a baby, give that your focus is meant to be on your constituents.
You had better let Tony Blair, David Cameron and Boris know.
skodadoda · 24/11/2021 17:28

@Dishwashersaurous

1. She is not allowed maternity cover.
  1. She is not allowed to vote from home, that was removed.
  1. She can't ask someone to vote on her behalf.

Because of this he only option is to take a very young baby with her into the chamber, when she should be at home with the baby.

There needs to be a locum arrangement for MRS on maternity and paternity leave. Then this issue wouldn't arise

Also, she had a speech to make. You’re right, because she’s elected no one can take her place.
iawbuwes · 24/11/2021 17:28

@Makingnumber2

Ugh *@iawbuwes*- how much is the patriarchy paying you to keep women in their place eh?
Hahah hilarious. Sorry to disappoint but I am a radical feminist.
OP posts:
ilovesooty · 24/11/2021 17:27

[quote youvegottenminuteslynn]@iawbuwes

And maybe your term in parliament is not the ideal time to have a baby, give that your focus is meant to be on your constituents.

Do you think the same about male MPs? They shouldn't have a term in parliament if they are planning on becoming a father, or have recently become a father? You would say that about them would you? [/quote]
Exactly. On that basis Boris Johnson should get the hell out of politics, given that he can't concentrate on his constituents let alone manage to be PM.