Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Optional" primary school projects

39 replies

neverbeenskiing · 24/11/2021 09:27

DD (7) has times tables and spellings to learn every week which they're tested on each Friday, these are supposed to be practiced each night. She also has one piece of English homework and one piece of Maths homework each week and we have to listen to her read, ask her questions about what she's read and comment on her understanding in her reading diary each night. They lose a house point if there are any gaps in their reading diary and they miss their playtime if any homework is not done. DH and I both work FT, I am usually home about 6pm and he gets home about 6.30pm. We also have a 2 year old. So fitting all this in along with DD's swimming and music lessons can be difficult but we manage and I accept that it needs to be done.

In addition to the above, DD's school like to regularly set 'optional' extra home learning tasks, which are then judged and a winner chosen from each class. These tend to be large, complicated projects that take a lot of time and no 7 year old could realistically do without a lot of parental involvement. Think constructing a castle with a working drawbridge and a moat, or designing and carrying out a science experiment and illustrating your method, hypothesis and results on a giant poster, that sort of thing. They will email us with the brief (which is usually an A4 page long) and a deadline, and the email will always say that it's "optional". Fair enough. My issue is that every time without fail DD will come home a few days before the deadline and tell us they've had an assembly where the Head Teacher has told them all about this very important project they "have to" do and that it needs to be really good because the best one will get a prize! One of us then ends up spending most of the weekend frantically trying to cobble together a project with DD while the other one deals with the toddler, at the expense of family time and all the other jobs that need to be done at weekends because we don't have time in the week.

AIBU in thinking that there is no point in the school framing something as being "optional" to parents if they're then going to get the kids all excited about it as the majority of parents will feel they have to do it?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
onemouseplace · 24/11/2021 16:04

If the project was so important to their learning, they would do it in schooltime.

By DC3 (and two terms of lockdown learning) I have lost what little enthusiasm I had for this sort of shit. I will facilitate if any DC is particularly interested in a topic but the deal is they do the vast majority of it.

GrandTheftWalrus · 24/11/2021 15:57

My dd is 5 and in primary 1 in Scotland. We get a load of homework that's to last 2 weeks home at a time. I have a dh that is constant nightshift and a 6 month old so I don't have the time to do all her homework. I do the important bits, like learning her words and letters etc. But playing with playdough I don't do, I don't go out to parks to get leaves etc.

We also have to take pics of their homework and upload them to a site. Again I just click hand in.

They are going back to paper homework soon which I think is better.

whatnumber · 24/11/2021 15:51

That is all very harsh. I wish this country would put aside its homework obsession. There really is no need at that age. When they are older it affects their mental health too. Id rather they stay an extra half hour at school to get it done but that obv would be costly etc etc

MsDidoTwite · 24/11/2021 15:24

Be strategic. You need 1. A sympathetic and willing DSis or LF (lovely friend), both if possible, who 2. Has been through this with their own year 1-6s and 3. has completed said optional projects with their own children ( useful if same school as they often do these mummy/daddy homework’s on repeat) or 4. Is a crafting/research/ project genius who loves doing this stuff just for the hell of it. If you get any pushback from school say you’re teaching valuable lesson on inter generational cooperation and time management. And recycling.
Anyone need a Tudor house (with jutting out bits)? Various swords? Holiday diary? Model working volcano? Gear operated mechanicals? Models of frogs insides? Cells with plasma jelly stuff in them??

ColdTattyWaitingForSummer · 24/11/2021 15:14

I would definitely feed back to the school that you feel it’s too much pressure. You’re probably not the only parent feeling this way, but if no one speaks up, nothing changes. I also think it’s rubbish when the expensive and / or parent made projects always win. Flowers

neverbeenskiing · 24/11/2021 15:12

@Hankunamatata they usually give us about 2-3 weeks from when the email goes out. But then they seem to do these assemblies where they get the kids all excited about it a few days before the deadline, at which point parents who have already decided not to do the "optional" project either have to disappoint their DC or cobble something together in a weekend.

OP posts:
neverbeenskiing · 24/11/2021 15:06

I learnt to ignore these "optional" projects with my second child as I really felt that it just created stress and spent too much of our weekend organising.

I totally agree. That's the thing though, I think as they say it's "optional" you should be able to ignore it, but it's difficult to ignore when your child comes home all hyped up because it's been sold to them in an assembly and they're now convinced that if they don't do it they'll be the only one!

OP posts:
turkeyboots · 24/11/2021 15:05

We had "optional" projects too. A list of 10 themed ones and kids were under pressure to do experiments and build models for prizes too.
I let DC do it, provided glue and paint as necessary. They never won a prize, but at least could claim it was their own work.

neverbeenskiing · 24/11/2021 14:58

And my potato didn’t even win

Grin

I bet your potato was beautiful, @minipie.

OP posts:
SeasonFinale · 24/11/2021 14:23

No just no. Get your child to do it. Don't do it for them. It is obvious which ones are the parent projects.

minipie · 24/11/2021 13:50

YANBU OP. Bloody make work which only the frustrated crafters and uber keen SAHMs actually like.

I still remember decorating a sodding potato at 10pm because DD had decided the night before the deadline that she really did want to join in the competition after all (having said nowt about it for the previous 2 weeks).

And my potato didn’t even win.

Wasabiprawns · 24/11/2021 13:43

My daughter had these kind of projects. They were supposed to take no more than 30 mins but that was a joke as they were always complicated and not much could be accomplished in 30 mins. They were always set on a Thursday and so had to be done over the weekend and we would tend to spend at least half a day motivating and trying to complete it as very few could be done without parental input. If we mentioned this to the teachers then they would say the standard "they're optional and no need to spend more than 30 mins".

However, one child created an amazing cake in the shape of a castle (mother was a cake decorator) and they earned the maximum house points. It always seemed that those projects created without obvious parental help didn't tend to get house points.

I learnt to ignore these "optional" projects with my second child as I really felt that it just created stress and spent too much of our weekend organising.

Hankunamatata · 24/11/2021 13:39

How long do they give you? If its like a month that would be too bad.

Homework wise she is getting to the age where she could do a small bit at childminders or afterschool's.

StandWithYou · 24/11/2021 13:35

I have mixed feelings about projects - some the children found interesting and really got into and others were just a chore to get done.. They came up with the ideas, we discussed it they would work and then they built them with varying amounts of help. One child loves craft projects and just gets on with it the other less keen and needs a bit more support but it always is their idea and work. However, we have a lot of craft items in already or can get hold of them which not everyone can do.

What is it teaching the child when their parent does the majority / all of it? They aren’t learning anything except that their efforts aren’t good enough. I wish schools wouldn’t reward those projects.

thetemptationofchocolate · 24/11/2021 13:26

I am old and my primary school days were not sullied by homework. We just didn't have it. We did have school activities outside school hours though, like sports and choir, but those were absolutely voluntary. No homework until we were old enough to tackle it by ourselves, i.e. secondary school.
I don't like seeing so much pressure put on families - when do the children get to play?

ElephantOfRisk · 24/11/2021 13:21

Why can't the parents who want the DC to do more just do stuff with their own children at home? Does it only have value if the school have set and marked the task? That really sound more like virtue signalling from the parents than anything desirable from a DC point of view.

There are any number of on-line or other resources for those that want to (and have the time to) stretch their children or give them other experiences or cater to specific interests.

I'm obviously not talking here about children who need additional support from school to meet their needs, I'm talking about parents wanting more homework or tasks so they can be seen to be doing more. Just do more if you want, it doesn't need to be "seen".

neverbeenskiing · 24/11/2021 13:13

@LethargicActress I completely understand this and I have no problem with the school setting optional extra projects for those that want them. My frustrations are
a.) they describe it as being "optional" in the email to parents but then make a big song and dance about it in assembly and tell the DC to "remind your parents" which sends a different message.
b.) The projects themselves are unecessarily complicated, time-consuming and reliant on a lot of parental input.

OP posts:
LethargicActress · 24/11/2021 12:36

The school has given you something optional because believe it or not, there are a lot of parents that beg for more homework than the usual spellings, reading etc.

They will never be able to please everyone.

ElephantOfRisk · 24/11/2021 12:08

@Pigsears

Why are the OTT ones- with very clear help from parents- mostly the ones chosen for the 'prize'?

If the prize was judged on 'own work' and 'recycled materials', then all kids could have a bash at it without much parental involvement. This would prevent mum/dad from spending hours on the project and dropping huge amounts of money at Cass Art and the like to get a semi professional finish.

In DCs class it was because they let the children vote and when they are young, they don't always take into account that the person had help, they just vote for the one that looks the best. It would be better for the teacher to pick as they have a better idea of which child has produced what and how much effort they've made.

so a prize for the best overall and another for the best effort would be good.

YahooTheMilkshake · 24/11/2021 12:04

I'd give her the resources to do the best she can.
A castle? Maybe Baker ross have something. Or maybe she can draw one on card and cut it out and use card and tape to stand it up. It won't have a working moat etc but at least she can say she did it herself. What is the point in setting the parents homework?

Science experiment, there are actually some science cupcake things I've seen in supermarket, you could do that together and she can draw a step by step poster herself. Or something out a science kit... if you have a printer, print off a photo of said project she can glue on. Or maybe even take a picture of steps and she can glue those on

Pigsears · 24/11/2021 12:00

Why are the OTT ones- with very clear help from parents- mostly the ones chosen for the 'prize'?

If the prize was judged on 'own work' and 'recycled materials', then all kids could have a bash at it without much parental involvement. This would prevent mum/dad from spending hours on the project and dropping huge amounts of money at Cass Art and the like to get a semi professional finish.

ElephantOfRisk · 24/11/2021 11:53

My DC are adults now but I used to hate this also. 2 working parents and DC did a lot of activities in evenings and weekends.

Once when youngest was about 8, their task was to make a puppet. I left DC to it with encouragement and he did a pretty good job. Think wooden spoon, glue, material, wool and marker pens type thing. Anyway, clearly some parents had helped (one was a complete string puppet!) The class voted and the parents efforts won a prize and DC was gutted. It wasn't really like him as he understood that you can't always win yada yada. However, the teacher ended up giving him a small prize after class had ended as she thought his was the best of the non helped ones. It tells something that i remember this about 13 years later!

SavoyCabbage · 24/11/2021 11:43

My dc went to a primary like this with parents bringing in massive projects on behalf of their dc who could barely use scissors as the parents would just take over every time they tried.

It will stop by year five when your own child will be mortified by your very existence and the other children would annihilate a working Tutankhamen project made by someone’s Mam.

You can’t throw time on this so throw some money at it if you want to help your dd do one of these projects. Provide her with the resources to make a really good project. Having the right stuff makes the whole thing a hell of a lot easier.

neverbeenskiing · 24/11/2021 11:25

The optional projects for that age actually sound ok, as long as you can just leave your child to get on with it and they don’t expect anything spectacular from the outcome

This is what frustrates me. The projects are always far too complicated for a 7 year old to be given the materials and left to it and the ones that win are always completely OTT, very obviously done by an adult while the child presumably has to watch them and try not to get in the way.

OP posts:
Chely · 24/11/2021 11:24

It's a firm NO from me. I hate these things and am far too old to be doing homework for my children. If they can do it mostly unaided they can crack on but I've got stuff to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread