Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 24/11/2021 11:47

She was one of 2,000 signatories on a letter written by Challenor. Hardly a connection.
And yet the other 67,218,000 people in the UK didn't sign said letter. So I don't view it as a coincidence that one of the tiny minority who did sign in support of a person with dubious links also has dubious views.

Melroses · 24/11/2021 11:46

How do you raise safeguarding when the next layer up has a vested interest and the HQ do not recognise that concern?

It is easy to get into the bottom rung of a struggling organisation and work your way up the ranks at rocket speed (we saw that with the Green Party).

The answer is not to change your policies from the top down so that you cannot see the risks.

This is just a warning shot. If GG just change their social media policies, and manage a few individuals, so that this stuff can no longer be seen and pointed out to them, the organisation will continue down this route.

They need to put the needs of the young girls in their organisation first.

If the Masons can do it, so can they.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 24/11/2021 11:44

Yes. Why did 9% YABU? I'd be interested in knowing because it owuld be really informative.

Misunderstanding?
Totally dfferent take on the issues involved?
Not really thought it through?
Just assumes it's 'anti trans' and obejcts?
Has an insight not yet voiced?

I'd like to discuss any and all of those, and any other reasons.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 11:41

@WholeClassKeptIn

It makes me sad too. I loved guiding as a movement and put my girls into it originally. But I think whereas transactivists will move onto the "next thing" to destroy that leaves so much damage and so many wjth a history to the movement. Its women that suffer of course :(

Its from the top down, the management is intentionally using guides to carry out its ageda which angers me. It isn't from the ranks of local guiders that have served for years.

@WholeClassKeptIn I saw your post on a thread a few years ago when someone was asking if they should whistleblow. You said you saw someone made out to be the problem when they raised a concern.

I'm a leader who also has concerns (don't loads of us - although these particular concerns are not about the trans issue). Could I possibly find out exactly what happened?

Thanks so much

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 11:41

Anyone who volunteers/works with GG should also seriously consider how this will reflect on their current or future employment prospects.

I image in the past volunteering for GG is the kind of thing all GG leaders would be proud to put on their CV or talk about at an interview.

However, anyone who works in fields that directly relate to safeguarding children should seriously think about how employers will view this now this is getting more day light now. You are working for an organisation that has actively put very poor safeguarding policies in place and sacked women who have brought up valid safeguarding concerns. It’s not like their safeguarding failures are from not enough time or money and policies that aren’t robust enough due to this. It’s not as if when raised they take it seriously and try to properly safeguard girls.

They spent time, money and effort putting together policies that allow males in the same tents, showers and toilets as girls. And policies that advocate teaching children to keep secrets with adults and to give 13 years contraception behind their parents backs.

Regardless of whether or not this directly impacts the division you are responsible for, if you’ve remained loyal to GG during this then employers will think very poorly of that and it could well mean the won’t consider you suitable for a safeguarding role. Even if you don’t put it on a CV they likely will find out when they do the basic social media check all employers conduct these days.

Personally I’d be thinking very seriously about that at present if I was a GG leader.

OP posts:
Skeumorph · 24/11/2021 11:34

@EverNapping

YABU - go back to the Feminism boards, that's what it's for
BULLSHIT that this is anything other than a bloody massive safeguarding concern that is horribly relevant to ANYONE with a female child.

The veil is being lifted on this crap and thank god for that, thank god for information and posts like this that can alert parents to the kind of misogynistic, harmful, anti-safeguarding agenda that the TRAs are pushing.

Nothing to do with feminism any more. EVERYTHING to do with parenting.

Whatwouldscullydo · 24/11/2021 11:34

I'm.intrigued by the 9 percent who think yabu op

I would like them to explain why they don't consider trans people to be capable of following social media policies and being a positive influence on the people they meet like everyone else has to be in the same positions.

These low behaviour expectations, the insinuation it needs to be allowed so that GG are inclusive enough, well its all awfully transphobic tbh

DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 11:23

I don't feel as though I'm being transphobic (although trans people would certainly disagree) I'm just thinking "better safe than sorry".

We don't need these safeguarding measures because they're trans, we need them because they're male. It's no more an insult than when these measures are applied to any other male bodied person. My husband is no risk to women, but he goes into the men's changing room when we all go swimming because it's a general, obvious, sex-related safeguarding measure. It's not an insult to him or any of the other men and it's not misandristic.

Lockheart · 24/11/2021 11:22

@AdamRyan

Girls aged under 13 should not be given contraception as they are not legally deemed to be capable of consenting to sexual activity Girls 13-16 also not deemed to be capable of consenting. This makes it sound like they legally can consent. I'm shocked. This almost encourages interest from people who are attracted to teenage girls.

As a parent as well, you might make a different decision about sending your daughter in GG camp if you thought it was an opportunity for underage sex. I think this is absolutely outrageous

Not quite.

The age of consent is 16.

The age under which it is deemed in law that you cannot consent to sex is 13.

These are two different things and GG is not wrong.

Two 14 or 15 year olds having sex, whilst not being over the age of consent, will not fall foul of the law. It would be in no-one's interest to prosecute them.

MsFogi · 24/11/2021 11:19

@lifeturnsonadime

How interesting that what a man who claims to be a woman does in their free time is irrelevant even when it is a major safeguarding red flag.

But a woman who holds the belief that a person cannot change sex is anti trans and must be hounded out of her job or threatened in her home.

Double standards.

This needs to be said over and over again!!
oxalisRed · 24/11/2021 11:18

Can we please just pause and consider this phrase "girls with penises"? Say it out loud to yourself. Hear the inherent absurdity, the absolute denial of reality.

As @Ionlydomassiveones posted earlier
Gender dysmorphia is a condition that needs psychological treatment. Or people need to chill out about what clothes people wear. It does not need society to be turned upside down and laws to be changed to appease those who would deny reality.

Gender ideology is incredibly harmful at best, systemic misogyny in disguise.

MsFogi · 24/11/2021 11:17

@Mummyoflittledragon

I’d just like to add the fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/ pronouns are like rohypnol link. That means we read she and automatically think that person is most likely weaker and safe. Unfortunately we have fallen under this spell. I have to check myself too.

@brighousepres I get it. Fast moving thread plus frustration… just wanted to erase the rohypnol.

Fair Play For Women is a great place to start for anyone who wants to get more information about self-id and consider for themselves the potential impact on women and girls.

This is also a really interesting read and shows how it is not just an issue in GG but in any area where there are vulnerable women/girls: Why do men with questionable histories want to work with vulnerable women?

crumpet · 24/11/2021 11:17

And it goes without saying that aside from falling foul of an organisation’s social media policies, or bringing them into disrepute, any adult responsible for children should be very careful about their social media activity, as the children they look after are likely to google them.

Genderless · 24/11/2021 11:17

[quote RedCarpetRebellion]@Genderless

The risk of rape needs emphasised again.

99%+ of all sexual assault is committed by males. Only 0.9% by females.

Yes in theory girls might be having sex on camps, but the likelihood of any girl or woman sexually assaulting posters dds is very very low. Add in males and that’s a very real risk. Especially when the risk assessment won’t have taken into account their maleness or safeguarded against the risk that indicates.[/quote]
Yes I agree. Thanks for expanding on what I was trying to say. I'd add pregnancy to that too - girls don't get each other pregnant.

AdamRyan · 24/11/2021 11:15

Girls aged under 13 should not be given contraception as they are not legally deemed to be capable of consenting to sexual activity
Girls 13-16 also not deemed to be capable of consenting. This makes it sound like they legally can consent. I'm shocked. This almost encourages interest from people who are attracted to teenage girls.

As a parent as well, you might make a different decision about sending your daughter in GG camp if you thought it was an opportunity for underage sex. I think this is absolutely outrageous

crumpet · 24/11/2021 11:11
  1. GG should not be in the business of dishing out contraception
  2. It is alarming that GG think that the age of consent is 13, not 16.
GG should not be placing the guides in a position where contraception might be necessary on a residential
  1. I would be very surprised if parents knew that this was what was set out in the guidelines
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 11:11

@Genderless

The risk of rape needs emphasised again.

99%+ of all sexual assault is committed by males. Only 0.9% by females.

Yes in theory girls might be having sex on camps, but the likelihood of any girl or woman sexually assaulting posters dds is very very low. Add in males and that’s a very real risk. Especially when the risk assessment won’t have taken into account their maleness or safeguarded against the risk that indicates.

OP posts:
HeyupitsChristmas · 24/11/2021 11:10

This is disgraceful. Absolutely disgraceful.

Who, in a position where you work with children, would think it appropriate to post provocative images of themselves on SM?

A transwoman running a children's activity isn't a problem. What is a problem is her dressing as a dominatrix and toting a rifle, not to mention the other photos.

I suppose the fact that this has all been brought to light is a the smallest of small positives, but in reality it shows how lax the background checks are on those wishing to volunteer into positions of trust with Girlguiding.

Mummyoflittledragon · 24/11/2021 11:08

I’d just like to add the fairplayforwomen.com/pronouns/ pronouns are like rohypnol link. That means we read she and automatically think that person is most likely weaker and safe. Unfortunately we have fallen under this spell. I have to check myself too.

@brighousepres I get it. Fast moving thread plus frustration… just wanted to erase the rohypnol.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 11:08

Girls deserve single sex spaces. Yep that’s it in a nutshell @lifeturnsonadime

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 11:06

I don’t think Helen Watts or Katie Alcock said they were anti trans.

They were merely and very sensibly suggesting that girls be kept safe by ensuring girls with penises aren’t given condoms to let them have sex with your daughter on Guide camp.

I think there is a huge danger of conflating safeguarding girls with being somehow anti trans people.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/11/2021 11:04

As for condoms, teenagers are full of hormones and I would much rather them have access to them than not (no matter who they get them from), especially when GG camps could technically have hormonal teenage penis' on site now as a result of current policies.

This should never ever have had to be GG policy.
Girls do not have penises.

Girls deserve single sex spaces.

MysteriousSoup · 24/11/2021 11:02

@lifeturnsonadime

How interesting that what a man who claims to be a woman does in their free time is irrelevant even when it is a major safeguarding red flag.

But a woman who holds the belief that a person cannot change sex is anti trans and must be hounded out of her job or threatened in her home.

Double standards.

This Well said
Genderless · 24/11/2021 11:01

That should say "the risk of sex with penises, pregnancy and rape that is the main issue".

Mummyoflittledragon · 24/11/2021 11:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.