Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:32

oops

for people get their heads around what has happened

averylongtimeago · 24/11/2021 16:32

What a person, be they man, woman, trans whatever, does in the privacy of their own home is their business alone (as long as it's within the law and with consenting adults of course)
No one should be hounded because they like to dress up or collect replica guns.

However- if you publish dodgy photos of yourself wearing BDSM gear, in a state of undress, brandishing weapons or making sexually suggestive comments under your own name, then want to volunteer or work with children, well you should expect your public profile to be examined.

This type of public post across multiple social media accounts would get you into trouble with almost all employers or public organisations.

The reason they are so important is they show how the failure of Girlguiding's safeguarding policy has allowed a person to access children.

This photo alone (originally published with the children's faces showing) should be enough to have the poster removed. If you think it doesn't and that including a picture of yourself semi clothed with a bunch of little girls is fine, well I wouldn't want you near my grandkids either.

To ask you to see who girl guides support.
VeryLongBeeeeep · 24/11/2021 16:31

The fact that people had to poke around her social media to find this suggest it's probably not a major part of her life anyway.

The profile and cover photos for this person's Twitter feed was a selfie of them topless in the bath and a row of young girls (pre-teen so far as was possible to tell) in party dresses in what looked like a church hall or similar with their faces visible. You think that's an appropriate juxtaposition for someone appointed to a senior Guiding position?

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:31

This is what people's energy should be focused on, not Monica herself.

And with the lack of trust in GG, if the full story is not being told about this person who has deliberately chosen their actions, how will parents know to then hold GG to account.

I do understand what you mean Eggy, but the reality is, people get their heads around what has happened and how it has happened, and that requires them seeing the images for themselves and reading articles about it. GG has low credibility that it will take any notice otherwise.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:29

@DrSbaitso

But holding her to account should be Girlguiding. The internet doesn't need to do it too.

It does when Girlguiding has a track record of firing those who want it held to account. Public response matters.

Yes - so make sure you hold Girlguiding to account. I'm absolutely not saying don't do that. Please, please do hold them to account. Just focus on Girlguiding, not Monica as an individual.
Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:27

This is one person. For clarity, I'm not saying it's ok. What I'm saying is that there will be more. And what's more important is how Girlguiding, as an organisation, deals with these issues, rather than this one individual, who will probably be next week's chip paper as the saying goes (except they don't use newspapers in chip shops any more).

On this I totally agree. And as a parent of a very recently left guide, who was looking to start rangers, I will be continuing to contact GG myself and will take every opportunity to campaign that this does not happen again.

Unfortunately, what you say about GG is also correct and they have form for not dealing with it. Hence the need to actually raise awareness about this so that parents of Guides can respond.

DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 16:27

But holding her to account should be Girlguiding. The internet doesn't need to do it too.

It does when Girlguiding has a track record of firing those who want it held to account. Public response matters.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:27

@MrsOvertonsWindow

I take your point about targeting the issue / the Guides, rather than the individual Eggybrains. The difficulty is that the issue was dismissed by the Guides when it was raised as a general concern. Women were sacked, silenced and told to go away. An instance like this of a remarkably senior GG (and not a naive young person) exemplifies how catastrophic that earlier decision was. So we're left with having to hammer home the message that this is what happens when you prioritise sexual politics rather than the needs of girls for a female only safe environment, free from sexual pressures that they face everywhere else. And that's why it's such a disaster.
@MrsOvertonsWindow I think we're on the same page, really. This is primarily an issue with Girlguiding, who have behave abhorrently in the past.

We now need to look to Girlguiding to perform better, but I doubt that they will.

This is what people's energy should be focused on, not Monica herself.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:24

@Echobelly

I haven't seen the Twitter account, and can't find it so can't say whether it's soft porn or not. If it's inappropriate I would say most of all I'm in agreement with *@Eggybrains* - take your concerns to Guides, don't smear this person on speculation based on a few pictures. It just gives ammo to people who say 'Oh you're just looking for an excuse to be transphobic' - NB not saying 'Oooh be nice and kind', but certainly saying, don't mudsling on individuals who have not been proved to have done anything wrong, nor even had any allegations made against them.

I do wish sometimes there was a verb/word to say 'I am not necessarily defending a person or standpoint, but I think the argument used undermines itself with speculation/inaccuracy!' (I don't think 'devil's advocate' is the same thing, for example)

There are plenty of screen shots floating around. I personally did see their twitter account.

And frankly, the image that a person in a bathtub (because I also saw the image the profile image was taken from) that is in front of a wide screen shot of them standing with a line of small girls in tutus that showed the girls faces was just one of the inappropriate style of posts for a GG divisional commissioner I would suggest.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:24

@Helleofabore

Eggy

The person at the heart of this discussion needs to also be held accountable because they were in that position. They chose to do this and to not follow the clearly set rules. The code of conduct clearly states that social media posts of a sexual nature are not acceptable.

This adult had the responsibility to follow this code of conduct and has chosen not to. It is infantilising them to lay the sole blame on GG here. Both are very much in the wrong.

Yes, true. But holding her to account should be Girlguiding. The internet doesn't need to do it too. If Girlguiding fails to hold her to account that is an abhorrent failure by Girlguiding, and the more significant issue is with Girlguiding.

In many cases, Girlguiding may be made aware of failures, but it doesn't reach the Daily Wail and Sun. What's really important is that Girlguiding deals with these effectively. You and I may not be aware of many, many other Monicas in Girlguiding.

It seems on past experience, they don't deal with issues, instead they get rid of the person raising them, like Katie and Helen.

This is one person, @Helleofabore. For clarity, I'm not saying it's ok. What I'm saying is that there will be more. And what's more important is how Girlguiding, as an organisation, deals with these issues, rather than this one individual, who will probably be next week's chip paper as the saying goes (except they don't use newspapers in chip shops any more).

Clymene · 24/11/2021 16:22

And I'm afraid to say that I think that this kind of media coverage is the only way you'll get GG to have a root and branch review of how things have gone so catastrophically wrong.

Clymene · 24/11/2021 16:20

@Echobelly

I haven't seen the Twitter account, and can't find it so can't say whether it's soft porn or not. If it's inappropriate I would say most of all I'm in agreement with *@Eggybrains* - take your concerns to Guides, don't smear this person on speculation based on a few pictures. It just gives ammo to people who say 'Oh you're just looking for an excuse to be transphobic' - NB not saying 'Oooh be nice and kind', but certainly saying, don't mudsling on individuals who have not been proved to have done anything wrong, nor even had any allegations made against them.

I do wish sometimes there was a verb/word to say 'I am not necessarily defending a person or standpoint, but I think the argument used undermines itself with speculation/inaccuracy!' (I don't think 'devil's advocate' is the same thing, for example)

I have. I'm not basing my opinion on an article in the Daily Mail. Do you honestly think they're making this up? Confused

Until yesterday, this person's Instagram, Facebook and Twitter were all open. I know, because I looked at them. They clearly state on their Twitter profile that they're a guide leader.

This person has no boundaries or sense of what is appropriate or inappropriate in a leadership role with children. And they are directly contravening the guides' Code of Conduct.

So either a) they don't know what it is or b) they know and don't care.

And why on earth shouldn't the press expose this kind of thing? The guides are failing in their duty of care to chidren.

Personally I care more about safeguarding than hurty feelz

MrsOvertonsWindow · 24/11/2021 16:19

I take your point about targeting the issue / the Guides, rather than the individual Eggybrains. The difficulty is that the issue was dismissed by the Guides when it was raised as a general concern. Women were sacked, silenced and told to go away.
An instance like this of a remarkably senior GG (and not a naive young person) exemplifies how catastrophic that earlier decision was. So we're left with having to hammer home the message that this is what happens when you prioritise sexual politics rather than the needs of girls for a female only safe environment, free from sexual pressures that they face everywhere else.
And that's why it's such a disaster.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:17

Eggy

The person at the heart of this discussion needs to also be held accountable because they were in that position. They chose to do this and to not follow the clearly set rules. The code of conduct clearly states that social media posts of a sexual nature are not acceptable.

This adult had the responsibility to follow this code of conduct and has chosen not to. It is infantilising them to lay the sole blame on GG here. Both are very much in the wrong.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:14

@Echobelly

I haven't seen the Twitter account, and can't find it so can't say whether it's soft porn or not. If it's inappropriate I would say most of all I'm in agreement with *@Eggybrains* - take your concerns to Guides, don't smear this person on speculation based on a few pictures. It just gives ammo to people who say 'Oh you're just looking for an excuse to be transphobic' - NB not saying 'Oooh be nice and kind', but certainly saying, don't mudsling on individuals who have not been proved to have done anything wrong, nor even had any allegations made against them.

I do wish sometimes there was a verb/word to say 'I am not necessarily defending a person or standpoint, but I think the argument used undermines itself with speculation/inaccuracy!' (I don't think 'devil's advocate' is the same thing, for example)

The Twitter account has now been deleted but there's plenty of screenshots out there.
Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:12

@Helleofabore

Eggy

I think posting these images on your social media while in a position where you know full well what the GG volunteer rules on conduct and on safeguarding or leaving them up after your appointment is actually rather indicative of their intention.

We are constantly told by activists that we should accept people for who they say they are. Leaving these images on two social media platforms is 'telling us who this person is'.

Why do you think this particular person should not be named?

Very true GG needs to take responsibility, but this is a 58 year old adult.

Their actions can only be taken as deliberate or else, they simply have no concept of what is required for the safety of children and should never have been appointed to that position. I look at their decisions across TWO social media platforms and I can only draw the conclusion it was deliberate choices here. GG allowed this to happen but they are jointly responsible with this particular person .

I didn't say that I didn't think that this person shouldn't be named. I don't think there's any issue with naming them.

I just think the most important thing is Girlguiding procedures for volunteers and deciding if they're suitable, and if they were followed rather than shouting at an individual. Shouting at an individual will achieve nothing. Getting Girlguiding to hold themselves accountable (I doubt that they will), has the potential to do so much more positively.

You say that they should never have been appointed. It was Girlguiding's decision to appoint them. Hold them to account.

HermioneKipper · 24/11/2021 16:11

I’m another one who’s horrified and disgusted by the whole thing.

I’d already decided not to enrol my daughter at Rainbows given my safeguarding concerns and now this absolute shitshow has come out.

Firing women for raising genuine concerns and instead hiring men who get their kicks from dressing up as women, BDSM and guns and happily showcase this across social media. NO.

What is going on. They’ve all lost their minds at HQ.

I went to rainbows, brownies and guides as a youngster and loved them all. I’m so angry that my daughter now will lose out on these experiences because GG thinks it’s better to prioritise men than focus on the girls their organisation was created for.

It’s a DISGRACE

MrsOvertonsWindow · 24/11/2021 16:10

@daringdoris

I went through GG and was a young leader but haven't been involved for over 20 years now. I loved it, our unit was really outdoorsy, and looking back, our Guider gave us the confidence to do so many things - lighting fires, building obstacle courses, making trails, learning about the night sky and so much more.

Thinking about previous posters who have said

99% of local guiders, leaders and helpers would agree that current GG safe-guarding policies are unsafe for girls

and also

that they have taken/would take otheir daughter out of GG, or not let her go in the first place, or not let her go to camps

Couldn't there be a grassroots movement from the leaders themselves, all of them who agree that this policy is demonstrably unsafe? A legal action, a refusal to carry out their duties, parents stop the subs? I don't know really, it's just that if we know there's such a strong grassroots feeling about this, from leaders and parents, then perhaps something can be done?
An advantage is that GG is an existing network, so 'finding recruits' should be easier (especially when we are aware that many of them agree!)
Doing it 'together' would also make it easier for leaders who are afraid to speak out on their own.

Just thinking out loud.

This is such a good idea. Sadly a number of senior guiders were sacked for raising issues about removing the single sex nature of the Guides and safeguarding. Those who remain are under strict instructions to keep quiet or they're out.

This mirrors what's happened to women everywhere who raise concerns about the removal of women and girl's rights to safe single sex spaces when vulnerable (hospital wards, intimate care, refuges, showers and changing rooms, even sport). No matter how respectful they are, they're bullied, their employment is threatened, they get death and rape threats.

You're right that there's safety in numbers and over issues like this, it's essential that parents and all responsible adults stand up for the safety of children.

It defies belief that someone who reaches such a senior position in the guides had no clue that displaying their fetishes / weapons on social media would be a problem. That person has no idea of appropriate boundaries and that's dangerous when working with the young and impressionable.

Echobelly · 24/11/2021 16:08

I haven't seen the Twitter account, and can't find it so can't say whether it's soft porn or not. If it's inappropriate I would say most of all I'm in agreement with @Eggybrains - take your concerns to Guides, don't smear this person on speculation based on a few pictures. It just gives ammo to people who say 'Oh you're just looking for an excuse to be transphobic' - NB not saying 'Oooh be nice and kind', but certainly saying, don't mudsling on individuals who have not been proved to have done anything wrong, nor even had any allegations made against them.

I do wish sometimes there was a verb/word to say 'I am not necessarily defending a person or standpoint, but I think the argument used undermines itself with speculation/inaccuracy!' (I don't think 'devil's advocate' is the same thing, for example)

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:02

Eggy

I think posting these images on your social media while in a position where you know full well what the GG volunteer rules on conduct and on safeguarding or leaving them up after your appointment is actually rather indicative of their intention.

We are constantly told by activists that we should accept people for who they say they are. Leaving these images on two social media platforms is 'telling us who this person is'.

Why do you think this particular person should not be named?

Very true GG needs to take responsibility, but this is a 58 year old adult.

Their actions can only be taken as deliberate or else, they simply have no concept of what is required for the safety of children and should never have been appointed to that position. I look at their decisions across TWO social media platforms and I can only draw the conclusion it was deliberate choices here. GG allowed this to happen but they are jointly responsible with this particular person .

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 15:50
  • so is not demonstrating they are well aware it must be kept away from children.
OP posts:
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 15:49

@Clymene

You don't take 'a particular view' on whether a person who has a photo on themselves on their Instagram profile in their real name in bondage gear is suitable for a role as a guide leader *@Echobelly*?

Does your mate with a bazooka photo also have a soft porn Twitter profile in their own name and is a guide leader?

At the very least, it's deeply deeply inappropriate.

I don’t care if my kids teacher is into all that in private. As long as he keeps it off of social media. By keeping it private he shows he knows it should be kept away from kids, which is good safeguarding.

The GG concerned is demonstrating they think it’s fine to demonstrate and indulge in their sexuality publicly, on platforms that children access. So is demonstrating that they are aware it must be kept separate from children.

If the GG was a teenager, very early 20s I’d say it’s possible that’s just naivety or lack of understanding, but this person is in 50s? No way any adult that age doesn’t know your sex life should be entirely kept away from children. Which begs the question what’s their motivation of posting?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 15:49

@Echobelly

You know I can't vouch for this woman and I take no particular view on her suitability for the role, but I am very irritated by some assumptions being made here, people seem to be lumping an awful lot of concerns they have about GG onto her on some tenuous evidence.

I am sick and tired, in this whole discussion of seeing both sides pick up on what appear to be at least partially misleading articles and not think about the context/check the facts because It Proves Their Point. I am really tired of seeing things and thinking 'OK, but I can see a massive Trans Rights bias here or a massive GC/trans-exclusionary one that's actually obscuring what's really going on'.

BDSM photo: yes, she has a sex life. BDSM doesn't mean 'into every perversion there including paedophelia'. The fact that people had to poke around her social media to find this suggest it's probably not a major part of her life anyway. The vast majority of BDSM enthusiasts are not paedophiles and regard them with the same disgust as everyone else.

Gun photo: There's a photo of my mate on holiday in Cambodia holding a loaded bazooka, but he's never blown anyone up, nor is he a 'gun nut'. So, she had a photo taken with a replica gun - that doesn't seem to be evidence of being a 'gun nut'

Signed Challenor letter: That one 1000+ people signed? www.thelondoneconomic.com/news/over-1000-people-have-signed-an-open-letter-condemning-pride-in-london-for-letting-an-anti-trans-group-lead-the-march-94296/ I actually used to be supportive of Glinner's stand for women initially, but really, trying to imply this woman is some best chum of Challenor for signing an open letter signed by 1000s is just barrel scraping and unfair. He writes about the vileness of Challenor's father in detail as though Sulley was his best mate or something. Not one of 1000s who signed an open letter that happen to have been created by his daughter, at a time it appears the Challenor scandal was not even known about, so I'm not sure how Sulley, who doesn't appear to be linked in any other way to Challenor, was to know about it. And to imply as much is plain cruel, however righteous you feel your cause is.

Who knows, maybe something truly dreadful will appear about her, because I don't know her and neither do you. Campaign against trans women being in these positions if that's how you feel, but digging up the slightest thing discredit an individual by extrapolating very thin evidence does not do your argument any credit.

Maybe you should read the thread if you have not.

It is the fact that this person has published these images and captions of themselves means that this is no longer their 'private life'.

It directly contravenes the GG code of conduct for volunteers. And it presents a safeguarding risk.

As does the poses with guns in a way that is not in anyway controlled or in an appropriate way to handle weapons.

NOBODY should be doing this. That is the entire point. Why wasn't it picked up before they were appointed.

Frankly, if you don't see it as a risk to safeguarding, that is on you.

I would like you to tell me why someone who seeks to lower sexual boundaries by publishing these images (because it is exhibitionism and is directly about lowering sexual boundaries of others), should ever be in a position of responsibility of children. Regardless of sex.

Please tell me why it is ok?

Clymene · 24/11/2021 15:42

You don't take 'a particular view' on whether a person who has a photo on themselves on their Instagram profile in their real name in bondage gear is suitable for a role as a guide leader @Echobelly?

Does your mate with a bazooka photo also have a soft porn Twitter profile in their own name and is a guide leader?

At the very least, it's deeply deeply inappropriate.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 15:42

As in sharing with the girls also.

OP posts: