Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 17:53

Got to teach girls to make their future husbands favourite drink correctly so she can be ready to wait on him when he gets home from work.

Goes so well with the twin sets favoured by both the mentioned tw on this thread.

OP posts:
RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 17:42

@EishetChayil

What is mixology when it's at home??
Making cocktails.

I’d assume GG is non alcoholic ones, but still.

OP posts:
MotherofTerriers · 24/11/2021 17:39

"Somewhere between a third and a half result from too much alcohol. A high proportion are domestic violence gone wrong. A blow struck one time too many: an egg-shell skull."

How does domestic violence go right? How can domestic violence be anything other than wrong?

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 17:37

so can't say whether it's soft porn or not

What level of 'porn' is good for a person in a position of responsibility of children to display on their social media feed, by the way?

Because, I am obviously a pearl clutcher who believes that any individual that has the responsibility of looking after my child should not have published ANY level of porn on their social media.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 17:37

@twelly

The GG movement began to change a few years ago in an attempt to become "appealing" to a wider group - they ditched the reference to "God' in their promise, they changes the badges and they basically alienated many of their leaders and in doing so put off many girls. Now they have attracted a new group of individuals whom in my view are alien to the old GG movement - I feel it is a very sad state of affairs. The GG movement over the years has done a lot to encourage girls and provided a fantastic opportunity for children whom cannot afford many of other clubs/societies, it encouraged them to try new things, broadening their horizon and provided them with role models. The movement has been very badly damaged and I wonder if it can recover its old identity
If a school is out into failing measures by ofsted then it has a complete over haul of leadership and reevaluates values and objectives.

So unless there’s a way of making GG do the same then no, they absolutely can’t recover. This is an institutional failing, and institutional failing they have already been made aware of by two GG leaders we know of and their response was to kick them out. The current entire leadership is completely unsuitable for working with children given those decisions, their policies and their employment of this person. They can’t recover from that.

The reality is they likely won’t face that reality yet, not until the very worst has happened and then there’s definitely no way to come back from that because they can not show they took every reasonable step possible to prevent harm.

The best we can hope for is that decent GG leaders band together and protest or all leave en mass and seek to establish their own independent network of organisations to honour GG original aims.

They could distance themselves from these safeguarding fails and dedicate their new movement to Baden powel.

The GG leaders on these threads, all four running currently, you need to let the parents know about this. If you don’t, and the GG policies mean the worst happens to their kid, they will view your lack of action just as bad as the predators GG policies are opening their doors to (there may not be any there yet, but predators go where they can get easy access to children and where institutional policy ensures they aren’t questioned, which is very true of GG ones).

OP posts:
Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 17:30

@Helleofabore

Don't know Eggy, will the truth ever come out?
I hope so
DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 17:27

@EishetChayil

What is mixology when it's at home??
Making mixed drinks.
EishetChayil · 24/11/2021 17:23

What is mixology when it's at home??

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 24/11/2021 17:21

Ex GG leader here.
I left because of the politicisation of the new programme, the trans issue and the crappy new programme they have issued featuring such crappy badges as "mixology"
GG has completely lost thr plot and is losing leaders left, right and centre.

RedCarpetRebellion · 24/11/2021 17:20

@averylongtimeago

What a person, be they man, woman, trans whatever, does in the privacy of their own home is their business alone (as long as it's within the law and with consenting adults of course) No one should be hounded because they like to dress up or collect replica guns.

However- if you publish dodgy photos of yourself wearing BDSM gear, in a state of undress, brandishing weapons or making sexually suggestive comments under your own name, then want to volunteer or work with children, well you should expect your public profile to be examined.

This type of public post across multiple social media accounts would get you into trouble with almost all employers or public organisations.

The reason they are so important is they show how the failure of Girlguiding's safeguarding policy has allowed a person to access children.

This photo alone (originally published with the children's faces showing) should be enough to have the poster removed. If you think it doesn't and that including a picture of yourself semi clothed with a bunch of little girls is fine, well I wouldn't want you near my grandkids either.

Even takeaway the top less in a bath tub pic who the fuck posts pics of other people’s kids to public social media.

Even if these are all very close family members children and the parents consented, it’s seems startlingly poor judgment to post little girls faces on line on a public platform.

OP posts:
Terfydactyl · 24/11/2021 17:00

Our energy needs to be focused on Girlguiding and their response, or lack of, to this. That is the only way things might change in Girlguiding. Saying repeatedly what an awful person Monica is will
not change things in Girlguiding
Who has said anything about Monica being an awful person? You could get that deleted if you see it. Just report the posts.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:58

Unfortunately Dotty there does seem to be a degree of protection being afforded here because of many issues. One being DBS checks if transitioners do not disclose their previous names. One being the pressure on people not to come forward, or even to discuss it because it is seen as coming from a place of phobia or hate. Rather than it actually being a very real need to apply the same rigour in safeguarding checks etc for males who ever they are.

No sacred groups should be allowed ever again.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:54

Don't know Eggy, will the truth ever come out?

DottyHarmer · 24/11/2021 16:52

I just don’t understand. There has been a concerted effort to root out undesirable volunteers in recent years, eg scoutmasters, priests, choirmasters etc (dh’s is in prison - eek) and now it seems it’s wrong to judge . We all know that some people are crafty and seek to access unaccompanied children; that is why we have dbs checks and safeguarding rules. Not foolproof, but discouraging to ne’er do wells.

This is not about trans people per se, btw, but anybody who posts Ill-judged and dubious pictures on social media should have their services dispensed with immediately.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:51

@Helleofabore

Has anyone asked if they got a reference for Monica before she began volunteering?

I think in my letter to them on Monday (before this became so widely known) I did ask what process was followed. As a parent asking, I would daresay that question will be completely ignored.

And while I agree it is better to focus on moving ahead now, we still have new posters who don't read through an entire thread who are questioning the relevance of what we are discussing. This is the nature of MN, of course.

So, I suggest there will be constant backwards and forwardsing that will annoy some posters.

I'm not annoyed, just saying!

I have reason to believe recruitment checking procedures are not followed, not uncommonly. I wonder if Monica's recruitment was the result of one of those failures, and if a reference would have identified these issues. If the reference did identify these issues, did Girlguiding follow up on these, and decide if she was a suitable volunteer for her post, both as a DC, and presumably also running a local Guiding group?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/11/2021 16:51

And I'm afraid to say that I think that this kind of media coverage is the only way you'll get GG to have a root and branch review of how things have gone so catastrophically wrong.

I completely agree.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:46

Has anyone asked if they got a reference for Monica before she began volunteering?

I think in my letter to them on Monday (before this became so widely known) I did ask what process was followed. As a parent asking, I would daresay that question will be completely ignored.

And while I agree it is better to focus on moving ahead now, we still have new posters who don't read through an entire thread who are questioning the relevance of what we are discussing. This is the nature of MN, of course.

So, I suggest there will be constant backwards and forwardsing that will annoy some posters.

Clymene · 24/11/2021 16:44

I am going to focus on Monica as an individual and girl guiding.

I am suspicious of the motives of a recently transitioned man with very poor boundaries choosing to join an previously single sex organisation where there are overnights with children with low adult child ratios.

I am not going to apologise for that.

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:41

@twelly

The GG movement began to change a few years ago in an attempt to become "appealing" to a wider group - they ditched the reference to "God' in their promise, they changes the badges and they basically alienated many of their leaders and in doing so put off many girls. Now they have attracted a new group of individuals whom in my view are alien to the old GG movement - I feel it is a very sad state of affairs. The GG movement over the years has done a lot to encourage girls and provided a fantastic opportunity for children whom cannot afford many of other clubs/societies, it encouraged them to try new things, broadening their horizon and provided them with role models. The movement has been very badly damaged and I wonder if it can recover its old identity
It needs to change dramatically, quickly, if it is to survive, which is so very sad.
DrSbaitso · 24/11/2021 16:41

Yes - so make sure you hold Girlguiding to account. I'm absolutely not saying don't do that. Please, please do hold them to account. Just focus on Girlguiding, not Monica as an individual.

How do we hold GG to account for taking on a person like Monica without explaining why Monica is an unsuitable person to be taken on by GG?

twelly · 24/11/2021 16:40

The GG movement began to change a few years ago in an attempt to become "appealing" to a wider group - they ditched the reference to "God' in their promise, they changes the badges and they basically alienated many of their leaders and in doing so put off many girls. Now they have attracted a new group of individuals whom in my view are alien to the old GG movement - I feel it is a very sad state of affairs. The GG movement over the years has done a lot to encourage girls and provided a fantastic opportunity for children whom cannot afford many of other clubs/societies, it encouraged them to try new things, broadening their horizon and provided them with role models. The movement has been very badly damaged and I wonder if it can recover its old identity

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 16:40

@Helleofabore

This is what people's energy should be focused on, not Monica herself.

And with the lack of trust in GG, if the full story is not being told about this person who has deliberately chosen their actions, how will parents know to then hold GG to account.

I do understand what you mean Eggy, but the reality is, people get their heads around what has happened and how it has happened, and that requires them seeing the images for themselves and reading articles about it. GG has low credibility that it will take any notice otherwise.

I agree with much of what you say. I believe Girlguiding can not be trusted. I also understand that to hold Girlguiding to account, you need an understanding of the situation, and this gives people some understanding of the situation, although I think this is just one small part of Girlguiding's failures.

Our energy needs to be focused on Girlguiding and their response, or lack of, to this. That is the only way things might change in Girlguiding. Saying repeatedly what an awful person Monica is will not change things in Girlguiding.

We're seen the pictures. People can make up their own minds. Now they need to hold Girlguiding to account and find out how this happened. Has anyone asked if they got a reference for Monica before she began volunteering?

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:38

And Echobelly, if this person cannot be held responsible enough to follow the published code of conduct of a Guiding volunteer and know the minute details and nuances of safeguarding, just how the hell are they supposed to ensure that as a divisional commissioner responsible for a large group of guides and their leaders that the guides are safe and not being harmed in any way?

DottyHarmer · 24/11/2021 16:36

It’s the Emperor’s New Clothes! Surely the rational response of an organisation, upon seeing such photos of one of its members - a member in close contact with young girls and in a position of leadership - should be to say “Sorry, mate, so long” without delay.

I would be horrified if this were my dc’s primary-school teacher. Why is GG any different? Safeguarding must not be eliminated in the pursuit of “being kind” to responsible adults.

Helleofabore · 24/11/2021 16:33

You are right though, they do look like party dresses and not tutus.