Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you to see who girl guides support.

391 replies

RedCarpetRebellion · 23/11/2021 23:46

www.google.com/amp/s/www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10235539/amp/Girlguides-launch-probe-trans-Commissioner-58-saucy-dominatrix-style-picture.html

A woman sacked for speaking up for girls safety was replaced by this person.

Girl guides are not safe for girls. AIBU?

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 25/11/2021 14:00

@Insidelaurashead

My best friend had a baby at 13. Most of my friends were having sex at that age. I wish guides had given out condoms
Most of your friends were having sex at 13? Really? I'm actually very surprised by that. Most of mine hadn't even had a proper kiss at that age!
DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 25/11/2021 13:55

@Eleganz

I am aware of this individual. I do not know a lot about their private life but I do know that they were heavily involved in scouting at a senior level before they transitioned. As such, I think it would be surprising if they were not aware of the safeguarding expectations for someone in their role. I suspect that they believe that their status as a transwoman means that such rules do not need to be followed by them because any criticism can be dismissed easily as transphobia either that or they are incredibly naïve about social media.
One wonders why he felt the need to change to GG given that scouting is a mixed sex organisation. Well we know don't we. For validation at best.
Shedmistress · 25/11/2021 10:47

What? Could you link, please? Thank you

It's in the safeguarding GG thread. 16:55 ish yesterday.

OnlyTheTitosaurusOfTheIceberg · 25/11/2021 10:42

On another thread, an ex GG leader is trying to set up an all female led group for girls and lo and behold, the local hall won't let them hold an all female led group for girls.

Everywhere is captured.

Yep, this would not surprise me in the slightest. I’m seeing this script played out over and over again.

“Let us into your single-sex spaces.”

“But then it wouldn’t be single-sex.”

“It’s transphobic not to let us in. We’re women.”

“Okay, but there might be some women uncomfortable with it - sexual abuse survivors, lesbians, women of some faiths/cultures etc.”

“Then they can set up their own female spaces. Let us in to this one. Be kind.”

“Okay. TWAW after all.”

“Hello, we’d like to set up a group just for women, you know natal women. May we use your space / social media platform please?”

“You can’t do that, it’s transphobic! Begone, T*RFS!”

DdraigGoch · 25/11/2021 10:38

domestic violence gone wrong

What the f* is that? It implies that domestic violence can be 'right'. And the person who said this helped GGUK write its policies?

DrSbaitso · 25/11/2021 09:32

@Shedmistress

The PP who suggested that it’s time for a dismantling of the old structure which has gone massively awry and a brand new movement which is for the benefit of GIRLS is probably onto something

On another thread, an ex GG leader is trying to set up an all female led group for girls and lo and behold, the local hall won't let them hold an all female led group for girls.

Everywhere is captured.

What? Could you link, please? Thank you.
elgreco · 25/11/2021 09:08

Teflon trans, a women with the same responsibility would not get away with this.

Shedmistress · 25/11/2021 09:02

The PP who suggested that it’s time for a dismantling of the old structure which has gone massively awry and a brand new movement which is for the benefit of GIRLS is probably onto something

On another thread, an ex GG leader is trying to set up an all female led group for girls and lo and behold, the local hall won't let them hold an all female led group for girls.

Everywhere is captured.

Lordamighty · 25/11/2021 09:02

The whole keeping quiet about what is going on in GG is probably a much bigger story than one individual parading their fetish on social media. The institutional capture of these organisations is astonishing & widespread.

brighousepres · 25/11/2021 08:34

….I would like to know why the Times & the Telegraph haven’t covered this…!? I know the BBC would back away, but then these days it’s always missing lots of stories.

Silencing unit leaders of many, many years service (ie Katie Alcock and Helen Watts) around the key safety issue, the departure of many more leaders, plus the ongoing concerns of some of the rest should be raising alarm bells in what is an age-old institution that millions of girls around the world have enjoyed and benefited from.

The PP who suggested that it’s time for a dismantling of the old structure which has gone massively awry and a brand new movement which is for the benefit of GIRLS is probably onto something.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 25/11/2021 08:28

I will never not be amazed by the amount of people but especially women who will accept a man is a woman because he says he is. You have to hand it to stonewall- it’s some next level marketing & selling strategy

The trustees of girl guides are not at all stupid ppl but they have completely bought into the beeee kiiiiinnd/ ‘the most vulnerable ever’ narrative

OnlyTheTitosaurusOfTheIceberg · 25/11/2021 07:11

Why isn't this bigger news?

Because transphobia. Because be kind. Because TWAW.

Sounds facetious…it really isn’t. The breadth and depth of institutional capture by an ideology which insists on affirmation, acceptance without exception, no debate and “I am what I say I am” and if you don’t agree men can identify as (and therefore be treated exactly the same in all respects as) women you are TRANSPHOBIC and worthy of threats and doxxing to shut you up is breathtaking. This is just one example. Some of the mainstream press has been well and truly captured; if the Guardian ever reported on this I’d need medical attention for shock because they are full-on TWAW. The BBC is slowly, gradually throwing off the Stonewall shackles but they have been in thrall to this ideology for many years until recently so you would never see a story painting a transperson in even a slightly negative light. At the moment it is predominantly the more right-wing press which seem to know what a woman is - the Mail, Telegraph and particularly the Times (which has done sterling work trying to draw attention to some of the more problematic elements of this belief system) are the only MSM likely to report on a story like this.

Coffeeandteevee · 25/11/2021 01:03

My daughter loves rainbows but unless something comes of this I'm pulling the plug. This has sickened me to my core.

I'm so fed up of female only spaces being diminished by penis-havers and then being called a terf for wanting female only spaces. They are clearly needed.

I remember reading so many comments on here/online elsewhere of people saying how transwomen ARE women and are no more of a risk to women when it comes to female only toilets et after the big JK Rowling uproar. Anyone who disagreed was just called transphobic.

Whoever calls these stupid shots needs to resign. Girlguides needs restructuring back to a point of sanity before all this virtue signalling and wokeness began and took over safeguarding our precious children which should be at the heart of the organisation.

People can like whatever the frig they like in private. Looking at this person's photos and knowing they are a guides leader just makes me feel sick to my stomach.

Why isn't this bigger news?

Eleganz · 24/11/2021 22:45

I am aware of this individual. I do not know a lot about their private life but I do know that they were heavily involved in scouting at a senior level before they transitioned. As such, I think it would be surprising if they were not aware of the safeguarding expectations for someone in their role. I suspect that they believe that their status as a transwoman means that such rules do not need to be followed by them because any criticism can be dismissed easily as transphobia either that or they are incredibly naïve about social media.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/11/2021 22:22

Female socialisation to "be kind" is a hell of a drug.

HermioneKipper · 24/11/2021 22:14

“Being mean to Monica” “being mean to girls with penises.”

NO.

This is about safeguarding our girls and young women and people are more worried about validating men’s little feelings and not being mean.

It’s disgraceful

PumpkinGin · 24/11/2021 21:50

I have tried to gather my thoughts on this. I don’t want to be mean to Monica and I am very happy for Monica that they have found themselves and seem to be looking being their best life as a woman. From the look of it with a great sex life.

But this is my issue

  1. Why are leaders sexualising children? I was really angry when GG tweeted about asexual week (even if I am Demi sexual and fall under the ace umbrella). GG should not talk to young girls about sex. At all. This is a discussion for parents and teachers under safeguarding conditions. Tweeting about sexuality was wrong.

  2. Monica had an extensive social media presence, open for all, where Monica posted pictures half naked, offered to send more intimate pictures and also posed as a dominatrix. Regardless of how you identify, this is completely inappropriate for a GG leader, let alone a senior position haver. Either GG failed massively in background checks or they didn’t care. But Monica is not a child. Monica needs to take response for Monica’s social media presence.

  3. GG have regulations where they recommend handing out condoms, morning after pills and take 13 year old girls to STD checks, all without parents’ knowledge unless the girl wants to tell. This is horrific. Not only should GG not do this but I was shocked to find out that there could be girls with penises at sleepovers, sleeping in the same dorm/tent and with a subsequent risk of pregnancy. This is beyond unacceptable.

In conclusion, there seem to be a complete lack of safeguarding in GG.

There is also a kindness problem. We had posters here telling us that this discussion should not be had on the main boards. We had posters saying that we were mean to Monica. But…. Maybe GG ignored the social media because they didn’t want to be mean to Monica? Maybe the condoms, morning after pill and STD check recommendations came because they didn’t want to be mean to girls with penises? Are there more Monica’s they don’t want to be mean to?

We have to be able to discuss these things openly and nobody should be treated with kid gloves because they identify in a certain way. Everyone should be held to the same standards. And 13 year old girls should not be sexualised, risk pregnancy and be given condoms and morning after pills behind the back of parents. By some random volunteers. These girls are sent there because responsible parents wants their girls to learn skills and have adventures. The leaders are in loco parentis and GG as an organisation has severely misplaced the trust of parents.

DismantledKing · 24/11/2021 19:17

@Clymene

I am going to focus on Monica as an individual and girl guiding.

I am suspicious of the motives of a recently transitioned man with very poor boundaries choosing to join an previously single sex organisation where there are overnights with children with low adult child ratios.

I am not going to apologise for that.

Yep. ‘Monica’ is one person I wouldn’t want in woman-only spaces.
brighousepres · 24/11/2021 18:51

For girls to be genuinely at Brownies / Guides then obviously parents need to feel confident.

I can’t see that happening whilst the current ideology is in force… Expelling leaders who speak out about their concerns is a MASSIVE red flag that the management is poor.

HermioneKipper · 24/11/2021 18:21

They’ve told parents in the past that it would breach personal data to tell them if there was a TW as a leader.

I mean you’d be able to tell at a meeting though. They don’t “pass” like they think they do

Flittingaboutagain · 24/11/2021 18:19

Can I ask her leaders if they have any males identifying as females as helpers?! (I know that is ridiculous)

^ I wondered that but unsure if this counts as confidential personnel info?!

HermioneKipper · 24/11/2021 18:18

@guiltynetter they won’t tell you if there are. Much like they won’t tell the parents of any guides that there are any boys identifying as girls sleeping in their daughters tents or using their showers.

It’s a real shitshow

Eggybrains · 24/11/2021 18:16

@guiltynetter

I've already decided she won't be going on any camping trips or sleep overs.
I've taken mine out and feel like a pile of sh*t. They enjoyed it.

And it's probably ok. And they probably won't come to harm and be abused there. But that's not really good enough is it?

guiltynetter · 24/11/2021 18:02

I've already decided she won't be going on any camping trips or sleep overs.

guiltynetter · 24/11/2021 18:01

My daughter has just started brownies 4 weeks ago and is really loving it, I'm about to buy her uniform this week.

I've read similar to this before and I did have my concerns but especially since this article. Can someone tell me what I can do? Should I be withdrawing her? She would be really upset. Can I write to anyone? Can I ask her leaders if they have any males identifying as females as helpers?! (I know that is ridiculous)