Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
HoardingSamphireSaurus · 24/11/2021 12:46

Sory @Eggybrains I meant the whole story around her as a GG leader, not that it was in the same place, that she personally had been replaced by this person. Though A N Other woman obviously was!

Not disinformation, just a tad too vaguely phrased.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 12:42

[quote PumpkinGin]@Helleofabore what is this new circle of hell???

Does it ever stop?[/quote]
I know! Right?

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 12:38

Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person. What they choose to do in their own time is fairly irrelevant.

What sexual boundaries does a person have when they are posting this stuff on line, knowing what the safeguarding and the leadership rules are for the organisation they are volunteering for? I actually think that in this instance, it is entirely relevant. And this shows the faults in their processes that it was not picked up. It was being posted before their appointment in July.

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 12:37

Discrimination towards disabled people? That is absolutely appalling.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 12:34

[quote brighousepres]@Eggybrains - you have concerns beside ditching girls rights? Please tell us what they are. GG aren’t going to tell us!

The GG policies are resulting in reducing the safety of girls in its care. I have a 10 year old and I’d like to know more please.

Clearly GG aren’t advertising their shitty policies and plus they allow all kinds of questionable behaviour from its leaders as evidenced by the sexual and gun social media.[/quote]
Where do I start?

Not bothering with recruitment checks like DBS - it's left up to volunteers, so you're relying on them to do them, and they may or may not have the training/ skills/ inclination to do so. I know this has happened but I don't know how widespread it is. Based on my very small sample size however, it's not uncommon. I think that they need to have an employed person who actually has a responsibility to ensure that this happens. This is absolutely basic.

Risk assessments - not adequate training/ skills. Again done by volunteers. These often aren't read and are appalling, to the extent I'm concerned that an insurer would try to wriggle out of liability if an incident occurred and they saw the risk assessments.

Direct and indirect discrimination against disabled people - they apologised for this in May, but seem to have done nothing to fix it other than put out some tweets "shout out to our asexual members" etc..

Appalling behaviour towards anyone who dares to speak up.

Do you want me to go on.....?

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 12:33

@Helleofabore what is this new circle of hell???

Does it ever stop?

lifeturnsonadime · 24/11/2021 12:32

*Is this really true? Helen was in Ealing, London wasn't she? And Monica in Nottinghamshire? Is this just something to make the story a bit more juicy?

I don't think they need to look far for genuine stories about safeguarding failures by Girlguiding*

I think that the confusion comes from this article www.newarkadvertiser.co.uk/news/amp/investigation-launched-into-guide-commissioners-social-medi-9227238/

linked earlier in the thread which states -

'Her appointment followed the departure of previous commissioner Helen Watts, who left the organisation after stating girls had a right to female-only spaces.'

That can easily be misinterpreted as suggesting that this person took over from Helen Watts which is not the case.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 12:31

Let's not forget though who was brought in as a consultant to GG to proudly shape their policies.

A male activist for the legalisation of extreme porn, including campaigning for the lowering of the age of porn actors to 16.

One who has implied that those males who murder their wives in DV are not really responsible due to the 'eggshell skulls' of those wives. And other misogynistic quotes. But was acclaimed as a top 100 lesbian last year.

DottyHarmer · 24/11/2021 12:25

Why on earth was I deleted? I said that the organisation appeared to have been infiltrated and taken over by perverts. My experience of those at grass roots level is that they are extremely dedicated women wanting the best for their girls . This is a top-down attempt to disrupt the ethos of GG.

CriticalCondition · 24/11/2021 12:23

[quote Lockheart]@Eggybrains you are right - Helen Watts is from Ealing and this individual is from Nottinghamshire.

I would be extremely surprised if they are linked.

As I said upthread, it would be great if we could stick to the facts and not start trying to exaggerate or make things up. It doesn't help our position. Unless we have proof that this is the same position?[/quote]
Yes, I also noted this. And as far as I'm aware they held different positions. Helen has written about being a Unit Leader.

Lockheart · 24/11/2021 12:22

@AdamRyan

Not interested in debating the precise legal definition of when underage children can consent to sex. People who plant a seed that children can be expected to be having sex on a trip for one gender, are shady in my opinion and not acting in those children's best interest.
It's not a debate, it's demonstrable fact.

And I don't think they are planting a seed. I think it's important that teenagers of appropriate ages have access to contraception if needed. I've also not seen anything about sex taking place on trips, but a lot of posters seem to have latched on to that and it's been repeated often. My reading of the policy is that it's for girls to ask if they need them for general use. Teen girls may well be having sex outside of Guides trips and GG may be the only place they feel they can ask adults for help. I'd like to think they can be supported and given help in an appropriate way at Guides if needed, especially where they may not be able to access doctors independently (the NHS will also give you free condoms) or may not have the money to buy them, for example.

Lockheart · 24/11/2021 12:15

@Eggybrains you are right - Helen Watts is from Ealing and this individual is from Nottinghamshire.

I would be extremely surprised if they are linked.

As I said upthread, it would be great if we could stick to the facts and not start trying to exaggerate or make things up. It doesn't help our position. Unless we have proof that this is the same position?

AdamRyan · 24/11/2021 12:13

Not interested in debating the precise legal definition of when underage children can consent to sex.
People who plant a seed that children can be expected to be having sex on a trip for one gender, are shady in my opinion and not acting in those children's best interest.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 12:10

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

"Last night, Helen Watts tweeted her reaction: "In case you forgot, I was thrown out of Girlguiding, ostensibly for breaching the social media policy, when I objected to sex self ID.

Initially it had bypassed me entirely that this was Helen Watts' position. That REALLY only adds to the questions that need to be asked.

Was this just an error or is it yet another of those deliberate 'take overs' we have seen in other organisations just a little bit too late?

Is this really true? Helen was in Ealing, London wasn't she? And Monica in Nottinghamshire? Is this just something to make the story a bit more juicy?

I don't think they need to look far for genuine stories about safeguarding failures by Girlguiding

Lockheart · 24/11/2021 12:08

@AdamRyan

Two 14 or 15 year olds having sex, whilst not being over the age of consent, will not fall foul of the law. It would be in no-one's interest to prosecute them. That's decriminalisation. It's still not legal - by law they can't consent. I'm very suspicious of someone/organisations who takes the decriminalisation position and uses it to imply 13-16 year olds can consent and therefore should be supplied contraceptives without parents being aware (with the exception of health are professionals). It's a massive safeguarding risk. Especially when adults over the age of 18 with penises are in a position where they have access to underage females.
Again, this isn't quite the legal position.

Those under 13 cannot consent in any circumstances and an offence will always have been committed in law if a 13 year old or under has been involved in sexual activity with another person.

If someone under 16 but older than 13 is involved in sexual activity with another person then although they cannot consent legally, whether an offence has been committed will be determined by other factors, such as the ages of those involved, whether one had a position of power over the other etc.

As an example, it may be deemed that a 16 year old having sex with a 15 year old has not committed an offence. The same conclusion is unlikely to be reached if a 30 year old has sex with a 14 year old. In both scenarios, there is a person involved who cannot consent but only in one is an offence committed.

lifeturnsonadime · 24/11/2021 12:05

I'll say it again, an organisation stated to be for women and girls is a single sex space and there should never ever be a need for barrier contraception in the first place.

It was bad enough when it was reported that inmates in women's prisons in California were being given condoms wbckfm.com/california-supply-womans-prisons-condoms-biological-men-housed-prisons/

Now it's our children.

This ideology harms vulnerable women and children.

Anyone turning a blind eye to this is complicit.

It's reprehensible.

AdamRyan · 24/11/2021 12:04

I.e. on a guide camp.
Honestly. I was abused on a children's camp at 11 in the 80s, so much work has been done about grooming and how abusers work to get access to victims that I thought children were safer in these scenarios.
This makes me think again.
Because of my experience, I would never ever send my children somewhere where there was a risk of them being alone with a penis owner I didn't know well. I've been called oversensitive for that. But now penis owners with malign intent can camouflage themselves like this under the guise of "being a woman" and it terrifies me.

CommonDen · 24/11/2021 12:01

@Magicpaintbrush

Sex education is already happening in schools, so why GG feel the need to get involved in this side of things at all is beyond me. I think when most parents sign their girls up to GG they envision a wholesome and nurturing space where girls can make friends, be creative and learn skills, run by women who can be trusted to keep their daughters safe. Wholesome is the furthest thing from what I have been reading about GG this week, they have absolutely lost their way. They are so busy virtue signalling and making sure the world knows how woke and inclusive they are that they are compromising the safety of the girls in their care and throwing under the bus those leaders who have dared to object or highlight these issues by kicking them out of the organisation - the very people who, it seems to me, care the most about the safety and well being of these children. It feels like children are being subjected to an endless deluge of talk about sex, whether it's the act of sex or the nature of a person's sexual orientation, like there is literally nothing else worth discussing in life, as though it's the only thing of importance, shoving it down their throats constantly. Kids are all talking about this stuff on a daily basis now because it's all they are bloody well being exposed to. There is no balance any more. Sex is a part of life, but it's not the only thing in life - but somehow at the moment it really feels like the opposite is true. And it's all very handy for sexual predators that confused and impressionable kids across the country are being prepped like this.
Completely agree. Since when did sex become the sole subject in life for pretty much all ages? It's really sad. Would hate to be a young person growing up today. Normal activities are now deemed "sensible" or "wholesome" or even introverted... because it's just always contrasted with the main seedy topic.
tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 24/11/2021 12:01

@Shedmistress

Presumably all safeguarding checks have been done on this person.

Risk assessments done on this person will be completed as if they are a female, not a male. Because trans women are women.

So the higher risk factors that are accounted for in risk assessing a male, are not accounted for here.

That is the point that Katie and Helen were trying to make and they got booted out for it.

You cannot presume anything once you subscribe to the ideology. Because people are what they say they are and nobody is allowed to question it.

Can I add it's the social media content that's highly fucking inappropriate too. Call me a facist if you will but I do not want ANYONE near my child who openly posts sexualised content about their fetish or asks admirers if they would like to see more body parts, on SM. It matters not who you identify as if you advertise this side of you then you shouldn't be allowed unsupervised access to kids especially if you may be in close quarters.
AdamRyan · 24/11/2021 12:00

Two 14 or 15 year olds having sex, whilst not being over the age of consent, will not fall foul of the law. It would be in no-one's interest to prosecute them.
That's decriminalisation. It's still not legal - by law they can't consent.
I'm very suspicious of someone/organisations who takes the decriminalisation position and uses it to imply 13-16 year olds can consent and therefore should be supplied contraceptives without parents being aware (with the exception of health are professionals).
It's a massive safeguarding risk. Especially when adults over the age of 18 with penises are in a position where they have access to underage females.

WholeClassKeptIn · 24/11/2021 12:00

Eggy ive sent a pm. Sorry Ive actually sent lots as couldnt see that it had been "sent." 🤦🏼‍♀️.

I'd be curious to know about other concerns too.

DottyHarmer · 24/11/2021 11:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 11:56

My old Brown Owl would be FURIOUS with this. She didn’t take shit from anyone.

brighousepres · 24/11/2021 11:55

@Eggybrains - you have concerns beside ditching girls rights? Please tell us what they are. GG aren’t going to tell us!

The GG policies are resulting in reducing the safety of girls in its care. I have a 10 year old and I’d like to know more please.

Clearly GG aren’t advertising their shitty policies and plus they allow all kinds of questionable behaviour from its leaders as evidenced by the sexual and gun social media.

WholeClassKeptIn · 24/11/2021 11:50

Hi Eggy. I'm not sure exactly what I said then but.

  • Helen Watts and Katie Alcock have both been removed from guiding for whistleblowing as you can see from mutliple threads, and they were right 😔.

  • I entered into an attempt at email correspondence ages ago when I didn't realise how entrenched all this is. I pointed out safeguarding concerns around male bodies in guides, overnights, secrecy aeound safeguarding and just got generic mass emails back. Nothing that addressed my concerns at all. I emailed back etc but still generic emails not addressing any of my points. I think we were all just written off as "wrong." I havent a problem with people being trans, or girl bodies in guides who might be questioning (indeed a safe place to so) etc it just seems guides is no longer safe.

I haven't got a specific local example as we removed ours from guiding for various reasons and I was only involved as a helper (after coming through gg myself.)

Swipe left for the next trending thread